Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Health Freedom

CJI reserves order: Medha Patkar’s plea for temporary release of convicts

The plea was filed against Bombay High Court’s order upholding the classification made by the HPC denying parole to convicts under special Acts like UAPA, MCOCA

Sabrangindia 14 Sep 2020

Image Courtesy:dnaindia.com

The Supreme Court has reserved its orders in a petition filed by activist Medha Patkar seeking interim release of prisoners from Maharashtra prisons on account of spread of Covid-19.

A special leave petition was filed by Patkar, her organisation, National Alliance for People’s Movement (NAPM) and activist Meera Kamath, to appeal against a Bombay High Court judgment which had upheld the state High powered Committee’s (HPC) recommendation to not release on emergency parole, those prisoners convicted for offences punishable with less than 7 years under special laws such as NDPS Act, UAPA, MCOCA etc.

The Supreme Court bench led by CJI SA Bobde along with Justices AS Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian heard the petition and CJI stated that the court will pass a reasoned wherein “the Bombay High Court & Maharashtra High Power Committee will be at liberty to modify its classification in accordance with the on-ground conditions," as reported by LiveLaw.

Advocates SB Talekar, PB Suresh, Vipin Nair, Karthik Jayshankar and Sughosh SN were appearing for the petitioners.

At the beginning of the lockdown, the Supreme Court had directed states to constitute HPCs to release prisoners on interim bail or emergency parole to reduce occupancy in over crowded jails, to curb the spread of Covid-19 in prisons. It was left up to the HPCs on how to classify prisoners to be released. Accordingly, the Maharashtra HPC recommended release of prisoners convicted of offences punishable with less than 7years imprisonment, except for those convicted under special Act or serious economic offences. Further, HPC also directed jail authorities across the state to favorably consider releasing such convicts sentenced to less than 7 years in prison, on emergency parole.

The petition contends,

"The HPC excluded the prisoners who were accused of offences punishable under the Special Acts for the purpose of availing interim bail on the ground that such Acts required observation of a separate procedure or imposition of additional conditions for the purpose of grant of bail. However, most of the special Acts did not provide for any special procedure or additional conditions for grant of bail…Once the HPC had classified the prisoners after applying the relevant parameters, it was not required to apply those and other relevant parameters once again by the lower courts, thereby making the entire exercise of classification of prisoners for the purpose of decongestion in the prisons, a futile attempt and illusory."

The petitioners argued that the classification was made without any intelligible differentia or a rational nexus with the objects sought to be achieved by such classification.

On August 5, the Bombay high Court had upheld these classifications and the petition asserts that the High Court had erroneously made its decision by holding that the HPC’s classification did not violate fundamental rights of prisoners.

https://ssl.gstatic.com/ui/v1/icons/mail/images/cleardot.gif

Related:

Delhi jails most crowded; number of unnatural deaths on the rise: Prison report 2019
Women in prisons: 2019
Sudha Bharadwaj’s heart condition result of incarecration, family & friends urge early hearing of bail petition 

 

CJI reserves order: Medha Patkar’s plea for temporary release of convicts

The plea was filed against Bombay High Court’s order upholding the classification made by the HPC denying parole to convicts under special Acts like UAPA, MCOCA

Image Courtesy:dnaindia.com

The Supreme Court has reserved its orders in a petition filed by activist Medha Patkar seeking interim release of prisoners from Maharashtra prisons on account of spread of Covid-19.

A special leave petition was filed by Patkar, her organisation, National Alliance for People’s Movement (NAPM) and activist Meera Kamath, to appeal against a Bombay High Court judgment which had upheld the state High powered Committee’s (HPC) recommendation to not release on emergency parole, those prisoners convicted for offences punishable with less than 7 years under special laws such as NDPS Act, UAPA, MCOCA etc.

The Supreme Court bench led by CJI SA Bobde along with Justices AS Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian heard the petition and CJI stated that the court will pass a reasoned wherein “the Bombay High Court & Maharashtra High Power Committee will be at liberty to modify its classification in accordance with the on-ground conditions," as reported by LiveLaw.

Advocates SB Talekar, PB Suresh, Vipin Nair, Karthik Jayshankar and Sughosh SN were appearing for the petitioners.

At the beginning of the lockdown, the Supreme Court had directed states to constitute HPCs to release prisoners on interim bail or emergency parole to reduce occupancy in over crowded jails, to curb the spread of Covid-19 in prisons. It was left up to the HPCs on how to classify prisoners to be released. Accordingly, the Maharashtra HPC recommended release of prisoners convicted of offences punishable with less than 7years imprisonment, except for those convicted under special Act or serious economic offences. Further, HPC also directed jail authorities across the state to favorably consider releasing such convicts sentenced to less than 7 years in prison, on emergency parole.

The petition contends,

"The HPC excluded the prisoners who were accused of offences punishable under the Special Acts for the purpose of availing interim bail on the ground that such Acts required observation of a separate procedure or imposition of additional conditions for the purpose of grant of bail. However, most of the special Acts did not provide for any special procedure or additional conditions for grant of bail…Once the HPC had classified the prisoners after applying the relevant parameters, it was not required to apply those and other relevant parameters once again by the lower courts, thereby making the entire exercise of classification of prisoners for the purpose of decongestion in the prisons, a futile attempt and illusory."

The petitioners argued that the classification was made without any intelligible differentia or a rational nexus with the objects sought to be achieved by such classification.

On August 5, the Bombay high Court had upheld these classifications and the petition asserts that the High Court had erroneously made its decision by holding that the HPC’s classification did not violate fundamental rights of prisoners.

https://ssl.gstatic.com/ui/v1/icons/mail/images/cleardot.gif

Related:

Delhi jails most crowded; number of unnatural deaths on the rise: Prison report 2019
Women in prisons: 2019
Sudha Bharadwaj’s heart condition result of incarecration, family & friends urge early hearing of bail petition 

 

Related Articles

Dalit Bahujan Adivasi

Bihar Govt has worst record on Land Rights to Adivasis: Brinda Karat

Speaking at the release of a fact-finding report about the firing in Adhaura block, Brinda Karat exposed the deeds of the Bihar Govt while lauding the democratic struggle of the Kaimur’s Kharwar Adivasi communities against an oppressive forest department

Dalit Bahujan Adivasi

Bihar Govt has worst record on Land Rights to Adivasis: Brinda Karat

Speaking at the release of a fact-finding report about the firing in Adhaura block, Brinda Karat exposed the deeds of the Bihar Govt while lauding the democratic struggle of the Kaimur’s Kharwar Adivasi communities against an oppressive forest department


Wednesday

14

Oct

11 am onwards

Not an Inch Back!

Main Gate KG-Campus

Friday

09

Oct

Albert Ekka Chowk, Ranchi

Monday

05

Oct

Valluvarkottam, Chennai

Theme

Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.
Delhi HC

Hate Speech and Delhi Pogrom 2020

A spate of provocative speeches, that amount to hate speech in law and should be prosecuted allowed blood letting to spill on the streets of north east Delhi in February-March 2020
hashimpura

Hashimpura Massacre

The Lemmings of Hashimpura
summer

Summer Culture

Our first summer culture bouquet features fiction from Syria and Iraq and poetry and art from Palestine.

Campaigns

Wednesday

14

Oct

11 am onwards

Not an Inch Back!

Main Gate KG-Campus

Friday

09

Oct

04 pm onwards

#IStandWithStanSwamy

Albert Ekka Chowk, Ranchi

Monday

05

Oct

Valluvarkottam, Chennai

Videos

I dissent! How a photojournalist is fighting hate

Can one be apolitical in these times of communal divide, hate and bigotry? How does one fight religious and caste prejudice? Photojournalist Vijay Pandey asks important questions in this SabrangIndia exclusive series ‘I dissent! Artists who are taking on bigotry’

I dissent! How a photojournalist is fighting hate

Can one be apolitical in these times of communal divide, hate and bigotry? How does one fight religious and caste prejudice? Photojournalist Vijay Pandey asks important questions in this SabrangIndia exclusive series ‘I dissent! Artists who are taking on bigotry’

IN FACT

Analysis

Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.
Delhi HC

Hate Speech and Delhi Pogrom 2020

A spate of provocative speeches, that amount to hate speech in law and should be prosecuted allowed blood letting to spill on the streets of north east Delhi in February-March 2020
hashimpura

Hashimpura Massacre

The Lemmings of Hashimpura
summer

Summer Culture

Our first summer culture bouquet features fiction from Syria and Iraq and poetry and art from Palestine.

Archives