SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/ News Related to Human Rights Mon, 16 Nov 2026 12:35:48 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/ 32 32 Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule https://sabrangindia.in/form-6-ecis-assurance-of-no-prosecution-to-deleted-voters-is-a-violation-election-law-rule/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 12:34:18 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50116 In its latest amended affidavit before the Supreme Court (SC) (November 14), the EC has “assured” the court that voters whose names are missing from the draft rolls will not face prosecution for making a false declaration and submitting names for re-inclusion under Form 6; this patch-work solution however is no solution to the violations […]

The post Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
In its latest amended affidavit before the Supreme Court (SC) (November 14), the EC has “assured” the court that voters whose names are missing from the draft rolls will not face prosecution for making a false declaration and submitting names for re-inclusion under Form 6; this patch-work solution however is no solution to the violations this process forces the voter to commit; why does the ECI remain committed to its faulty SIR procedures rather than the clear-cut classifications available for re-inclusion of wrongly deleted voters (public audit), Form 6 (new voters), Form 7 (deletions), Form 8 (changes on name, address, other details)?

ECI’s SIR procedures are violations of both the 2021 amendment to the RPA available through a notification dated June 17, 2022


The Election Commission of India (ECI) has now told the Supreme Court that voters whose names appeared in earlier electoral rolls but are missing from the draft rolls prepared during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) can submit Form 6 for inclusion in the final electoral roll without facing prosecution merely on account of their previous enrolment! However, the ECI remains obdurately committed to a procedure that statutorily involves a “false declaration” by a previous elector. Moreover, the ECI is clearly resistant to nationwide demands to scrap the faulty and exclusionary process of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in its entirety and a reversion to the 2024, pre-SIR electoral rolls.

The assurance, contained in a supplementary affidavit filed on November 14, 2026, comes after apprehensions that such voters could face action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, for submitting a declaration in Form 6 despite having been enrolled earlier.

However, the Commission’s clarification raises a larger question about the procedure being followed for voters who have already been enrolled once. Why should an elector whose name was present in an earlier electoral roll have to seek fresh enrolment through Form 6, a form prescribed for the inclusion of a new elector?

What the ECI has told the Supreme Court

In its supplementary affidavit in Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors., Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1246 of 2026, the ECI stated that some previously enrolled electors whose names did not appear in the draft electoral rolls were hesitant to submit Form 6. The affidavit may be read below this story.

Since September 2026 specifically, but even before the use of Form 6 by the ECI for re-inclusion of voters deleted due to either ineptness or deliberate intent by the ECI has raised nationwide condemnation. Articles on the issue may be read here, here and here.

The criticisms, outrage and apprehensions arose because of the inherent statutory flaw in the SIR that had no reasoning nor basis. Form 6 is prescribed for New Voters alone. Under the SIR, through an annexure to Form 6, a declaration form prescribed required the applicant (older voter who was seeking re-instatement in the rolls) to state that their name is being included in the electoral roll for the first time. This amounts clearly to a false declaration and expose them to prosecution under Section 31 of the 1950 Act, that too for no fault of theirs.  Belatedly responding to this, the Commission issued a clarification through its letter dated November 3, 2026, addressed to the Chief Electoral Officers of all States and Union Territories.

The letter states that an elector whose name does not appear in the draft roll can submit Form 6 to seek inclusion in the final electoral roll, irrespective of whether the person had been enrolled previously. The ECI has maintained that submitting the form in these circumstances is not, by itself, a false declaration merely because the applicant was previously enrolled.

The protection against prosecution is, however, subject to two conditions. The applicant must not already be enrolled in another Parliamentary or Assembly constituency, and the declaration must otherwise be in accordance with law.

The Commission has directed Chief Electoral Officers to publicise this clarification widely, including in local languages. It has also relied on the Delhi High Court’s October 14, 2026 judgment in Nilotpal Datta & Anr. v. Election Commission of India & Ors., in which the Court permitted the petitioners to submit Form 6 for consideration in accordance with law.

Vote for Democracy (VFD) Experts decry this move

Dr Pyarelal Garg, expert associated with the Vote for Democracy (VFD) has sharply decried the move. He has pointed to the statutory framework governing the prescribed forms. The Election Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021, published in the Gazette of India on December 30, 2021, amended the Representation of the People Act, 1950, among other provisions. The subsequent notification issued by the Ministry of Law and Justice on June 17, 2022, introduced amendments to the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. These amendments came into force on August 1, 2022.

The June 17 notification, S.O. 2802(E), substituted Rule 13 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The amended provision makes a distinction between the forms used for different electoral registration purposes, clearly.

The copy of June 17, 2022 notification can be accessed from here

Rule 13(1) provides that every claim for inclusion of a name in the electoral roll as a new elector shall be made in Form 6.

Rule 13(2) provides for Form 7 in cases involving objections to proposed inclusion or applications for deletion of an existing entry.

Rule 13(3) prescribes Form 8 for objections to particulars in an existing entry, shifting of residence and correction or updation of entries.

The distinction is significant. Form 6 is specifically prescribed for a new elector, while the rules provide distinct and separate forms for objections, deletion, shifting and correction of existing entries.

It is this distinction that Dr Garg says the Commission cannot overlook while asking previously enrolled voters, whose names have disappeared during the SIR, to seek fresh enrolment through Form 6.

ECI’s position is a violation of the statutory framework. Speaking to SabrangIndia, Dr Pyaralal Garg strongly criticised the Election Commission’s arguments before the Supreme Court.

In sum, he said, “ECI arguments before SC on Form 6 are further violations of the statutory framework that the Commission is governed under: It is strange (and inexplicable) that the ECI has dared forward these arguments in that are an outright mockery of both the Supreme Court and Parliament! This ‘invitation to committing a crime lays an innocent elector open to threat and inducement.”

Ministry of Law and Justice vide notification dated 17.06.2022 in compliance of amendments to RP Act 1950 notification dated 30.12.2021.” The copy of December 30, 2021 notification can be accessed from there

Separate relief for voters marked ASDD

The supplementary affidavit also details another set of measures announced by the Commission following a suggestion made by the Supreme Court on October 28, 2026, in proceedings concerning the Delhi SIR in Anjali Bhardwaj v. Election Commission of India.

The Court had suggested that the Commission examine ways to reach voters marked Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD), whose names were left out of the draft electoral rolls. Following this, the ECI issued directions on November 6, 2026, to the Chief Electoral Officers of Delhi, Maharashtra, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Jharkhand, Telangana and Nagaland.

Under these directions, booth-wise lists of such electors are to be displayed afresh at polling stations, Panchayat Bhawans and urban local body offices, as well as on the websites of the respective Chief Electoral Officers. The lists must also indicate the probable reasons for non-inclusion.

The Commission has directed electoral officials to make fresh efforts to contact these voters through Booth Level Officers, including by visiting their homes and contacting family members, neighbours and Resident Welfare Associations wherever necessary. Partially filled Enumeration Forms are also to be generated again through the ERO dashboard on ECINET.

Electors who have not shifted residence can submit their signed Enumeration Forms along with a statement explaining why they could not submit the form earlier. These can be submitted to the Electoral Registration Officer, Assistant Electoral Registration Officer or Booth Level Officer, either personally or through family members. An online submission facility with e-signature is also to be made available.

For electors who have shifted residence within the same State, the Commission has provided a separate procedure. They are not required to submit Form 8 for this purpose. Instead, they can submit the Enumeration Form along with a statement giving their new address and Assembly Constituency, supported by address proof, to the ERO or AERO of the new constituency. Homeless persons who do not possess the listed address documents can rely on the BLO’s field verification report.

Importantly, the November 6 directions provide that these Enumeration Forms will be processed by the EROs under Rule 21(1) of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, after verification of eligibility, ordinary residence and other relevant particulars. If accepted, the elector will be assigned the same EPIC number that was held before the SIR.

The ECI has also clarified that an elector who has already submitted Form 6 for fresh enrolment during the SIR need not submit the Enumeration Form again. Their application will be processed under the “November 3 clarification”.

The unresolved question

The supplementary affidavit sets out two different measures: a general clarification allowing previously enrolled voters missing from the draft roll to submit Form 6 without facing prosecution merely because of their earlier enrolment, and a separate procedure for ASDD electors in seven States and Union Territories through the resubmission of Enumeration Forms under Rule 21(1).

While these measures provide additional opportunities for electors to seek inclusion in the final rolls, they do not settle the statutory question raised by VFD that whether Form 6, prescribed for a new elector, is the appropriate route for someone whose name was already included in an earlier electoral roll.

The ECI has maintained that its objective is to ensure that eligible electors are included in the final rolls while preventing duplicate enrolments. In the concluding portion of its affidavit, the Commission acknowledged the challenges arising from the large volume of data involved in the exercise and stated that it remained committed to addressing inconsistencies while ensuring that eligible voters are not left out.

The issue, therefore, is not limited to an assurance against prosecution. It also concerns the procedure through which an elector already recognised in the electoral rolls is required to establish their eligibility again during the SIR.

The affidavit may be read here:

Related:

ECI affidavit says SIR decisions were unanimous, but questions over two commissioners’ objections remain

UP voter lists: Software manipulates Voter’s names, Pilibhit investigation finds 10,470 irregular entries

The post Form 6: ECI’s “assurance of no prosecution” to deleted voters is a violation election law & rule appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG https://sabrangindia.in/tn-cm-vijays-unilateral-decision-to-disband-hlc-into-inter-state-relations-condemned-ccg/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 05:03:07 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50111 A prominent body of former civil servants belonging to both the All-India Services and the Central Services have severely questioned the unilateral decision of the Joseph Vijay-led TVK government in Tamil Nadu (TN)’s to suddenly disband, on November 6, 2026, the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by a former Supreme Court judge, Justice Kurian Joseph that was due to present the second part of its report on May 31, 2027, just seven to eight-months from now.

The post TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG) has seriously questioned the sudden disbanding of the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by a former Supreme Court judge, Justice Kurian Joseph. In an open letter, dated November 14, 2026, written to the Tamil Nadu Chief Minister, C. Joseph Vijay, the collective of former civil servants belonging to the All-India Services and the Central Services, the CCG traces the history and background of an issue that touches upon the crucial issue of Federalism and deepening of Constitutional Values. As many as seventy-two former senior civil servants have signed the letter. 

The HLC had submitted Part I of its report in February 2026 and was working towards bringing out Part II of the report by the scheduled date of 31 May 2027. This sudden move is particularly questionable –says the CCG communication– given that Part I of the Report of the HLC had been widely appreciated by all segments of society — Union government Ministers, politicians from different political parties, including the BJP, academics, leading public intellectuals, the legal fraternity and former civil servants. 

Important areas of federal functioning, including emergency provisions, disaster management, inter-state river water disputes, local government, climate change, environment and forests, Union-State legislative and financial relations, Inter-State Council, All India Judicial Service, Mines & Minerals and Union agencies, were to be covered in Part II of the Report and considerable work on this was already under way.

Background to TN’s Initiatives on Union-State Relations

Elaborating on this sudden decision conveyed to the public through the Government Order (GO) of November 6, the CCG letter analyses how the GO mentions that the now disbanded HLC is non-statutory in nature. But then, the State Law Commission is also an executive body, established by a GO of 1994 and reconstituted subsequently through executive orders. There is no bar on a non-statutory body undertaking an inquiry into centre-state relations and suggesting measures for a healthier and more responsive federal structure. The Tamil Nadu (TN) government had set up the Rajamannar Committee (1969-71) and the Union government had constituted the Sarkaria (1983-88) and Punchhi (2007-10) Commissions for this very purpose through executive orders only. Even the Law Commission of India is not a statutory body but only an executive body.

“A specious and unconvincing justification has been advanced in the November 6, GO that there is similarity or overlap in the nature and scope of the functions entrusted to the HLC and the State Law Commission, states CCG in its open letter. 

The CCG communication traces the rich contribution of Tamil Nadu to the issue of Federalism within the Indian Constitution. It states that the excuse now being advanced of ‘the HLC being a non-statutory body’ has not ‘inhibited successive TN governments from constituting high-level committees to examine issues relating to the legislative relations between the State and Union governments. In any case, there is no evidence on record that the State Law Commission has, in the over three decades of its existence, examined issues relating to Union-State relations nor are any of its past reports available on your government’s website or elsewhere for study and evaluation.’

Moreover, transferring the task of preparation of Part II of the Report from the HLC to the State Law Commission six months before the deadline for its submission is a retrograde step. There is every likelihood of loss of institutional knowledge acquired in the HLC research efforts and inconsistencies in constitutional interpretation and analytical approach. An integrated, coherent analysis of the complex issues involved requires a single body applying its mind. The transfer to the State law Commission will also delay its publication.

Finally CCG states that, “We understand that PDF copies of the English and Tamil versions of Part I of the Report have been removed with unseemly haste from the Tamil Nadu government website. Considering that the reputed international publishing house, Bloomsbury, undertook the publication of Part I, which is perhaps the first of its kind for a Report commissioned by a state government and a testimony to the high quality of the Report, the removal of the Report from the website seems to indicate that the current government seeks to disown the Report commissioned by its predecessor government and shrug off any association with the Report.”

“As former civil servants who have worked closely with the political executive throughout our years of public service, we find it difficult to discern any compelling justification for your Government’s decision. Two possible explanations suggest themselves:

“First, your government may not fully subscribe to the ideal of a genuinely federal democracy, in which power is decentralised to the lowest levels of governance – Gram Panchayats and Municipalities – and higher levels exercise only those functions that cannot be effectively discharged below.

“Second, your government may be reluctant to displease the Union government and the ruling party at the Centre, a government and party that are obsessed with the ideology of an overarching centralisation of Constitutional functions and whose actions over the past few years, including effecting Constitutional changes altering the distribution of powers between the Union and the States, conditional fiscal transfers and rigidly structured centrally sponsored schemes have progressively constrained the financial and administrative autonomy of the States and tilted the federal balance towards the Union.

Finally, the CCG letter dated November 14, 2026 ends in the hope that the TN government “will affirm its commitment to a strong federal democracy, with devolution of powers to local government institutions. Restoring the remit of the High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations to complete its task of bringing out Part II of the Report will be a welcome step in this direction. “

Some of the signatories to the effort are G Balachandran, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt of West Bengal, Vappala Balachandran, IAS (Retd),Former Special Secretary, Cabiner Secretariat, GOI, Rana Banerjee, RAS (Retd), Former Special Secretary, Cabiner Secretariat, GOI, Aurobinda Behra, IAS (Retd), Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt of Odisha, Pradip Bhattacharya, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretaru, Development & Planning and Administrative Training Institute, Govt of West Bengal,  Anna Dani, IAS (Retd), Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt of Maharashtra, Vibha Puri Das, IAS (Retd) Former Secretary, Ministry of Tribal affairs, GoI, MG Devasahayam, IAS (Retd), Former Secretary, Govt of Haryana.

Rest of the Signatories may be viewed here.

Yours sincerely,

Constitutional Conduct Group (72 signatories, as below)

1. Anand Arni RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
2. R. Badri Narayan IRTS (Retd.) Former Chief Administrative Officer, Traffic Transportation & Business  Research Unit, Northern Railway, GoI
3. G. Balachandhran IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
4. Vappala Balachandran IPS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
5. Gopalan Balagopal IAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
6. Sushant Baliga Engineering Services (Retd.) Former Additional Director General, Central PWD, GoI
7. Rana Banerji RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
8. Sharad Behar IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
9. Aurobindo Behera IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Odisha
10. Pradip Bhattacharya IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Development & Planning and Administrative Training Institute, Govt. of West Bengal
11. Nutan Guha Biswas IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Police Complaints Authority, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
12. Ravi Budhiraja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Jawaharlal Nehru Port Trust, GoI
13. R. Chandramohan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary, Transport and Urban Development, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
14. Rachel Chatterjee IAS (Retd.) Former Special Chief Secretary, Agriculture, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
15. Gurjit Singh Cheema IAS (Retd.) Former Financial Commissioner (Revenue), Govt. of Punjab
16. F.T.R. Colaso IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Karnataka & former Director General of Police, Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir
17. Anna Dani IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
18. Vibha Puri Das IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, GoI
19. M.G. Devasahayam IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Govt. of Haryana
20. Renu Sahni Dhar IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Adviser to Chief Minister, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
21. Kiran Dhingra IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Textiles, GoI
22. Suresh K. Goel IFS (Retd.) Former Director General, Indian Council of Cultural Relations, GoI
23. H.S. Gujral IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Govt. of Punjab
24. Meena Gupta IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Environment & Forests, GoI
25. Syed Masood Husain IES (Retd.) Former Chairman, Central Water Commission & ex officio Secretary, Ministry of Jal Shakti, GoI
26. Siraj Hussain IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Department of Agriculture, GoI
27. Mathew John IRTS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Railway Board, GoI
28. Gita Kripalani IRS (Retd.) Former Member, Settlement Commission, GoI
29. Subodh Lal IPoS (Resigned) Former Deputy Director General, Ministry of Communications, GoI
30. P.M.S. Malik IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Myanmar & Special Secretary, MEA, GoI
31. Harsh Mander IAS (Retd.) Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
32. Aditi Mehta IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Rajasthan
33. Sudhansu Mohanty IDAS (Retd.) Former Financial Adviser (Defence Services), Ministry of Defence, GoI
34. Ruchira Mukerjee IP&TAFS (Retd.) Former Advisor (Finance), Telecom Commission, GoI
35. Deb Mukharji IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to Bangladesh and former Ambassador to Nepal
36. Jayashree Mukherjee IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
37. Shiv Shankar Mukherjee IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to the United Kingdom
38. Gautam Mukhopadhaya IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Myanmar
39. Sobha Nambisan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary (Planning), Govt. of Karnataka
40. Ramesh Narayanaswami IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
41. Amitabha Pande IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Inter-State Council, GoI
42. Rajesh Prasad IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to the Netherlands
43. N.K. Raghupathy IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Staff Selection Commission, GoI
44. V.P. Raja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission
45. Venu Rajamony IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to the Netherlands
46. V. Ramani

 

IAS (Retd.) Former Director General, YASHADA, Govt. of Maharashtra
47. Archana Ranjan IRS (Retd.) Former Director General, Central Economic Intelligence Bureau, GoI
48. Madhukumar Reddy A. IRTS (Retd.) Former Principal Executive Director, Railway Board, GoI
49. Julio Ribeiro IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Punjab
50. Manabendra N. Roy IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
51. A.K. Samanta IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police (Intelligence), Govt. of West Bengal
52. Deepak Sanan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Adviser (AR) to Chief Minister, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
53. G.V. Venugopala Sarma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Odisha
54. S. Satyabhama IAS (Retd.) Former Chairperson, National Seeds Corporation, GoI
55. N.C. Saxena IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Planning Commission, GoI
56. A. Selvaraj IRS (Retd.) Former Chief Commissioner, Income Tax, Chennai, GoI
57. Ardhendu Sen IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
58. Abhijit Sengupta IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Culture, GoI
59. Aftab Seth IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Japan
60. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Govt. of Gujarat
61. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Finland and Estonia
62. Navrekha Sharma IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Indonesia
63. Raju Sharma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh
64. Avay Shukla IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary (Forests & Technical Education), Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
65. Mukteshwar Singh IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Madhya Pradesh Public Service Commission
66. Tara Ajai Singh IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Karnataka
67. R. Sreenivasa Murthy IFoS (Retd.) Former Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Member Secretary, MP State Biodiversity Board, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
68. Prakriti Srivastava IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Special Officer, Rebuild Kerala Development Programme, Govt. of Kerala
69. Anup Thakur IAS (Retd.) Former Member, National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
70. P.S.S. Thomas IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary General, National Human Rights Commission
71. Geetha Thoopal IRAS (Retd.) Former General Manager, Metro Railway, Kolkata
72. Rudi Warjri IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Colombia, Ecuador and Costa Rica

 

The post TN: CM Vijay’s unilateral decision to disband HLC into Inter-State Relations Condemned: CCG appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP https://sabrangindia.in/chinas-medog-dam-indias-siang-project-could-multiply-disaster-risks-warns-sandrp/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 04:34:25 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50105 A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people […]

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.

The report, titled “The Riskiest Place to Dam a River: Medog, SUMP and the Untamed Yarlung Tsangpo Gorge”, has been authored by Parineeta Dandekar with Chintan Sheth. It argues that the combination of seismic activity, landslides, glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), extreme sediment flows and climate change makes the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge an exceptionally hazardous location for large hydropower infrastructure.

The report comes amid growing opposition in Arunachal Pradesh to the proposed SUMP, which the state government has presented as a strategic response to China’s Medog project on the Yarlung Tsangpo, known as the Siang after it enters India and the Brahmaputra further downstream.

According to the report, China’s Medog project, described as the world’s largest hydropower project, is expected to have an installed capacity of approximately 60,000 MW. However, Beijing has not made public essential details concerning the project’s precise locations, reservoir capacities, water discharge arrangements and operational objectives.

The report says that the lack of transparency is particularly concerning because the project is located close to India’s border and could have significant implications for downstream regions in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

It notes that China’s proposed project is being promoted on grounds of national security, energy production, ecological considerations and international cooperation, but the absence of reliable technical information makes it difficult for downstream countries to assess its potential consequences.

Against this backdrop, Arunachal Pradesh is advancing the proposed 11,000 MW SUMP, which Chief Minister Pema Khandu has described as a water-defence project. The proposed project is expected to involve a dam approximately 280-300 metres high, with a reservoir capacity of 9-10 billion cubic metres.

However, the report questions whether constructing another massive dam downstream is an appropriate response to the risks associated with China’s project.

It points out that the proposed SUMP could completely submerge 27 Adi tribal villages and partially affect another 40-45 villages. Thousands of orange and pineapple farms and traditional wet-rice terraces could also be affected, while more than 100,000 indigenous people could face displacement or loss of livelihoods and land.

The report describes the opposition of indigenous communities as a struggle over their land, livelihoods and future, arguing that the concerns of the Adi people cannot be overlooked in the pursuit of strategic and hydropower objectives.

Beyond the geopolitical concerns, the report identifies the geographical and geological characteristics of the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge as a major reason for questioning both projects.

The gorge, located around the Namcha Barwa or Eastern Himalayan Syntaxis, is among the deepest river gorges in the world. The river makes a dramatic horseshoe-shaped turn around Namcha Barwa before entering India, descending approximately 2,000 metres over a relatively short stretch.

According to the report, this region experiences some of the world’s highest rates of tectonic uplift, rock erosion and river sediment transport. It is also highly vulnerable to earthquakes, landslides, avalanches and glacial lake outburst floods.

The report cites the 1950 Assam earthquake, which measured 8.6 on the Richter scale, as evidence of the region’s seismic vulnerability. It also refers to research documenting more than 200 earthquakes of magnitude above four between 1950 and 2018 in the gorge region.

The sediment carried by the river is another major concern. According to the report, hydrological measurements show that the Yarlung Tsangpo carries approximately 15-30 million tonnes of sediment annually at Nuxia/Pai on the Tibetan plateau. By the time it reaches Pasighat in Arunachal Pradesh, the annual sediment load rises to approximately 210-250 million tonnes.

Studies cited in the report estimate that 61-74 per cent of the sediment reaching Pasighat originates from the relatively small gorge region. Although this area constitutes less than three per cent of the Brahmaputra basin, it contributes approximately 45 per cent of the sediment reaching Bangladesh through the river system.

The report warns that large storage dams could substantially alter this natural sediment movement. Such dams can trap most of the sediment flowing into their reservoirs, affecting downstream river ecology, agriculture and the stability of river channels.

It cites the example of the Tehri Dam, which reportedly retains approximately 95 per cent of the sediment it receives.

If the proposed SUMP traps large quantities of sediment arriving from upstream, its reservoir capacity and ability to accommodate floodwaters could progressively decline. The report also warns that reduced sediment flows downstream could increase riverbank erosion and affect communities dependent on the river’s natural sediment supply.

The report further draws attention to a series of major landslides and river-blocking incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge, demonstrating the scale of natural hazards that could affect projects in the region.

One of the most significant incidents occurred in 2000, when a massive landslide in the Yigong-Parlung Tsangpo valley blocked a tributary, creating a natural dam. The resulting lake eventually breached in June that year, sending floodwaters downstream into Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

The report recalls that the flood swept away forest areas and several bridges. It cites accounts of approximately 30 deaths and destruction affecting more than 50 villages in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

Another major series of incidents occurred in 2017, when landslides and rock-ice collapses in the Sedongpu valley partially blocked the Yarlung Tsangpo. The Siang river in India subsequently turned into a dark, muddy flow, affecting fish and local drinking-water infrastructure.

In October 2018, two successive rock-and-ice avalanches completely blocked the main river channel, creating temporary barrier lakes. The resulting changes in water levels affected downstream flows in Arunachal Pradesh before the blockages were breached and surges of water and debris moved towards Assam.

A further major rock-and-ice collapse in March 2021 again blocked the river.

The report says these incidents demonstrate how landslides, glacier collapses, river blockages and sudden floods can combine to create disasters across international boundaries.

It also highlights the impact of climate change, noting that the Tibetan plateau is warming at approximately twice the global average rate. Rising temperatures are accelerating glacier retreat and permafrost degradation, increasing the potential for landslides, avalanches, glacial lake outburst floods and extreme river flows.

The authors warn that these developments could make the region increasingly unpredictable for large hydropower projects.

A major concern raised in the report is the absence of an effective mechanism for sharing hydrological and disaster-related information between China and India.

The existing memorandum of understanding on hydrological data sharing between the two countries expired in June 2023 and has not been formally renewed. Although China agreed in principle in 2025 to share information on a limited emergency and humanitarian basis, the report says that a reliable institutional arrangement is still lacking.

It recalls that during the 2017 Doklam standoff, China withheld hydrological information on the Brahmaputra and Sutlej rivers for the entire flood season. It also points to the lack of advance warnings during several major landslide-related incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo basin.

The authors argue that the absence of reliable information-sharing arrangements, combined with the possibility of sudden dam releases and natural river blockages, could significantly increase the risks for downstream communities.

The report also questions the flood-control rationale of SUMP. It argues that a large storage reservoir intended to generate electricity would need to retain water and therefore could not remain empty at all times to accommodate sudden floods originating upstream.

If the reservoir’s capacity to absorb floodwaters is reduced by sediment accumulation, the consequences of an upstream disaster could be particularly serious.

According to the report, the proposed SUMP could face extreme flows resulting from upstream dam releases, heavy precipitation or natural disasters. If the reservoir loses a substantial part of its flood-storage capacity because of sediment accumulation, its ability to perform its intended flood-control function could be compromised.

The authors conclude that China’s Medog project poses a serious geopolitical and environmental challenge, particularly because of Beijing’s lack of transparency. However, they argue that India’s decision to construct a massive storage dam downstream could create an additional and potentially permanent vulnerability.

“India is responding to an external upstream hazard by building a permanent domestic structural vulnerability,” the report states.

It adds that the risks associated with SUMP cannot be adequately addressed simply by presenting it as a strategic response to China’s project.

The report calls for China to disclose essential technical information about the Medog project and share it with India and Bangladesh. It also recommends a trilateral basin consultation and a joint transboundary environmental impact assessment involving the countries affected by developments on the river.

Among its other recommendations, the report calls for India to establish an independent earth-observation and early-warning system for the Yarlung Tsangpo basin, using satellite capabilities to monitor landslides, seismic activity, glacial changes and potential river blockages.

It also recommends installing monitoring systems along the border at Gelling, Bishing and Tuting, alongside satellite-based surveillance and scientifically reviewed assessments of geological and hydrological risks.

Equally important, the authors emphasise that the concerns of indigenous communities in Arunachal Pradesh must be taken seriously before proceeding with the proposed SUMP.

The report concludes that the combination of geological instability, climate change, inadequate information-sharing arrangements and the absence of effective disaster-warning mechanisms makes the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang region one of the most dangerous locations in the world for constructing mega hydropower projects.

It says that the risks associated with the proposed Indian project could outweigh its promised benefits, particularly when the potential consequences for downstream communities, river ecosystems and livelihoods are taken into account.

Courtesy: CounterView

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying https://sabrangindia.in/the-bitter-cost-of-the-brew-why-mothers-in-assams-tea-gardens-are-still-dying/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 07:51:19 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50101 Every morning, as the mist lifts over the emerald hills of Assam, thousands of women bend over tea bushes, their fingers moving in a blur to pluck the “two leaves and a bud.” They produce more than half of India’s tea, a beverage savored in drawing rooms across the globe. Yet, in the cramped, damp […]

The post The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Every morning, as the mist lifts over the emerald hills of Assam, thousands of women bend over tea bushes, their fingers moving in a blur to pluck the “two leaves and a bud.” They produce more than half of India’s tea, a beverage savored in drawing rooms across the globe. Yet, in the cramped, damp labor lines where these women return at dusk, a quiet tragedy continues to unfold.

For decades, Assam has recorded some of the highest maternal mortality ratios (MMR) in the country, as documented in the special bulletins of the Sample Registration System (SRS). While the state’s overall numbers have improved over the last twenty years, this progress has not trickled down to the tea estates. Here, among the Adivasi communities—descendants of workers brought from central and eastern India in the 19th century to clear land and pluck leaf—mothers are still dying from entirely preventable causes.

When a woman from the labor lines dies in pregnancy or childbirth, the death certificate will list a medical cause. But the true culprits are rarely just medical. They are social, economic, and systemic.

The Silent Killer Beneath the Surface

The immediate medical causes of these deaths are familiar to obstetricians worldwide: postpartum hemorrhage, high blood pressure disorders like pre-eclampsia, infections, and obstructed labor. The World Health Organization notes that most of these are highly preventable.

But in the tea gardens, these acute crises are built upon a chronic foundation: severe anemia.

The National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) found that around two-thirds of women aged 15 to 49 in Assam are anemic, with the numbers even higher among pregnant women. Studies from tea-growing districts reveal the problem is acutely worse among garden workers. Their diets are notoriously low in iron and protein. Worm infestations and malaria compound the blood loss, and the grueling physical work of plucking continues late into pregnancy.

Simply put, an anemic woman has no physiological reserve. The blood loss that a healthy mother’s body would easily survive can be fatal to hers.

This physical vulnerability is compounded by early and closely spaced pregnancies. NFHS-5 shows that child marriage before 18 and teenage childbearing are more common in Assam than the national average. A girl who conceives at 16 or 17, already thin and anemic, and then has a second child within two years, enters each labor weaker than the last.

The Gauntlet of the “Three Delays”

In public health, maternal deaths are analyzed through the “Three Delays” model. In the tea gardens, these delays are not just bureaucratic hurdles; they are a physical gauntlet that can claim a life in a single night.

The first delay begins at home. Danger signs—swelling, severe headaches, fits, or bleeding—may not be recognized as emergencies by the family. Furthermore, a day away from the bushes is a day without wages for the woman, or for the family member who must accompany her. The decision to seek care often rests with a husband or mother-in-law, and the hesitation costs precious time.

The second delay is one of distance. Many estates are located far from a hospital equipped to perform a caesarean section or administer a blood transfusion. The roads inside and around the gardens are poor, turning into impassable slush during the monsoon. An ambulance called in the middle of the night may take hours to navigate the terrain.

The third delay is the hardest to accept, as it happens inside the healthcare system itself. A woman may finally reach a facility, only to find no obstetrician, no anesthetist, or no blood on the shelves. She is referred onward, sometimes more than once, losing time she simply does not have.

Patches on a Torn Fabric

It would be unfair to say Assam is standing still. The proportion of women delivering in hospitals and health centers has risen sharply since the inception of the National Health Mission (NHM). ASHAs (Accredited Social Health Activists), including those specifically appointed for tea-garden areas, are the unsung heroes of this shift. They register pregnancies early, accompany women to check-ups, and are often the first to notice when something is wrong. Free ambulance services and free delivery care under central schemes have removed some of the financial barriers that kept families at home.

The state has also targeted the gardens directly. Mobile medical units visit the estates, and some garden hospitals have been upgraded through partnerships with the health mission. A wage compensation scheme for pregnant women in tea gardens pays them to rest and eat better before and after delivery, conditional on attending check-ups and delivering in a facility. Anemia testing and iron-folic acid supplements are now part of routine antenatal care.

These interventions are lifelines. But they are not reaching everyone equally.

Beyond the Clinic: What Must Change

To truly protect these women, we must look beyond the delivery room.

First, the Plantations Labour Act of 1951 mandates that estates provide medical facilities for workers and their families. On the ground, compliance varies wildly. Some garden hospitals boast doctors, nurses, and functioning labor rooms; others are little more than empty buildings. The government and the tea industry must agree, estate by estate, on clear responsibilities. Inspections must be regular, and their findings made public.

Second, blood must be closer to the bushes. Establishing and maintaining fully staffed, well-stocked blood storage units at first-referral hospitals in the tea districts would save more lives than almost any other single intervention.

Third, we must treat the girl before she becomes a mother. Anemia must be found and treated long before labor begins, starting in adolescence. Handing out iron tablets is useless if no one checks whether they are being taken, or if the patient isn’t tested again. Furthermore, girls need to stay in school and marry later. Couples need reliable access to contraception so that pregnancies can be safely spaced.

Fourth, every maternal death must be reviewed honestly. These audits should be conducted to find out where the system failed, not to assign blame to the family or the ASHA.

Finally, we must mandate respectful care. A woman who is shouted at, ignored, or made to wait on the floor will not return, and she will tell her neighbors not to go either. Care delivered in a language the woman understands, by staff who treat her with basic human dignity, is not a luxury. It is a medical necessity.

A Legacy Worth Saving

For over 150 years, the women of Assam’s tea gardens have carried a massive industry on their backs. That they still face a significantly higher risk of dying in childbirth than most Indian women is a profound failure of policy and attention. But it is a failure that can be corrected. It is time the system that relies on their labor ensures their survival.

—

Dr. Bhimi Daimari, MBBS, MS (Obstetrics and Gynaecology), is an obstetrician-gynaecologist from Assam. Click here about the author

Courtesy: CounterView

The post The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence https://sabrangindia.in/srfti-under-siege-alifa-demands-vcs-removal-independent-inquiry-into-campus-violence/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 05:04:26 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50098 13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for […]

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for a free and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September; prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones, recall of rustication orders, withdrawal of orders enforcing academic closure, removal of police presence on campus, a full-time Vice Chancellor for the institute and protection of the right to protest peacefully. 

For 40 days now, the SRFTI campus has been under a siege-like situation, with increasing police presence, and academic activity suspended till 11th December, 2026. The circumstances have placed students under immense stress, with women and transgender students at the receiving end of sexual harassment and trauma. This is on top of the expulsion of six students on the 15th October, for a year, on trumped-up charges. Two contractual faculty members and six resource persons were also suspended on 5th November for the ‘crime’ of standing with their students. Over the past month, life in SRFTI has come to a grinding halt, with the administration hell-bent on treating students as criminals. 

Resistance to Right-Wing Event and Repression at SRFTI

 On 27th September, an event was organised by the RSS-affiliated Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat (ABGP) in the Main Theatre, without a discussion with the student body. The usual convention has been a prior discussion with the student body, before letting the Main Theatre out for any purpose. When students protested the same, they were chased and beaten up by outsiders. Library staff and faculty members were also hurt. The attacks on the students included targeted harassment of female and transgender students, who were sexually harassed and verbally abused, including being given rape threats.

Female students report being made uncomfortable by the event organisers, even before the altercation began, including an incident where they had interrupted a shoot on campus. Furthermore, a rowdy mob had pelted stones on campus, calling students ‘terrorists’ and ‘anti-nationals’. Their ambulance was attacked. It is also painful to note that two students needed extensive plastic surgery, as a result of this mindless violence. Since then, the administration headed by Mr. Santosh Ajmera, Vice-Chancellor has taken one draconian step after the other.

On 4th October, a rally organised by the Bangiya Hindu Jagaran Mancha reached the gates of the institution and injured students again by pelting stones and bottles from outside the gates. The administration failed to name the organisation in their police complaint! Between 5th – 7th October, students protesting peacefully were physically confronted by the institute’s staff and threatened with ‘career destruction’. The administration’s methods became even more heavy-handed from 12th October when the students began an indefinite sit-in demanding the removal of the Vice-Chancellor. On 15th October, the administration installed CCTVs on campus without prior intimation to the students. This happened despite a 2024 pact between the students and the administration, where the administration after a discussion with the Student Union had assured that any CCTV installation and placement will only be done after consultation with student representatives and the department concerned where the CCTV was being installed. Students have expressed extreme discomfort with Mr. Munshi, the Chief Security Officer and his subordinates having access to CCTV footage. This is especially in the light of numerous complaints lodged against Mr. Munshi by female staff in the past, which the administration had not taken any cognizance of.

Notably, the current Vice-Chancellor (VC) made an oral promise to offer 3-days’ notice to the students before the installation of any CCTV; a promise that the students have on record. This was rescinded on the grounds of the alleged vandalization of his office on 14th October, along with the manhandling of the VC. Campus security has denied the occurrence of any such vandalization to the police. The Vice-Chancellor, has also rusticated six students for a year, on allegations of ‘misdemeanour’ with no specific charges but identical, cyclostyled orders! In yet another repressive measure, on 5th November, even as the city was gearing up for Deepavali and Kali Pujo celebrations, the administration suspended two contractual faculty members, six resource persons, who merely stood in solidarity and extended academic closure till 11th December!

The increased police surveillance on campus and outside has given rise to a siege-like situation. Students protesting peacefully have been constantly monitored and photographed. The Vice-Chancellor has hired bouncers for his ‘personal security’, who have been seen going towards the hostel premises that should be out-of-bounds for outsiders. This places students at grave personal risk on campus and hostels, which the administration seems to be oblivious to. Barricades have been set up around the campus, with police officers taking regular photographs and also entering into altercations with students. Reportedly, a young female student was also ‘grilled’ by the police for having the ‘temerity’ to step out for a cup of tea!

Reclaiming SRFTI from the Clutches of the Regressive Administration:

It is indeed tragic and unacceptable that a premier institution like the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute is being converted into a fortress and another ground for the right-wing take over of educational and learning spaces. It has also become abundantly evident that the current VC, Mr. Santosh Ajmera, a PIB official with a history of derogatory comments towards women on X (such as actress Rani Mukherjee), is utterly incapable of managing an institute of learning and is determined to treat students as criminals, going all the way to hire personal bouncers; while neglecting the security, physical and mental health of the students, not to mention their careers and futures.

We therefore support all the legitimate demands of the students, including: 

  1. Fair and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September, 2026.
  2. Prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones.
  3. Fair and independent inquiry into the alleged violence on the VC on 14th October.
  4. Immediate recall of rustication orders of students.
  5. Complete recall of orders enforcing academic closure until 11th December.
  6. Review of CCTV cameras and hearing students’ concerns regarding Mr. Munshi’s past misconduct.
  7. Immediate withdrawal of suspension of two contractual faculty members and six resource persons.
  8. Immediate removal of the Vice-Chancellor’s personal bouncers from campus, with a review of his own conduct in putting the security of students at risk.
  9. A full-time competent Vice Chancellor, who truly upholds the values and spirit of SRFTI.
  10. Removal of police presence on campus and safeguarding the right to protest peacefully.

A film school is a place of practice and study. It is a matter of great shame that Mr. Santosh Ajmera and his administration have subjected students to extreme trauma, throughout the festive season, while operating with complete impunity. We stand in full solidarity with progressive students and faculty of SRFTI, in reclaiming their campus in true spirit of freedom and creativity.

Issued by: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA – NAPM)          

Contact: narivadinapm@gmail.com

Courtesy: https://countercurrents.org/

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad https://sabrangindia.in/a-prisoner-of-conscience-dr-kafeel-khan-on-two-terms-in-prison-i-teesta-setalvad/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 04:09:39 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50094 Twice he has been imprisoned, once because he helped procure oxygen cylinders to save lives , including new born basis in a Gorakhpur hospital (2017), then because he dared, as an Indian Muslim to speak out on the infamous CAA 2019 & NRC (2020). Both times, he was ill-treated be it in the prison in […]

The post A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Twice he has been imprisoned, once because he helped procure oxygen cylinders to save lives , including new born basis in a Gorakhpur hospital (2017), then because he dared, as an Indian Muslim to speak out on the infamous CAA 2019 & NRC (2020). Both times, he was ill-treated be it in the prison in Gorakhpur or Mathura: subject to brute custodial violence.
In a deeply personal conversation with Teesta Setalvad, he speaks once again about the humiliation endured by his family, his mother’s courage, his wife’s unwavering support, and his continued commitment to medicine and teaching. He also reflects on the children and families he has never forgotten, the role of mainstream media in shaping public perceptions, and the many people still waiting for justice and bail.
As both his books show, The History Sheeter (recently released) and The Gorakhpur Hospital Tragedy: A Doctor’s Memoir of a Deadly Medical Crisis, Dr Khan remains irrepressible and a powerful communicator. Scenes from his first book were even used in the Shahrukh Khan film featured Jawan though the film did not acknowledge this!
What does it take to hold on to hope without giving in to bitterness? Dr Khan shows us how, in this conversation that reveals courage, abiding humanity and perseverance.

The post A Prisoner of Conscience: Dr Kafeel Khan on Two Terms in Prison I Teesta Setalvad appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? https://sabrangindia.in/health-why-do-women-in-india-still-carry-the-burden-of-sterilisation/ Fri, 13 Nov 2026 12:38:44 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50089 Exploring the inherent patriarchal attitudes that govern Indian government policies on family planning, the author, a renowned specialist argues how the focus, timing and methods must be on encouraging men to perform vasectomies rather than the more commonly performed intrusive tubectomy on women and specifically advocates more robust all-round efforts than the token November 21-December 4, government observed Vasectomy Fortnight

The post Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
India’s family planning programme rests on one operation, and it is performed only on women. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5, 2019–21), around 37.9% of currently married women aged 15–49 have been sterilised. For men the figure is 0.3%. In 1992–93 the first NFHS recorded male sterilisation at about 3.5%, so the gap has widened over thirty years. Fact sheets from NFHS-6 (2023–24) put the figures at about 36.5% and 0.5%.

As a gynaecologist, I find this hard to defend on medical grounds. The simpler and safer operation is the one we almost never perform.

Two operations, compared

A tubectomy closes the fallopian tubes so that the egg and sperm cannot meet. To reach the tubes, the surgeon has to enter the abdomen. In a minilaparotomy (“minilap”) this is done through a small cut in the lower abdomen, usually under local anaesthesia with sedation. In laparoscopic sterilisation a thin telescope is passed through a small cut near the navel after the abdomen is filled with gas, and a ring or clip is placed on each tube. Both are short and safe in trained hands, but they are –still—an abdominal surgery. The risks, though uncommon, include infection, bleeding, injury to the bowel or bladder, and problems with anaesthesia.

A vasectomy closes the two thin tubes that carry sperm. These lie just under the skin of the scrotum. In no-scalpel vasectomy the doctor reaches them through a single tiny puncture, under local anaesthesia. There is no entry into the abdomen and usually no stitch. The man walks home and can return to light work within a couple of days. Complications are mostly minor, such as bruising, swelling or a small infection. It does not affect erections, sexual desire or physical strength. One point needs honest counselling: a vasectomy does not work at once, and the couple needs another method (of contraception) for about three months afterwards.

Both operations are highly effective. The World Health Organisation (WHO)-supported family planning handbook puts first-year failure at about 0.5 per 100 for female sterilisation and about 0.15 per 100 for vasectomy. Both should be treated as permanent.

On every count, vasectomy is the lighter procedure. Yet the heavier one is done over a hundred times more often.

Camps, Targets and Bilaspur

This did not happen by accident. For decades the programme was run on numerical targets. After the coercive vasectomy drives of the Emergency in the mid-1970s, sterilising men became politically untouchable, and the targets shifted to women. The 1994 International Conference on Population and Development in Cairo moved the world from population control towards reproductive rights, and in 1996 India announced a Target Free Approach. On paper, targets ended. In practice “expected levels of achievement”, incentive payments to acceptors and motivators, and pressure on frontline workers kept much of the old logic going.

Its cost became impossible to ignore in November 2014. At a sterilisation camp in Takhatpur, in Bilaspur district of Chhattisgarh, 83 women were sterilised at a single camp. Thirteen of them died in the days that followed.

In September 2016, in Devika Biswas v Union of India, the Supreme Court held that what was happening in such camps violated women’s right to health and reproductive freedom. The court directed the Union government to phase out sterilisation camps within three years and to strengthen regular health facilities instead. It also said states must not set even informal targets, that consent must be explained in a language the woman understands, that deaths and failures must be audited and reported, and that compensation should be raised.

The standards were already there. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare publishes manuals on standards and quality assurance in sterilisation services, covering screening, asepsis, the number of cases a team may do in a day, and follow-up. The Family Planning Indemnity Scheme provides compensation for death, complications and failure after sterilisation. What has been missing is consistent practice.

Why the gap persists

Myths come first. Many men, and many families, believe vasectomy causes weakness, ends a man’s capacity for hard labour or damages his sexual life. None of this is true, but families who depend on his wages often share the fear. NFHS-5 found that about 35% of men agreed that contraception is women’s business and a man should not have to worry about it.

Then there is timing. A woman meets the health system at delivery, and sterilisation is often offered soon after childbirth or with a caesarean section. That suits the system, but it is not always a good moment for a permanent decision. NFHS-5 gives the median age at sterilisation as 25.7 years. A decision made at 25, sometimes within days of a birth, has to last a lifetime.

Counselling is thin. Among sterilised women in NFHS-5, only about 65% said they had been told about other methods, and about 59% had been told about possible side effects. The public sector now offers a wider range: the intrauterine device (IUCD), including after delivery; the injectable contraceptive MPA under the Antara programme; the non-hormonal weekly pill Chhaya; condoms and daily pills. A woman who has never been offered these has not really chosen sterilisation.

Every year from November 21 to December 4, the government observes a Vasectomy Fortnight to encourage men to come forward. It is welcome, but a fortnight cannot undo a year of silence.

What needs to Change

Counselling must be real: unhurried, in the woman’s own language, without the husband or the motivator answering for her, and never in the labour room. Reversible methods should be offered first to young couples, with steady supplies so that a missed injection does not become an unwanted pregnancy.

Quality standards must apply in every facility, with follow-up visits that actually take place. States should publish what the Supreme Court asked for: how many procedures, how many complications, how many deaths, how many failures, and what was done about each.

Men need to be reached directly. ASHAs and ANMs speak mostly to women. We need male health workers, satisfied vasectomy users and trained no-scalpel vasectomy providers at district level, speaking to men where they work.

Finally, a woman must be free to say no, to sterilisation or to any method, without losing a benefit or the goodwill of the health worker she will need again. Family planning was meant to give women control over their bodies. A programme where one sex does nearly all the bleeding has not yet done that.

(The author holds a degree in medicine, an MBBS, MS [Obstetrics and Gynaecology], is an obstetrician-gynaecologist from Assam and is also a medical reviewer at abortion-riyadh.com)

Sources

  1. NFHS-5 (2019–21), India Fact Sheet, IIPS and MoHFW: https://rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5_FCTS/India.pdf
    2. NFHS-5 (2019–21), India National Report, IIPS and ICF: https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR375/FR375.pdf
    3. Devika Biswas v Union of India & Ors, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 95 of 2012, Supreme Court of India, judgment of 14 September 2016 (summary, Human Rights Law Network): https://www.hrln.org/litigation/devika-biswas-versus-union-of-india-and-ors-writ-petition-c-no-95-of-2012-the-supreme-court-of-india
    4. National Health Mission, MoHFW, Family Planning programme, guidelines and manuals: https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=2&sublinkid=821&lid=222
    5. WHO, Family planning/contraception methods fact sheet: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/family-planning-contraception
    6. WHO/Johns Hopkins, Family Planning: A Global Handbook for Providers, contraceptive effectiveness: https://fphandbook.org/sites/default/files/legacy/book/fph_appendix_a/index.shtml
    7. Centre for Economic Data and Analysis, Ashoka University, “Female sterilisation in India: prevalence, informed choice and regret” (2024): https://ceda.ashoka.edu.in/female-sterilisation-in-india-prevalence-informed-choice-and-regret/
    8. UNFPA, International Conference on Population and Development (Cairo, 1994): https://www.unfpa.org/icpd


Related:

Menstrual health of women in shambles: Surveys highlight need for inclusive and accessible healthcare services

Human rights of Women in mental health institutions violated: SC

India’s Poorest Women Benefit Less From Public Health, Nutrition Services

The post Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination https://sabrangindia.in/god-beyond-patriarchy-recovering-the-feminine-in-the-islamic-imagination/ Fri, 13 Nov 2026 05:55:39 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50085 To affirm that God transcends gender is not merely a doctrinal statement. It is a spiritual and ethical commitment.

The post God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
“I believe femininity is at least as close to divinity as masculinity. The masculine bias in this matter is one of the worst forms of anthropomorphism.” So wrote the process philosopher Charles Hartshorne. Decades later, Christian writer Sarah Bessey would make a related claim in a different register: “Patriarchy is not God’s dream for humanity.”

While these statements emerged from Christian and philosophical contexts, they raise a question that Muslims should not dismiss too quickly: What happens when we confuse God with our own social arrangements? More specifically, what happens when patriarchal culture becomes so deeply embedded in religious interpretation that divine reality itself begins to appear male?

The irony is striking. Islam’s central theological principle, tawhid, insists that God is utterly unlike creation. “There is nothing whatever like unto Him” (Q. 42:11). Yet Muslims frequently imagine and speak of God through overwhelmingly masculine imagery. Even when acknowledging that God’s essence transcends gender, religious discourse often unconsciously associates divine authority, power, judgment, and leadership with masculinity.

Hartshorne’s observation remains devastatingly relevant. If God is neither male nor female, then privileging masculine imagery as somehow closer to divine reality is not theological sophistication. It is anthropomorphism. It is projecting human social structures onto the divine.

Islamic theology, at its best, has always recognized this danger. The Qur’an relentlessly critiques idolatry not merely as the worship of statues but as the tendency to fashion God according to human desires and assumptions. Idolatry begins not only when we worship false gods but when we create God in our own image.

This is why the divine names matter.

Among Allah’s ninety-nine names are al-Rahman and al-Rahim, typically translated as “The Most Compassionate” and “The Most Merciful.” What is often forgotten is that both are linguistically linked to the Arabic word rahm, meaning womb. Classical Muslim scholars frequently noted this connection. The most frequently invoked attributes of God in the Qur’an are rooted in imagery associated with nurturing, care, protection, and life-giving relationality.

The significance of this cannot be overstated.

The Qur’an could have foregrounded sovereignty alone. It could have emphasized divine domination and power above all else. Yet the first words Muslims encounter before almost every chapter are “In the Name of God, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.” Divine mercy precedes divine judgment. Compassion grounds authority. Relationship comes before command.

These are not exclusively feminine qualities, of course. But neither are they traditionally masculine. They point beyond rigid gender binaries toward a richer understanding of the divine.

Indeed, Muslim mystics often grasped this more clearly than legalists and theologians. The great Persian tradition of madhhab-i ‘ishq, the “school of love,” found in figures such as Farid al-Din Attar and Hafez, understood that God is encountered not primarily through domination or hierarchy but through intimacy, beauty, longing, and love. The lover-beloved relationship became a powerful metaphor for humanity’s relationship with the Divine.

quranictheology_NewAGEiLSM.gif

Love dissolves hierarchy.

One cannot meaningfully speak of being over, above, or superior to another while simultaneously speaking the language of genuine love. Love draws persons into communion rather than domination. It creates reciprocity without erasing difference.

This insight carries profound implications for Muslim discussions about gender.

Too often contemporary debates about women in Islam become trapped between two unsatisfactory choices. On one side stand defenders of traditional patriarchy who assume that male leadership reflects some eternal divine order. On the other stand secular critics who conclude that religion itself is inherently patriarchal and therefore irredeemable.

Both positions miss something important.

The deeper question is not whether particular historical Muslim societies were patriarchal. Most were. The real question is whether patriarchy is intrinsic to Islam’s vision of God and humanity.

The Qur’an’s theological trajectory suggests otherwise.

Human beings, male and female, are described as originating from a single soul (nafs wahida). Moral worth is measured not by gender but by taqwa, God-consciousness. The believing men and believing women are repeatedly mentioned together as equal participants in the spiritual project. The creation narrative lacks the notion that woman is somehow a derivative or secondary being whose existence serves male purposes.

When these principles are taken seriously, patriarchy begins to look less like a theological necessity and more like a historical accommodation.

This is where Hartshorne’s critique becomes particularly useful. If God is the supreme exemplar of relationality, love, responsiveness, and care rather than unilateral domination, then our religious communities should mirror those attributes. Authority becomes service rather than control. Leadership becomes empowerment rather than hierarchy. Strength becomes the capacity to nurture flourishing rather than to command obedience.

Such a vision resonates deeply with the Qur’anic conception of divine mercy encompassing all things.

For Muslims today, the challenge is not simply to include more women in religious institutions, important though that is. The challenge is theological. It is to recover aspects of the Islamic tradition that have been obscured by centuries of patriarchal assumptions and to reimagine God not as a cosmic patriarch but as the source of boundless mercy, beauty, creativity, and love.

Patriarchy, after all, narrows both women and men. It restricts human potential by confining people within rigid expectations of what masculinity and femininity should be. The God of the Qur’an is far greater than such limitations.

To affirm that God transcends gender is not merely a doctrinal statement. It is a spiritual and ethical commitment. It means refusing to sanctify social hierarchies simply because they are old. It means measuring our communities against divine compassion rather than inherited power structures.

And perhaps it means taking seriously the possibility that Hartshorne and Bessey, each in their own way, were pointing toward a truth that the Islamic tradition has always contained but has not always fully embraced: that the closer we draw to God, the less convincing patriarchy becomes. For a God whose mercy is womb-like, whose love exceeds every category, and whose reality transcends every human projection can never be reduced to the image of a celestial patriarch. The God of tawhid is infinitely more beautiful, more relational, and more liberating than that.

Adis Duderija is an Associate Professor in Islam and Society and Griffith University and a book series editor of a new book series on Islam and Process-Relational Thought (Routledge).

Courtesy: New Age Islam

The post God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR https://sabrangindia.in/vote-chori-fake-applications-to-delete-28-voters-uttarakhand-court-directs-police-to-register-fir/ Thu, 12 Nov 2026 09:32:05 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50076 A concrete case of allegations of criminality and violation of election law and rules, especially related to the Form 7 method of ‘mass deletions’ has come to light from Uttarakhand, with a BLA-2 (Ikram Ali himself petitioning the court for registration of an FIR after his identity and email were misused for 28 deletions: Ali had also approached the Haldwani judicial magistrate for directions to register an FIR which the court has directed on October 6.

The post Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
NEW DELHI – A judicial magistrate court in Haldwani, Uttarakhand, has directed police to register a First Information Report (FIR) and investigate allegations that Form-7 applications were fraudulently submitted in the name of a Booth Level Agent (BLA-2) to seek the deletion of 28 voters from the electoral rolls. The matter came to light after the complainant and petitioner–Ikram Ali — himself the BLA-2 in question whose identity had been purportedly fraudulently misused –had filed complaints for redressal. Alleging that he informed concerned election officials in writing, and when faced with silence sent his complaint to the Banbhoolpura police station by speed post on August 24, which was received by the police on August 27, according to the court order. The order was passed on October 6, The grave issue has been reported in Hindustan, Dainik Jagran and Hindustan Gazette.

After allegedly receiving no effective action at the police station, Ali submitted yet another complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Nainital, on August 29. The complaint was received on August 31, the order recorded. However, the court noted that despite the complaints, no FIR had been registered and no effective investigative action had been taken, prompting Ali to approach the magistrate. In its order, the court examined the police report sought in the matter as is required under Section 175 (3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023.[1]

Advocate Manish Kumar Pandey, represents complainant, Ikram Ali, a resident of Indiranagar in Banbhulpura. While rejecting the stay application, the court scheduled the next hearing on the revision petition for December 7, 2026, noting that the non-registration of an FIR to date is also a serious matter.

Judicial Magistrate First Class Shubhangi Gupta, in an order dated October 6, accepted a petition filed by Ikram Ali, a resident of Ward No. 31 in Haldwani, under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023. The court directed the officer in charge of Banbhoolpura police station to register an FIR on the basis of the complaint received on August 24 and investigate the matter in accordance with law.

The Magistrate’s order relates to serious illegalities in the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Ali, the petitioner and original complainant before the police, has reportedly told the court that he was working as a BLA-2 during the revision process when he learnt on August 20 that Form-7 applications had been submitted online in his name on August 12, seeking the deletion of 28 voters from Part No. 134 of the electoral roll. According to the petition, Ali denied submitting any such applications, either for himself or on behalf of any other voter. He also denied authorising anyone to file them in his name.

In the petition, Ali alleged that unidentified persons had misused his identity to prepare and submit the applications, purportedly presenting themselves as him before the election office. Ali has also contended that he informed the concerned election officials in writing after learning about the applications. He subsequently sent a written complaint to Banbhoolpura police station by speed post on August 24, which was received by the police on August 27, according to the court order.

It was only after he reportedly received no effective action at the police station, that Ali submitted another complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Nainital, on August 29. The complaint was received on August 31, the order stated. The court observed that despite the complaints, no FIR had been registered and no effective investigative action had been taken, prompting Ali to approach the magistrate.

In the first instance, as observed by the court in its order, the court examined the police report sought in the matter. The report stated that the complaint concerned alleged forgery and identity theft in connection with SIR Form-7 applications. It also suggested that the complainant could raise his objection before the relevant Assistant Returning Officer under the existing procedure.

According to available media reports, Ikram Ali, the BLA-2 in question has stated that he reached Delhi on October 30, where he met senior Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi, and P. Chidambaram. In addition, he met with more than 20 MPs and senior leaders of the INDIA alliance, including a representative of SP chief Akhilesh Yadav, TMC MP Mahua Moitra, and former Jammu & Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti. Ikram informed all the leaders about the misuse of portal IDs and the deletion of voters’ names from the list using fake identities in Haldwani’s Indiranagar area. According to Ikram, all the leaders assured him that they are keeping a close watch on the matter and will take the issue forward.

The controversy surrounding the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is no longer limited to concerns about voters being asked to prove their eligibility or submit forms to remain on the rolls. The conscious and deliberate misuse of Form 7 for third party deletions, that too by dominant political actors, has been a recurring aspect of the controversial SIR process.

Widely reported investigations by The Hindu, both in Delhi and Karnataka have raised another serious question: who can or should initiate the process for deletion of voters, on what basis, and how effectively are such deletion processes being checked?

Detailed directions by the Court

In the Order dated October 6, the magistrate held that the availability of an alternative remedy before the election authorities was not sufficient grounds to reject the plea seeking a police investigation.

“The remedy available before the Assistant Returning Officer and the relief sought by the applicant operate in different fields and are not alternatives to each other,” the court observed.

The court noted that the election authority’s role was limited to matters such as correction and maintenance of electoral rolls, whereas the complaint concerned an alleged offence committed by unidentified persons.

The order of the court further observes that the relevant election authority did not have the power to investigate the criminal offence or obtain electronic records such as user IDs and login details, registered mobile numbers and email addresses, OTP and authentication information, IP addresses, and device-related records that could help identify those responsible.

The court said the mere availability of an alternative remedy was not sufficient grounds to dismiss the petition.

The magistrate referred to the Supreme Court’s judgments in *Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh* (2014) 2 SCC 1 and *Priyanka Srivastava v. State of U.P.* (2015) 6 SCC 287 while examining the requirements for directing police action.

Referring to *Lalita Kumari*, the court noted that where information prima facie discloses a cognisable offence, registration of an FIR is a legal duty of the police, followed by an investigation in accordance with law.

The court also observed that the police report had not rejected the complainant’s allegations or stated that no cognisable offence was made out. Nor did it refer to any investigation conducted at the police-station level.

The magistrate said that, at first glance, the alleged submission of applications in the complainant’s name by concealing his actual identity and impersonating him in official proceedings appeared to fall within the scope of a suspected criminal offence.

The court clarified, however, that it was not expressing a final opinion on the offences involved, which would have to be determined during the investigation.

Allowing the petition, the court directed the officer in charge of Banbhoolpura police station to register an FIR on the basis of Ali’s complaint dated August 24, 2026, and investigate the case in accordance with law.

It also ordered that a copy of the order be sent immediately to the concerned police station.

The order does not establish who submitted the disputed Form-7 applications or whether the 28 voters were ultimately removed from the electoral rolls. Those issues remain subject to investigation.


[1] Unlike its predecessor, Section 156 (3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure this section—175 (3) has controversially added “several procedural” steps ostensibly to prevent misuse of magisterial powers. These include submission of the said complaint to the Superintendant of Police (SP), accompanied by an affidavit as also recording of the police version.


Related:

SIR: Form 7 controversies raise fresh questions about the continued power to delete voters

The post Vote Chori: Fake Applications to Delete 28 Voters; Uttarakhand court directs police to register FIR appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint https://sabrangindia.in/diwali-2026-smoke-noise-fires-and-the-failure-of-restraint/ Thu, 12 Nov 2026 07:43:15 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50064 Across cities, Diwali celebrations brought severe pollution, excessive noise, fires, deaths and violence, the events raise questions about civic responsibility and enforcement: when existing rules repeatedly fail, what measures can ensure celebrations do not endanger others?

The post Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Diwali night began with celebrations, but in several cities, it was followed by smoke, severe pollution and a large number of emergency calls. In Delhi, air quality deteriorated sharply as the evening progressed.

On November 8, at 10 pm, the city’s overall AQI stood at 371, while 20 monitoring stations were in the “severe” category. Smoke hung over roads and residential neighbourhoods, visibility dropped and residents reported difficulty breathing. The manner and method of India’s recording of pollution levels (AQI) is controversial. Independent platforms like AQI.in and IQAir reported morning readings between 600 and 610 (“hazardous”). The numbers differ because of Indian authorities/government playing around with statistics: India’s official National Air Quality Index (NAQI) caps its scale at 500 and averages data over 24 hours. Private trackers typically use the US EPA standard—which has stricter thresholds for fine particulate matter (\ (PM_ {2.5}\)) and no upper cap—and report real-time hourly spikes rather than 24-hour averages! So, in reality air quality in Delhi was worse than what was propagated.

Restrictions were ostensibly already in place, with green firecrackers permitted only during prescribed hours. Yet crackers continued to be burst in several parts of the city, and pollution continued to rise through the night. The following morning, Delhi recorded some of its worst pollution readings in years, with PM[1] 2.5 concentrations crossing 2,000 micrograms per cubic metre at several locations. At Mundka, the reading reached 3,744 µg/m³, while other stations recorded concentrations above 3,000.

The national 24-hour standard for PM 2.5 is 60 µg/m³[2].

These are not marginal departures from permissible levels. They clearly show the scale of pollution produced when a city already struggling with winter air quality enters a night of widespread firecracker bursting. AQI can be checked here: Link: https://www.aqi.in/in

When the monitors went silent

The pollution issue also raised serious questions about monitoring and public information. According to the Indian Express, on Diwali night, 45 of Delhi’s 59 monitoring stations had missing hourly readings for at least one pollutant. By midnight, 29 stations were not reporting some readings, and by 1 am the number had risen to 36. This was also the period when particulate pollution was peaking.

Data later released by the Delhi Pollution Control Committee showed that several of the missing periods coincided with extremely high concentrations. An analysis found that all 125 station-hour readings missing from the Central Pollution Control Board’s records were above 1,000 µg/m³ in the corresponding DPCC data, the Times of India reported.

The gaps matter because people cannot protect themselves from a danger whose extent is not being clearly recorded or publicly reflected during the period when exposure is at its highest.

Stubble burning cannot explain away everything

The issue of Delhi’s air pollution has often been reduced to one familiar explanation: farm fires and stubble burning. Crop-residue burning remains a serious source of pollution across the wider northern air shed. On Diwali day, Punjab recorded 1,152 farm fires, the highest single-day figure of the season, sharply increasing the state’s cumulative tally.

But acknowledging the contribution of stubble burning cannot explain away what happened within Delhi as evening celebrations intensified. The pollution surge followed sunset and continued through the night, with experts pointing to stagnant winter conditions combined with substantial firecracker emissions. At several locations, pollution levels rose sharply during the hours when crackers were being burst.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by The News Man (@thenews.man)

Mumbai also recorded sharp localised spikes after nightfall, while several inland cities in Maharashtra reported poor and very poor air quality. Pune, Pimpri-Chinchwad, Nagpur, Malegaon and other cities recorded serious deterioration.

The available evidence does not require a choice between farm fires and firecrackers. Both can contribute. The problem arises when one source is repeatedly invoked to minimise or divert attention from another.

Mumbai’s averages and the air people actually breathed

Mumbai initially appeared to have had a better Diwali, with its citywide AQI lower than during the corresponding period last year. But citywide averages concealed what was happening in individual neighbourhoods.

In Andheri, PM2.5 stood at 42 at 8 pm. Within two hours, it had surged to nearly 500 in one set of readings and even higher on private monitoring platforms.

Malad recorded similarly extreme levels, while Chembur saw PM10 concentrations of around 480. Other parts of the city also recorded sharp spikes after dark.

A citywide average may suggest improvement, but a resident does not breathe the city’s average. People breathe the air immediately around their homes, workplaces and neighbourhoods.

This is particularly important for children, elderly people and those already affected by respiratory or other health conditions.

The morning after Diwali brought little relief to several areas. Eight monitoring locations in Mumbai entered the “poor” category, with Bandra East among the worst affected.

Even the upper floors are not an escape

A study in Mumbai added another dimension to the problem of urban pollution. There is often an assumption that living high above the street means living above the worst of the city’s polluted air. The findings suggested otherwise.

According to a study by the Mumbai Ecological Research and Analysis Group (MERAG), across residential complexes in Wadala, upper floors of high-rises could be up to 40 per cent more polluted than lower levels. Researchers found a persistent increase in pollution with height in the buildings examined. Smoke and fine particles do not necessarily remain at street level. Air currents, distant emissions and complicated wind patterns created by clusters of high-rise buildings can carry and trap pollutants at higher elevations. For residents of increasingly vertical cities, moving higher may not always mean moving away from pollution.

Less noise, but still too much

There was one limited positive trend. Mumbai’s peak firecracker noise levels were reported to have fallen sharply compared with levels recorded two decades ago. A recent study found peak readings significantly lower than those recorded in 2006. \

But lower does not necessarily mean acceptable or safe.

A peak reading of around 93 decibels was still above permissible ambient noise limits for residential areas. Mumbai has notified silence zones where firecrackers are prohibited and restrictions also exist on bursting crackers late at night.

The purpose of these restrictions is not difficult to understand. An elderly person, a patient, an infant or someone seriously ill cannot simply choose to stop hearing explosions outside the home.

The issue is therefore not merely whether some people enjoy loud celebrations. It is whether others have any right to peace, rest and safety within their own homes.

That question lies at the heart of the larger problem.

Are appeals and restrictions enough?

For years, the response has largely followed a familiar pattern. Courts issue directions. Authorities prescribe timings. Green crackers are promoted. Silence zones are notified. Appeals are made for restraint.

Yet every year there are reports of violations.

But later, allowed certified green crackers in Delhi-NCR for two Diwali days.

On October 15, Bombay High Court had extended the total ban on bursting firecrackers on public streets, lanes, and footpaths to apply throughout the year and across all festivals, including Navratri, Diwali, and Christmas.

The question that now needs to be asked more directly is whether limited permissions and appeals to voluntary compliance can actually be enforced at the scale required in large Indian cities.

If the answer is repeatedly no, then the debate over stronger restrictions or prohibitions cannot simply be dismissed as hostility towards a festival.

A ban or prohibition is not automatically the answer. But if existing regulation repeatedly produces toxic air, excessive noise, injuries and deaths, the effectiveness of the present system must be honestly examined.

The question is whether India can have a Diwali that is celebratory without turning into a night when the elderly and sick live in dread of the next explosion.

A ten-year-old and a firecracker

In Delhi’s Narela, a ten-year-old boy died after a firecracker burst in his hands. He had reportedly been holding a flower-pot firecracker outside his home when it exploded.

The flames burned his chest, and his family initially believed the injury might be minor. He later fainted, was taken to hospital and declared dead. On the same Diwali, the Delhi Fire Services received 281 calls, with at least 24 related to fires caused by bursting crackers.

The danger is known. The repeated injuries are known. The risks of allowing children to handle firecrackers are known. Yet the question remains whether the knowledge of these dangers is reflected in how people actually behave.

Fires across the Mumbai region

In Mumbai, firecrackers were linked to 137 of the 142 fire calls received on Diwali. In Thane, all 44 fire calls received by Sunday night were reportedly caused by firecrackers.

Across the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, more than 500 fire incidents were reported over the weekend.

A day after Diwali, authorities in Mumbai, Nagpur and Thane imposed restrictions on rockets and similar aerial firecrackers following the surge in fire incidents.

In Mumbai, a lift operator died after being trapped as smoke spread through a high-rise building.

Other fires were also reported in residential and commercial structures.

The pattern again raises a question about regulation. Why do additional restrictions so often follow major incidents rather than preventing them?

Fifty people rescued in Thane

In Thane, a major fire engulfed a residential building during the Diwali night. Residents fled through smoke-filled passages, while some took shelter in balconies and utility ducts.

Around 50 people were rescued as the fire spread through several floors of the 17-storey building. An elderly resident described being trapped as flames and smoke spread, while others sheltered with ageing parents.

Firefighters worked through the night, while the exact cause was examined. The episode again demonstrated how vulnerable densely populated vertical cities can become when fire spreads through a residential building.

Thane’s fire services were also reportedly facing a serious manpower shortage, and firefighters from Mumbai had to be called in.

Cities have grown taller and more densely populated. The risks associated with fire have grown with them.

Two families, twelve deaths

In Madhya Pradesh, the scale of tragedy was even greater. Six members of a family were killed in a fire in Katni, including three children and a two-month-old infant.

The fire broke out in a residential-cum-commercial building, and the family was trapped upstairs as the blaze spread. A preliminary inquiry pointed to an earthen lamp as a possible source. The fire was fuelled by highly inflammable material stored below, while rescue teams struggled for hours to save those trapped inside. The district collector later apologised to families and residents, acknowledging that six lives could not be saved despite the deployment of fire tenders.

On the same night, another fire in Seoni killed six members of another family. In both cases, families were asleep when the fires spread.

Twelve people from two families were dead, including children, elderly people and members of different generations.

The other problem: how do we live with one another?

The pollution and fires are one part of the story. The other is the increasingly visible absence of civic restraint. Firecrackers are burst inside housing societies, near parked vehicles, beneath balconies and beside buildings occupied by hundreds of residents.

Those who do not wish to participate have little control over what happens around them.

An elderly person cannot prevent smoke from entering the home. A family with an infant cannot control where a rocket will land. A patient cannot necessarily escape a night of explosions by simply closing a window.

The issue is not whether people have a right to celebrate. It is whether celebration gives anyone the right to disregard the safety and peace of those living around them.

This is a question of civic sense and shared urban life.

One argument, one death

In Mumbai, a dispute connected with firecrackers ended in the death of a 19-year-old. Shubhankar Mukhiya and his friends were heading towards Juhu beach when crackers were burst near a parked motorcycle.

An argument followed. According to police, the motorcycle belonged to one of the accused, and the confrontation initially appeared to have ended.

Police alleged that the accused later returned with two others and that Mukhiya and his friends were attacked with kicks and punches. Mukhiya fell, suffered a severe head injury and later died.

A disagreement over firecrackers had escalated into an alleged fatal assault.

The question is not simply what caused the argument. It is why an increasingly ordinary disagreement in public life can so quickly become an occasion for violence.

Violence around the celebration

In Delhi, another teenager did not return home from a Diwali outing. Sixteen-year-old Devansh had reportedly gone out with friends to buy crackers.

Police said that a group of men allegedly tried to snatch his money and phone. When he resisted, he was stabbed and later died after being taken to hospital. The circumstances were different from the Mumbai case, but both the incidents form part of a larger and troubling picture of aggression in public spaces. Diwali is meant to be a festival of homes, families and communities. Yet the night also produced fights, assaults and confrontations.

When those enforcing the rules are attacked

There is another dimension to the problem. Rules are meaningful only if someone can enforce them. When police personnel or other officials attempt to enforce restrictions on firecrackers, noise or public safety, they can themselves become targets of hostility or violence.

The image of a lone policeman attempting to enforce a rule, while facing an aggressive crowd or being attacked, raises a basic question about civic conduct. What does it say about respect for law when a person performing a public duty becomes the object of anger merely for attempting to enforce regulations?

The issue cannot be reduced to firecrackers alone. It concerns a wider relationship between citizens, public authority and shared rules.

Are we becoming an insensate and uncivil society?

This is the more difficult question raised by the events surrounding Diwali. Are Indians becoming increasingly insensitive to the effect of their actions on those living around them? Are we becoming more aggressive, less restrained and less willing to accept even the most basic rules of shared civic life?

The evidence of one festival cannot answer such a large question by itself. But it can expose a pattern.

Smoke is treated as someone else’s problem. Noise is treated as a neighbour’s problem. A falling rocket is treated as an accident waiting to happen somewhere else.

Rules are often accepted in principle but resented when they are enforced against us. And when a disagreement arises, too often the response is not restraint but aggression.

The old, the sick and the very young have little power in this situation. They cannot negotiate with the person bursting crackers outside their home. The person who chooses silence cannot impose it on the person who chooses noise.

The family that follows the rules cannot guarantee that its neighbours will do the same.

Urban life requires restraint

Living in a crowded city necessarily requires limits.

A person living in a high-rise, an apartment block or a densely populated neighbourhood does not live in isolation. Every action takes place close to someone else.

That is why urban life requires civic restraint.

It requires recognising that a celebration in one flat can become a disturbance in another, and that an act carried out for pleasure can impose danger or suffering on someone who has not chosen to participate.

This is not an argument against celebration.

It is an argument against the belief that celebration means freedom from responsibility.

The question before the next Diwali

The Diwali of 2026 again demonstrated the limits of relying only on appeals, partial restrictions and voluntary compliance.

Court directions and institutional controls remain important, but they are meaningful only when they can be implemented and enforced.

The debate must therefore move beyond the familiar argument between those who want unrestricted celebrations and those who seek restrictions.

The more practical question is what actually works.

Can limited permissions, prescribed timings and appeals to civic sense deliver a genuinely safer and less polluted Diwali?

If they cannot, should authorities consider stronger restrictions, clearer prohibitions and designated spaces where activities involving serious risks can be more effectively controlled?

A saner Diwali should not be impossible to imagine.

It should not be a night when elderly people and patients dread the next explosion, when children lose their lives, when homes and high-rises catch fire, or when those attempting to enforce the rules face violence.

What the Diwali night left behind

A ten-year-old died after a firecracker burst in his hands. A 19-year-old died after an argument connected with crackers escalated into an alleged assault, while another teenager was stabbed after going out to buy Diwali crackers.

Hundreds of fire calls were received across the Mumbai region, around 50 people were rescued from a burning high-rise in Thane, and twelve members of two families died in separate fires in Madhya Pradesh.

Delhi’s pollution monitors developed gaps as particulate levels surged, while corresponding data later showed some readings in the thousands.

Mumbai’s overall air quality appeared better in aggregate, but individual neighbourhoods recorded dramatic spikes after dark. Noise levels may have fallen over the years, but they continued to exceed permissible limits.

The festival has passed, but the questions remain.

What kind of institutional controls can actually ensure compliance? Is a stronger prohibition necessary where limited regulation repeatedly fails? And what does our conduct during these celebrations say about our capacity to live with consideration for others?

These are not questions about whether people should celebrate their festivals.

They are questions about how they celebrate them, and whether celebration can coexist with civic responsibility, public safety and respect for the people living around us.

A festival cannot become an occasion when the old and sick live in dread, young lives are lost, public spaces turn violent and even those attempting to enforce the law face aggression.

The smoke, noise, fires and violence of this Diwali should force a more serious conversation before the next one arrives.


 

[1] PM means Particulate Matter (also known as particle pollution), which is a mix of microscopic solid particles and liquid droplets suspended in the air).

[2] µg/m³ stands for micrograms per cubic meter and measures the mass concentration of a pollutant in a specific volume of air.

 

Related:

Diwali has been celebrated by Muslims for centuries

Toxic Air To Blame For Lung Cancer; No Longer Just A Smoker’s Disease

The post Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>