A Mumbai sessions court has granted anticipatory bail to a Muslim man booked under Maharashtra’s newly enacted Freedom of Religion Act, 2026, after finding that the material placed before it did not, at this stage, establish that his Hindu wife had been unlawfully converted to Islam. The court took particular note of the fact that the couple had solemnised their marriage under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, and that the police had found no entry recording a Nikah between them in the register seized from the Maulavi allegedly involved in the ceremony.
The order, passed on November 20 by Additional Sessions Judge P.A. Sane of the City Civil and Sessions Court at Dindoshi, Mumbai, is significant as the first reported case registered in Mumbai under the new anti-conversion legislation and one of the earliest, if not the first, anticipatory bail applications to be decided under the law in Maharashtra.
The case arose from a complaint filed by the woman’s mother at Meghwadi police station, alleging that the accused had induced her 22-year-old daughter, a Hindu, to convert to Islam by promising to marry her. The accused was booked under Section 9(1) of the Maharashtra Freedom of Religion Act, 2026, which penalises unlawful religious conversion.
However, the court’s examination of the circumstances surrounding the marriage brought into focus a crucial distinction: the allegation of religious conversion was being pursued despite the couple having already entered into a legally registered civil marriage under a law that permits interfaith marriages without either person having to change their religion.
A civil marriage under the Special Marriage Act preceded the allegations
According to the complaint, the couple had been in contact since the COVID-19 lockdown, when the woman’s family had given her a mobile phone for educational purposes. The complainant alleged that the relationship continued despite her family’s objections and that, at one point, the accused had told her daughter that he would marry her if she accepted Islam. The complainant further alleged that the family subsequently moved from Jogeshwari to Virar to distance the daughter from the accused. However, the two continued to remain in contact.
On October 18, 2026, the woman left home for work and did not return. Her mother subsequently approached the Virar police, reporting her missing and expressing apprehension that she might have been abducted. Two days later, the daughter informed her mother that she had married the accused in Bandra. She also showed her the marriage certificate and told the police that the marriage had been registered voluntarily. The chronology of the marriage, however, became central to the anticipatory bail proceedings.
The accused’s counsel, Advocate Karim Pathan, submitted that the couple had jointly issued a statutory notice of their intended marriage to the Marriage Officer, Mumbai Suburban District, on September 15, 2026, under Section 5 of the Special Marriage Act, 1954. Their marriage was subsequently solemnised and registered on October 16, 2026, well before the invitation card that became the basis of the complainant’s allegations was circulated.
The marriage certificate also retained the woman’s original name. Her husband had forwarded a copy of the certificate to her family, and she had independently informed the police that she had married voluntarily. Pathan argued that the couple’s decision to marry under the Special Marriage Act, which provides a legal framework for marriages between persons belonging to different religions without requiring conversion, contradicted the suggestion that the accused had made marriage conditional upon a change of faith.
A wedding invitation and a photograph of the woman in a burkha became the basis of the conversion allegations
The immediate trigger for the complaint was an invitation card sent by the accused to the woman’s brother on October 24, eight days after the civil marriage had already been solemnised. The card announced a wedding ceremony scheduled for November 6 and carried a Muslim name alongside the woman’s name, with the latter appearing as ‘Ayesha’. The complainant alleged that this indicated that her daughter had been induced to change her religion. The complainant’s side also relied upon photographs showing the woman wearing a burkha and alleged that a Nikah had been performed. A video purportedly showing the ceremony was also referred to during the proceedings.
The defence, however, disputed that these materials established either a religious conversion or the performance of a Nikah. Pathan argued that the name ‘Ayesha’ had been used as an alternative name and that merely mentioning it on an invitation card could not establish that the woman had changed her religion. He further submitted that the reference to Nikah in the invitation was in the context of a religious or social ceremony following the civil marriage.
The defence also placed before the court a signed statement by the woman asserting her freedom, as an adult, to decide what she wished to wear, including a burkha. Her choice of clothing, counsel argued, could not be treated as evidence of a religious conversion.
The prosecution and the complainant’s counsel opposed anticipatory bail, arguing that the allegations required further investigation. They sought custodial interrogation to examine the alleged Nikah, question the Maulavi, scrutinise WhatsApp conversations and other social media communications, and ascertain whether there had been any financial transactions, inducement, blackmail or pressure.
The prosecution also questioned whether the statutory requirements under Section 6 of the Act had been complied with and argued that the investigation needed to establish how the woman had come to use the name ‘Ayesha’ and whether any other persons had facilitated the alleged conversion.
Seized Nikah register contained no entry of a ceremony between the couple
One of the most significant aspects of the proceedings was the examination of the register seized by the investigating officer from the Maulavi, in connection with the allegation that the couple had undergone a Nikah. During the hearing, the investigating officer and the Additional Public Prosecutor submitted a joint pursis informing the court that an examination of the Maulavi’s register had revealed no entry recording a Nikah between the accused and the woman.
The court noted that the Maulavi maintained a register in which entries were ordinarily made when a Nikah was performed. The absence of any such entry therefore became an important consideration in assessing the prosecution’s claim that a religious marriage had taken place. The court observed that there was no documentary material establishing the performance of a Nikah. It also considered the fact that the couple’s marriage had already been solemnised under the Special Marriage Act.
Examining the evidentiary value of the invitation card and photographs, Judge Sane questioned whether the mere use of a Muslim name could establish that the woman had converted to Islam. The court observed:
“Now, the question is that whether only quoting the name as Ayesha would be the ground to consider that she has converted her religion to Islam and in this regards as discussed above the register of the Maulavi particularly states that there is no entry in the register which is seized by the IO that Nikah has been taken place between the applicant and daughter ‘S’.” (Para 16)
It further held that the photographs of the woman wearing a burkha could not, by themselves, establish conversion.
“So far as alleged photograph and wearing burkha will not be the sole ground to believe that daughter ‘S’ has converted to Islam.” (Para 16)
The observations are particularly relevant to the allegations in the case because the materials relied upon by the complainant to suggest a change of religion were the alternative name on the invitation card, photographs of the woman in a burkha and the alleged performance of a Nikah. The court found that these materials, particularly in the absence of any corresponding entry in the seized register, did not establish the alleged religious ceremony at this stage.
Woman personally appears before court, affirms marriage was voluntary
Another important consideration was the woman’s own position during the proceedings. The 22-year-old appeared personally before the court, filed her Vakalatnama and opposed no relief being granted to her husband. She expressly stated that she had acted voluntarily and that neither the accused nor anyone else had subjected her to force, coercion, threats, pressure or inducement. The court also noted that her voluntary statements had previously been recorded by the police.
This was crucial because the allegations had been initiated by her mother rather than through a complaint by the woman herself alleging that she had been forced into marriage or converted against her will. The court considered her statement alongside the chronology of the relationship, the marriage certificate and the absence of documentary evidence establishing a Nikah.
It noted that the FIR itself indicated that the couple had been in contact since the pandemic period and that their relationship had continued over several years. Both were adults, and they had given prior statutory notice before solemnising their marriage under the Special Marriage Act.
On this basis, the court found it difficult, at the stage of considering anticipatory bail, to conclude that the ingredients of Section 3 of the Act, concerning conversion through coercion, fraud or other prohibited means, had been set into motion.
“As the register shows that no Nikah has been performed, at this point of time there would no question of sec. 6 and in view of the above discussion, as there is a love relationship between them since the pandemic situation, apparently it is seen that both are the adults and it is difficult to believe that any of the ingredients of Sec.3 are put into motion but at the same time when it is alleged that there is Nikah and one video however, there is no material at this point of time and considering these aspects, in view of the above discussion, I am of the view that the custodial interrogation of the applicant/accused is not required.” (Para 16)
Court finds custodial interrogation unnecessary, grants anticipatory bail
Having considered the submissions, the material on record and the woman’s personal statement, the court concluded that custodial interrogation of the accused was not necessary. It allowed Anticipatory Bail Application No. 1566 of 2026 and directed that, in the event of arrest, the accused be released on a personal recognisance bond of Rs. 50,000, with one surety for an equivalent amount.
The court imposed conditions requiring him to report to the concerned police station every Monday and Friday between noon and 3 p.m. for 90 days, cooperate with the investigation and refrain from tampering with evidence or contacting the complainant, witnesses or other persons connected with the case. He was also directed not to leave India without the court’s permission.
Importantly, the court clarified that if further material emerged during the investigation supporting the prosecution’s allegations, the investigating officer would be at liberty to seek cancellation of bail. The judge also expressly clarified that the observations in the order were confined to the anticipatory bail application and would not determine the merits of the case.
The order, therefore, does not conclude the investigation or pronounce upon the accused’s guilt or innocence. It does, however, record the court’s assessment that the material then available, including the wedding invitation, photographs and allegations of a Nikah, was insufficient to justify custodial interrogation in the absence of evidence establishing the alleged conversion.
The complete order may be accessed below:
Related:
Bilkis Bano Case: SC grants bail to two convicts, suspends life sentences pending appeal
Hate Watch: Jihad rhetoric, forced sloganeering mark UP-Uttarakhand week
Fetters on Autonomy of Choice: Maharashtra gets a “Freedom of Religion Act”, 2026

