<> Angry Centre wants OTT platforms to ‘only’ ban Hindu-phobic content | SabrangIndia Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Communalism Politics

Angry Centre wants OTT platforms to ‘only’ ban Hindu-phobic content

Sabrangindia 25 Oct 2019

The Centre is likely to issue a ‘negative list’ of don’ts for OTT platforms like Netflix and Hotstar


Netflix

In the past week there has been a lot of noise around online video streaming OTT platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime and Hotstar among others. Citing an uptick in ‘Hindu-phobic’ content, the Information and Broadcasting Ministry is likely to issue a negative list of don’ts for online streaming platforms.

The negative list has prohibited the use of content which disrespects the national emblem or national flag, promotes child pornography or intends to outrage religious sentiments.

The apparent nail in the coffin was the Netflix show Leila which riled up Hindutva organizations such as RSS and VHP for showing the Hindu religion, customs and rituals in a bad light, apart from terming it as ‘Hindu-phobic’ propaganda.





An unnamed member of SanghParivar said, “It represents ancient Hindu concepts such as Aryavarta and Shuddhikaran as oppressive and dictatorial, suppressing women and restricting their reproductive rights. Nowhere in Hindu scriptures will you find such an occurrence, which is why we raised concerns about the series being defamatory and insulting,”

Solanki had also complained about American comedian Hasan Minhaj’s show Patriot Act in which he offers his commentary on various global and US-centric issues, apart from his views about the political and social situation in India.



Not only Leila, it is even the extremely popular Sacred Games that has found itself to be the ire of the BJP. Delhi BJP spokesperson TajinderBagga had filed an FIR against Sacred Games director AnuragKashyap for “intentionally hurting Sikh sentiments”. Bagga was referring to a scene in the show in which actor Saif Ali Khan, who portrays a Sikh cop, takes off his Kada and throws it into the sea. Not only that, the show is also said to insult the Guru-shishyaparampara in its portrayal.



Ghoul, another Netflix series that depicts a dystopian future where Muslims are persecuted by a fascist Hindu state, shows the Indian Army in a bad light claimed the Hindu Jagruti Organisation, ruffling the feathers of right-wing Hindutva supporters.
Visual of Ghoul Netflix Series

A local non-profit group, Justice for Rights Foundation, late last year filed a case against Amazon Prime Video, Netflix and Hotstar for showing sexually explicit content and demanding a regulator for online content, its founder Satyam Singh said.

Currently, there are as many as 9 PILs against the alleged ‘anti-Hindu’ and ‘anti-National’ content pegged by these shows. In May, the Supreme Court had also issued a notice to the Centre to regulate the content featured on these OTT platforms.

What the Law says
While film and TV certification bodies already moderate public content in India, the country’s laws do not allow censorship of content on OTT platforms.

A government official said there was also concern about disparity in how some content appeared on different mediums. Smoking scenes in Bollywood movies on Amazon and Netflix in India, for example, do not carry the mandatory anti-tobacco textual warnings.

On Monday, rumours of top Netflix executive ShrishtiBehlArya meeting the representatives of the RSS had floated. Asked about the same, Arya, who is director - International Original Film, India, Netflix, dubbed the story "fake news".

She said, unlike storytelling, the law of the land is not subjective. "The law is the law. It's not like, 'I don't like you, and so I'm going to stab you.' Whatever is permitted by the law, we would go into those spaces and the rest is all about the stories that creators want to tell."

Three years ago, the RSS had established the BharatiyaChitraSadhana with the objective of promoting a “Bharatiya” narrative across cinema and television, urging filmmakers to make short films and documentaries on Indian culture, values, folk art, Hinduism, national security and nation-building. In the last few months, representatives from the BharatiyaChitraSadhana have been reaching out to filmmakers and scriptwriters to promote this Hindu-dominated narrative.

What the Big Question is
Netflix, Amazon and other platforms don’t just portray content that tilt towards depicting a particular religion in a certain way. Shows like the The Young Pope, Spotlight, Supernatural, The Handmaid’s Tale depict Christianity controversially.

Why is the Centre not calling for a ban on these shows?

Why is the majority only out to protect its own culture? Does the protection of the culture of the minorities not mean much to it?

The big question is – Can the Centre be secular in its bans?

Related
Netflix drops comedy show criticizing Saudi Arabia
Elections 2019: Modi biopic and a trail of violations
‘Modified’: A Film About GMOs and the Corruption of the Food Supply for Profit
 
 

Angry Centre wants OTT platforms to ‘only’ ban Hindu-phobic content

The Centre is likely to issue a ‘negative list’ of don’ts for OTT platforms like Netflix and Hotstar


Netflix

In the past week there has been a lot of noise around online video streaming OTT platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime and Hotstar among others. Citing an uptick in ‘Hindu-phobic’ content, the Information and Broadcasting Ministry is likely to issue a negative list of don’ts for online streaming platforms.

The negative list has prohibited the use of content which disrespects the national emblem or national flag, promotes child pornography or intends to outrage religious sentiments.

The apparent nail in the coffin was the Netflix show Leila which riled up Hindutva organizations such as RSS and VHP for showing the Hindu religion, customs and rituals in a bad light, apart from terming it as ‘Hindu-phobic’ propaganda.





An unnamed member of SanghParivar said, “It represents ancient Hindu concepts such as Aryavarta and Shuddhikaran as oppressive and dictatorial, suppressing women and restricting their reproductive rights. Nowhere in Hindu scriptures will you find such an occurrence, which is why we raised concerns about the series being defamatory and insulting,”

Solanki had also complained about American comedian Hasan Minhaj’s show Patriot Act in which he offers his commentary on various global and US-centric issues, apart from his views about the political and social situation in India.



Not only Leila, it is even the extremely popular Sacred Games that has found itself to be the ire of the BJP. Delhi BJP spokesperson TajinderBagga had filed an FIR against Sacred Games director AnuragKashyap for “intentionally hurting Sikh sentiments”. Bagga was referring to a scene in the show in which actor Saif Ali Khan, who portrays a Sikh cop, takes off his Kada and throws it into the sea. Not only that, the show is also said to insult the Guru-shishyaparampara in its portrayal.



Ghoul, another Netflix series that depicts a dystopian future where Muslims are persecuted by a fascist Hindu state, shows the Indian Army in a bad light claimed the Hindu Jagruti Organisation, ruffling the feathers of right-wing Hindutva supporters.
Visual of Ghoul Netflix Series

A local non-profit group, Justice for Rights Foundation, late last year filed a case against Amazon Prime Video, Netflix and Hotstar for showing sexually explicit content and demanding a regulator for online content, its founder Satyam Singh said.

Currently, there are as many as 9 PILs against the alleged ‘anti-Hindu’ and ‘anti-National’ content pegged by these shows. In May, the Supreme Court had also issued a notice to the Centre to regulate the content featured on these OTT platforms.

What the Law says
While film and TV certification bodies already moderate public content in India, the country’s laws do not allow censorship of content on OTT platforms.

A government official said there was also concern about disparity in how some content appeared on different mediums. Smoking scenes in Bollywood movies on Amazon and Netflix in India, for example, do not carry the mandatory anti-tobacco textual warnings.

On Monday, rumours of top Netflix executive ShrishtiBehlArya meeting the representatives of the RSS had floated. Asked about the same, Arya, who is director - International Original Film, India, Netflix, dubbed the story "fake news".

She said, unlike storytelling, the law of the land is not subjective. "The law is the law. It's not like, 'I don't like you, and so I'm going to stab you.' Whatever is permitted by the law, we would go into those spaces and the rest is all about the stories that creators want to tell."

Three years ago, the RSS had established the BharatiyaChitraSadhana with the objective of promoting a “Bharatiya” narrative across cinema and television, urging filmmakers to make short films and documentaries on Indian culture, values, folk art, Hinduism, national security and nation-building. In the last few months, representatives from the BharatiyaChitraSadhana have been reaching out to filmmakers and scriptwriters to promote this Hindu-dominated narrative.

What the Big Question is
Netflix, Amazon and other platforms don’t just portray content that tilt towards depicting a particular religion in a certain way. Shows like the The Young Pope, Spotlight, Supernatural, The Handmaid’s Tale depict Christianity controversially.

Why is the Centre not calling for a ban on these shows?

Why is the majority only out to protect its own culture? Does the protection of the culture of the minorities not mean much to it?

The big question is – Can the Centre be secular in its bans?

Related
Netflix drops comedy show criticizing Saudi Arabia
Elections 2019: Modi biopic and a trail of violations
‘Modified’: A Film About GMOs and the Corruption of the Food Supply for Profit
 
 

Related Articles

Minorities

A United States Commission calls out Indian government’s bias against Muslim community

Many issues have erupted in Assam after the NRC updation process began a few years ago. The economically weaker sections have suffered the most and there is a looming fear amongst the people of Assam of being rendered stateless. In the midst of all this, there appears to be a clear agenda of the ruling government against the Muslim community which it has clearly manifested in its Citizenship Amendment Bill, which it plans to re-introduce in the current winter session.

Minorities

A United States Commission calls out Indian government’s bias against Muslim community

Many issues have erupted in Assam after the NRC updation process began a few years ago. The economically weaker sections have suffered the most and there is a looming fear amongst the people of Assam of being rendered stateless. In the midst of all this, there appears to be a clear agenda of the ruling government against the Muslim community which it has clearly manifested in its Citizenship Amendment Bill, which it plans to re-introduce in the current winter session.


Monday

18

Nov

Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi

Saturday

30

Nov

Jana Natya Manch, New Delhi

Thursday

07

Nov

Thrissur, Kerala

Theme

Ayodhya 1992

Ayodhya 1992

Excerpts from the Report of the Liberhan Ayodhya Commission of Inquiry
babri

How the Babri Masjid was demolished

Citizens Tribunal on Ayodhya
babri

Fact and Faith

Allahabad High Court Judgement in Babri Demolition Case, 2010
kashmir

How Green Is My Valley

The killing of innocent Hindus by Pakistan-trained mercenaries in J and K is one more bid to convert the Kashmiriyat issue into a Hindu-Muslim problem

Campaigns

Monday

18

Nov

Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi

Saturday

30

Nov

Jana Natya Manch, New Delhi

Thursday

07

Nov

12 am onwards

Vibgyor Film Collective

Thrissur, Kerala

Videos

Communalism

What is the Ram Temple REALLY about?

For the many who do not know what the original Ram Temple movement is and the many who may have forgotten the mayhem, eminent activist and journalist Teesta Setalvad presents a ready reckoner on what the Ram Temple movement really is about and why has it been so conveniently resurrected, twenty six years later in 2018.

Communalism

What is the Ram Temple REALLY about?

For the many who do not know what the original Ram Temple movement is and the many who may have forgotten the mayhem, eminent activist and journalist Teesta Setalvad presents a ready reckoner on what the Ram Temple movement really is about and why has it been so conveniently resurrected, twenty six years later in 2018.

Analysis

Ayodhya 1992

Ayodhya 1992

Excerpts from the Report of the Liberhan Ayodhya Commission of Inquiry
babri

How the Babri Masjid was demolished

Citizens Tribunal on Ayodhya
babri

Fact and Faith

Allahabad High Court Judgement in Babri Demolition Case, 2010
kashmir

How Green Is My Valley

The killing of innocent Hindus by Pakistan-trained mercenaries in J and K is one more bid to convert the Kashmiriyat issue into a Hindu-Muslim problem

Archives