Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Rule of Law

Bombay HC slams Centre’s affidavit defending faulty PMCARES Fund ventilators

The court noted that it would be better if the affidavit avoided the blame game and showed sensitivity towards Covid-19 patients

Sabrangindia 28 May 2021

Image Courtesy:livelaw.in

The Bombay High Court (Aurangabad Bench) pulled up the Modi Government for defending defective ventilator manufacturer, Jyoti CNC, and for claiming that the doctors and paramedics are not properly trained to operate them.

According to a LiveLaw report, Justices Ravindra Ghuge and BU Debadwar said that the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, G.K. Pillai, who filed the affidavit, should have avoided playing the “blame game” and shown sensitivity towards Covid-19 patients.

During the last hearing on May 25, the Bench had observed, “We find a serious issue before us as regards the defective functioning of the ventilators. Except the 37 ventilators which are yet to be un-boxed, 113 ventilators put to use are found to be defective…We find the above situation as regards the dysfunctional ventilators supplied through the PM Cares Fund, to be quite serious. We, therefore, call upon the learned ASGI to state, as to what action would the Union of India initiate in these circumstances.”

Today, the Central Government reportedly submitted that the 150 ventilators in question were supplied through “Make-in-India and not through the PMCARES Fund.” To this, the court remarked, “We would have appreciated, had that affiant (author of the affidavit) avoided entering into a blame game and would have shown sensitivity towards the patients, it being the paramount object of a welfare state to take care of the health of its citizens.”

The Division Bench further asked the Health Ministry to respect the reports from medical experts, which claimed the ventilators were defective, and concentrate on rectifying it. LiveLaw quoted it saying, “We will also appreciate if the MOHFW refrains from questioning the reports of medical experts and respect such reports in the larger interest of society, rectifying the said machines. We are unable to accept the contentions of the ASGI that the ventilators are in perfect operating conditions, and it is the hospitals who do not have trained personnel to operate them properly. The affidavit before us has a semblance of virtually defending the manufacturer and declaring the ventilators are in immaculate condition.”

Further slamming the Centre’s affidavit, the Bench opined, “We find such statements to be demonstrating insensitivity on the part of MOHFW. Instead of expressing wholehearted support to ensure that such machines are put to optimum utilization in the interest of the lives of the patients, it appears that the affiant found it advantageous to contend that there is no merit in the report of the dean of the Government Medical College (GMCH)”.

The Bench then asked the Additional Solicitor General of India, Ajay Talhar, to take further instructions on a fresh report submitted by the GMCH. The report listed reasons to conclude that the ventilators are unsafe for patient’s use, and it was decided not to test any of these machines on patients.

The Additional Solicitor General then apprised the Aurangabad Bench that the Central government would take remedial steps and ensure the ventilators would operate adequately and all defects, if any, would be removed. The matter will be heard on June 2, 2021.

On May 25, the court had also taken note of some news reports where politicians started visiting Hospitals to find out about the ventilators and some, without having the expertise, just declared that all the ventilators are in good working conditions. Some also said that the ventilators have been lying idle, so they have become dysfunctional.

The court had taken a dim view of this and said, “We express our displeasure as regards such indulgence by the people’s representatives. This is likely to cause more botheration to the medical faculty than render any assistance. Contrary statements are being issued by the politicians which we find distasteful as some politicians have visited the hospital, posing as if they have the knowledge and the expertise to inspect the ventilators and recommend correctional steps. We would appreciate it if political colour is not attached to this issue of dysfunctional ventilators.”

The order dated May 25 may be read here: 

The order may be read here:

Related:

Activist moves SC to include PM CARES Fund as respondent in Covid case
Is the PMCARES Fund using the national emblem illegally?
Plea in Bombay HC seeks CAG audit of PM CARES fund
SC dismisses plea seeking transfer of funds from PM CARES to NDRF

Bombay HC slams Centre’s affidavit defending faulty PMCARES Fund ventilators

The court noted that it would be better if the affidavit avoided the blame game and showed sensitivity towards Covid-19 patients

Image Courtesy:livelaw.in

The Bombay High Court (Aurangabad Bench) pulled up the Modi Government for defending defective ventilator manufacturer, Jyoti CNC, and for claiming that the doctors and paramedics are not properly trained to operate them.

According to a LiveLaw report, Justices Ravindra Ghuge and BU Debadwar said that the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, G.K. Pillai, who filed the affidavit, should have avoided playing the “blame game” and shown sensitivity towards Covid-19 patients.

During the last hearing on May 25, the Bench had observed, “We find a serious issue before us as regards the defective functioning of the ventilators. Except the 37 ventilators which are yet to be un-boxed, 113 ventilators put to use are found to be defective…We find the above situation as regards the dysfunctional ventilators supplied through the PM Cares Fund, to be quite serious. We, therefore, call upon the learned ASGI to state, as to what action would the Union of India initiate in these circumstances.”

Today, the Central Government reportedly submitted that the 150 ventilators in question were supplied through “Make-in-India and not through the PMCARES Fund.” To this, the court remarked, “We would have appreciated, had that affiant (author of the affidavit) avoided entering into a blame game and would have shown sensitivity towards the patients, it being the paramount object of a welfare state to take care of the health of its citizens.”

The Division Bench further asked the Health Ministry to respect the reports from medical experts, which claimed the ventilators were defective, and concentrate on rectifying it. LiveLaw quoted it saying, “We will also appreciate if the MOHFW refrains from questioning the reports of medical experts and respect such reports in the larger interest of society, rectifying the said machines. We are unable to accept the contentions of the ASGI that the ventilators are in perfect operating conditions, and it is the hospitals who do not have trained personnel to operate them properly. The affidavit before us has a semblance of virtually defending the manufacturer and declaring the ventilators are in immaculate condition.”

Further slamming the Centre’s affidavit, the Bench opined, “We find such statements to be demonstrating insensitivity on the part of MOHFW. Instead of expressing wholehearted support to ensure that such machines are put to optimum utilization in the interest of the lives of the patients, it appears that the affiant found it advantageous to contend that there is no merit in the report of the dean of the Government Medical College (GMCH)”.

The Bench then asked the Additional Solicitor General of India, Ajay Talhar, to take further instructions on a fresh report submitted by the GMCH. The report listed reasons to conclude that the ventilators are unsafe for patient’s use, and it was decided not to test any of these machines on patients.

The Additional Solicitor General then apprised the Aurangabad Bench that the Central government would take remedial steps and ensure the ventilators would operate adequately and all defects, if any, would be removed. The matter will be heard on June 2, 2021.

On May 25, the court had also taken note of some news reports where politicians started visiting Hospitals to find out about the ventilators and some, without having the expertise, just declared that all the ventilators are in good working conditions. Some also said that the ventilators have been lying idle, so they have become dysfunctional.

The court had taken a dim view of this and said, “We express our displeasure as regards such indulgence by the people’s representatives. This is likely to cause more botheration to the medical faculty than render any assistance. Contrary statements are being issued by the politicians which we find distasteful as some politicians have visited the hospital, posing as if they have the knowledge and the expertise to inspect the ventilators and recommend correctional steps. We would appreciate it if political colour is not attached to this issue of dysfunctional ventilators.”

The order dated May 25 may be read here: 

The order may be read here:

Related:

Activist moves SC to include PM CARES Fund as respondent in Covid case
Is the PMCARES Fund using the national emblem illegally?
Plea in Bombay HC seeks CAG audit of PM CARES fund
SC dismisses plea seeking transfer of funds from PM CARES to NDRF

Related Articles

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Theme

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Campaigns

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Videos

Communalism

Hate Speech is rampant while Free speech is criminalised | Teesta Setalvad

Eminent speakers like Justice Anjana Prakash, Saba Naqvi expressed grave concerns over the draconian laws, used to put down the struggles of the labouring masses and the manner in which the law enforcement have been taking down students, academicians, political and human rights activists, artists, Dalits, Muslims and tribal people.

Communalism

Hate Speech is rampant while Free speech is criminalised | Teesta Setalvad

Eminent speakers like Justice Anjana Prakash, Saba Naqvi expressed grave concerns over the draconian laws, used to put down the struggles of the labouring masses and the manner in which the law enforcement have been taking down students, academicians, political and human rights activists, artists, Dalits, Muslims and tribal people.

IN FACT

Analysis

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Archives