Politics | SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/category/politics/ News Related to Human Rights Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:43:21 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png Politics | SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/category/politics/ 32 32 Rajasthan SSR draft lists 11.67 lakh more voters than SIR roll, but count still 18 lakhs below State Election Commission count https://sabrangindia.in/rajasthan-ssr-draft-lists-11-67-lakh-more-voters-than-sir-roll-but-count-still-18-lakhs-below-state-election-commission-count/ Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:43:21 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50144 Published on November 12, Rajasthan’s Special Summary Revision (SSR) 2027 draft lists 5.26 crore electors, compared with 5.15 crore after the SIR in February and 5.45 crore in the State Election Commission’s October roll, leaving substantial differences unexplained

The post Rajasthan SSR draft lists 11.67 lakh more voters than SIR roll, but count still 18 lakhs below State Election Commission count appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Rajasthan’s draft electoral roll published on November 12 under the Special Summary Revision (SSR) 2027 has once again brought the state’s voter count into focus. The draft lists 5,26,67,416 electors, around 11.67 lakh more than the 5.15 crore recorded in the final and controversial Special Intensive Revision (SIR) roll published in February 2026. However, the figure remains around 18.33 lakh below the 5.45 crore electors recorded in the State Election Commission’s (SEC) final roll in October.

The difference between the three figures is close to 30 lakh voters. Although the rolls were prepared by different election authorities and for different elections, the variation raises questions about their authenticity, integrity of coverage/inclusion, the basis of their preparation and how the figures were arrived at.

The latest revision also comes amid continuing scrutiny of the ECI’s SIR exercise across the country, particularly over the large number of names removed from draft electoral rolls and concerns about the process through which voters were identified for deletion.

Three different voter counts in Rajasthan

The February 2026 SIR final roll recorded approximately 5.15 crore electors. This followed the intensive revision undertaken by the ECI, during which existing electors were required to submit enumeration forms for verification.

During the Local Body Elections, the State Election Commission’s final electoral roll published in October 2026 recorded 5.45 crore electors. This was around 30 lakh higher than the February SIR figure.

The latest ECI draft, published on November 12, contains 5,26,67,416 electors. According to Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) Naveen Mahajan, this includes 2,75,24,780 male voters, 2,51,42,052 female voters and 584 transgender voters.

The three figures do not represent successive versions of a single electoral roll. The ECI prepares electoral rolls for parliamentary and Assembly elections, while the State Election Commission is responsible for elections to local bodies, including panchayats and urban local bodies.

However, the difference between the October SEC count and the November ECI draft remains significant. The fact that the rolls are maintained by separate authorities does not, by itself, explain a difference of more than 18 lakh electors. Their respective reference dates, coverage, sources of voter data and methods of updating entries need to be examined.

A district-wise and Assembly constituency-wise comparison of the three rolls would help establish where the differences arise. It would also clarify whether the variation is linked to geographical coverage, different qualifying dates, additions and deletions or other factors in the preparation of the rolls.

Rajasthan’s SIR figures and the questions that remain

The SIR exercise in Rajasthan had itself resulted in a substantial change in the state’s electoral records. The February final roll, at approximately 5.15 crore, became the baseline against which subsequent changes could be examined.

The latest SSR draft has increased that figure, but it does not provide a detailed reconciliation of the names removed during the SIR and those subsequently added. Nor does the headline figure explain whether voters who could not establish their eligibility during the intensive exercise have returned to the list through the ordinary enrolment process.

This is particularly relevant in light of the ECI’s September 29 instructions asking states to identify eligible voters who may have been left out during the SIR. The special drive was intended to provide an avenue for their enrolment through Form 6, without applying the additional declaration introduced for the SIR exercise.

The questions are therefore not limited to the overall increase in the SSR draft. How many names were added after the February final roll? How many were deleted during the current revision? How many applications came from voters who had been excluded during the SIR? And how many of those applications were accepted?

The draft figure alone does not answer these questions. Without the corresponding data, it is difficult to assess the extent to which the latest revision has addressed the concerns arising from the earlier exercise.

Claims and objections open until December 11

The claims and objections period for the Rajasthan SSR draft runs from November 12 to December 11. The final electoral roll is scheduled to be published on January 4, 2027.

Eligible citizens can apply for inclusion through Form 6, while Form 7 can be used to raise objections to entries and seek deletion in accordance with the prescribed procedure. Form 8 is meant for corrections and other changes to existing electoral entries.

The ECI has also allowed advance applications from young citizens who will attain the age of 18 on the subsequent qualifying dates in 2027. Applications can be submitted through the ECINet app, the Voters’ Portal or through the respective Booth Level Officers.

The CEO’s office has stated that copies of the draft rolls have been provided to recognised political parties and that voters can access the lists through the CEO Rajasthan and District Election Officer websites.

However, the opportunity to file claims and objections does not replace the need for the authorities to explain the differences between the existing electoral records. The publication of district-wise and constituency-wise comparative data, along with a clear account of additions and deletions, would allow political parties and voters to examine the changes rather than rely only on the overall figures.

SSR follows scrutiny over SIR deletions

The ECI announced the SSR on October 15, 2026, for 17 states and Union Territories, including Rajasthan, where the SIR had already been completed. The sole reasons behind this announcements were the huge controversies, outrage and public protests around mass exclusions in the SIR post September 2026. The annual summary revision had been skipped in 2026 as the Commission was undertaking the SIR in phases across the country.

The announcement came after the SIR process faced criticism over the scale of deletions. An investigation by The Indian Express, reported that more than 13 crore names had been removed from draft electoral rolls across 30 states and Union Territories. It also reported that two Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had raised objections within the Commission over changes to Form 6 and the centralised control of the ECINet electoral database.

A few days later, on September 29, the ECI instructed states where the SIR had been completed to undertake a special drive to enrol eligible voters who may have been left out, along with young and first-time electors. Officials were also asked to compare pre-SIR and post-SIR rolls and identify voters who might have been excluded despite not being deceased, permanently shifted or duplicates.

The Commission subsequently announced the SSR, stating that the exercise would facilitate the enrolment of eligible electors for the January 1, 2027 qualifying date, while also allowing advance applications from those who would become eligible on April 1, July 1 and October 1, 2027.

Under the SSR, the existing electoral roll is carried forward as the basis for revision. Unlike the SIR, which required existing electors to submit enumeration forms and undergo verification, the summary revision does not require every voter to establish their eligibility afresh. Eligible new voters can seek inclusion, while deletions and corrections are processed through the prescribed procedure.

The distinction is important in Rajasthan, where the new draft has added around 11.67 lakh names to the February SIR figure. However, the increase alone does not establish how many of these electors are first-time voters, people who were left out during the SIR or voters added through other updates. A detailed account of the additions and deletions during the current revision would help clarify this.

Rajasthan now has three official voter counts within less than a year: approximately 5.15 crore in the February SIR final roll, 5.45 crore in the October SEC roll and 5.26 crore in the November SSR draft. The differences do not, on their own, establish wrongful inclusion or exclusion. But in the wake of the concerns raised during the SIR, the ECI needs to explain how the latest figure has been arrived at and how the voters missing from the earlier roll have been accounted for. The final SSR roll in January will provide another count; what remains necessary is a transparent comparison of the figures that preceded it.

Related:

Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule

ECI affidavit says SIR decisions were unanimous, but questions over two commissioners’ objections remain

UP voter lists: Software manipulates Voter’s names, Pilibhit investigation finds 10,470 irregular entries

SIR 2025-26: Dismantling the very Idea of India?

 

 

The post Rajasthan SSR draft lists 11.67 lakh more voters than SIR roll, but count still 18 lakhs below State Election Commission count appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule https://sabrangindia.in/form-6-ecis-assurance-of-no-prosecution-to-deleted-voters-is-a-violation-election-law-rule/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 12:34:18 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50116 In its latest amended affidavit before the Supreme Court (SC) (November 14), the EC has “assured” the court that voters whose names are missing from the draft rolls will not face prosecution for making a false declaration and submitting names for re-inclusion under Form 6; this patch-work solution however is no solution to the violations […]

The post Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
In its latest amended affidavit before the Supreme Court (SC) (November 14), the EC has “assured” the court that voters whose names are missing from the draft rolls will not face prosecution for making a false declaration and submitting names for re-inclusion under Form 6; this patch-work solution however is no solution to the violations this process forces the voter to commit; why does the ECI remain committed to its faulty SIR procedures rather than the clear-cut classifications available for re-inclusion of wrongly deleted voters (public audit), Form 6 (new voters), Form 7 (deletions), Form 8 (changes on name, address, other details)?

ECI’s SIR procedures are violations of both the 2021 amendment to the RPA available through a notification dated June 17, 2022


The Election Commission of India (ECI) has now told the Supreme Court that voters whose names appeared in earlier electoral rolls but are missing from the draft rolls prepared during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) can submit Form 6 for inclusion in the final electoral roll without facing prosecution merely on account of their previous enrolment! However, the ECI remains obdurately committed to a procedure that statutorily involves a “false declaration” by a previous elector. Moreover, the ECI is clearly resistant to nationwide demands to scrap the faulty and exclusionary process of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in its entirety and a reversion to the 2024, pre-SIR electoral rolls.

The assurance, contained in a supplementary affidavit filed on November 14, 2026, comes after apprehensions that such voters could face action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, for submitting a declaration in Form 6 despite having been enrolled earlier.

However, the Commission’s clarification raises a larger question about the procedure being followed for voters who have already been enrolled once. Why should an elector whose name was present in an earlier electoral roll have to seek fresh enrolment through Form 6, a form prescribed for the inclusion of a new elector?

What the ECI has told the Supreme Court

In its supplementary affidavit in Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors., Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1246 of 2026, the ECI stated that some previously enrolled electors whose names did not appear in the draft electoral rolls were hesitant to submit Form 6. The affidavit may be read below this story.

Since September 2026 specifically, but even before the use of Form 6 by the ECI for re-inclusion of voters deleted due to either ineptness or deliberate intent by the ECI has raised nationwide condemnation. Articles on the issue may be read here, here and here.

The criticisms, outrage and apprehensions arose because of the inherent statutory flaw in the SIR that had no reasoning nor basis. Form 6 is prescribed for New Voters alone. Under the SIR, through an annexure to Form 6, a declaration form prescribed required the applicant (older voter who was seeking re-instatement in the rolls) to state that their name is being included in the electoral roll for the first time. This amounts clearly to a false declaration and expose them to prosecution under Section 31 of the 1950 Act, that too for no fault of theirs.  Belatedly responding to this, the Commission issued a clarification through its letter dated November 3, 2026, addressed to the Chief Electoral Officers of all States and Union Territories.

The letter states that an elector whose name does not appear in the draft roll can submit Form 6 to seek inclusion in the final electoral roll, irrespective of whether the person had been enrolled previously. The ECI has maintained that submitting the form in these circumstances is not, by itself, a false declaration merely because the applicant was previously enrolled.

The protection against prosecution is, however, subject to two conditions. The applicant must not already be enrolled in another Parliamentary or Assembly constituency, and the declaration must otherwise be in accordance with law.

The Commission has directed Chief Electoral Officers to publicise this clarification widely, including in local languages. It has also relied on the Delhi High Court’s October 14, 2026 judgment in Nilotpal Datta & Anr. v. Election Commission of India & Ors., in which the Court permitted the petitioners to submit Form 6 for consideration in accordance with law.

Vote for Democracy (VFD) Experts decry this move

Dr Pyarelal Garg, expert associated with the Vote for Democracy (VFD) has sharply decried the move. He has pointed to the statutory framework governing the prescribed forms. The Election Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021, published in the Gazette of India on December 30, 2021, amended the Representation of the People Act, 1950, among other provisions. The subsequent notification issued by the Ministry of Law and Justice on June 17, 2022, introduced amendments to the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. These amendments came into force on August 1, 2022.

The June 17 notification, S.O. 2802(E), substituted Rule 13 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The amended provision makes a distinction between the forms used for different electoral registration purposes, clearly.

The copy of June 17, 2022 notification can be accessed from here

Rule 13(1) provides that every claim for inclusion of a name in the electoral roll as a new elector shall be made in Form 6.

Rule 13(2) provides for Form 7 in cases involving objections to proposed inclusion or applications for deletion of an existing entry.

Rule 13(3) prescribes Form 8 for objections to particulars in an existing entry, shifting of residence and correction or updation of entries.

The distinction is significant. Form 6 is specifically prescribed for a new elector, while the rules provide distinct and separate forms for objections, deletion, shifting and correction of existing entries.

It is this distinction that Dr Garg says the Commission cannot overlook while asking previously enrolled voters, whose names have disappeared during the SIR, to seek fresh enrolment through Form 6.

ECI’s position is a violation of the statutory framework. Speaking to SabrangIndia, Dr Pyaralal Garg strongly criticised the Election Commission’s arguments before the Supreme Court.

In sum, he said, “ECI arguments before SC on Form 6 are further violations of the statutory framework that the Commission is governed under: It is strange (and inexplicable) that the ECI has dared forward these arguments in that are an outright mockery of both the Supreme Court and Parliament! This ‘invitation to committing a crime lays an innocent elector open to threat and inducement.”

Ministry of Law and Justice vide notification dated 17.06.2022 in compliance of amendments to RP Act 1950 notification dated 30.12.2021.” The copy of December 30, 2021 notification can be accessed from there

Separate relief for voters marked ASDD

The supplementary affidavit also details another set of measures announced by the Commission following a suggestion made by the Supreme Court on October 28, 2026, in proceedings concerning the Delhi SIR in Anjali Bhardwaj v. Election Commission of India.

The Court had suggested that the Commission examine ways to reach voters marked Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD), whose names were left out of the draft electoral rolls. Following this, the ECI issued directions on November 6, 2026, to the Chief Electoral Officers of Delhi, Maharashtra, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Jharkhand, Telangana and Nagaland.

Under these directions, booth-wise lists of such electors are to be displayed afresh at polling stations, Panchayat Bhawans and urban local body offices, as well as on the websites of the respective Chief Electoral Officers. The lists must also indicate the probable reasons for non-inclusion.

The Commission has directed electoral officials to make fresh efforts to contact these voters through Booth Level Officers, including by visiting their homes and contacting family members, neighbours and Resident Welfare Associations wherever necessary. Partially filled Enumeration Forms are also to be generated again through the ERO dashboard on ECINET.

Electors who have not shifted residence can submit their signed Enumeration Forms along with a statement explaining why they could not submit the form earlier. These can be submitted to the Electoral Registration Officer, Assistant Electoral Registration Officer or Booth Level Officer, either personally or through family members. An online submission facility with e-signature is also to be made available.

For electors who have shifted residence within the same State, the Commission has provided a separate procedure. They are not required to submit Form 8 for this purpose. Instead, they can submit the Enumeration Form along with a statement giving their new address and Assembly Constituency, supported by address proof, to the ERO or AERO of the new constituency. Homeless persons who do not possess the listed address documents can rely on the BLO’s field verification report.

Importantly, the November 6 directions provide that these Enumeration Forms will be processed by the EROs under Rule 21(1) of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, after verification of eligibility, ordinary residence and other relevant particulars. If accepted, the elector will be assigned the same EPIC number that was held before the SIR.

The ECI has also clarified that an elector who has already submitted Form 6 for fresh enrolment during the SIR need not submit the Enumeration Form again. Their application will be processed under the “November 3 clarification”.

The unresolved question

The supplementary affidavit sets out two different measures: a general clarification allowing previously enrolled voters missing from the draft roll to submit Form 6 without facing prosecution merely because of their earlier enrolment, and a separate procedure for ASDD electors in seven States and Union Territories through the resubmission of Enumeration Forms under Rule 21(1).

While these measures provide additional opportunities for electors to seek inclusion in the final rolls, they do not settle the statutory question raised by VFD that whether Form 6, prescribed for a new elector, is the appropriate route for someone whose name was already included in an earlier electoral roll.

The ECI has maintained that its objective is to ensure that eligible electors are included in the final rolls while preventing duplicate enrolments. In the concluding portion of its affidavit, the Commission acknowledged the challenges arising from the large volume of data involved in the exercise and stated that it remained committed to addressing inconsistencies while ensuring that eligible voters are not left out.

The issue, therefore, is not limited to an assurance against prosecution. It also concerns the procedure through which an elector already recognised in the electoral rolls is required to establish their eligibility again during the SIR.

The affidavit may be read here:

Related:

ECI affidavit says SIR decisions were unanimous, but questions over two commissioners’ objections remain

UP voter lists: Software manipulates Voter’s names, Pilibhit investigation finds 10,470 irregular entries

The post Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG https://sabrangindia.in/tn-cm-vijays-unilateral-decision-to-disband-hlc-into-inter-state-relations-condemned-ccg/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 05:03:07 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50111 A prominent body of former civil servants belonging to both the All-India Services and the Central Services have severely questioned the unilateral decision of the Joseph Vijay-led TVK government in Tamil Nadu (TN)’s to suddenly disband, on November 6, 2026, the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by a former Supreme Court judge, Justice Kurian Joseph that was due to present the second part of its report on May 31, 2027, just seven to eight-months from now.

The post TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG) has seriously questioned the sudden disbanding of the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by a former Supreme Court judge, Justice Kurian Joseph. In an open letter, dated November 14, 2026, written to the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister, C. Joseph Vijay, the collective of former civil servants belonging to the All-India Services and the Central Services, the CCG traces the history and background of an issue that touches upon the crucial issue of Federalism and deepening of Constitutional Values. As many as seventy-two former senior civil servants have signed the letter. 

The HLC had submitted Part I of its report in February 2026 and was working towards bringing out Part II of the report by the scheduled date of 31 May 2027. This sudden move is particularly questionable –says the CCG communication– given that Part I of the Report of the HLC had been widely appreciated by all segments of society — Union government Ministers, politicians from different political parties, including the BJP, academics, leading public intellectuals, the legal fraternity and former civil servants. 

Important areas of federal functioning, including emergency provisions, disaster management, inter-state river water disputes, local government, climate change, environment and forests, Union-State legislative and financial relations, Inter-State Council, All India Judicial Service, Mines & Minerals and Union agencies, were to be covered in Part II of the Report and considerable work on this was already under way.

Background to TN’s Initiatives on Union-State Relations

Elaborating on this sudden decision conveyed to the public through the Government Order (GO) of November 6, the CCG letter analyses how the GO mentions that the now disbanded HLC is non-statutory in nature. But then, the State Law Commission is also an executive body, established by a GO of 1994 and reconstituted subsequently through executive orders. There is no bar on a non-statutory body undertaking an inquiry into centre-state relations and suggesting measures for a healthier and more responsive federal structure. The Tamil Nadu (TN) government had set up the Rajamannar Committee (1969-71) and the Union government had constituted the Sarkaria (1983-88) and Punchhi (2007-10) Commissions for this very purpose through executive orders only. Even the Law Commission of India is not a statutory body but only an executive body.

“A specious and unconvincing justification has been advanced in the November 6, GO that there is similarity or overlap in the nature and scope of the functions entrusted to the HLC and the State Law Commission, states CCG in its open letter. 

The CCG communication traces the rich contribution of Tamil Nadu to the issue of Federalism within the Indian Constitution. It states that the excuse now being advanced of ‘the HLC being a non-statutory body’ has not ‘inhibited successive TN governments from constituting high-level committees to examine issues relating to the legislative relations between the State and Union governments. In any case, there is no evidence on record that the State Law Commission has, in the over three decades of its existence, examined issues relating to Union-State relations nor are any of its past reports available on your government’s website or elsewhere for study and evaluation.’

Moreover, transferring the task of preparation of Part II of the Report from the HLC to the State Law Commission six months before the deadline for its submission is a retrograde step. There is every likelihood of loss of institutional knowledge acquired in the HLC research efforts and inconsistencies in constitutional interpretation and analytical approach. An integrated, coherent analysis of the complex issues involved requires a single body applying its mind. The transfer to the State law Commission will also delay its publication.

Finally CCG states that, “We understand that PDF copies of the English and Tamil versions of Part I of the Report have been removed with unseemly haste from the Tamil Nadu government website. Considering that the reputed international publishing house, Bloomsbury, undertook the publication of Part I, which is perhaps the first of its kind for a Report commissioned by a state government and a testimony to the high quality of the Report, the removal of the Report from the website seems to indicate that the current government seeks to disown the Report commissioned by its predecessor government and shrug off any association with the Report.”

“As former civil servants who have worked closely with the political executive throughout our years of public service, we find it difficult to discern any compelling justification for your Government’s decision. Two possible explanations suggest themselves:

“First, your government may not fully subscribe to the ideal of a genuinely federal democracy, in which power is decentralised to the lowest levels of governance – Gram Panchayats and Municipalities – and higher levels exercise only those functions that cannot be effectively discharged below.

“Second, your government may be reluctant to displease the Union government and the ruling party at the Centre, a government and party that are obsessed with the ideology of an overarching centralisation of Constitutional functions and whose actions over the past few years, including effecting Constitutional changes altering the distribution of powers between the Union and the States, conditional fiscal transfers and rigidly structured centrally sponsored schemes have progressively constrained the financial and administrative autonomy of the States and tilted the federal balance towards the Union.

Finally, the CCG letter dated November 14, 2026 ends in the hope that the TN government “will affirm its commitment to a strong federal democracy, with devolution of powers to local government institutions. Restoring the remit of the High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations to complete its task of bringing out Part II of the Report will be a welcome step in this direction. “

Some of the signatories to the effort are G Balachandran, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt of West Bengal, Vappala Balachandran, IAS (Retd),Former Special Secretary, Cabiner Secretariat, GOI, Rana Banerjee, RAS (Retd), Former Special Secretary, Cabiner Secretariat, GOI, Aurobinda Behra, IAS (Retd), Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt of Odisha, Pradip Bhattacharya, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretaru, Development & Planning and Administrative Training Institute, Govt of West Bengal,  Anna Dani, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt of Maharashtra, Vibha Puri Das, IAS (Retd) Former Secretary, Ministry of Tribal affairs, GoI, MG Devasahayam, IAS (Retd), Former Secretary, Govt of Haryana.

Rest of the Signatories may be viewed here.

Yours sincerely,

Constitutional Conduct Group (72 signatories, as below)

1. Anand Arni RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
2. R. Badri Narayan IRTS (Retd.) Former Chief Administrative Officer, Traffic Transportation & Business  Research Unit, Northern Railway, GoI
3. G. Balachandhran IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
4. Vappala Balachandran IPS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
5. Gopalan Balagopal IAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
6. Sushant Baliga Engineering Services (Retd.) Former Additional Director General, Central PWD, GoI
7. Rana Banerji RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
8. Sharad Behar IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
9. Aurobindo Behera IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Odisha
10. Pradip Bhattacharya IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Development & Planning and Administrative Training Institute, Govt. of West Bengal
11. Nutan Guha Biswas IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Police Complaints Authority, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
12. Ravi Budhiraja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Jawaharlal Nehru Port Trust, GoI
13. R. Chandramohan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary, Transport and Urban Development, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
14. Rachel Chatterjee IAS (Retd.) Former Special Chief Secretary, Agriculture, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
15. Gurjit Singh Cheema IAS (Retd.) Former Financial Commissioner (Revenue), Govt. of Punjab
16. F.T.R. Colaso IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Karnataka & former Director General of Police, Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir
17. Anna Dani IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
18. Vibha Puri Das IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, GoI
19. M.G. Devasahayam IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Govt. of Haryana
20. Renu Sahni Dhar IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Adviser to Chief Minister, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
21. Kiran Dhingra IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Textiles, GoI
22. Suresh K. Goel IFS (Retd.) Former Director General, Indian Council of Cultural Relations, GoI
23. H.S. Gujral IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Govt. of Punjab
24. Meena Gupta IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Environment & Forests, GoI
25. Syed Masood Husain IES (Retd.) Former Chairman, Central Water Commission & ex officio Secretary, Ministry of Jal Shakti, GoI
26. Siraj Hussain IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Department of Agriculture, GoI
27. Mathew John IRTS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Railway Board, GoI
28. Gita Kripalani IRS (Retd.) Former Member, Settlement Commission, GoI
29. Subodh Lal IPoS (Resigned) Former Deputy Director General, Ministry of Communications, GoI
30. P.M.S. Malik IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Myanmar & Special Secretary, MEA, GoI
31. Harsh Mander IAS (Retd.) Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
32. Aditi Mehta IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Rajasthan
33. Sudhansu Mohanty IDAS (Retd.) Former Financial Adviser (Defence Services), Ministry of Defence, GoI
34. Ruchira Mukerjee IP&TAFS (Retd.) Former Advisor (Finance), Telecom Commission, GoI
35. Deb Mukharji IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to Bangladesh and former Ambassador to Nepal
36. Jayashree Mukherjee IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
37. Shiv Shankar Mukherjee IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to the United Kingdom
38. Gautam Mukhopadhaya IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Myanmar
39. Sobha Nambisan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary (Planning), Govt. of Karnataka
40. Ramesh Narayanaswami IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
41. Amitabha Pande IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Inter-State Council, GoI
42. Rajesh Prasad IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to the Netherlands
43. N.K. Raghupathy IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Staff Selection Commission, GoI
44. V.P. Raja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission
45. Venu Rajamony IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to the Netherlands
46. V. Ramani

 

IAS (Retd.) Former Director General, YASHADA, Govt. of Maharashtra
47. Archana Ranjan IRS (Retd.) Former Director General, Central Economic Intelligence Bureau, GoI
48. Madhukumar Reddy A. IRTS (Retd.) Former Principal Executive Director, Railway Board, GoI
49. Julio Ribeiro IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Punjab
50. Manabendra N. Roy IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
51. A.K. Samanta IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police (Intelligence), Govt. of West Bengal
52. Deepak Sanan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Adviser (AR) to Chief Minister, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
53. G.V. Venugopala Sarma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Odisha
54. S. Satyabhama IAS (Retd.) Former Chairperson, National Seeds Corporation, GoI
55. N.C. Saxena IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Planning Commission, GoI
56. A. Selvaraj IRS (Retd.) Former Chief Commissioner, Income Tax, Chennai, GoI
57. Ardhendu Sen IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
58. Abhijit Sengupta IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Culture, GoI
59. Aftab Seth IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Japan
60. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Govt. of Gujarat
61. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Finland and Estonia
62. Navrekha Sharma IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Indonesia
63. Raju Sharma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh
64. Avay Shukla IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary (Forests & Technical Education), Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
65. Mukteshwar Singh IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Madhya Pradesh Public Service Commission
66. Tara Ajai Singh IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Karnataka
67. R. Sreenivasa Murthy IFoS (Retd.) Former Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Member Secretary, MP State Biodiversity Board, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
68. Prakriti Srivastava IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Special Officer, Rebuild Kerala Development Programme, Govt. of Kerala
69. Anup Thakur IAS (Retd.) Former Member, National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
70. P.S.S. Thomas IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary General, National Human Rights Commission
71. Geetha Thoopal IRAS (Retd.) Former General Manager, Metro Railway, Kolkata
72. Rudi Warjri IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Colombia, Ecuador and Costa Rica

 

The post TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence https://sabrangindia.in/srfti-under-siege-alifa-demands-vcs-removal-independent-inquiry-into-campus-violence/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 05:04:26 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50098 13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for […]

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for a free and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September; prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones, recall of rustication orders, withdrawal of orders enforcing academic closure, removal of police presence on campus, a full-time Vice Chancellor for the institute and protection of the right to protest peacefully. 

For 40 days now, the SRFTI campus has been under a siege-like situation, with increasing police presence, and academic activity suspended till 11th December, 2026. The circumstances have placed students under immense stress, with women and transgender students at the receiving end of sexual harassment and trauma. This is on top of the expulsion of six students on the 15th October, for a year, on trumped-up charges. Two contractual faculty members and six resource persons were also suspended on 5th November for the ‘crime’ of standing with their students. Over the past month, life in SRFTI has come to a grinding halt, with the administration hell-bent on treating students as criminals. 

Resistance to Right-Wing Event and Repression at SRFTI

 On 27th September, an event was organised by the RSS-affiliated Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat (ABGP) in the Main Theatre, without a discussion with the student body. The usual convention has been a prior discussion with the student body, before letting the Main Theatre out for any purpose. When students protested the same, they were chased and beaten up by outsiders. Library staff and faculty members were also hurt. The attacks on the students included targeted harassment of female and transgender students, who were sexually harassed and verbally abused, including being given rape threats.

Female students report being made uncomfortable by the event organisers, even before the altercation began, including an incident where they had interrupted a shoot on campus. Furthermore, a rowdy mob had pelted stones on campus, calling students ‘terrorists’ and ‘anti-nationals’. Their ambulance was attacked. It is also painful to note that two students needed extensive plastic surgery, as a result of this mindless violence. Since then, the administration headed by Mr. Santosh Ajmera, Vice-Chancellor has taken one draconian step after the other.

On 4th October, a rally organised by the Bangiya Hindu Jagaran Mancha reached the gates of the institution and injured students again by pelting stones and bottles from outside the gates. The administration failed to name the organisation in their police complaint! Between 5th – 7th October, students protesting peacefully were physically confronted by the institute’s staff and threatened with ‘career destruction’. The administration’s methods became even more heavy-handed from 12th October when the students began an indefinite sit-in demanding the removal of the Vice-Chancellor. On 15th October, the administration installed CCTVs on campus without prior intimation to the students. This happened despite a 2024 pact between the students and the administration, where the administration after a discussion with the Student Union had assured that any CCTV installation and placement will only be done after consultation with student representatives and the department concerned where the CCTV was being installed. Students have expressed extreme discomfort with Mr. Munshi, the Chief Security Officer and his subordinates having access to CCTV footage. This is especially in the light of numerous complaints lodged against Mr. Munshi by female staff in the past, which the administration had not taken any cognizance of.

Notably, the current Vice-Chancellor (VC) made an oral promise to offer 3-days’ notice to the students before the installation of any CCTV; a promise that the students have on record. This was rescinded on the grounds of the alleged vandalization of his office on 14th October, along with the manhandling of the VC. Campus security has denied the occurrence of any such vandalization to the police. The Vice-Chancellor, has also rusticated six students for a year, on allegations of ‘misdemeanour’ with no specific charges but identical, cyclostyled orders! In yet another repressive measure, on 5th November, even as the city was gearing up for Deepavali and Kali Pujo celebrations, the administration suspended two contractual faculty members, six resource persons, who merely stood in solidarity and extended academic closure till 11th December!

The increased police surveillance on campus and outside has given rise to a siege-like situation. Students protesting peacefully have been constantly monitored and photographed. The Vice-Chancellor has hired bouncers for his ‘personal security’, who have been seen going towards the hostel premises that should be out-of-bounds for outsiders. This places students at grave personal risk on campus and hostels, which the administration seems to be oblivious to. Barricades have been set up around the campus, with police officers taking regular photographs and also entering into altercations with students. Reportedly, a young female student was also ‘grilled’ by the police for having the ‘temerity’ to step out for a cup of tea!

Reclaiming SRFTI from the Clutches of the Regressive Administration:

It is indeed tragic and unacceptable that a premier institution like the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute is being converted into a fortress and another ground for the right-wing take over of educational and learning spaces. It has also become abundantly evident that the current VC, Mr. Santosh Ajmera, a PIB official with a history of derogatory comments towards women on X (such as actress Rani Mukherjee), is utterly incapable of managing an institute of learning and is determined to treat students as criminals, going all the way to hire personal bouncers; while neglecting the security, physical and mental health of the students, not to mention their careers and futures.

We therefore support all the legitimate demands of the students, including: 

  1. Fair and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September, 2026.
  2. Prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones.
  3. Fair and independent inquiry into the alleged violence on the VC on 14th October.
  4. Immediate recall of rustication orders of students.
  5. Complete recall of orders enforcing academic closure until 11th December.
  6. Review of CCTV cameras and hearing students’ concerns regarding Mr. Munshi’s past misconduct.
  7. Immediate withdrawal of suspension of two contractual faculty members and six resource persons.
  8. Immediate removal of the Vice-Chancellor’s personal bouncers from campus, with a review of his own conduct in putting the security of students at risk.
  9. A full-time competent Vice Chancellor, who truly upholds the values and spirit of SRFTI.
  10. Removal of police presence on campus and safeguarding the right to protest peacefully.

A film school is a place of practice and study. It is a matter of great shame that Mr. Santosh Ajmera and his administration have subjected students to extreme trauma, throughout the festive season, while operating with complete impunity. We stand in full solidarity with progressive students and faculty of SRFTI, in reclaiming their campus in true spirit of freedom and creativity.

Issued by: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA – NAPM)          

Contact: narivadinapm@gmail.com

Courtesy: https://countercurrents.org/

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad https://sabrangindia.in/a-prisoner-of-conscience-dr-kafeel-khan-on-two-terms-in-prison-i-teesta-setalvad/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 04:09:39 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50094 Twice he has been imprisoned, once because he helped procure oxygen cylinders to save lives , including new born basis in a Gorakhpur hospital (2017), then because he dared, as an Indian Muslim to speak out on the infamous CAA 2019 & NRC (2020). Both times, he was ill-treated be it in the prison in […]

The post A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Twice he has been imprisoned, once because he helped procure oxygen cylinders to save lives , including new born basis in a Gorakhpur hospital (2017), then because he dared, as an Indian Muslim to speak out on the infamous CAA 2019 & NRC (2020). Both times, he was ill-treated be it in the prison in Gorakhpur or Mathura: subject to brute custodial violence.
In a deeply personal conversation with Teesta Setalvad, he speaks once again about the humiliation endured by his family, his mother’s courage, his wife’s unwavering support, and his continued commitment to medicine and teaching. He also reflects on the children and families he has never forgotten, the role of mainstream media in shaping public perceptions, and the many people still waiting for justice and bail.
As both his books show, The History Sheeter (recently released) and The Gorakhpur Hospital Tragedy: A Doctor’s Memoir of a Deadly Medical Crisis, Dr Khan remains irrepressible and a powerful communicator. Scenes from his first book were even used in the Shahrukh Khan film featured Jawan though the film did not acknowledge this!
What does it take to hold on to hope without giving in to bitterness? Dr Khan shows us how, in this conversation that reveals courage, abiding humanity and perseverance.

The post A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR https://sabrangindia.in/vote-chori-fake-applications-to-delete-28-voters-uttarakhand-court-directs-police-to-register-fir/ Thu, 12 Nov 2026 09:32:05 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50076 A concrete case of allegations of criminality and violation of election law and rules, especially related to the Form 7 method of ‘mass deletions’ has come to light from Uttarakhand, with a BLA-2 (Ikram Ali himself petitioning the court for registration of an FIR after his identity and email were misused for 28 deletions: Ali had also approached the Haldwani judicial magistrate for directions to register an FIR which the court has directed on October 6.

The post Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
NEW DELHI – A judicial magistrate court in Haldwani, Uttarakhand, has directed police to register a First Information Report (FIR) and investigate allegations that Form-7 applications were fraudulently submitted in the name of a Booth Level Agent (BLA-2) to seek the deletion of 28 voters from the electoral rolls. The matter came to light after the complainant and petitioner–Ikram Ali — himself the BLA-2 in question whose identity had been purportedly fraudulently misused –had filed complaints for redressal. Alleging that he informed concerned election officials in writing, and when faced with silence sent his complaint to the Banbhoolpura police station by speed post on August 24, which was received by the police on August 27, according to the court order. The order was passed on October 6, The grave issue has been reported in Hindustan, Dainik Jagran and Hindustan Gazette.

After allegedly receiving no effective action at the police station, Ali submitted yet another complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Nainital, on August 29. The complaint was received on August 31, the order recorded. However, the court noted that despite the complaints, no FIR had been registered and no effective investigative action had been taken, prompting Ali to approach the magistrate. In its order, the court examined the police report sought in the matter as is required under Section 175 (3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023.[1]

Advocate Manish Kumar Pandey, represents complainant, Ikram Ali, a resident of Indiranagar in Banbhulpura. While rejecting the stay application, the court scheduled the next hearing on the revision petition for December 7, 2026, noting that the non-registration of an FIR to date is also a serious matter.

Judicial Magistrate First Class Shubhangi Gupta, in an order dated October 6, accepted a petition filed by Ikram Ali, a resident of Ward No. 31 in Haldwani, under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023. The court directed the officer in charge of Banbhoolpura police station to register an FIR on the basis of the complaint received on August 24 and investigate the matter in accordance with law.

The Magistrate’s order relates to serious illegalities in the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Ali, the petitioner and original complainant before the police, has reportedly told the court that he was working as a BLA-2 during the revision process when he learnt on August 20 that Form-7 applications had been submitted online in his name on August 12, seeking the deletion of 28 voters from Part No. 134 of the electoral roll. According to the petition, Ali denied submitting any such applications, either for himself or on behalf of any other voter. He also denied authorising anyone to file them in his name.

In the petition, Ali alleged that unidentified persons had misused his identity to prepare and submit the applications, purportedly presenting themselves as him before the election office. Ali has also contended that he informed the concerned election officials in writing after learning about the applications. He subsequently sent a written complaint to Banbhoolpura police station by speed post on August 24, which was received by the police on August 27, according to the court order.

It was only after he reportedly received no effective action at the police station, that Ali submitted another complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Nainital, on August 29. The complaint was received on August 31, the order stated. The court observed that despite the complaints, no FIR had been registered and no effective investigative action had been taken, prompting Ali to approach the magistrate.

In the first instance, as observed by the court in its order, the court examined the police report sought in the matter. The report stated that the complaint concerned alleged forgery and identity theft in connection with SIR Form-7 applications. It also suggested that the complainant could raise his objection before the relevant Assistant Returning Officer under the existing procedure.

According to available media reports, Ikram Ali, the BLA-2 in question has stated that he reached Delhi on October 30, where he met senior Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi, and P. Chidambaram. In addition, he met with more than 20 MPs and senior leaders of the INDIA alliance, including a representative of SP chief Akhilesh Yadav, TMC MP Mahua Moitra, and former Jammu & Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti. Ikram informed all the leaders about the misuse of portal IDs and the deletion of voters’ names from the list using fake identities in Haldwani’s Indiranagar area. According to Ikram, all the leaders assured him that they are keeping a close watch on the matter and will take the issue forward.

The controversy surrounding the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is no longer limited to concerns about voters being asked to prove their eligibility or submit forms to remain on the rolls. The conscious and deliberate misuse of Form 7 for third party deletions, that too by dominant political actors, has been a recurring aspect of the controversial SIR process.

Widely reported investigations by The Hindu, both in Delhi and Karnataka have raised another serious question: who can or should initiate the process for deletion of voters, on what basis, and how effectively are such deletion processes being checked?

Detailed directions by the Court

In the Order dated October 6, the magistrate held that the availability of an alternative remedy before the election authorities was not sufficient grounds to reject the plea seeking a police investigation.

“The remedy available before the Assistant Returning Officer and the relief sought by the applicant operate in different fields and are not alternatives to each other,” the court observed.

The court noted that the election authority’s role was limited to matters such as correction and maintenance of electoral rolls, whereas the complaint concerned an alleged offence committed by unidentified persons.

The order of the court further observes that the relevant election authority did not have the power to investigate the criminal offence or obtain electronic records such as user IDs and login details, registered mobile numbers and email addresses, OTP and authentication information, IP addresses, and device-related records that could help identify those responsible.

The court said the mere availability of an alternative remedy was not sufficient grounds to dismiss the petition.

The magistrate referred to the Supreme Court’s judgments in *Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh* (2014) 2 SCC 1 and *Priyanka Srivastava v. State of U.P.* (2015) 6 SCC 287 while examining the requirements for directing police action.

Referring to *Lalita Kumari*, the court noted that where information prima facie discloses a cognisable offence, registration of an FIR is a legal duty of the police, followed by an investigation in accordance with law.

The court also observed that the police report had not rejected the complainant’s allegations or stated that no cognisable offence was made out. Nor did it refer to any investigation conducted at the police-station level.

The magistrate said that, at first glance, the alleged submission of applications in the complainant’s name by concealing his actual identity and impersonating him in official proceedings appeared to fall within the scope of a suspected criminal offence.

The court clarified, however, that it was not expressing a final opinion on the offences involved, which would have to be determined during the investigation.

Allowing the petition, the court directed the officer in charge of Banbhoolpura police station to register an FIR on the basis of Ali’s complaint dated August 24, 2026, and investigate the case in accordance with law.

It also ordered that a copy of the order be sent immediately to the concerned police station.

The order does not establish who submitted the disputed Form-7 applications or whether the 28 voters were ultimately removed from the electoral rolls. Those issues remain subject to investigation.


[1] Unlike its predecessor, Section 156 (3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure this section—175 (3) has controversially added “several procedural” steps ostensibly to prevent misuse of magisterial powers. These include submission of the said complaint to the Superintendant of Police (SP), accompanied by an affidavit as also recording of the police version.


Related:

SIR: Form 7 controversies raise fresh questions about the continued power to delete voters

The post Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Maharashtra Gokul Controversy: Mahayuti’s bid to seize control of the state’s largest milk cooperative? https://sabrangindia.in/maharashtra-gokul-controversy-mahayutis-bid-to-seize-control-of-the-states-largest-milk-cooperative/ Wed, 11 Nov 2026 12:41:33 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50051 Faced with a narrow defeat last week --a Congress-led panel had won 13 seats to Mahayuti’s 12 seats last week, the Fadnavis government in a widely criticised move, altered rules to nominate members and give them voting rights; this tilted the balance in Mahayuti’s favour after a courtroom drama that first directed elections and thereafter refused to stay or scrutinise the hastily changed rules; Fadnavis Govt alters rules & Voila(!), Mahayuti Candidate is Chairman of Gokul Dairy after a courtroom drama also unfolds last week

The post Maharashtra Gokul Controversy: Mahayuti’s bid to seize control of the state’s largest milk cooperative? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Brute majority as exercised by the union government was/is also evident in the state of Maharashtra. Despite stiff opposition from dairy farmers in Kolhapur, led by Congress MLC, Satej Patil, the Fadnavis-led Mahayuti government “seized” control of the lucrative Gokul dairy on November 10, yesterday.

Tens of thousands of farmers of Kolhapur and areas around —a sea of humanity —angrily joined a rally led by led by Congress MLC Satej Patil in Kolhapur on Monday, November 9, to protest the promulgation of an ordinance that allows the state government to nominate five directors to the boards of large federal cooperative societies, of whom four get voting rights. Dairy farmers from Thane, Sangli, Satara, Pune and Dharashiv participated in the protest march, titled Sangharsh Morcha, over 1.5km, alleging that the government move undermined democratic principles and the autonomy of the cooperative sector. These were visuals on social media that reflected rural Maharashtra’s outrage against the brazen attempt by the Fadnavis-led Mahayuti government to seize control over this dairy that has 5.5 lakh farmers associated with it (with at least five-and-half-thousand minor cooperatives linked to Gokul).

Monday’s rally had participants, which included women farmers, arrived in bullock carts and brought buffaloes, horses and other animals. Banners alleging “vote and power theft” were erected at multiple locations. Former MP Raju Shetti, Kolhapur MP Shahu Chhatrapati, Sangli MP Vishal Patil, MP Dhairyasheel Mohite-Patil, MLAs Jayant Patil and Vishwajeet Kadam, and MPSC student activist Vivekanand Patil joined the march. Many elected representatives from local bodies and cooperative institutions were also present.

However, the very next day, a controversial decision of the Aurangabad Bench of the Bombay High Court, that had first directed elections of the 25 members later (vacation bench) refused to stay the hastily changed rules dated November 4 that granted the MahaYuti the majority! Later this month, the Bombay high court is slated to hear a petition by the Congress-led panel for quashing the controversial amendment. As mentioned above, in its hearing on November 9, the court had refused to stay the election. However, the court has said that the results of the elections would be subject to the court’s final decision on the matter and had asked Gokul officials to keep the ballots of the elected directors and the government-nominated directors separate.

Former legislator from the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) Rajesh Patil, representing a Mahayuti-backed panel, was elected as the chairperson, defeating the Congress-led panel’s Shashikant Patil-Chuyekar. Thereafter, the newly elected chairman of the Kolhapur District Milk Producers’ Union (Gokul) and former MLA Rajesh Patil pays floral tribute to the statue of Gokul founder Anandrao Patil-Chuyekar, in Kolhapur on November 10, 2026. The board of Gokul, Maharashtra’s largest milk-producing co-operative, saw a Mahayuti-backed member being elected its chairperson on Tuesday (November 10), days after the Maharashtra government allowed four nominated members to vote, thereby upturning a Congress-led panel’s victory in elections held last month. Rajesh Patil bagged 16 votes, whereas Patil-Chuyekar bagged 13 votes.

The dairy is Maharashtra’s largest milk co-operative – with a turnover of over Rs 5,000 crore – and works with more than 8,400 milk societies and nearly five and a half lakh milk producers in the crucial western Maharashtra region. Control over Gokul allows political leaders to be in direct contact with lakhs of families, and also allows them to wield considerable financial influence over their lives through the disbursal of payments to them.

The election to the 25-member board of directors was held on October 19 and saw the Congress-led panel, led by Congress MLC Satej Patil, bagging a narrow victory over the Mahayuti panel, bagging 13 votes to the Mahayuti panel’s 12 votes.

However, two weeks after the elections, the Devendra Fadnavis government on November 4 promulgated an ordinance nominating five members to the boards of major co-operative institutions like Gokul and giving four of the five nominated members the right to vote in the chairperson’s election.

The move garnered heavy flak – Congress leader and Lok Sabha LoP Rahul Gandhi said the move was a “theft of milk producers’ votes”, whereas Cockroach Janta Party chief Abhijeet Dipke alleged that Fadnavis was attempting a “hostile takeover” of Gokul. Satej Patil criticised the decision and said it would make elections redundant.

“If the government’s policy is to disregard the people’s mandate and take decisions according to its own wishes, then there is no point in holding elections. It would be better to cancel all elections, appoint government nominees and let them run sugar factories, spinning mills and municipal corporations,” he had said. Reported the Indian Express.

Satej Patil had also organised a protest in Kolhapur on Monday (November 9), which saw tens of thousands of protesters march on the streets of the city.

The move for this brazen change of rules had even been opposed even by former Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai who, in a legal opinion offered to the Congress-led panel’s advocate Shrikrishna Ganbavale, reportedly said such a move was not “sustainable on the ground that such an action would be hit by the doctrine of manifest arbitrariness and would amount to colourable exercise of powers.”

Ganbavale submitted Gavai’s opinion to the Fadnavis government. Despite this, the very next day, the Fadnavis government approved an amendment in the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, allowing government-nominated and designated directors to vote in the elections of a chairperson or other members.

It was this hastily crafter move that tilted the scales in favour of the Mahayuti panel’s candidate and, as was widely expected, Tuesday’s election saw Patil bagging 16 votes and registering a victory, even though the original election results had seen the Congress-panel emerging victorious. Fadnavis had defended the amendment, pointing to the lack of a quorum in a meeting held on October 29 to elect a chairperson. The Mahayuti directors had abstained from the meeting, thereby preventing the meeting from reaching the quorum of 14 directors.

“One side had won 13 seats and the other 12 seats. Therefore, the quorum required for the meeting was not being met. The meeting had to be cancelled twice due to a lack of quorum. If the meeting had been cancelled for the third time due to a lack of quorum, the election itself would have been cancelled. That is why the government took the decision,” Fadnavis had posted on ‘X’, in response to Gandhi’s criticism.

However, Congress leaders have rejected Fadnavis’s explanation, pointing to the fact that the Mahayuti directors could have been asked to remain present for the board meeting, instead of abstaining. This, they said, would have ensured adequate quorum for the meeting to take place.

Why Gokul maters and could be a predecessor in other ‘take-overs’

Every day, twice a day, they together collect and distribute milk that results in come worth Rs 1 crore approximately every eight days and close to Rs 5,000 crores annually. This attempt by Fadnavis to seize control is being viewed as a devious route to capturing control of both this sector and its rich earnings. The entire economy of Kolhapur rests on this and is at the centre of the economic structure of the district.

Critiques recall how prior to 2023 state elections in Karnataka and a crude bid to “replace” the popular local dairy brand of Nandini (also a cooperative structure) by the Gujarat-run Amul (National Dairy Development Board, Anand).

Watch this 2023 Video on the issue here

As senior journalist, Niranjan Takle –also an independent youtuber states (at 28.40 minutes) in this interview with Bushra Khanam, it is only under the Narendra Modi government that a ‘Co-Operative Minustry’ was created or brought into the Union Ministry and Amit Shah, Home Minister given the portfolio. Takle also points out that Gyanesh Kumar, the controversial Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) was previously Secretary under Shah to this Ministry and, during this tenure worked with the Gujarat (Anand)-based NDDB to “expand rural dairy infrastructure” across states. For critiques including Takle this is a sign that the move of the MahaYuti government is first to gain control over a lucrative economic base that currently is “owned” by farmers of Kolhapur and second, to give economic control and advantage (away from Maharashtra’s farmers) to Gujarat!

As senior journalist, Niranjan Takle –also an independent youtuber states (at 28.40 minutes) in this interview with Bushra Khanam, it is only under the Narendra Modi government that a ‘Co-Operative Minustry’ was created or brought into the Union Ministry and Amit Shah, Home Minister given the portfolio. Takle also points out that Gyanesh Kumar, the controversial Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) was previously Secretary under Shah to this Ministry and, during this tenure worked with the Gujarat (Anand)-based NDDB to “expand rural dairy infrastructure” across states. For critiques including Takle this is a sign that the move of the MahaYuti government is first to gain control over a lucrative economic base that currently is “owned” by farmers of Kolhapur and second, to give economic control and advantage (away from Maharashtra’s farmers) to Gujarat!

The Video (in Hindi) may be viewed here.

Why Gokul is key

Gokul dairy is the state’s largest milk producers’ co-operative, and collects over 17 lakh litres of milk from nearly five lakh milk producers every day. While most of the producers are based in and around Kolhapur district, Gokul’s distribution is spread across Maharashtra, as well as parts of Karnataka and Goa.

Controlling Gokul allows political leaders to exert influence over lakhs of families across western Maharashtra. The region has traditionally been a stronghold of the Congress and the NCP. Control over Gokul will also allow the BJP to fledge its wings in the region.

Related:

Failure of BJP-led Mahayuti Government in management of fertilisers & procurement

Maharashtra SIR: Over 2 crore names left off draft rolls; report finds uneven burden across regions and groups

Labour rights, health of workers hit in the name of “reform”: PUCL Maharashtra

The post Maharashtra Gokul Controversy: Mahayuti’s bid to seize control of the state’s largest milk cooperative? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
SIR: Form 7 controversies raise fresh questions about the continued power to delete voters https://sabrangindia.in/sir-form-7-controversies-raise-fresh-questions-about-the-continued-power-to-delete-voters/ Wed, 11 Nov 2026 05:31:50 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50042 The meeting Election Commission held on September 26, 2026 provided certain procedures for voters left out or issued notices during SIR, but fresh cases from Delhi and Karnataka show that the wider machinery through which existing names can be challenged and processed for deletion remains in place

The post SIR: Form 7 controversies raise fresh questions about the continued power to delete voters appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The controversy surrounding the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is no longer limited to concerns about voters being asked to prove their eligibility or submit forms to remain on the rolls. The conscious and deliberate misuse of Form 7 for third party deletions, that too by dominatnpolitical actors, has been a recurring aspect of the controversial SIR process.

Widely reported investigations by The Hindu, both in Delhi and Karnataka have raised another serious question: who can or should initiate the process for deletion of voters, on what basis, and how effectively are such deletion processes being checked?

Incidentally, the obduracy within the existing Election Commission of India (ECI) –despite the reported “dissent” from two Commissioners, Vivek Joshi and Sukhbir Singh Sandhu –is evident from the September 26 “clarificatory press note” issues by the Commission. This followed the sensational and important expose by The Indian Express on September 23. Even after the storm of protests that followed, the ECI continued to “allow” as many as 50 deletions per BLA (Booth Level Agent) of political parties, which is a misnomer for motivated mass deletions!

In Delhi’s Mustafabad Assembly constituency, hundreds of Form 7 applications seeking the deletion of Muslim voters have been linked to BJP-appointed Booth Level Agents (BLAs), many of whom have reportedly denied filing or signing them. One BLA, however, claimed to have filed more than 500 such applications despite the Election Commission later imposing restrictions on the number of Form 7 applications an individual could file.

Meanwhile, in Karnataka, where SIR was also meant to identify and remove duplicate or ineligible entries, the final electoral rolls have continued to show serious errors. The Hindu found that in Mahadevapura Assembly constituency alone, 803 voter IDs were linked to just 397 people. There were also cases involving the same EPIC number appearing in two different constituencies and hundreds of instances of individuals having multiple voter IDs.

Together, the two developments raise serious questions about the claim that the SIR process is meant to ensure cleaner and more reliable electoral rolls.

What the Election Commission held on September 26

The Election Commission’s Press Note issued after its meeting on September 26, 2026 dealt directly with some of the concerns arising during the ongoing SIR process.

The September 26 Press Note does not alter or restrict the existing role of Booth Level Agents (BLAs) in relation to objections or applications for deletion through Form 7. Its directions primarily concern the handling of notices issued during the SIR and the facilitation of inclusion of persons whose names were left out. The Press Note does not address the powers or role of BLAs in filing or pursuing Form 7 objections against entries in the electoral roll, leaving that underlying process unaffected.

ECI caps individual Form 7 applications

In October, the ECI capped the number of Form 7 applications that an individual elector can file at 10 during the claims and objections period and five per month during continuous updation of electoral rolls. The Commission said bulk objections filed on unsubstantiated grounds could inconvenience the elector whose name is challenged and increase the workload of field-level officials. The limits apply to both online and physical submissions, while recognised political parties’ BLAs remain governed by separately prescribed limits.

Form 7: the route through which names can be challenged

Form 7 is used to seek the deletion of an existing elector’s name from the electoral roll or to object to the inclusion of a name.

During the continuing SIR process in Delhi, The Hindu reported that 1,021 deletion applications had been filed in Mustafabad. Of these, 787 applications — or about 77% of the total — named 20 BJP-appointed BLAs as the objectors.

All 787 applications were directed against Muslim electors.

The scale becomes even more significant when third-party applications alone are considered. According to the publicly available list of Form 7 applications on the Delhi Chief Electoral Officer’s website, 787 of the 837 deletion applications filed by third parties — around 94% — were linked to these 20 BJP BLAs. But when contacted by The Hindu, 16 of the 20 BLAs denied filing or signing the applications attributed to them. Many reportedly said they had no knowledge that forms had been submitted using their names.

The controversy is therefore not merely about whether deletion applications should ultimately succeed. It raises a prior and fundamental question: who actually filed the applications seeking the removal of these voters?

Applications allegedly filed in other people’s names

One of the BLAs named as an objector in 32 Form 7 applications, Ankit Yadav, reportedly denied filing any of them. According to The Hindu’s report, he said he discovered that his details had allegedly been used to seek the deletion of Muslim voters living in his own neighbourhood. He subsequently submitted a complaint and formally resigned as a BLA to party representatives.

The newspaper reported that, with the assistance of the local Booth Level Officer, the electors concerned were found living at their registered addresses.

The BLO also reportedly said that he had not received physical copies of the relevant Form 7 applications.

Another person, Nitin Kumar, was named as an objector in applications relating to an area which, according to him, was not even his area. He too denied filing the forms, although he had received messages relating to their verification. The report also identified several other BJP BLAs who were named as objectors in dozens of deletion applications but denied filing them. The forms reportedly cited reasons such as “absent/permanently shifted”, “already enrolled” and “death” for seeking the deletion of names. The question is therefore not simply whether a voter ultimately remains on or is removed from the roll. The controversy concerns the ability of applications for deletion to enter the official system in the first place, including allegations that individuals’ names and details may have been used without their knowledge.

One BLA says he filed ‘over 500’ applications

Among the 20 BLAs named in the applications, one person stood apart.

BJP BLA Robin Singh Dhama, named as an objector in 57 cases in the publicly available records cited by The Hindu, acknowledged filing Form 7 applications and claimed that he had submitted “500 of those”. His claim became particularly significant because the Election Commission had introduced restrictions on the number of Form 7 applications that could be filed by an individual elector.

On October 9, 2026, the ECI imposed a cap of 10 Form 7 applications from an individual elector during the entire claims and objections period.

BLAs are permitted to submit applications in bulk under a separate procedure, but this involves applications filled by other electors and submitted along with the prescribed undertaking.

Senior ECI officials had earlier told The Hindu that a BLA filing Form 7 applications in his own name as an objector, without the prescribed undertaking for bulk submissions, would be covered by the restriction. The newspaper further reported that the forms naming the 20 BLAs as objectors had been filed without the prescribed BLA undertaking or the prescribed format for such submissions.

The Delhi District Election Officer, the Chief Electoral Officer and the ECI did not respond to questions from The Hindu, according to the report. Earlier, the District Election Officer had stated that deletion claims would be physically verified by the BLO and the ERO or Assistant ERO, and that action would be taken against applications found to be false or “mischievous”.

What September 26 did not change

The September 26 order laid down procedures for voters who had received notices during SIR because they were “unmapped” or had “logical discrepancies”, and for those left out of the rolls. It provided for BLO visits, collection and uploading of documents, and routes for inclusion through continuous updation and a special enrolment drive.

However, it did not remove the wider statutory and administrative process through which objections to existing voters can be raised and deletion proceedings initiated. The Mustafabad controversy demonstrates why this remains significant: where hundreds of deletion applications are generated and persons named as objectors deny filing them, serious questions arise about the integrity, traceability and safeguards of the deletion mechanism.

SIR removes voters, yet duplicate entries remain

The developments in Delhi come alongside findings from Karnataka that raise a different question about the effectiveness of SIR. In Mahadevapura Assembly constituency, The Hindu found that 803 voter IDs were linked to just 397 people after the exercise, including cases of individuals having multiple voter IDs and the same EPIC number appearing in different constituencies.

The report also identified more than 500 cases of persons having multiple voter IDs within polling stations and around 300 cases across different polling stations. These findings are significant because SIR has been justified as a means of removing duplicate and ineligible entries and improving the accuracy of electoral rolls. Yet serious duplication and inconsistencies reportedly remained even after the process.

The problem is not only duplication — it is exclusion

These developments point to a larger contradiction. In Delhi, hundreds of voters could simultaneously become the subject of deletion proceedings, while in Karnataka, an intensive revision intended to improve accuracy still left substantial duplication and other errors in the rolls.

The issue, therefore, cannot be addressed only by providing procedures after voters receive notices or are left out of the rolls. A system that subjects existing voters to large-scale scrutiny and potential deletion must also demonstrate that it can prevent erroneous exclusion and ensure accuracy. Once a genuine voter is deleted, the burden of discovering the deletion and seeking restoration can fall on the voter.

Why the demands from the Online Assembly remain relevant

The continuing controversies surrounding SIR, Form 7 applications and errors in revised electoral rolls reinforce the demands adopted in the resolution of the Online Assembly.

The concerns raised across States show that the issues with SIR are not isolated errors but raise wider questions about scrutiny, exclusion and verification. The demand to scrap SIR therefore remains central.

The resolution also calls for institutional accountability, including disbanding the present Election Commission and repealing the 2023 law governing the appointment of Election Commissioners, to protect the independence and credibility of the electoral process.

Finally, it calls for reverting to the 2024 electoral rolls while ensuring the inclusion of all genuinely eligible new voters through a public audit process as is mandated. Electoral revision should expand participation and facilitate inclusion—not place existing voters at risk of exclusion or make the process of restoring their names unnecessarily difficult.

Related:

Public Hearing on Sewer Workers – Hearing the victims and their families

Does the ECI’s Nov 6 communication signal a step-back on re-enrolment in the ASSD list?

The post SIR: Form 7 controversies raise fresh questions about the continued power to delete voters appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Maharashtra SIR: Over 2 crore names left off draft rolls; report finds uneven burden across regions and groups https://sabrangindia.in/maharashtra-sir-over-2-crore-names-left-off-draft-rolls-report-finds-uneven-burden-across-regions-and-groups/ Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:18:03 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50036 A preliminary analysis of Maharashtra’s SIR-2026 draft roll by the Sabar Institute finds that 20.69 million names which is a significant 21.1 % of the state’s 97.9 million electors— close to one in five pre-revision electors — were missing in the draft electoral roll published on August 31, 2026; these voters were placed on the ASDD list; the report also identifies sharp geographical variations in the deletion

The post Maharashtra SIR: Over 2 crore names left off draft rolls; report finds uneven burden across regions and groups appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Maharashtra’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has left 20,688,421 names off the SIR-2026 draft electoral roll, according to a preliminary report by the Sabar Institute, a public policy research organisation. This amounts to 21.1 per cent of the state’s 97,854,049 electors on the roll before the revision — effectively one in every five voters. In sum this means that the proportionate deletions of voters in Maharashtra (21.1 per cent) is second only to Arunachal Pradesh which ultimately saw 22 % of its electorate deleted. After Maharashtra, is Karnataka with 99.3 lakh electors vanishing from the electorate which amounts to 18 per cent of the state’s voters previous to the SIR.

The report, which examines deletions across all 288 Assembly constituencies and 36 districts, also reveals that the overwhelming majority of those whose names were placed on the ASDD — absent, shifted, dead and duplicate — lists were not recorded as dead.

It also finds substantial variations between Mumbai and the rest of Maharashtra, between urban and less urban districts, and among different categories of electors. The report cautions that it is preliminary and concerns the names left off the draft roll. Some affected persons may have reapplied and could subsequently appear on the final electoral roll. It also stresses that “correlation is not causation.”

It is on the Diwali weekend that the Sabar Institute made these public on X.

“Maharashtra’s Special Intensive Revision has left 2,06,88,421 names off the draft electoral roll. That is 1 in 5 electors (21.1 per cent). We analysed every single name, across all 288 constituencies,” the institute said in a post on X. Analysing the ECI’s constituency-wise data, the report found that deaths accounted for only 16.8% of the deletions. The remaining 83% were recorded under other categories, including “untraceable/absent” (37.5%), “permanently shifted” (37.1%) and “already enrolled” (8.5%).

Most of those removed are alive

One of the report’s central findings is that deaths accounted for only 16.8 per cent of the total deletions. According to the report, 17,206,190 people — or 83 per cent of all deletions — were marked as permanently shifted, untraceable or absent, or already enrolled elsewhere.

The report notes that 46 per cent of these living voters were below the age of 40. State-wide, the largest recorded category was “untraceable / absent” at 37.5 per cent, closely followed by “permanently shifted” at 37.1 per cent. Another 8.5 per cent were marked as “already enrolled”. The report notes that death becomes the dominant recorded reason primarily among older age groups, while among voters below 40, the overwhelming majority were placed in non-death categories.

Mumbai and its satellite cities carry the heaviest losses

The report identifies Mumbai and the surrounding urban belt as the area with the highest concentration of deletions.

According to the findings, Mumbai’s 36 constituencies account for 11 per cent of Maharashtra’s electors but 17 per cent of all deletions.

The report states that Mumbai lost 34.7 per cent of its electorate, compared with 19.5 per cent elsewhere in the state.

Thane district recorded particularly high losses. The report says 35.4 per cent of its electorate was affected by non-death deletions, placing it at the top of the district-level list. Other districts with high levels of non-death deletions included Mumbai City, Mumbai Suburban, Pune, Nagpur and Palghar.

At the other end of the scale, Hingoli and Gadchiroli recorded the lowest levels of non-death deletions, at about 6.6 per cent, according to the report.

Colaba saw more deletions than votes cast in 2024

The report highlights the scale of deletions in some individual Assembly constituencies by comparing them with voting figures from the 2024 Maharashtra Assembly election. Its most striking example is Colaba, where 119,606 names were deleted, while 118,499 votes had been cast in the constituency in the 2024 election. The report describes Colaba as the only seat where deletions exceeded the total number of votes cast in 2024, with deletions amounting to 1.01 times the number of votes cast.

It further says that 22 other seats in Mumbai, Thane, Palghar and Pune recorded deletions equivalent to between 75 and 100 per cent of the votes cast in 2024.

The stakes are electoral

The report also compares non-death deletions with the winning margins in the 2024 Assembly election. It finds that non-death deletions exceeded the 2024 winning margin in 190 of Maharashtra’s 288 Assembly constituencies.

In 95 constituencies, the report says, the “untraceable / absent” category alone exceeded the winning margin. The report does not claim that these deletions changed election results. Rather, the comparison is used to show the scale of the deletions relative to the margins by which seats were won.

The report’s summary states: “In two out of three seats, more living voters were removed than the number of votes that decided the 2024 winner.”

No evidence of an alliance pattern after controls

One of the report’s political findings is that it found no statistically significant alliance pattern once other factors were taken into account. At a simple state-wide level, seats won by the Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) recorded higher non-death deletions than those won by the Mahayuti. However, the report says this difference was substantially linked to the geographical concentration of MVA seats in Mumbai.

Outside Mumbai, the pattern changed. After controlling for Mumbai, region, reservation status, urbanisation and electorate size, the report found that the difference between MVA-held and Mahayuti-held seats was −0.27 percentage points, with a p-value of 0.82.

The report therefore concludes: “No alliance pattern survives Mumbai and urbanisation.”

Where turnout was lower, deletions were higher

The report identifies low voter turnout in the 2024 Assembly election as the strongest predictor of higher non-death deletions. It reports a Spearman correlation of −0.81 state-wide, and −0.74 outside Mumbai According to the report, constituencies in the lowest fifth of turnout recorded 34.9 per cent non-death deletions, while those in the highest fifth recorded 7.7 per cent.

The report says each percentage point of lower turnout was associated with 0.83 percentage points more non-death deletions. It interprets this relationship as being consistent with the possibility of stale electoral rolls, while presenting it as an association rather than proof of causation.

Two young women marked ‘shifted’ for every young man outside Mumbai

The report identifies a significant gender pattern among young voters marked as “permanently shifted”. Outside Mumbai, among electors aged 18 to 29, 822,798 women and 379,991 men were recorded as permanently shifted.

This amounts to approximately 2.2 women for every man. The report says this pattern is consistent with women moving to their husband’s residence after marriage and subsequently needing to enrol at a new address. Mumbai showed a different pattern, with young male deletions exceeding young female deletions. The report says this is consistent with the role of migration and male migrant workers in the city.

Overall, however, women and men were deleted at nearly identical rates — 21.4 per cent of women and 21.2 per cent of men on the 2024 roll. The difference became more visible after deaths were excluded. Outside Mumbai, 51.2 per cent of living voters removed were women, compared with 43.4 per cent in Mumbai.

More than half of third-gender electors were deleted

The report identifies third-gender electors as the group with the highest deletion rate.

According to its findings, 3,250 of Maharashtra’s 6,101 third-gender electors on the 2024 roll were placed on the ASD list. This represents 53.3 per cent of the third-gender electorate — more than two and a half times the overall state deletion rate of 21.1 per cent. The report says that 54.9 per cent of third-gender deletions were recorded as “untraceable / absent”, compared with 37.5 per cent among women and men.

Only 3.7 per cent of third-gender deletions were recorded as deaths. The report also notes that 75 per cent of the third-gender electors removed were below the age of 40. At the constituency level, it records particularly high deletion shares in several seats. In Bhiwandi West, 151 of 158 third-gender electors were deleted, while in Malad West, 313 of 345 were removed, according to the report.

Muslim-named electors account for 14.6% of deletions

The report estimates religious patterns through a name-based classification system, and explicitly states that this is a statistical estimate rather than an Election Commission record of an elector’s religion. According to this classification, 3,020,173 Muslim-named electors accounted for 14.6 per cent of all deletions.

The report compares this with a Census 2011 expectation of approximately 12.1 per cent, while also noting that the composition of deletions varies substantially across districts. The report says the Muslim-named share of deletions was 21.3 per cent in Mumbai and 13.2 per cent elsewhere.

It also emphasises the limits of name-based classification and says that its classifier was re-tested specifically on Maharashtra names.

Already enrolled” gap remains after comparing voters of the same age and seat

The report finds a difference in the recorded reasons for deletion when comparing Muslim-named electors with other electors. According to the findings, 12.3 per cent of Muslim-named deletions were marked “already enrolled”, compared with 7.9 per cent of other deletions.

Because deaths are more common among older populations, the report says it conducted comparisons between people of the same age group and in the same constituency.

After this adjustment, it found that the odds of a Muslim-named elector being recorded as “already enrolled” rather than dead were 2.07 times those of other electors of the same age in the same seat. For the “untraceable / absent” category, the corresponding odds ratio was 1.40, while the odds ratio for “permanently shifted” was 1.13.

However, the report expressly cautions against treating these findings as proof that any group was deliberately targeted.

It states: “None of this proves that any group was targeted. It shows where an audit of individual duplicate deletions would be best placed.”

Urbanisation, rather than community composition, explains much of the district pattern

At the district level, the report says that urbanisation is the strongest factor associated with higher levels of non-death deletions.

Outside Mumbai, it finds that districts with a larger urban population tended to have substantially higher deletion rates.

The report says that the relationship between urbanisation and non-death deletions was stronger than the relationship with the district’s Scheduled Caste, Muslim or Buddhist population shares. It cautions that these are area-level associations and should not be used to infer that individual members of a particular community were necessarily more or less likely to be deleted.

The report’s conclusion on this issue is that “urbanisation, not community share, drives the district pattern.”

The report’s broader warning: consequences may extend beyond voting

In its conclusion, the Sabar Institute says the implications of electoral-roll exclusion may extend beyond the right to vote.

The report notes that electoral-roll status can become connected with access to documentation and government services. It refers to difficulties involving passport renewal, the Public Distribution System, domicile and residence certificates, education, land transactions and vehicle registration.

It says prolonged uncertainty over electoral status can also create financial stress, psychological distress and disruption to family life. The report further raises concerns about delays in adjudication and appeals, arguing that a formal right to appeal may have limited value where people cannot easily obtain legal assistance, understand procedures, secure documents or afford repeated visits to administrative offices.

It identifies migrant workers, women changing residence after marriage, students, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, third-gender electors and people without continuous documentary records as groups that may face greater difficulty in documentation-heavy verification systems.

Demand for transparency, review and a countrywide study

The report calls for greater transparency around the use of algorithms, automated tools and logical discrepancy filters, saying these require independent examination and meaningful human review.

It also calls for sustained media coverage, civil society engagement and greater democratic oversight, including discussion in Parliament. Finally, the report says an independent countrywide study of the SIR is urgently required. Such a study, it says, should examine deletions and restorations, appeals and adjudication delays, demographic and regional patterns, documentary requirements, the use of algorithms and the social and economic consequences of exclusion.

Its concluding position is that maintaining accurate electoral rolls is necessary, but that “accuracy must be accompanied by transparency, accountability, accessible appeals, legal aid and protection against wrongful exclusion.”

The full report can be accessed from here.

Related

SIR: ECI “removes Form 6 declaration” but serious questions on legality of procedure remain

“It Is Not Just Numbers”: Prakash Raj on the Exclusion of 13.6 Crore Indians | SIR | Teesta Setalvad

The post Maharashtra SIR: Over 2 crore names left off draft rolls; report finds uneven burden across regions and groups appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
SIR: ECI “removes Form 6 declaration” but serious questions on legality of procedure remain https://sabrangindia.in/sir-eci-removes-form-6-declaration-but-serious-questions-on-legality-of-procedure-remain/ Tue, 10 Nov 2026 07:26:00 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50030 The Election Commission has separated the SIR declaration from the statutory Form 6 after two Election Commissioners objected to its inclusion and one called the change “unauthorised/illegal”, the issue comes as the Supreme Court is hearing the separate question of requiring deleted Delhi voters to seek inclusion again through Form 6

The post SIR: ECI “removes Form 6 declaration” but serious questions on legality of procedure remain appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has removed the Special Intensive Revision (SIR)-related declaration from within the online version of Form 6 and placed it separately. This “decision” followed a year and of sharp criticism related to the constitutionality and legality of having such a declaration in Form 6 instead of using established procedures for re-instating wrongly deleted voters (2025), the September 23 expose by The Indian Express and the aftermath: mass protests around an ill-motivated and unconstitutional SIR!

In the September 23 media disclosures, the dissent reportedly raised (in earlier months) by the two other Election Commissioners over the inclusion of the declaration in a statutory form prescribed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, figured prominently.

According to a subsequent November 4, 2026 investigation by The Indian Express, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had separately questioned the change. The online form had required applicants to answer an additional SIR-related declaration before proceeding. The declaration was placed between Sections J and K of Form 6 as an annexure.

Applicants were required to choose between three statements. They had to state whether their name appeared in the electoral roll during the last SIR held in the early 2000s, whether the name of a parent or grandparent appeared in that roll, or whether neither their name nor the name of a parent appeared. An applicant could not proceed without answering the question.

What is crucial for all Indians to understand is that, all three options —in fact the procedure itself was self-concocted by the Gyanesh Kumar-headed ECI; the original decision to include the declaration, and the now, subsequent one to ‘remove’ it are both unauthorised procedures amounting to sacrilege upon sacrilege. Form 6 is only for registration of new, first-time voters. For re-instatement of voters deleted due to intended or otherwise deletions (mass or single) by the ECI, the ECI may only exercise its powers under Rule 18 of the Electors Rules 1960 that allows for restoration of deleted names by public hearing without any application or any form being filled.

If according to the recorded objections recorded by the other two Election Commissioners, a major one was that given the fact that Form 6 is not simply an ordinary, administrative document but a statutory form prescribed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, any changes to it could only happen through a legal amendment, which means going to Parliament. (It was on noting’s of May 16 and August 13 that EC, Vivek Joshi had first recorded this objection and thereafter his colleague EC Sandhu had described it as “unauthorised and illegal”, stating it should be removed. Despite these internal objections, Indian Express had reported that the additional (false) declaration continued to appear on the online version of the form during the SIR process. Only after the second media disclosure has this been separated.

The Commission changed its position more than once

The latest move is significant because it is not the first position taken by the ECI on the issue. When the controversy first came into public focus (September 2026) , the Commission defended its actions and maintained that its decisions had been taken in accordance with law. In a subsequent position—declared in the press release signed by all three Commissioners on September 26, 2026 — the Commission said that the SIR declaration would remain attached to the online Form 6 during the SIR period, while the ordinary statutory form would be used outside that period.

The position has now changed again. The ECI has separated the SIR declaration from Form 6 altogether. The Commission’s affidavit before the Supreme Court states that its Electoral Roll Division decided on October 21 that the online application should be in two parts: the statutory Form 6 and the separate SIR declaration.

According to the affidavit referred to by The Indian Express, the original reason for putting the declaration together with Form 6 was “administrative convenience.” The Commission said that combining the two would allow the applicant to generate a single OTP and a single e-signature instead of having to complete two separate digital processes.

However, the affidavit also acknowledges an important concern. It states that issues arose because the manner in which the declaration was displayed on the online system could be understood as though Form 6 itself had been amended. The affidavit further accepts that Form 6 can only be amended by the Central Government. This is the central issue in the controversy.

The question was not merely whether an additional question could be displayed on an online portal. The question was whether a statutory form prescribed under law could effectively be changed in its implementation through an additional mandatory declaration unilaterally, without a legally ensured amendment. The ECI has now removed the declaration from within Form 6. But the wider dispute over the use of the form remains.

A statutory form and the question of procedure

Form 6 has a specific legal purpose. The electoral registration system contains different forms and procedures for different situations. A person seeking inclusion as a new elector is not necessarily in the same position as a person whose name was already included in an electoral roll and was subsequently removed. This distinction has become increasingly important during the SIR process.

Large numbers of voters have raised concerns after names were excluded from draft electoral rolls. In some cases, the question has arisen whether these voters should be required to seek inclusion again by filing Form 6. The issue is not simply one of filling out an online application.

A statutory form requires a person to make particular declarations. Those declarations are based on the legal and factual position of the applicant. If a person is genuinely seeking registration for the first time, the form may be appropriate.

But if a person was already an elector, had previously appeared on the electoral roll and was subsequently deleted, the circumstances are different. The reason for deletion becomes relevant. The procedure through which restoration is sought also becomes relevant.

The controversy over Form 6 has therefore raised a wider question: when a voter is deleted from an electoral roll, should the person automatically be required to start again as a new applicant, or should there be a clear and lawful procedure to examine the deletion and restore the name where the exclusion was wrongful? No. The Electoral Rolls 1960 provide a route, the question is why is this method not being followed? For re-instatement of voters deleted due to intended or otherwise deletions (mass or single) by the ECI, the ECI may only exercise its powers under Rule 18 of the Electors Rules 1960 that allows for restoration of deleted names by public hearing without any application or any form being filled

Bombay High Court and the problem of false declarations

A recent decision of the Bombay High Court has added another legal dimension to the debate over the use of Form 6. As reported by LiveLaw, the Court considered the position of voters who had shifted their residence.

The question was whether such voters could be required to use Form 6 or an SIR-related enumeration process requiring declarations that did not accurately reflect their actual position.

The Court distinguished between a genuinely new voter and a person who was already registered but had shifted residence. According to the LiveLaw report, the Court observed:

“Having considered the specific declarations that are to be made by a new voter in contrast to those that are required to be made by a voter who is applying for shifting of residence, it would be quite obvious that if a voter shifting residence as in the case of the present Petitioners, had filed an application in Form 6, they would not only be making a false declaration in their application for inclusion in an Electoral Roll for the first time, but would also be falsely declaring that their name was not included in any Assembly Constituency or Parliamentary Constituency in the past.”

The observation is important because it focuses on the truthfulness of the declaration itself. A voter cannot be expected to make a factually incorrect declaration merely because a particular administrative form is prescribed. As reported by LiveLaw, the Court also noted that false declarations may have consequences under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950.

Though the Bombay High Court matter concerned voters who had shifted residence, the principle has wider relevance to the Form 6 controversy. A first-time applicant, a voter who has shifted residence, and a voter whose name was wrongly deleted are in different factual situations. The procedure must recognise these distinctions, particularly when declarations in a statutory form carry legal consequences.

Deleted voters and the Delhi SIR dispute

The issue is now before the Supreme Court in relation to Delhi’s SIR process. The ECI’s November 3 clarification allowed persons missing from the draft roll, including previously registered voters, to seek inclusion through Form 6. Petitioners argue that voters who were already enrolled should be restored rather than treated as fresh applicants.

The ECI has said that, in specified circumstances, such applicants would not face action for a false declaration. But this itself raises a question: if special protection is needed for previously registered voters using Form 6, should the same form be used for fundamentally different categories of voters at all? The issue remains connected with the Supreme Court proceedings.

What the October 3 Online Assembly resolution says

The wider concerns over SIR and electoral-roll exclusions were also addressed in a resolution adopted at the Public Online National Assembly held on October 3, 2026. This assembly called by Vote for Democracy (VFD) included over 100 experts, professionals and activists from across India.

The resolution calls for the removal or resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner, the complete scrapping of SIR and a return to the 2024 electoral rolls, with lawful revisions for additions and deletions. It also seeks the disbanding of the existing ECI, repeal of the 2023 law governing the appointment of Election Commissioners, and a new broad-based and accountable appointment process.

The resolution further demands greater transparency in electoral data and software, including public access to electoral information in machine-readable form and disclosure of source code used in systems such as ECINet and ERONet.

It also raises concerns about Forms 6 and 7, software-driven exclusions, pending appeals and the denial of effective opportunities for verification and hearing.

Public notice, verification and the right to object

One of the important parts of the October 3 resolution concerns the process of deletion from electoral rolls. The resolution calls for a public social audit of electoral rolls and for greater participation by citizens and local communities in examining exclusions. It states that every proposed deletion should be publicly disclosed. This is in line with established ECI procedures: For re-instatement of voters deleted due to intended or otherwise deletions (mass or single) by the ECI, the ECI may only exercise its powers under Rule 18 of the Electors Rules 1960 that allows for restoration of deleted names by public hearing without any application or any form being filled

A voter should have a meaningful opportunity to challenge the deletion and seek restoration where the exclusion is wrongful. The resolution also says there should be transparency about who sought the deletion, the grounds on which it was sought and what verification was carried out. Most importantly, it states:

No electoral-roll change should be affected without public notice, verification and an effective opportunity to object.

This principle is central to the present controversy.

If a voter has been wrongly deleted, the process should not simply end with an instruction that the person must submit a new form. The circumstances of the deletion must matter. The voter should have an effective opportunity to challenge the exclusion. The electoral authorities should have a procedure to examine the case and restore the name where the deletion was wrongful. The resolution also calls for documentation of wrongful deletions, pending claims and objections, Forms 6 and 7 and procedural violations across SIR-affected states.

The larger question remains

The ECI has removed the SIR declaration from within Form 6, addressing the immediate concern that the online presentation could create the impression that a statutory form had been amended. But the central question remains: should previously enrolled voters whose names have been deleted be required to seek inclusion again through Form 6?

The Bombay High Court has highlighted the difficulty of requiring voters to make declarations that do not correctly reflect their factual position. The issue is now also before the Supreme Court in relation to Delhi.

Removing the additional declaration from Form 6 may address one part of the controversy. It does not, however, settle the question of whether Form 6 is the appropriate procedure for restoring voters who were already enrolled and were subsequently deleted nor the inherently unlawful exercise being conducted presently –which is the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).


Related:

“It Is Not Just Numbers”: Prakash Raj on the Exclusion of 13.6 Crore Indians | SIR | Teesta Setalvad

Does the ECI’s Nov 6 communication signal a step-back on re-enrolment in the ASSD list?

The post SIR: ECI “removes Form 6 declaration” but serious questions on legality of procedure remain appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>