Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Environment Politics

Protest in ‘Struggle To Save Aarey ‘ in Mumbai

Harsh Thakor 26 Aug 2022

Aarey

On 21st August, A protest demonstration was staged at Picnichen Spot, Opp Shaheed Birsa Munda Statue, Aarey forest, Mumbai. It opposed the present Maharashtra Government of Shinde-Fadnavis in installing Metro 3 depot at Aarey and to project the truth behind depot politics and land scam.

More than 500 persons protested, from a broad strata of society.. Students,  Dalits,  Adivasis and activists of many NGOs, Political Parties. and social organisations. participated. The main participant was Army. An important role has also been played by activists of Disha Students group, Naujwan Bharat Sabha and Bigul Mazdoor dasta like Avinash Bittu and Baban.

Around three weeks ago being embarrassed to the core  from the growing youth protest, the fascist Shinde-Fadnavis government issued instructions to brutally subvert  every initiative  to organize people against the illegal destruction of Aarey Forest.

Avinash, a first year M.A. student of Philosophy from Mumbai University and member of Disha Students’ Organization and Dr. Pooja, an occupational therapist and member of Progressive Doctors’ League, both constituent organizations of the Save Aarey Joint Action Committee hade been detained at Aarey Police Station along with 11 other local residents and environmental activists.

THE TRUTH BEHIND THE DEPOT POLITICS

  • The Kanjur depot plot measures 41 ha (102 acres).
  • If an integrated depot for Line 3, 6 and upcoming Line 4&14 is planned at Kanjur, then the entire plot will be consumed by the Metro. This also eliminates the need for Aarey or land in Thane.(pg48)
  • If Metro 3 depot plot is shifted to Aarey and Line 4 uses land in Thane, then Metro 6 only requires 15 ha (37 acres) leaving the balance area of nearly 26ha (65 acres) open to residential and/or commercial development.
  • Denying Kanjur land for Metro 3 paves the way for the exploitation of balance areas of the plots in Aarey and Kanjur under the disguise of ‘ancillary development’. The plot chosen in Thane also becomes vulnerable. (pg 32-33)
  • An area of 165 ha in Aarey has also been exempted thus adding more lands to be exploited (pg 8,9)
  • Taking into account the available FSI, the plot areas of Aarey and Kanjur and the current ready reckoner rates, the monetary potential of just these two plots touches One lakh crores!

Thus Aarey became the egg  or hub of this real estate extravaganza.

Unfortunately this scam which will only benefit a few, has been used to stall the work of critical metro lines and delaying them.

The people backing this distorted decision are answerable if it is in Mumbai’s interest to

  • Forfeit an important forested area like Aarey?
  • Suffer delay in completion of the Mumbai Metro network?
  • Deprive Mumbaikars of better connectivity between the various lines and dismantle the

Convenient linkage of suburbs like Powai, Thane, Badlapur to Western suburbs and South

Mumbai

  • Suffer loss of land, time and hard -earned taxpayers money.

What is the motive behind this? Thirst for Profits to quench greed for the real estate groups and associated lobbyists?

_Slogans were vociferously raised ’Stop LiesToSupremeCourt  ,‘SaveAareyForest’   ‘Save Indigeneous People’  ‘SaveAdivasis ‘  ‘Adivasi LivesMatter’   ‘SaveMumbaikar ‘ SaveAaarey ‘Save Nature ‘ ‘ShiftMetroCarShed3ToKanjurMarg’,  ‘AareyDepotIs LandScam ‘  ‘JaiBhimLalSalaam’  ‘Inquilab Zindabad

Background to ‘Save Aarey.Movement

The struggle to save Aarey Forest has been going on for a considerable period time now and the movement has received support from individuals and organizations encompassing the country and the world At its current stage, an obstacle is created by from the Environmental approach of NGO’s of several individuals, many of whom happily continue to blow their trumpet n their social media profiles of having received awards from Uddhav Thackeray and Devendra Fadnavis. For these people, ‘environmentalism’ is a business – they raise funds for their ‘activism’ from various corporates, resort to crowd funding if the issue is a popular one and also ‘partner’ with the government whenever possible. They simply fail to gauge the base of bankruptcy of ruling class politics. The movement’s seeds were planted in response to the State deciding to allot public hand in order to benefit a handful of capitalists and real estate barons. The ‘metro car shed’ in Aarey is a façade which allows the state to pretend as if the project is in public interest when the real purpose is in fact to allow the builders and developers to come in through the backdoor. The lives of over 1100 species of plants and animals hang in jeopardy  to allow them to develop luxury apartments providing great aerial views of Sanjay Gandhi National Park, facilitating  the rich the pleasure of living ‘close to nature’. Each such flat will sell for Crores of rupees making every tree felled and animal killed for the purpose worth the effort. It is because such powerful interests are at stake that this plan has crystallised in such a determined and organized manner, despite all government reports and public protests advising against the measure. In their thirst for power, each party – whether it is the BJP, Shiv Sena, MNS, Congress, NCP, or VBA – cut throats of each other projecting itself as the superior alternative.. These parties never promote welfare for the environment. Their “concern lays only within the boundaries of their material interests. No matter which party reaches to the chair the funds which steer them to power invariably comes from the wealthy – the capitalists, builder-developers, corporates and real estate moguls. As soon as they gain seat of power, they will first try to appease their bosses – those capitalists who have patronised them to reach this destination – and in fact, that is their only purpose. They get to enjoy the privileges of power only so long as they are faithfully bootlick their bosses (and this is precisely what happened when the Fadnavis government came to power). Once the political class takes a decision to please it the task of enforcing this decision falls on the executive .Here the police intervenes s to ensure that the dictates of the ruling class are obeyed and that all voices of dissent are suppressed. In such a situation, all foolish tactics such as as garlanding, pleading, giving roses to or prostrating before the police are purposeless.

In addition to such stupidity, some “NGO environmentalists” endorse great faith in legalism and seriously believe that the courts will come to their rescue. When the movement is steered on the course of independent political direction and the people are united, the authoritarian behaviour of the judiciary is checked and the courts act in people’s interest. However, when the movement is weak and confused as it is now, it is clear to even the layman that the court will mainly act to crush any remnant of the movements or stall until such a point where it basically achieves its goal and the legal fight is rendered baseless. Only by establishing the power of the people can the movement can succeed. As of today however, the movement is veering towards the opposite direction. The NGO Environmentalists, following the doctrine of “An enemy’s enemy is a friend” is looking to appease as many opposition political parties as it can. But the truth is that every political party which has come to power in Maharashtra has endorsed the destruction of the Aarey forest! Even though some parties may make claims to support the movement to Save Aarey at present it is important to remember the history of these political parties’ actions when in power in the past .The nexus between the BJP, Congress and ShivSena in executing many a project jointly is an ideal illustration in recent decades.

Democratic intellectuals need to be brought in the forefront of this struggle .Workers  and peasants must grasp the inter relation between such developments and their day to day lives and its link with liberalisation and globalisation.. The focus in the movement is in garnering forces to confront the neo-fascist BJP.Postive to witness how the ruling calluses are shaken by the youth protests of ‘Save Aarey.’ agitation.

Harsh Thakor is a freelance Journalist who covers mass movements all around the country.

Courtesy: https://countercurrents.org

Protest in ‘Struggle To Save Aarey ‘ in Mumbai

Aarey

On 21st August, A protest demonstration was staged at Picnichen Spot, Opp Shaheed Birsa Munda Statue, Aarey forest, Mumbai. It opposed the present Maharashtra Government of Shinde-Fadnavis in installing Metro 3 depot at Aarey and to project the truth behind depot politics and land scam.

More than 500 persons protested, from a broad strata of society.. Students,  Dalits,  Adivasis and activists of many NGOs, Political Parties. and social organisations. participated. The main participant was Army. An important role has also been played by activists of Disha Students group, Naujwan Bharat Sabha and Bigul Mazdoor dasta like Avinash Bittu and Baban.

Around three weeks ago being embarrassed to the core  from the growing youth protest, the fascist Shinde-Fadnavis government issued instructions to brutally subvert  every initiative  to organize people against the illegal destruction of Aarey Forest.

Avinash, a first year M.A. student of Philosophy from Mumbai University and member of Disha Students’ Organization and Dr. Pooja, an occupational therapist and member of Progressive Doctors’ League, both constituent organizations of the Save Aarey Joint Action Committee hade been detained at Aarey Police Station along with 11 other local residents and environmental activists.

THE TRUTH BEHIND THE DEPOT POLITICS

  • The Kanjur depot plot measures 41 ha (102 acres).
  • If an integrated depot for Line 3, 6 and upcoming Line 4&14 is planned at Kanjur, then the entire plot will be consumed by the Metro. This also eliminates the need for Aarey or land in Thane.(pg48)
  • If Metro 3 depot plot is shifted to Aarey and Line 4 uses land in Thane, then Metro 6 only requires 15 ha (37 acres) leaving the balance area of nearly 26ha (65 acres) open to residential and/or commercial development.
  • Denying Kanjur land for Metro 3 paves the way for the exploitation of balance areas of the plots in Aarey and Kanjur under the disguise of ‘ancillary development’. The plot chosen in Thane also becomes vulnerable. (pg 32-33)
  • An area of 165 ha in Aarey has also been exempted thus adding more lands to be exploited (pg 8,9)
  • Taking into account the available FSI, the plot areas of Aarey and Kanjur and the current ready reckoner rates, the monetary potential of just these two plots touches One lakh crores!

Thus Aarey became the egg  or hub of this real estate extravaganza.

Unfortunately this scam which will only benefit a few, has been used to stall the work of critical metro lines and delaying them.

The people backing this distorted decision are answerable if it is in Mumbai’s interest to

  • Forfeit an important forested area like Aarey?
  • Suffer delay in completion of the Mumbai Metro network?
  • Deprive Mumbaikars of better connectivity between the various lines and dismantle the

Convenient linkage of suburbs like Powai, Thane, Badlapur to Western suburbs and South

Mumbai

  • Suffer loss of land, time and hard -earned taxpayers money.

What is the motive behind this? Thirst for Profits to quench greed for the real estate groups and associated lobbyists?

_Slogans were vociferously raised ’Stop LiesToSupremeCourt  ,‘SaveAareyForest’   ‘Save Indigeneous People’  ‘SaveAdivasis ‘  ‘Adivasi LivesMatter’   ‘SaveMumbaikar ‘ SaveAaarey ‘Save Nature ‘ ‘ShiftMetroCarShed3ToKanjurMarg’,  ‘AareyDepotIs LandScam ‘  ‘JaiBhimLalSalaam’  ‘Inquilab Zindabad

Background to ‘Save Aarey.Movement

The struggle to save Aarey Forest has been going on for a considerable period time now and the movement has received support from individuals and organizations encompassing the country and the world At its current stage, an obstacle is created by from the Environmental approach of NGO’s of several individuals, many of whom happily continue to blow their trumpet n their social media profiles of having received awards from Uddhav Thackeray and Devendra Fadnavis. For these people, ‘environmentalism’ is a business – they raise funds for their ‘activism’ from various corporates, resort to crowd funding if the issue is a popular one and also ‘partner’ with the government whenever possible. They simply fail to gauge the base of bankruptcy of ruling class politics. The movement’s seeds were planted in response to the State deciding to allot public hand in order to benefit a handful of capitalists and real estate barons. The ‘metro car shed’ in Aarey is a façade which allows the state to pretend as if the project is in public interest when the real purpose is in fact to allow the builders and developers to come in through the backdoor. The lives of over 1100 species of plants and animals hang in jeopardy  to allow them to develop luxury apartments providing great aerial views of Sanjay Gandhi National Park, facilitating  the rich the pleasure of living ‘close to nature’. Each such flat will sell for Crores of rupees making every tree felled and animal killed for the purpose worth the effort. It is because such powerful interests are at stake that this plan has crystallised in such a determined and organized manner, despite all government reports and public protests advising against the measure. In their thirst for power, each party – whether it is the BJP, Shiv Sena, MNS, Congress, NCP, or VBA – cut throats of each other projecting itself as the superior alternative.. These parties never promote welfare for the environment. Their “concern lays only within the boundaries of their material interests. No matter which party reaches to the chair the funds which steer them to power invariably comes from the wealthy – the capitalists, builder-developers, corporates and real estate moguls. As soon as they gain seat of power, they will first try to appease their bosses – those capitalists who have patronised them to reach this destination – and in fact, that is their only purpose. They get to enjoy the privileges of power only so long as they are faithfully bootlick their bosses (and this is precisely what happened when the Fadnavis government came to power). Once the political class takes a decision to please it the task of enforcing this decision falls on the executive .Here the police intervenes s to ensure that the dictates of the ruling class are obeyed and that all voices of dissent are suppressed. In such a situation, all foolish tactics such as as garlanding, pleading, giving roses to or prostrating before the police are purposeless.

In addition to such stupidity, some “NGO environmentalists” endorse great faith in legalism and seriously believe that the courts will come to their rescue. When the movement is steered on the course of independent political direction and the people are united, the authoritarian behaviour of the judiciary is checked and the courts act in people’s interest. However, when the movement is weak and confused as it is now, it is clear to even the layman that the court will mainly act to crush any remnant of the movements or stall until such a point where it basically achieves its goal and the legal fight is rendered baseless. Only by establishing the power of the people can the movement can succeed. As of today however, the movement is veering towards the opposite direction. The NGO Environmentalists, following the doctrine of “An enemy’s enemy is a friend” is looking to appease as many opposition political parties as it can. But the truth is that every political party which has come to power in Maharashtra has endorsed the destruction of the Aarey forest! Even though some parties may make claims to support the movement to Save Aarey at present it is important to remember the history of these political parties’ actions when in power in the past .The nexus between the BJP, Congress and ShivSena in executing many a project jointly is an ideal illustration in recent decades.

Democratic intellectuals need to be brought in the forefront of this struggle .Workers  and peasants must grasp the inter relation between such developments and their day to day lives and its link with liberalisation and globalisation.. The focus in the movement is in garnering forces to confront the neo-fascist BJP.Postive to witness how the ruling calluses are shaken by the youth protests of ‘Save Aarey.’ agitation.

Harsh Thakor is a freelance Journalist who covers mass movements all around the country.

Courtesy: https://countercurrents.org

Related Articles

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Theme

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Campaigns

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

IN FACT

Analysis

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Archives