The Supreme Court’s decision to suspend the life sentences of two men convicted in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gang rape and murder case, granting them bail after citing more than 17 years of incarceration, raises some questions about the manner in which prolonged imprisonment, individual circumstances and the gravity of an offence are weighed when judicial relief is considered. Particularly in question appears to be the absence of any discussion in the latest order of the substantial periods that the two convicts had already spent outside prison, first on parole and furlough and subsequently following the Gujarat government’s controversial decision to grant remission to all 11 convicts in 2022.
The latest order also leaves unaddressed an important part of the case’s procedural history: the Supreme Court had previously dismissed the Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) filed by the convicts challenging the Bombay High Court judgment that upheld their convictions in 2017. The Court’s own January 2024 judgment quashing the remission granted to the 11 accused records that the convicts’ challenges to the High Court verdict were dismissed in July and November 2017. Neither Bilkis Bano not her advocates were heard in these proceedings.
On October 28, a Bench of Justices MM Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, granting them bail pending adjudication of their appeals against the Bombay High Court’s May 2017 judgment upholding their convictions. The Bench relied on three principal considerations: the appellants’ incarceration for more than 17 years, the fact that one of them was severely handicapped, and the existence of questions of fact and law that would require adjudication in their appeals.
The order records the defence’s contention that one of the appellants had not been named in the original First Information Report (FIR) and had been implicated nearly three years after the incident. The prosecution, represented by Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre, vehemently opposed the applications, arguing that both the trial court and the High Court had considered the relevant evidence, particularly given the seriousness of the offences. The Court nevertheless ordered the suspension of their sentences, leaving the terms and conditions of bail to the concerned trial court.
The decision is significant not merely because two of the 11 convicts are set to walk out of prison again. It raises questions about the treatment of their custodial history, the grounds on which their fresh appeals have been entertained despite the earlier dismissal of SLPs, and whether the remaining nine convicts could seek similar relief.
Earlier SLPs dismissed in 2017: What does the fresh challenge mean?
One of the most consequential aspects of the latest proceedings is the procedural history of the convictions themselves. The Bombay High Court, on May 4, 2017, upheld the convictions and life sentences imposed on the 11 men by the special CBI court. The convicts challenged the High Court judgment before the Supreme Court. In its subsequent judgement related to the untimely remissions dated January 8, 2024 judgment in Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India, the Supreme Court recorded that the SLPs filed by the convicts against the High Court judgment had been dismissed through orders dated July 10, 2017 and November 20, 2017. The Court expressly noted that these dismissals upheld the findings rendered by the High Court as well as the sentences awarded.
Yet, the October 28, 2026 order arises from fresh SLPs filed by Joshi and Modhiya against the very same Bombay High Court judgment of May 4, 2017. The order records that leave has now been granted, converting the petitions into appeals, and suspends the sentences of the two appellants pending their adjudication.
This procedural history demands some scrutiny. The latest order does not refer to the earlier dismissal of the convicts’ SLPs, explain the circumstances in which the fresh challenges have come before the Court, or indicate whether the present petitions raise grounds materially different from those considered in the earlier proceedings.
It would be inaccurate to suggest that an earlier dismissal of an SLP automatically bars every subsequent challenge to the same judgment. The legal effect of an SLP dismissal depends, among other things, on the nature of the earlier order and whether leave had been granted. A dismissal at the threshold does not invariably result in the merger of the High Court judgment with the Supreme Court’s order. However, the existence of earlier proceedings and the dismissal of challenges to the same convictions raise questions of finality, successive litigation and the basis on which a fresh challenge is being entertained. These are not peripheral procedural details. The convictions had been upheld by the High Court and the convicts’ earlier challenges had been dismissed by the Supreme Court. The latest order, while granting leave and suspending the sentences, does not address this history. Most significant through all this is the fact that in the hearing of this application for bail by these two accused, neither were Bilkis Bano’s lawyers summoned or heard nor was she served notice for a chance to be heard.
More than 17 years of incarceration, but what does the complete prison record reveal?
The Supreme Court’s reliance on more than 17 years of incarceration deserves to be examined against the convicts’ actual custodial history, particularly the periods during which they were permitted to leave prison. According to details of the Gujarat government’s affidavit submitted before the Supreme Court in October 2022, as reported by The Telegraph, Joshi had spent 909 days on parole and another 170 days on furlough, amounting to 1,079 days outside prison. Modhiya had availed himself of 1,011 days of parole and 223 days of furlough, taking his total to 1,234 days outside prison, according to the figures published by the newspaper.
These figures amount to nearly three years for Joshi and more than three years for Modhiya. They are not incidental details. They form part of the official custodial history of the very convicts whose prolonged incarceration has now been invoked as a ground for suspending their life sentences. The timeline becomes even more consequential when the 2022 remission episode is taken into account.
On August 15, 2022, the Gujarat government released all 11 convicts prematurely, citing their eligibility under its remission policy and their conduct in prison. They remained outside prison until January 21, 2024, when they surrendered following the Supreme Court’s decision to quash the remission orders.
This was not an ordinary release. The Supreme Court, in its January 8, 2024 judgment in Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India, held that Gujarat was not the appropriate government to grant remission, as the trial had taken place in Maharashtra and the convicts had been sentenced by a court there. It held the remission orders illegal and vitiated, and directed all 11 convicts to surrender within two weeks. Thus, the two men had not only availed themselves of substantial periods of parole and furlough before their premature release, but had also spent approximately 17 months outside prison following the Gujarat government’s remission decision.
The latest Supreme Court order does not refer to these periods. Nor does it explain how the assertion of more than 17 years of incarceration was assessed against the complete history of temporary releases and the period during which the convicts remained free following the now-quashed remission.
Delayed implication nearly three years later: a defence submission, not a judicial finding
Another ground recorded by the Supreme Court is the defence’s contention that one of the appellants was not named in the original FIR and was implicated nearly three years after the occurrence. This is a significant issue that may require examination during the appeals. However, the distinction between a submission made by the defence and a finding established by the Court must be maintained.
The Indian Express reports today, November 17, that one of the accused in this bail application, Bipin Kanaiyalal Joshi was a neighbour of the survivor Bilkis Bano before the 2002 Gujarat carnage in the Randhikpur village of the Dahod district of Gujarat. The second accused Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya had a hotel in the same area. Not only were the two men, whose life terms were suspended by the Supreme Court on Monday among the 11 convicted by a Special CBI Court in Mumbai on January 20028, but the Bombay High Court had upheld the convictions in May 2017.
Most significantly, in its judgment, the trial court had recorded an eyewitness account of Modhiya being part of the mob that went on a rampage in Randhikpur on February 28, 2002, the day after the Godhra train burning. Prosecution witness Imtiyaz Yusuf Ghanchi had told the court that he had seen Modhiya pelting stones. He had also identified Modhiya’s brother Naresh, now dead, as being part of the mob and said he (Naresh) was holding a knife. Imtiyaz had said he fled with his mother and sister, and took shelter in a neighbour’s house for two days.Another prosecution witness, Salim Adam Ghanchi, had named Joshi among those he saw in the mob. According to the court order, Joshi’s father was a medical practitioner, and Bilkis Bano’s father was among his patients.
The October 28 order merely records the submission. It does not explain the circumstances of the subsequent implication or conclude that the delay undermines the prosecution’s case. Both men were convicted by the special CBI court in January 2008, and their convictions were upheld by the Bombay High Court in May 2017. The delayed implication argument must therefore be considered alongside the evidence on which the two courts based their findings of guilt.
The defence had also argued during earlier proceedings that the survivor had not named the two appellants in her initial police statement concerning the rape allegations or in her statement recorded during her medical examination. It further contended that no specific overt act had been attributed to them and that the evidence against them was limited to their alleged presence in the mob. These are grounds raised by the defence and remain matters for adjudication in the appeals.
The other individual consideration was Joshi’s severe physical disability. While disability and its implications for an individual’s health, dignity and conditions of incarceration are legitimate considerations in deciding bail, the order does not elaborate on the nature of his disability or the medical circumstances that informed the decision.
The question is not whether disability or prolonged incarceration should be disregarded. It is whether these considerations have been weighed against the complete evidentiary and custodial record, particularly in a case involving convictions for gang rape and multiple murders during the 2002 Gujarat communal violence.
A survivor should not have to repeatedly fight to preserve the outcome of a conviction
The Bilkis Bano case has become emblematic of the struggle for accountability following communal and gender-based violence. It has also demonstrated the enormous burden placed on survivors when executive decisions threaten to undo the outcomes of criminal proceedings.
Reacting to the development, Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta, who represented Bilkis Bano, spoke to Sabrangindia and described the Supreme Court’s decision as shocking. She said that just when Bilkis had hoped to find some measure of peace, the release of the two convicts had once again left her confronting the uncertainty surrounding the case. Gupta questioned the way the two men had secured their release, describing it as “not a straightforward procedure”.
The appeals are still to be decided. But the questions raised by this order cannot wait until then: what constitutes prolonged incarceration when the custodial record includes years of temporary release and a period of premature freedom? How consistently will the Court apply the grounds on which it has now granted relief? And what does this mean for a survivor who has already had to fight once to ensure that a judicially imposed sentence was not undone?
The 2022 remission controversy cannot be separated from the latest relief
The latest order comes against the backdrop of a prolonged legal battle in which the survivor herself had to approach the Supreme Court to challenge the premature release of the 11 convicts. Bilkis Bano was five months pregnant when she was gang raped during the 2002 Gujarat communal violence. Fourteen members of her family were murdered, including her three-year-old daughter.
The investigation was subsequently transferred to the CBI, and the Supreme Court transferred the trial from Gujarat to Maharashtra in 2004, citing concerns about the fairness of the proceedings. In January 2008, a special CBI court convicted 11 men and sentenced them to life imprisonment. The Bombay High Court upheld the convictions in May 2017.
Despite these judicial findings, the Gujarat government granted remission to all 11 men in August 2022, releasing them from prison. The decision prompted widespread outrage and was challenged before the Supreme Court, including by Bilkis Bano. In its January 8, 2024 judgment, the Supreme Court did considerably more than identify a technical jurisdictional error. It examined the circumstances surrounding the remission exercise, the suppression of material facts and the manner in which the Gujarat government had proceeded despite not being the appropriate government.
The Bench of Justices BV Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan held that the Gujarat government had usurped the powers of Maharashtra and that the remission orders were illegal. It also observed that the May 2022 order directing Gujarat to consider remission had been obtained through suppression of material facts and misrepresentation. The Court directed all 11 convicts to return to prison, emphasising that the consequences of an illegal remission had to follow.
Detailed reports may be read here, here and here.
The October 2026 order now provides two of those convicts another avenue to secure their release, this time through suspension of their sentences by the Supreme Court itself. Perhaps the most immediate legal implication of the October 28 order concerns the remaining nine convicts. The order could provide the remaining convicts with grounds to seek similar relief, particularly if they can demonstrate comparable periods of incarceration or raise issues in their own appeals. The principle of parity may also become relevant.
The complete order may be read here:
Related:
Justice once more for Bilkis Bano, but what now lies ahead?
Bilkis Bano speaks: First person account, Godhra Relief Camp, March 2002
Today, I Can Breathe Again: Bilkis Bano on landmark Supreme Court judgement

