Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Politics

Coercive Funding of Patel Statue by CPSUS Improper: Former Bureaucrat

Sabrangindia 06 Nov 2018

In a strongly worded letter to I Srinivas, secretary, ministry of corporate affairs, government of India, a former senior civil servant, EAS Sarma has raised serious questions on the coercive funding of the ‘historic’ Sardar Patel statue in south Gujarat.


Sardar patel Statue
 
A senior bureaucrat with the government of India, now retired raises serious questions about the impropriety of compelling CPSUs to contribute through their CSR funding to the Patel statute.
 
Sarma relies on a C&AG sport (Report No 18/2018) on Central PSUs. He states that the Report (see Para 4.5.4.4) has brought out serious irregularities in the case of five PSUs under the administrative control of Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas (MPNG). Apparently, under extraneous pressure, the five PSUs, namely, ONGC, HPCL, IOC, Bharat Petroleum and Oil India contributed Rs 146.83 crores towards their expenditure under the head of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel in Gujarat. 
 
As pointed out by C&AG, it was highly irregular on the part of the concerned PSUs to incur such expenditure under CSR, as envisaged under Section 135 of the Companies Act. It is surprising that neither the Audit Committee of any of these PSUs nor the independent directors nor the other directors have cared to question such irregular expenditure, apparently in fear of reprisals from those in authority.
 
Whether these are Central PSUs or State PSUs, they are owned by the people of India. There are other shareholders such as public financial institutions and small minority shareholders who have a heavy stake in each of these PSUs. If anyone has arm-twisted the PSUs into incurring such expenditure, not in line with its business activity, it amounts to weakening the public sector.
The entire text of the letter, dated November 6, may be read here.
 
To
Govt of India
Dear Shri Srinivas,
 
I enclose here a copy of C&AG sport (Report No 18/2018) on Central PSUs. The Report (see Para 4.5.4.4) has brought out serious irregularities in the case of five PSUs under the administrative control of Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas (MPNG). Apparently, under extraneous pressure, the five PSUs, namely, ONGC, HPCL, IOC, Bharat Petroleum and Oil India contributed Rs 146.83 crores towards their expenditure under the head of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel in Gujarat. 
 
In addition, 14 PSUs in the State of Gujarat also seem to have spent Rs 104.88 crores under CSR for the same project.
 
I understand that the project for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel has cost the nation around Rs 3,000 crores!. Sardar Patel's contribution to the unity of India is no doubt immeasurable but he himself would not have endorsed such a huge expenditure of public funds for constructing his statue. What is more important is to respect his views on nation building and do everything that reinforces his idea of a nation. 
 
As pointed out by C&AG, it was highly irregular on the part of the concerned PSUs to incur such expenditure under CSR, as envisaged under Section 135 of the Companies Act. It is surprising that neither the Audit Committee of any of these PSUs nor the independent directors nor the other directors have cared to question such irregular expenditure, apparently in fear of reprisals from those in authority.
 
Whether these are Central PSUs or State PSUs, they are owned by the people of India. There are other shareholders such as public financial institutions and small minority shareholders who have a heavy stake in each of these PSUs. If anyone has arm-twisted the PSUs into incurring such expenditure, not in line with its business activity, it amounts to weakening the public sector.
 
I was trying to find out the implications of the statue project from the point of view of the economy. There is very little in the project that is Indian. Mostly, the project in question has benefitted Chinese companies and contributed to employment benefits for the Chinese. To armtwist both Central and State PSUs into diverting public funds into such a project is highly objectionable.
 
It appears from this that there has been a complete breakdown of corporate governance in the 19 PSUs referred above. The Audit Committees should have played the role expected of them under Section 177 of the Companies Act and prevented the respective managements from yielding to the diktat of the concerned government. Apparently, they have chosen to acquiesce in it. Under Section 149, the independent directors are required to safeguard the interests of the shareholders but they too seem to have failed in discharging their role.
 
At a time when the ordinary citizen is forced to pay high prices for petroleum products, such irregular expenditure burden on the petroleum PSUs should be looked upon as highly undesirable and regressive.
 
I request you, as the administrative head of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, to order a thorough investigation and consider taking deterrent action against the concerned PSU managements, including the members of the Audit Committees and the other independent directors. Inaction on the part of your Ministry will set a bad precedent for the public sector undertakings in general.
 
Regards,
 
Yours sincerely,
E A S Sarma
Former Secretary to GOI
Visakhapatnam
 
 
Related articles:
Tribal Protests, Black Balloons Cloud Modi’s Unveiling of ‘Statue of Unity’
An Open Letter to Sardar Patel: Medha Patkar

Ex-GOI Secretary criticises gov’t’s move over DNA profiling bill

Letter from former civil servants to Chief Secretary, Haryana on intimidation of Muslims offering namaz

 
 
 
 

Coercive Funding of Patel Statue by CPSUS Improper: Former Bureaucrat

In a strongly worded letter to I Srinivas, secretary, ministry of corporate affairs, government of India, a former senior civil servant, EAS Sarma has raised serious questions on the coercive funding of the ‘historic’ Sardar Patel statue in south Gujarat.


Sardar patel Statue
 
A senior bureaucrat with the government of India, now retired raises serious questions about the impropriety of compelling CPSUs to contribute through their CSR funding to the Patel statute.
 
Sarma relies on a C&AG sport (Report No 18/2018) on Central PSUs. He states that the Report (see Para 4.5.4.4) has brought out serious irregularities in the case of five PSUs under the administrative control of Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas (MPNG). Apparently, under extraneous pressure, the five PSUs, namely, ONGC, HPCL, IOC, Bharat Petroleum and Oil India contributed Rs 146.83 crores towards their expenditure under the head of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel in Gujarat. 
 
As pointed out by C&AG, it was highly irregular on the part of the concerned PSUs to incur such expenditure under CSR, as envisaged under Section 135 of the Companies Act. It is surprising that neither the Audit Committee of any of these PSUs nor the independent directors nor the other directors have cared to question such irregular expenditure, apparently in fear of reprisals from those in authority.
 
Whether these are Central PSUs or State PSUs, they are owned by the people of India. There are other shareholders such as public financial institutions and small minority shareholders who have a heavy stake in each of these PSUs. If anyone has arm-twisted the PSUs into incurring such expenditure, not in line with its business activity, it amounts to weakening the public sector.
The entire text of the letter, dated November 6, may be read here.
 
To
Govt of India
Dear Shri Srinivas,
 
I enclose here a copy of C&AG sport (Report No 18/2018) on Central PSUs. The Report (see Para 4.5.4.4) has brought out serious irregularities in the case of five PSUs under the administrative control of Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Gas (MPNG). Apparently, under extraneous pressure, the five PSUs, namely, ONGC, HPCL, IOC, Bharat Petroleum and Oil India contributed Rs 146.83 crores towards their expenditure under the head of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel in Gujarat. 
 
In addition, 14 PSUs in the State of Gujarat also seem to have spent Rs 104.88 crores under CSR for the same project.
 
I understand that the project for the construction of the statue of Sardar Patel has cost the nation around Rs 3,000 crores!. Sardar Patel's contribution to the unity of India is no doubt immeasurable but he himself would not have endorsed such a huge expenditure of public funds for constructing his statue. What is more important is to respect his views on nation building and do everything that reinforces his idea of a nation. 
 
As pointed out by C&AG, it was highly irregular on the part of the concerned PSUs to incur such expenditure under CSR, as envisaged under Section 135 of the Companies Act. It is surprising that neither the Audit Committee of any of these PSUs nor the independent directors nor the other directors have cared to question such irregular expenditure, apparently in fear of reprisals from those in authority.
 
Whether these are Central PSUs or State PSUs, they are owned by the people of India. There are other shareholders such as public financial institutions and small minority shareholders who have a heavy stake in each of these PSUs. If anyone has arm-twisted the PSUs into incurring such expenditure, not in line with its business activity, it amounts to weakening the public sector.
 
I was trying to find out the implications of the statue project from the point of view of the economy. There is very little in the project that is Indian. Mostly, the project in question has benefitted Chinese companies and contributed to employment benefits for the Chinese. To armtwist both Central and State PSUs into diverting public funds into such a project is highly objectionable.
 
It appears from this that there has been a complete breakdown of corporate governance in the 19 PSUs referred above. The Audit Committees should have played the role expected of them under Section 177 of the Companies Act and prevented the respective managements from yielding to the diktat of the concerned government. Apparently, they have chosen to acquiesce in it. Under Section 149, the independent directors are required to safeguard the interests of the shareholders but they too seem to have failed in discharging their role.
 
At a time when the ordinary citizen is forced to pay high prices for petroleum products, such irregular expenditure burden on the petroleum PSUs should be looked upon as highly undesirable and regressive.
 
I request you, as the administrative head of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, to order a thorough investigation and consider taking deterrent action against the concerned PSU managements, including the members of the Audit Committees and the other independent directors. Inaction on the part of your Ministry will set a bad precedent for the public sector undertakings in general.
 
Regards,
 
Yours sincerely,
E A S Sarma
Former Secretary to GOI
Visakhapatnam
 
 
Related articles:
Tribal Protests, Black Balloons Cloud Modi’s Unveiling of ‘Statue of Unity’
An Open Letter to Sardar Patel: Medha Patkar

Ex-GOI Secretary criticises gov’t’s move over DNA profiling bill

Letter from former civil servants to Chief Secretary, Haryana on intimidation of Muslims offering namaz

 
 
 
 

Related Articles

Communal Organisations

According to RSS, if you speak Bengali, you are a Bangladeshi: Mohammed Salim

In this interview, Teesta Setalvad speaks to senior CPI(M) leader and ex- MP Mohammed Salim on NRC and its implementation in Bengal and what is the state of minorities currently along with the gradual growth of RSS in West Bengal. They go on to discuss the Ayodhya Verdict, the Kashmir issue and the fear among citizens with respect to their own rights and duties.

Communal Organisations

According to RSS, if you speak Bengali, you are a Bangladeshi: Mohammed Salim

In this interview, Teesta Setalvad speaks to senior CPI(M) leader and ex- MP Mohammed Salim on NRC and its implementation in Bengal and what is the state of minorities currently along with the gradual growth of RSS in West Bengal. They go on to discuss the Ayodhya Verdict, the Kashmir issue and the fear among citizens with respect to their own rights and duties.


Monday

18

Nov

Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi

Saturday

30

Nov

Jana Natya Manch, New Delhi

Thursday

07

Nov

Thrissur, Kerala

Theme

JNU

‘Stand by JNU!’ Solidarity Statements from across the world

A campaign launched by the university’s students and teachers challenging the intolerance of dissent
Ambedkar

Ambedkar and the Sangh Parivar

Repeated attempts by the RSS-driven Sangh Parivar to appropriate Dr BR Ambedkar throw up contradictions and evasions
Hindutva

Hindutva and Democracy

Communalism Combat 9th Anniversary Special
HCU

#Stand with HCU

Solidarity Statements and Video Testimonies

Campaigns

Monday

18

Nov

Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi

Saturday

30

Nov

Jana Natya Manch, New Delhi

Thursday

07

Nov

12 am onwards

Vibgyor Film Collective

Thrissur, Kerala

Videos

Freedom

Stop Nationwide NRC: Activists gather in Protest

On 13th November, Molded and Minority Development Council organised a meeting to oppose the nationwide implementation of NRC and Citizenship Amendment Bill. The meeting was attended by progressive politicians and Activists.

Freedom

Stop Nationwide NRC: Activists gather in Protest

On 13th November, Molded and Minority Development Council organised a meeting to oppose the nationwide implementation of NRC and Citizenship Amendment Bill. The meeting was attended by progressive politicians and Activists.

Analysis

JNU

‘Stand by JNU!’ Solidarity Statements from across the world

A campaign launched by the university’s students and teachers challenging the intolerance of dissent
Ambedkar

Ambedkar and the Sangh Parivar

Repeated attempts by the RSS-driven Sangh Parivar to appropriate Dr BR Ambedkar throw up contradictions and evasions
Hindutva

Hindutva and Democracy

Communalism Combat 9th Anniversary Special
HCU

#Stand with HCU

Solidarity Statements and Video Testimonies

Archives