Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Health Rule of Law

Tablighi Jamaat case: Bandra Court discharges 12 foreign nationals 

Court notes that the Indonesian men didn’t disobey orders or negligently spread Covid1-19

Sabrangindia 13 Oct 2020

Tablighi jamaat

Twelve foreign nationals from Indonesia who had come to India in February this year to attend the Tablighi Jamaat event in Delhi were discharged by the Bandra Metropolitan Magistrate’s Court on September 29, 2020. The Foreign nationals had filed a discharge application through their lawyer Ishrat Khan before the Court on September 8.

Metropolitan Magistrate Jaydeo Y. Ghule noted that nothing reveals that theaccused had deliberately disobeyed the order duly promulgated by the Public Servant as well as negligently, they were acting in the manner as was likely to spread the infection of the disease dangerous to life." The court also directed the accused to be discharged from all charges levelled against them, to return their seized passports with due identification and cancel their bail bond.

In August, the police had submitted a chargesheet against them and dropped the more serious sections under Indian Penal Code sections 304 (II) (culpable homicide not amounting to murder) and 307 (attempt to murder). The less serious charges under the Epidemic Diseases Act, the Foreigners Act, and Disaster Management Act were however retained.

The discharge plea stated that the delegates had arrived in Delhi in different batches on February 29, March 2 and March 6, 2020. Thereafter, all the accused left Delhi by train and reached Mumbai on March 7, 2020. At the time, all those who had assembled at the Tablighi Jamaat Markaz in Delhi’s Nizamuddin were tested when they reached the other places across the country. Some of them tested positive for Covid. Likewise, when the 12 members arrived in Mumbai, they were also sent to a quarantine centre in Mumbai and tested for the virus where 10 were tested negative and two were found positive for the virus.

The Counsel relied upon the ruling of Bombay High Court in the case of Konan Kodio Ganstone and ors. v. State of Maharashtra [Criminal Writ Petition No. 548/2020] and submitted that the Bombay High Court discharged the accused of the same offences in the said matter, after giving detailed reasons.

The court observed that even the Investigating Officer in Form 5E has acknowledged that the accused were not liable in spreading Covid or caused the death of any person. Under section 14(b) of the Foreigners Act, the court also noted that the accused were not responsible for any breach of their VISA condition.

The news about Tablighi Jamaat attendees’ irresponsible behaviour in the pandemic has been doing the rounds since March but the Hon’ble High Courts have offered some glimmer of hope.

Bombay High Court

On August 21, 2020 the Division bench of Justices T.V. Nalawade and M.G. Sewlikar quashed FIRs registered against 29 foreign nationals and six Indian citizens. The court said that though certain restrictions are put on the foreigners who come to India on tourist visas, there is no restriction on them to visit religious places to attend the normal religious activities like attending religious discourse. It further noted that all the foreign nationals entered India on a valid tourist visa in February or in March, but before March 10. “Activity of Tablighi Jamaat got stalled only after declaration of lock down in Delhi and till then it was going on. There is nothing on the record to show that this activity is prohibited permanently by the Government. These things need to be kept in mind while considering the cases filed against the petitioners,” noted the court.

The court also recognised the criminalisation of foreign nationals through news platforms and the malicious intent behind the FIR’s. “There was big propaganda in print media and electronic media against the foreigners who had come to Markaz Delhi and an attempt was made to create a picture that these foreigners were responsible for spreading covid-19 virus in India. There was virtually persecution against these foreigners. A political Government tries to find the scapegoat when there is pandemic or calamity and the circumstances show that there is probability that these foreigners were chosen to make them scapegoats,” the Bench commented.

A broader and more detailed analysis of this judgment may be read here.

Madras High Court

On June 12, 2020 the Madras High Court granted bail to 31 participants and directed to release the petitioners on their own bond that can be submitted online before a magistrate. The applicants were arrested in April for participating in the religious congregation in violation of the lockdown. The Single Judge Bench of Justice G.R. Swaminathan said that “They are normal human beings. They are now stuck in alien surroundings. The petitioners came here propelled by a sense of religious idealism. But their mission went awry. They are now eager to go back to their families.” Noting the petitioners have been in prison for more than two months, the bench remarked their “acts have not prejudiced public tranquillity.”

Allahabad High Court

On June 9, 2020 the Allahabad High Court granted interim Bail to six Bangladeshi nationals while granting permission to reside at the place mentioned in the tourist Visas and were given liberty to receive disclosed financial support from their relatives in Bangladesh or anyone in India and if necessary, directed the government to provide them financial support. The court also suggested that the Centre enter into a dialogue with the Government of Bangladesh and decide upon the criminal case without having to resort to a criminal trial, to avoid the same.

On October 5, 2020 the Allahabad High Court had ordered that the criminal cases against members of the Tablighi Jamaat registered in different districts of Uttar Pradesh be heard by three Chief Judicial Magistrates (CJM) of Lucknow, Bareilly and Meerut. In an order passed by a Division Bench comprising Justices Shashi Kant Gupta and Shamim Ahmed, the court observed that all the cases against the Jamaat members be heard and decided by the three CJM courts within eight weeks. The Bench ordered that the Registrar General monitor the progress of the cases transferred to the CJMs and submit a report within three months to the Allahabad High Court Chief Justice as reported by The Indian Express.


The order may be read here:

 

Related:

Tablighi Jamaat members still under the scanner

How courts rescued Tablighi Jamaat members from further hatred

Tablighi Jamaat: HCs come to rescue of foreign nationals, grant bail

Tablighi Jamaat case: Bandra Court discharges 12 foreign nationals 

Court notes that the Indonesian men didn’t disobey orders or negligently spread Covid1-19

Tablighi jamaat

Twelve foreign nationals from Indonesia who had come to India in February this year to attend the Tablighi Jamaat event in Delhi were discharged by the Bandra Metropolitan Magistrate’s Court on September 29, 2020. The Foreign nationals had filed a discharge application through their lawyer Ishrat Khan before the Court on September 8.

Metropolitan Magistrate Jaydeo Y. Ghule noted that nothing reveals that theaccused had deliberately disobeyed the order duly promulgated by the Public Servant as well as negligently, they were acting in the manner as was likely to spread the infection of the disease dangerous to life." The court also directed the accused to be discharged from all charges levelled against them, to return their seized passports with due identification and cancel their bail bond.

In August, the police had submitted a chargesheet against them and dropped the more serious sections under Indian Penal Code sections 304 (II) (culpable homicide not amounting to murder) and 307 (attempt to murder). The less serious charges under the Epidemic Diseases Act, the Foreigners Act, and Disaster Management Act were however retained.

The discharge plea stated that the delegates had arrived in Delhi in different batches on February 29, March 2 and March 6, 2020. Thereafter, all the accused left Delhi by train and reached Mumbai on March 7, 2020. At the time, all those who had assembled at the Tablighi Jamaat Markaz in Delhi’s Nizamuddin were tested when they reached the other places across the country. Some of them tested positive for Covid. Likewise, when the 12 members arrived in Mumbai, they were also sent to a quarantine centre in Mumbai and tested for the virus where 10 were tested negative and two were found positive for the virus.

The Counsel relied upon the ruling of Bombay High Court in the case of Konan Kodio Ganstone and ors. v. State of Maharashtra [Criminal Writ Petition No. 548/2020] and submitted that the Bombay High Court discharged the accused of the same offences in the said matter, after giving detailed reasons.

The court observed that even the Investigating Officer in Form 5E has acknowledged that the accused were not liable in spreading Covid or caused the death of any person. Under section 14(b) of the Foreigners Act, the court also noted that the accused were not responsible for any breach of their VISA condition.

The news about Tablighi Jamaat attendees’ irresponsible behaviour in the pandemic has been doing the rounds since March but the Hon’ble High Courts have offered some glimmer of hope.

Bombay High Court

On August 21, 2020 the Division bench of Justices T.V. Nalawade and M.G. Sewlikar quashed FIRs registered against 29 foreign nationals and six Indian citizens. The court said that though certain restrictions are put on the foreigners who come to India on tourist visas, there is no restriction on them to visit religious places to attend the normal religious activities like attending religious discourse. It further noted that all the foreign nationals entered India on a valid tourist visa in February or in March, but before March 10. “Activity of Tablighi Jamaat got stalled only after declaration of lock down in Delhi and till then it was going on. There is nothing on the record to show that this activity is prohibited permanently by the Government. These things need to be kept in mind while considering the cases filed against the petitioners,” noted the court.

The court also recognised the criminalisation of foreign nationals through news platforms and the malicious intent behind the FIR’s. “There was big propaganda in print media and electronic media against the foreigners who had come to Markaz Delhi and an attempt was made to create a picture that these foreigners were responsible for spreading covid-19 virus in India. There was virtually persecution against these foreigners. A political Government tries to find the scapegoat when there is pandemic or calamity and the circumstances show that there is probability that these foreigners were chosen to make them scapegoats,” the Bench commented.

A broader and more detailed analysis of this judgment may be read here.

Madras High Court

On June 12, 2020 the Madras High Court granted bail to 31 participants and directed to release the petitioners on their own bond that can be submitted online before a magistrate. The applicants were arrested in April for participating in the religious congregation in violation of the lockdown. The Single Judge Bench of Justice G.R. Swaminathan said that “They are normal human beings. They are now stuck in alien surroundings. The petitioners came here propelled by a sense of religious idealism. But their mission went awry. They are now eager to go back to their families.” Noting the petitioners have been in prison for more than two months, the bench remarked their “acts have not prejudiced public tranquillity.”

Allahabad High Court

On June 9, 2020 the Allahabad High Court granted interim Bail to six Bangladeshi nationals while granting permission to reside at the place mentioned in the tourist Visas and were given liberty to receive disclosed financial support from their relatives in Bangladesh or anyone in India and if necessary, directed the government to provide them financial support. The court also suggested that the Centre enter into a dialogue with the Government of Bangladesh and decide upon the criminal case without having to resort to a criminal trial, to avoid the same.

On October 5, 2020 the Allahabad High Court had ordered that the criminal cases against members of the Tablighi Jamaat registered in different districts of Uttar Pradesh be heard by three Chief Judicial Magistrates (CJM) of Lucknow, Bareilly and Meerut. In an order passed by a Division Bench comprising Justices Shashi Kant Gupta and Shamim Ahmed, the court observed that all the cases against the Jamaat members be heard and decided by the three CJM courts within eight weeks. The Bench ordered that the Registrar General monitor the progress of the cases transferred to the CJMs and submit a report within three months to the Allahabad High Court Chief Justice as reported by The Indian Express.


The order may be read here:

 

Related:

Tablighi Jamaat members still under the scanner

How courts rescued Tablighi Jamaat members from further hatred

Tablighi Jamaat: HCs come to rescue of foreign nationals, grant bail

Related Articles

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Thursday

05

Nov

Pan India

Wednesday

14

Oct

11 am onwards

Not an Inch Back!

Main Gate KG-Campus

Theme

Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.
Delhi HC

Hate Speech and Delhi Pogrom 2020

A spate of provocative speeches, that amount to hate speech in law and should be prosecuted allowed blood letting to spill on the streets of north east Delhi in February-March 2020
hashimpura

Hashimpura Massacre

The Lemmings of Hashimpura
summer

Summer Culture

Our first summer culture bouquet features fiction from Syria and Iraq and poetry and art from Palestine.

Campaigns

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Thursday

05

Nov

10 am onwards

All India road blockade

Pan India

Wednesday

14

Oct

11 am onwards

Not an Inch Back!

Main Gate KG-Campus

Videos

Communalism

How Ekal Vidyalayas are helping hindutva nationalists grow deep roots in Bengal

Watch this sabrangindia exclusive to know how the one-teacher Ekal Vidyalayas, running on temples and unclaimed open spaces, in impoverished villages, have quietly helped the Hindutva nationalists grow deep roots in Bengal. And how they are promoting brahminical ideas of religion amongst an unsuspecting population by promising free education.

Communalism

How Ekal Vidyalayas are helping hindutva nationalists grow deep roots in Bengal

Watch this sabrangindia exclusive to know how the one-teacher Ekal Vidyalayas, running on temples and unclaimed open spaces, in impoverished villages, have quietly helped the Hindutva nationalists grow deep roots in Bengal. And how they are promoting brahminical ideas of religion amongst an unsuspecting population by promising free education.

IN FACT

Analysis

Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.
Delhi HC

Hate Speech and Delhi Pogrom 2020

A spate of provocative speeches, that amount to hate speech in law and should be prosecuted allowed blood letting to spill on the streets of north east Delhi in February-March 2020
hashimpura

Hashimpura Massacre

The Lemmings of Hashimpura
summer

Summer Culture

Our first summer culture bouquet features fiction from Syria and Iraq and poetry and art from Palestine.

Archives