Assasination | SabrangIndia News Related to Human Rights Fri, 24 Aug 2018 05:55:16 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png Assasination | SabrangIndia 32 32 Sanatan Sanstha Remains Untouched https://sabrangindia.in/sanatan-sanstha-remains-untouched/ Fri, 24 Aug 2018 05:55:16 +0000 http://localhost/sabrangv4/2018/08/24/sanatan-sanstha-remains-untouched/ Even though it has been established now that the SS was behind all the four political murders and is also involved in a larger conspiracy in the country, neither Athavale, nor the office bearers of the organisation have been interrogated.   Image Courtesy: The Indian Express   Sanatan Sanstha (SS), a Goa based Hindu-terror organisation, […]

The post Sanatan Sanstha Remains Untouched appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Even though it has been established now that the SS was behind all the four political murders and is also involved in a larger conspiracy in the country, neither Athavale, nor the office bearers of the organisation have been interrogated.
 
Sanatan sanstha
Image Courtesy: The Indian Express
 
Sanatan Sanstha (SS), a Goa based Hindu-terror organisation, and its founder remain untouched by the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS), police, the state governments of Maharashtra and Goa, and the Central government. The SS has been named by the Special Investigation Team (SIT), which is investigating the assassination of journalist-activist Gauri Lankesh, to be the brain behind the assassinations of not only Ms. Lankesh but also of Dr. Narendra Dabholkar, Govind Pansare and M. M. Kalburgi. The SIT has also brought to light a larger conspiracy of the SS and its affiliates.

Vaibhav Raut, an SS sympathiser and a member of the Hindu Govansh Raksha Samiti was arrested by the ATS on August 10, 2018. The ATS, which raided his house, recovered at least eight country-made bombs, along with other explosives and literature of the SS. Following Raut, the ATS tracked down Sharad Kalaskar and Sudhanwa Gondhalekar, who were stacking explosives and various weapons and had planned to plant these explosives in various parts of Maharashtra. The ATS has established that all three were members of the SS.

Following the arrests by the ATS and the SIT revelations, civil societies across Maharashtra, Karnataka and Goa are demanding the ban of this terror organisation. Two important questions that are in front of us are: first, is banning the SS the solution? If the answer is yes, then, what purpose would the ban serve? And if the answer is no, then, with the strongly emerging evidence establishing the organisation as a terror outfit, what should be done with it? And secondly, would the current government with its allegiance to the ideology of a Hindu Rashtra, take a stand on the SS, an organisation from which both the ruling party BJP and its originator RSS have been distancing themselves? A look into the structure, ideology and functioning of the SS would provide us with answers for both of these questions.

The organisation believes and advocates violence as a tool for the “protection of religion” and establishing a Hindu Rashtra. The activists of the organisation have been arrested in several bomb blast cases in the past. The SS had also been accused and two of its supporters were given 10 years imprisonment for bomb blasts in the Gadkari Rangayatan auditorium in Thane on June 4, 2008. This was done as a protest against a play, Amhi Pachpute, which they claimed, showed Hindu Gods in a poor light. Those arrested are currently out on bail.

The Goa police arrested six SS members involved in a bomb blast in Madgaon, Goa, in October 2009. According to the police, two SS supporters, Malgonda Patil and Yogesh Naik, were allegedly carrying a bomb in their scooter, to plant near the Narkasur effigy competition in Madgaon. The duo died as the bomb went off prematurely.

The National Investigation Agency (NIA) took over the investigation of the case. Investigators alleged that an SS member, who was an engineering student, played a key role in preparing the Improvised Explosive Devices (IED) and carrying detonators and timer devices for the blast. However, all six were acquitted even as some of the SS members are still absconding.

The first demand to ban the organisation was made in 2011 by the ATS, and once again in 2015. The 2011 ATS reports requesting for the ban had said,
“from the incidents in Vashi, Panvel, Thane and Goa, it is evident that the arrested and wanted (and) accused formed an unlawful association to encourage and aid the other members to carry out subversive activities of sabotage (terror act) for promoting enmity between different groups of religion with the intent to disrupt maintenance of communal harmony, to threaten the sovereignty of the state, or to strike terror in the minds of people by indulging in terror acts using IEDs, which were made in violation of the provisions governing the purchase and possession of explosive materials and firearms and ammunition and thereby, attempted to wage war against the government of India.”

The central government was not convinced that the SS was a terrorist organisation. In 2015, in the light of the investigations into the cases of Dabholkar, Pansare and Kalburgi, the ATS once again submitted a report demanding for the ban. However, now the ATS seems to have changed their position adopting the view that banning the organisation does not serve any purpose, as the SS is not a ‘single entity’.

Sanatan Sanstha and its avatars
The SS was founded and registered by a hypnotherapist, Dr. Jayant Balaji Athavale. According to the Maharashtra state home department, the SS has twenty-odd registered organisations and all of these organisations have different units, and these units are independently registered. This organisation which is not registered as a single entity but as separate units in every district and city, also has various ashrams in Goa alone with different names. This simply implies, the SS is widespread. Like the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti or Hindu Yuva Sena, the SS operates through various organisations. These numerous affiliates of the SS- which as an organisation pledges to propagate Hinduism and fight for ‘Hindu Rashtra’, organise various events either commemorating a Hindu Festival, or workshops on Hindu Rashtra across its districts and towns.

For example, the SS organised an event recently in Jalkot in Nanded district. The website noted, “Mrs. Anita Bunge of Sanatan Sanstha was invited to the Bhagwat Saptah organised by the well-wishers of Sanatan Sanstha and its advertisement donors, and the construction chairman of Jalkot Panchayat Samiti Mr. Ramakant Raivar, to give guidance. 500 devotees benefitted from the guidance on ‘Hindu Dharma, Hindu nation, Dharma Shikshan’ given by Mrs. Bunge.” The website also noted that RSS volunteers were part of the event.

jalkot.PNG

In Kolhapur, where comrade Govind Pansare was assassinated, the Sanatan Sanstha and its affiliates (unnamed) organised a procession celebrating it’s founder Athavale’s birthday.

kohlapur.PNG

Another note said, they organised a one-day workshop in Alibag for “devout Hindus” involved in the organisation of the “Hindu Dharmajagruti Sabha”.

Ramnath.PNG

If the SS is banned, it hardly makes any difference and also won’t put an end to its terror activities, as its affiliates would still continue propagating its extremist ideology and carry on with violent acts. The assassination of the rationalists and journalists in the country are not just murders. They are political murders, and an attack on ideology. The core of SS ideology is Hindu Rashtra and the organisation is determined to kill all those who oppose it. Even though it has been established now that the SS was behind all the four political murders and is also involved in a larger conspiracy in the country, neither Athavale, nor the office bearers of the organisation have been interrogated. When the ATS has already said that banning the SS is not going to serve any purpose, why are they reluctant to interrogate the organisation? The ATS, the state governments of Maharashtra an Goa, the police and the Central Government have to answer this question.

This article was first published on newsclick.in.

The post Sanatan Sanstha Remains Untouched appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Urmilesh: Media Being Used to Turn the Country Against Kashmir https://sabrangindia.in/urmilesh-media-being-used-turn-country-against-kashmir/ Mon, 18 Jun 2018 07:18:48 +0000 http://localhost/sabrangv4/2018/06/18/urmilesh-media-being-used-turn-country-against-kashmir/ In this episode of ‘Hafte ki Baat, Urmilesh ke Saath’ we discuss increasing assault on free speech, the rise of militancy in Kashmir and the way the narrative around Kashmir is being shaped by big media houses, all in light of the recent murder of Kashmiri journalist Shujaat Bukhari. This article was first published on NewsClick.in.

The post Urmilesh: Media Being Used to Turn the Country Against Kashmir appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
In this episode of ‘Hafte ki Baat, Urmilesh ke Saath’ we discuss increasing assault on free speech, the rise of militancy in Kashmir and the way the narrative around Kashmir is being shaped by big media houses, all in light of the recent murder of Kashmiri journalist Shujaat Bukhari.

This article was first published on NewsClick.in.

The post Urmilesh: Media Being Used to Turn the Country Against Kashmir appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Thousand Tears, not Enough https://sabrangindia.in/thousand-tears-not-enough/ Fri, 15 Jun 2018 14:22:02 +0000 http://localhost/sabrangv4/2018/06/15/thousand-tears-not-enough/ Shujaat Bukhari’s Assassination a Sinister Warning to the Media Fraternity. Journalists vow to not be cowed down at the shooting down of Editor, Rising Kashmir.   People in Kashmir and journalist fraternity world-wide have been shocked at the assassination of Shujaat Bukhari, a veteran journalist and the editor of Rising Kashmir, the Kashmir based newspaper. […]

The post Thousand Tears, not Enough appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Shujaat Bukhari’s Assassination a Sinister Warning to the Media Fraternity. Journalists vow to not be cowed down at the shooting down of Editor, Rising Kashmir.

 
People in Kashmir and journalist fraternity world-wide have been shocked at the assassination of Shujaat Bukhari, a veteran journalist and the editor of Rising Kashmir, the Kashmir based newspaper. He was killed by ‘unknown gunmen’ on June 14 evening as he was coming out of his office in Press Enclave, at the heart of Srinagar in Jammu and Kashmir. Two of his security guards were also killed in the same incident.

So far no militant organisation has claimed responsibility for his death.

He was killed merely hours after the UN’s human rights office announced the findings of a first ever human rights reports on the state of Jammu and Kashmir, in which the UN called for an independent inquiry into human rights violations in both parts of Kashmir, administered respectively by India and Pakistan. Analysts, including Shujaat Bukhari believed and expressed on various platforms that the report had significant implications for human rights conditions in the valley as it was for the first time an international body had recognised the deep distress within the valley and recommended the independent investigation.

A journalist of the people

As the news of his death was confirmed last evening, personal narratives of friends and well-wishers haven’t stopped flowing. The Indian Express, in its piece said “Shujaat Bukhari, perhaps embarrassed about his tall and distinct demeanour, hunched just a wee bit to make his friends comfortable. His two children, before they were five, would walk with their head distinctly bent to the right, as that was a good imitation of Abba, always on the cellphone, trying to be hands-free”

Intimate anecdotes flowed on Facebook as some recalled him for his quick response to new writers, while some regretted not having met him just a few hours ago. Another person recollected that he recently sent a message to Farooq Abdullah congratulating him on wearing jeans.

The shock and grief expressed across platforms and in Kashmir are truly indicative of one fact.

Shujaat Bukhari was not merely a name. He was the embodiment of a voice of sanity, reason and human rights in the turbulent Kashmir valley, marked by too frequent episodes of violence, impunity and unaccountability.
 
A sketch of Shujaat Bukhari

Bukhari himself belonged to an illustrious family with the father as a journalist and elder brother Basharat Bukhari, a PDP leader and an MLA from the Sangrama constituency in North Kashmir.
However, Bukhari didn’t merely rest on the laurels of his family, but used the power of his pen to bring to light the most inconvenient truth. Bukhari consistently spoke truth to power and was recognised across the world as the leading and most rational voice speaking on Kashmir
Bukhari was The Hindu bureau chief for Jammu and Kashmir from 1997 to 2012 and a contributor to Frontline magazine. He was based in Srinagar and was running Rising Kashmir for over a decade. Bukhari wrote fluently in English, Urdu and Kashmiri. He was also the president of Adbee Markaz Kamraz, the biggest and oldest cultural and literary organisation of the valley.
 
A martyr for truth

Ironically, just three months ago, Bukhari wrote in an editorial in Rising Kashmir on the occasion of the tenth anniversary of his newspaper, “Survival is the first challenge for any journalism venture in Kashmir.”

Shujaat Bukhari was the missing link between the outside world and the dark alleys of Kashmir clouded with tales of atrocities and human rights violations, reporting from where is an both an act of courage and defiance. After Burhan Wani, the Hijb Mujahiddeen commander was killed in July 2016 and curfew followed along with snapping of mobile and internet connection in the valley, he wrote for the BBC, “But when I called the office, one of our employees confirmed that our printing press had been raided, staff held and printed copies of the newspaper seized.”

Not only 2016, the Rising Kashmir newspaper faced challenges in 2008 and 2010 as well, when armed struggle in Kashmir was on a rise owing to India’s failing political interventions in the region. Shujaat Bukhaari highlighted, “Authorities had forced us to suspend publication during the protests against Indian rule in 2008 and 2010 as well.” Further, in 2013 when Afzal Guru was hanged under mysterious circumstances in India, Bukhari wrote, “When Afzal Guru, a Kashmiri separatist convicted over the 2001 Indian parliament attack was hanged in 2013, copies of newspapers were seized from the press and the stands. I remember my newspaper ceased publication for four days. During the 2010 agitation, we were forced to stop publishing for 10 days.”

A key point that Bukhaari highlighted about the state’s measure to quell protests when discontent in the valley rose to uncontrollable proportions, “Imposing an information blockade had been part of the state “strategy” in 2010 as well and the scene is rewinding this time.”

Bukhaari was a living testimony to the transition that media went through after the outbreak of armed rebellion in Kashmir in the 1990s. He said that the media had to work on a razor’s edge and that journalists typically faced “threats to life, intimidation, assault, arrest and censorship have been part of the life of a typical local journalist.”
Bukhari survived three assassination attempts on previous occasions.

The last time a journalist was killed in Kashmir was over a decade ago. Srinagar saw killings in 2003, Parvez Muhammad Sultan, a reporter for a local news agency, was shot by gunmen in his office and August 2000, when a bomb blast killed Pradeep Bhatia, a photographer

Awards and accolades

Bukhaari was the recipient of World Press Institute USA fellowship. He had earlier pursued his Masters in Journalism from Ateneo de Manila University, Manila as a fellow of Asian Centre for Journalism. He was also a fellow at east West Centre at USA’s Hawaii.

He had just returned from Lisbon where he participated as a speaker during the Global Editors Network summit.

Bukhari was part of India’s delegation for ‘informal’ peace talks on Kashmir with Pakistani representatives held in Dubai last year.

Astute political analysis and commentary on recent events

Bukhari was consistently writing, calling an end to the cross-border firing along the Line of Control (LoC). He emphasised on the need for a Standard Operating Procedure in an article on March 3, a time when it was witnessing massive cross border firing, “As things have gone from bad to worse what is missing is a Standard Operating Procedure that could be followed in a ceasefire. A mechanism is also missing and nearly no contact between the two countries is adding to the woes of the people,”

Criticising Modi government’s policies at the center, Bukhari said, “New Delhi’s Kashmir policy since the beginning had not been based on justice and fairness while the Modi government had pushed them to the wall.”

Bukhari had commented on the recent ceasefire in J&K for Ramzaan, a holy month for Muslims across the world, saying, “Despite the scepticism from various quarters and even outright rejection, the announcement came as a glimmer of hope for the common people who have been suffering due to the continuous grind of violence. Death of both the militants who have joined the ranks in past few years and the civilians who become the collateral damage has become unbearable.”

Bukhaari’s writings, apart from giving a deep insight into the “sharp degeneration of politics in the state” were an indictment that the Indian government’s policies in Kashmir had not worked. He also wrote stories highlighting why Kashmiri youth were drawn towards militancy.
 
“Psychological war” of Indian media on Kashmir

In an opinion piece titled, “Prime Time Propaganda“, published exactly an year before, Bukhari once again exposed the hyper-nationalist and jingoist Indian media which, rather than investigating the allegations of human rights violations in Jammu and Kashmir believes in shrill high pitched rhetoric to further its propaganda. He said, “The comments made almost every day by hired panelists are part of a psychological war that has been unfolding to make the people submit”

In the same piece, he drew attention to the shallowness of the Indian media, here I quote him verbatim, “In recent days, two comments made by panelists on a TV channel enraged people but in one case there was much amusement and social media was full of jokes. The one comment which evoked a sharp reaction was made by one RSN Singh, a retired Colonel who was briefly with Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW) official and has been engaged by a newly launched TV channel as its contributor. His disgraceful comment insinuated that Kashmiri youngsters were the ‘illegitimate offspring’ of foreign militants and that is why they were valiantly taking on government forces. When Singh was making this uncouth remark, the anchor was clearly enjoying it. This demonstrated the depths that such debate has sunk to and become the hallmark of these channels. No one intervened as the panelist abused Kashmiris and that is how the response of the government is also shaped.”
 
His staff and journalists from Rising Kashmir gave him a befitting tribute, saying, “You left all too sudden but you will always be our leading light with your professional conviction and exemplary courage. We wont be cowed down by the cowards who snatched you from us. We will uphold your principle of telling the truth howsoever unpleasant it may be”

The post Thousand Tears, not Enough appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>