g20 summit | SabrangIndia News Related to Human Rights Mon, 20 Nov 2023 11:47:20 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png g20 summit | SabrangIndia 32 32 Hiding the Poor but letting poverty reign- skewed policy on urban poor needs change https://sabrangindia.in/hiding-the-poor-but-letting-poverty-reign-skewed-policy-on-urban-poor-needs-change/ Wed, 27 Sep 2023 07:53:07 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=30054 The G20 summit and the allied meetings India has been hoisting for the past year saw participation of delegates in various meetings, in various cities of India. Some cities however also saw rudimentary attempts by the city administration to beautify them, by covering up some slums with curtains.[1] This article is about those curtains; not […]

The post Hiding the Poor but letting poverty reign- skewed policy on urban poor needs change appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The G20 summit and the allied meetings India has been hoisting for the past year saw participation of delegates in various meetings, in various cities of India. Some cities however also saw rudimentary attempts by the city administration to beautify them, by covering up some slums with curtains.[1] This article is about those curtains; not the G20.

The G20 is merely one of the many summits where a city will be visited by a powerful foreign dignitary. Given the missing organisational structure and a powerful voice, the grouping’s importance and importance of its presidency being not what the government had made it out to be, a discussion of G20 can wait. Let us talk about the curtains.

Imagine a kid playing in her neighbourhood in a bustling city sees a curtain or a green sheet covering their neighbourhood in a way that the commuters on the main road cannot see it. When she asks the elders, the elders say that the curtains are being put so that the dignitaries do not have to see the slum. What kind of questions would rise in her mind? What kind of assumptions or conclusions would she make about the entire happenings? We will never know because the city never cared to ask her. It is doubtful whether the city even sees the kid or not. By choosing to ignore the kid, the city somehow becomes apathetic to a significant part of itself. The state makes the city apathetic to a part of itself. This apathy manifests itself in many ways, apart from the curtains.

Ever wondered why the average bench, at a bus stop, in a city has become narrower? It is as if they are almost designed to make one stand while waiting for the bus, but one is too busy to notice the change. A large section of our people that would, however, notice the un-usability of the benches would be the Homeless who have traditionally used public spaces to sleep at night. In Mumbai, flower beds on the street outside many buildings and bungalows had pointy granite stones embedded in the concrete; the surfaces of concrete parapets around the trees on the street bristle with sharp pebbles to prevent anyone from loitering in the shade.[2] This kind of design of public spaces is called Hostile Design. Hostile Design has been used to control or restrict behaviour of people, in public spaces. Hostile Design is one of the many components of how cities are being run, maintained, and perceived today.

Let us take another example of Roads and Footpaths. Has there been any focus or emphasis from governments across the country, to ensure footpaths and public transport, as strong as the push to build “better” roads/flyovers? In most Indian Cities, 20-40% of the work trips happen as Pedestrian trips and yet, footpaths and other such pedestrian facilities are never the newsmakers or markers whenever they are inaugurated.[3] Within this section of people who walk to work, a higher percentage are women.[4]

State power and the urban poor

Issues with public transport, public space architecture, and the apathy towards those living in temporary settlements or slums are part of a systemic issue of how the state and the ruling classes perceive the poor.

From the 2000s to now, the dignity of the poor has been taken away from them, in the name of beautification and presenting a ‘good image’ of India to the outside world. Prof Amita Baviskar argues that spectacular events require massive social and spatial transformations of dubious economic and social value which otherwise would be difficult to achieve if not for the setting aside of normal procedures processes by speedy processes. What does this mean? If the government were to cover up slums or any dwelling settlements during “normal time” (non –G-20 times for instance), there would be a furore, and there would be much opposition to the act.

However, the acceptance of this act, during an event such as the G20 or a visit by a foreign dignitary; or a special event like the Commonwealth games, is easily obtained from the rest of the city. This acceptance and the swiftness, argues Baviskar, is enabled by promoting the belief that “national prestige and status” is at stake and by the idea that cities should compete for recognition, in the globalised world.[5]

In 2000, under the NDA I government, when the then President of the United States of America Bill Clinton visited Hyderabad, all the beggars in the city were rounded up and hoarded into homes where beggars complained of ill treatment.[6]

During the Commonwealth Games too (UPA-II governed then), the discussion was about how hosting the Games represents the coming of age of India as a super-power and Delhi as a ‘world-class’ city. In 2010, the city of Delhi saw massive slum clearance operation before the Commonwealth games.[7]  This kind of beautification been done for the G20 summit too by using the prestige of the nation as an excuse to deny people of their dignity. In 2020, many efforts were taken by the Ahmedabad city authorities to hide a slum from former President of the USA Donald Trump while he was on a visit.[8]

The urban poor came and continue to come to the cities in search of work and they do find work but in a low wage market. This, combined with the fact that price of housing in mega cities is always sky high, made them settle on land that is not theirs.[9] The urban poor who resides in slum like settlements might not have all the necessary utilities such as water, sanitation, and electricity. This means that they are required to deliver what the city asks them without having to cater to their needs fairly or properly. Since that is not possible, they are excluded from the cityscape in all possible ways except their physical presence. Not only do they work in places where their voices are of little importance, but they also end up being negligible political actors. The urban poor, despite living in the city, are often also dubbed “illegal squatters” or occupants of government land. Once they get these tags, they are excluded from the economic, social, political and cultural spheres of the city, thus broadening the divide between them and those who claim the city. Once this exclusion and divide is large enough, the city does not care as to what happens to them-whether it be covering their houses with curtains or demolishing their houses. This cycle of exclusion continues and the people who are excluded become more excluded.

The demolition of houses we see regularly in news, across cities is also a result of the apathy that the state has built over time, for the poor. Additionally, the state also claims legitimacy from different sections of the society by land it gets after it demolishes the slums. After all, only a powerful institution could make all those people living in a slum homeless and still get away with it.

What do we do, then?

The right to live with Human dignity is within the Right to Life and Personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution as declared by the Supreme Court in the case of Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India. In Francis Coraile vs. The Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi, the Supreme Court held that the right to life includes right to live with Human Dignity and all that goes along with it, namely clothing, shelter and facilities for reading, writing, and expressing oneself in diverse forms, freely moving about and mixing and commingling with fellow human beings. The court stated as follows:

 “Every act which offends against or impairs human dignity would constitute deprivation pro    tanto of this right to live and it would have to be in accordance with reasonable, fair and just procedure established by law which stands the test of other fundamental rights. Therefore, any form of torture or cruel, inhuman or  degrading treatment would be offensive to human dignity and constitute an inroad into this right to live and it would,  on this  view, be prohibited by Article 21 unless it is in accordance with procedure prescribed by law, but no law which authorises and  no procedure which leads to such torture or  cruelty, inhuman or degrading treatment can ever stand the  test of  reasonableness and non-arbitrariness: it would  plainly be  unconstitutional and  void  as  being violative of Article 14 and 21.(emphasis supplied)

This dignity cannot just come from giving the people who are living in occupied lands, in slums, some title deeds i.e., ownership of the land. The government would still cover up their neighbourhoods in the next G20 or whichever event the country hosts next instead of bettering the slums or making sure that the city authorities make ample plans for the migrants coming into the city. The solution is also not one pronged; it must be holistic. The solution should not be derived from mere discussion by the city authorities or the governments, within themselves.

The solution, for it to be holistic and work, has to come from an inclusive process that gives the urban poor the same seat at the table as has been given to other classes. In social, political, and cultural spaces too, the people living in slums should be included so that the practices followed by the authorities are not invalidating of the dignity of the poor. This would mean that there will be voices advocating for better transport facilities from areas or to such areas in the city that were not covered before.

A better participation of the urban poor in social sphere would mean that there would be objection to administration putting up green curtains around the slums even during G20. An equal seat at the table mean that the urban poor can advocate for a decent park or a playground for its children to play and thrive. And if the state still tries to impose its unfair conditions, the urban poor will be much more poised to deal with the State, whether that be in judicial forums or via other democratic means.

Only with inclusion of different groups into the processes that govern the city, can there be a bond between different social groups and only with such bonds can communities be built with empathy for each other.

This inclusion of urban poor in the governance of cities, in all spheres should not take away the discussion completely from the fact that they will continue to face problems as long as the government talks in market language when it comes to housing and other rights of its citizens and defers plans for welfare in the name of lack of investment; or as long as private profit is prioritised over public welfare.

(The author is a legal researcher with the organisation)


[1] Hassan, A., & Ellis-Petersen, H. (2023, September 8). ‘Ashamed of our presence’: Delhi glosses over plight of poor as it rolls out G20 red carpet. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/08/ashamed-of-our-presence-delhi-glosses-over-plight-of-poor-as-it-rolls-out-g20-red-carpet

[2] Date, V. (2018, April 1). HDFC spikes: Mumbai’s tony Pali Hill also uses hostile design to deter workers, hawkers from sitting. Scroll.In. https://scroll.in/article/873947/hdfc-spikes-mumbais-tony-pali-hill-also-uses-hostile-design-to-deter-workers-hawkers-from-sitting

[3] Jha, A., Tiwari, G., Mohan, D., & Banerjee, S. (2017, January 1). Analysis of Pedestrian Movement on Delhi Roads by Using Naturalistic Observation Techniques. SAGE. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/315988449_Analysis_of_Pedestrian_Movement_on_Delhi_Roads_by_Using_Naturalistic_Observation_Techniques

[4] Tiwari, G. (2022, June 15). Walking in Indian Cities – A Daily Agony for Millions. The Hindu Centre. https://www.thehinducentre.com/the-arena/current-issues/walking-in-indian-cities-a-daily-agony-for-millions/article65551959.ece#one1

[5]   Baviskar, A. (2013). “Spectacular Events, City Spaces and Citizenship: The Commonwealth Games in Delhi”  In  Jonathan Shapiro Anjaria & Colin McFarlane (Eds.), Urban Navigations Politics, Space and the City in South Asia. Routledge India. https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9780203085332-7/spectacular-events-city-spaces-citizenship-commonwealth-games-delhi-amita-baviskar

[6]   RADHAKRISHNA, F. G. S. (2000, March 23). HOARDINGS HIDE PLIGHT OF BEGGARS. Telegraph India. https://www.telegraphindia.com/india/hoardings-hide-plight-of-beggars/cid/902196

[7]   Suri. P (2010, March 25). Poor lose homes as Delhi cleans up. Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2010/3/25/poor-lose-homes-as-delhi-cleans-up

[8]   The Wire. (2020, February 13). A Wall Is Being Built in Ahmedabad to Block a Slum From Donald Trump’s View. The Wire. https://thewire.in/government/gujarat-ahmedabad-slum-wall-donald-trump

[9]   Neuwirth, R. (2005). Shadow Cities. Routledge. https://www.routledge.com/Shadow-Cities-A-Billion-Squatters-A-New-Urban-World/Neuwirth/p/book/9780415953610


Related:

India’s Poor Paid for G20 With Homes and Livelihoods Halted

Delhi Police attempts to stop meeting critical of the G20 summit, restricts people from entering the venue

G20 related evictions and violence on India’s poor must stop: Jury

The post Hiding the Poor but letting poverty reign- skewed policy on urban poor needs change appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
India’s Poor Paid for G20 With Homes and Livelihoods Halted https://sabrangindia.in/indias-poor-paid-for-g20-with-homes-and-livelihoods-halted/ Fri, 08 Sep 2023 04:32:00 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=29709 More people will be left homeless and unemployed than before India decided to host the G20 Summit in Delhi.

The post India’s Poor Paid for G20 With Homes and Livelihoods Halted appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Occasions like the G20 presidency are an opportunity to boost a nation’s image and instil a sense of pride among citizens. A country’s standing in the international community matters, as do attracting tourism, boosting investment, and strengthening international cooperation. Yet, the domestic manifestations of ‘global’ events cannot be overlooked, for they create both gainers and losers.

So, while basking in pride, it is crucial for India to identify who gained and lost from the G20 events. India must be especially careful, lest we take from the poor whatever little they have and give it to the rich.

The range of distress caused to the poor by the preparations for the G20 summit has been widely reported all year. Since January, over 3 lakh of the capital’s poor have been displaced, while other cities that hosted G20 events reported more evictions and displacements. The lives of India’s poor are jeopardised in the process of urban ‘beautification’ projects meant to please visiting foreign dignitaries and other attendees.

Eighty per cent of Delhi’s workforce is employed in the informal sector, and 15% of its population lives below the poverty line. The city and central administrations, which prepare the capital for summits, have repeatedly behaved with contempt towards its poorest residents. Walls were constructed to hide the city’s poverty and poor residents during the Commonwealth Games in 2020. And in 2023, slums and shelters for the homeless were razed to make way for dazzling optics for the G20 Summit.

The city allocated a expense budget—Rs 1,000 crore—to prepare for this Summit and related events, choosing to chase away the poor rather than work towards poverty reduction. Slum settlements and shelters for the homeless were pulled apart or concealed and demolished with no alternative arrangements made for residents. In effect, more people have been left homeless and unemployed than before India decided to host this event. Homes were declared encroachments and bulldozed, roadside vendors were evicted, and lakhs whose voices are never heard were further destabilised. The brilliant lights of the newly-decorated city darkened lives—and the coming effective ‘shutdown’ of a large and prominent section of the city will worsen the situation.

When a city as large and economically diverse as Delhi is brought to a halt, people are likely to face challenges, significantly more so its weaker and disadvantaged sections. Of the ways in which the poor are affected, the easiest to identify is the loss of daily wages, for instance of the hawkers in parts of the city that are being subjected to near-total lockdown during the forthcoming summit.

While the lockdown may officially apply to sections of the city, roads passing through this crucial area will out of bounds during the days of the G20 programmes. It is bound to affect thoroughfare, having a ripple effect across the city.

Most of Delhi’s poor residents—over 49 lakh people, according to a 2022 estimate—work in the informal sector. They rely on daily wages to support themselves and their families. Any disruption in normal economic activities results in a substantial loss of income, making it difficult for families to meet basic needs. Many poor might find it impossible to stock up on essential food items to provide them with two meals a day when they are forced not to work. This is what leads to food insecurity and hunger for those who live from day to day.

Further, road and office closures can disrupt access to essential services such as healthcare, education, and social support. Vulnerable populations may find it challenging to access medical care or emergency services during this period. Even a short shutdown can have lasting economic consequences for poor individuals and the local economy. Job losses and income reductions during a shutdown can create financial struggles that persist after normal economic activities resume. It’s a fact that today’s food is tomorrow’s work energy: a poor worker who goes hungry today will not have the energy to work tomorrow, perpetuating poverty beyond the days when work was unavailable, and pushing families deeper into poverty.

It is crucial that governments host international events while ensuring that the urban poor are not disproportionately affected by disruptions. Proactive and inclusive policies are needed, which the government can put in place for the welfare of all citizens even as it showcases a city on the global stage.

It is essential for local authorities, NGOs, and community organisations to implement support measures, including targeted financial assistance, food distribution, access to health care services, and housing support for vulnerable populations, especially if a ‘shutdown’ like in Delhi is being imposed.

Any disturbance to normal economic activity is sure to hurt people, and people living on the margins will be disproportionately affected. Since the burden of disturbances is not equal for all, is important to design them very carefully. If a glittering capital is a must during the G20 presidency, it is equally important to hear voices of distress echoing from behind the glamour. The welfare of people is the single-most important domestic policy and it cannot be subservient to any other outcome, howsoever important it might appear.

To sum up, the well-being of the urban poor during the coming ‘shutdown’—call it by whatever name—is of the utmost importance. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Provide ample notice to the affected sections about the event and its impacts on their lives, in terms of gains and losses. Engaging in community consultations to understand and address needs and concerns is a must.
  2. Targeted financial assistance programs to compensate for lost income during the shutdown is a must. This could include cash transfers or subsidies to help families cover basic expenses.
  3. Temporary food distribution centres in affected areas must ensure that vulnerable households have access to nutritious meals, so that they can rejoin the workforce immediately on resumption of normal economic activity.
  4. Healthcare services, especially emergency services, must remain operational during the event. Mobile medical clinics should be considered for the affected neighbourhoods.
  5. Preventing evictions should be the priority and housing support must be provided for people whose homes and shelters have been razed.

The authors are associate professors at Zakir Husain Delhi College, University of Delhi. The views are personal.

Courtesy: Newsclick

The post India’s Poor Paid for G20 With Homes and Livelihoods Halted appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Delhi Police attempts to stop meeting critical of the G20 summit, restricts people from entering the venue https://sabrangindia.in/delhi-police-attempts-to-stop-meeting-critical-of-the-g20-summit-restricts-people-from-entering-the-venue/ Sat, 19 Aug 2023 13:44:54 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=29277 Organisers, activist, speakers express anguish, calls this an unbelievable step to undermine criticisms, deem it to be an attempt by Modi government to suppress voices

The post Delhi Police attempts to stop meeting critical of the G20 summit, restricts people from entering the venue appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The present union government has transitioned the nation’s previous atmosphere of tolerance and freedom, implementing measures that curtail those who raise questions about its actions and policies. The Delhi Police, on August 19, stopped participants from attending a meeting critical of the G20 summit, claiming that the event was being held without permission. Notably, the summit had been organised from August 18 to August 20 to discuss issues related to shrinking democratic spaces, inequality, privatisation of public services, agriculture and climate crisis, among others.

The Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh stated that, the Delhi Police stopped people from attending the ‘We20 meeting’ organised by activists inside a building that belongs to the CPI(M). Ramesh has also tweeted that while he managed to enter at 10.30 am, before Delhi Police began its “operations,” but he had difficulty exiting.

The tweet can be read here:

As per a report in The Wire, Political activist Kavita Kabeer, who was part of the organising committee of the event, provided that no prior permission was required as the event is being held in a closed hall. She further added that the police initially urged those attending to leave, but later restricted more people from entering the Surjeet Bhavan. As per a report in the Scroll, over 30 police personnel had arrived at the Surjeet Bhavan. Barricades were also placed around the venue, as per The Wire’s report. 

A public statement has also been released on the attempt to shut down the summit by the Modi administration. The statement provided: “In an unbelievable step, Delhi Police barricaded the gates to Surjeet Bhawan not letting anyone in around 11 am. This when Jairam Ramesh, Aneel Hegde, MP (RS), Medha Patkar (NBA), Vandana Shiva (Navdanya), Anjali Bhardwaj, Nikhil Dey, Thomas Franco, Shaktiman Ghosh and others were analysing how the Modi administration projected to the global leaders of G20 that he is governing India in the best traditions of liberal democracy. Why then was he afraid of a few hundred activists gathering to examine his claims in Delhi that he had to direct the police to disrupt the proceedings!!”

The statement further provides: “What’s happening in Surjeet Bhawan is how the situation is across India. People are not allowed to participate in meaningful democracy to question and hold accountable the Modi administration. Why, even Parliament has been stepped aside and laws that fundamentally protect human rights, environment, biodiversity, privacy, etc. have been rendered meaningless. Anyone who dares to question the government, be it an activist, a trade unionist, academic, even a Minister or Deputy Chief Minister, is targeted with fabricated cases and hauled through the tortuous process of criminal trials, and even locked up under draconian laws. This is how things are in India today.”

The complete statement can be read here:

 

On Saturday, individuals such Congress General Secretary (Communication) Jairam Ramesh, advocate Vandana Shiva, and Janata Dal (United) MP Aneel Hegde were scheduled to speak. Scheduled talks were on the following issue: ‘Does Modi Administration Really Deliver on Tackling Climate Change, to Protect Environment, Biodiversity & Associated Human Rights, as claimed with G20 & Other Global Fora?’ On the day of inauguration, the inaugural session was attended by a host of political leaders, movement activists, and civil society organisations including Teesta Setalvad, Medha Patkar, Jayati Ghosh, Manoj Jha, Harsh Mander, Arun Kumar, Brinda Karat, Hannan Mollah, Rajeev Gowda among others. Over 500 economists, activists, journalists and politicians from across the country are taking part in it.

A total of nine workshops were planned in the summit to deliberate on key issues pertinent to the G20 agenda such as agriculture and food security, climate crisis and just energy transition, rising inequalities, labour and employment, alternative ideas of development, democracy and dissent and more.

Related:

FIR against student Lois Sophia who shouted anti-BJP slogan on flight quashed: Madras High Court

Attack on freedom of speech: CPI(M) leader receives call from police over meme on Savarkar

IIM faculty members write an open letter to corporate India to ‘De-fund Hate Speech’

Attempts to control academic freedom gives rise to protest by faculty, Ashoka University and IISc an example

FIR against members NSIW fact-finding team, academics & activists

The post Delhi Police attempts to stop meeting critical of the G20 summit, restricts people from entering the venue appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
G20 related evictions and violence on India’s poor must stop: Jury https://sabrangindia.in/g20-related-evictions-and-violence-indias-poor-must-stop-jury/ Tue, 23 May 2023 12:47:28 +0000 https://sabrangindia.com/?p=26284 G20 has become an extra constitutional event, not abiding by the rule of law, were the preliminary remarks made by a jury at a public hearing on “Forced Evictions” organised by concerned citizens in New Delhi; G20 related evictions and violence on the poor must stop.

The post G20 related evictions and violence on India’s poor must stop: Jury appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
While G20 is being projected as a “national pride”, it seems the government is prejudiced about its own people, particularly the poor. These were the broad conclusions arrived at in preliminary remarks by a concerned citizens jury addressing the issue in New Delhi on Monday May 22. The Jury members are Pamela Philipose, senior journalist; Beena Pallikal, National Campaign for Dalit Human Rights; Tikender Panwar, former deputy mayor, Shimla; Anand Yagnik, Advocate, Gujarat High Court; and Harsh Mandar, rights Activist.

“Having heard about the atrocities and evictions since this morning, it appears that the G20 event has become an extra constitutional event which does not abide by the rule of law. Such temporary suspension of constitution owing to G20 overturning High court or Supreme Court orders is unthinkable. What should we call it Amrit kaal or rakshas Kaal?” asked jury member Anand Yagnik.

A public hearing addressing the pressing issue of forced evictions in India took place on May 22 at Surjeet Bhawan, New Delhi. Organized by Concerned Citizens, a collective of organisations from varied fields, the public hearing was to shed light on the unjust evictions taking place across the country, particularly targeting farmers, street vendors, waste pickers, and residents of bastis (shantytowns), as part of the preparations for the G20 summit and the beautification of cities. While the glitter, glitz and pride around hosting the G20 has become an exercise of showcasing the “development” story of the regime, the public hearing brought to fore what is carefully omitted, i.e., the brutal saga of bulldozers razing homes to dust.

While G20 is being projected as a “national pride”, it seems the government is prejudiced about its own people, particularly the poor. Jammu Anand from Nagpur said, “A judge recently said there will be a mega event of Civil 20 as part of the G20 process, and hence the people of Nagpur should remain in discipline. This was enough of a signal for the local administration to take measures to save Nagpur’s pride. The Police Commissioner issued a public order that no beggars must be visible in the crossroads. Instead of Gareebi Hatao they are now doing Gareebi Chupao. In Nagpur in the context of the C20 inauguration we saw bastis being hidden with iron sheets with plastic grass on the surface so that they look “green”.

The testimonials spoke of extreme brutality in the evictions on the part of the authorities. Puja from Bela Estate, Delhi said, “We were given three hrs to pack our things which was next to impossible. Many students missed their board exams due to eviction drives on April 29. In a month’s time bulldozers were unleashed on us thrice. They first broke the hand pumps so that we have to leave immediately as one can’t survive without water. Kids had to miss their exams to save their houses. We now live under the flyover.” Abdul Shakeel from Basti Suraksha Manch said, “The Tuglakabad eviction was so brutal, that even those of us who have been working for decades with such evictions, have not seen something of this magnitude. Police surrounded the basti, jammers were installed so that no one could share videos, the phones of activists were snatched, the nearby hotels and shops were shut and the entire basti was razed in two days.” Rajender Ravi said, “It is not just the demolition of their houses; it is also erasing of their histories and all the roots and connections they have had with the space.”

Induprakash said, “On January 31, Horticulture department, for G20 related beautification near Sarai Kale Khan region, the shelter home which is coming in the way should be demolished. Thus an order was issued within a short time and the shelter home was levelled.” Jury member Pamela Philipose said “The aggravated use of bulldozer is absolutely a clear symbol of brutality and cruelty of the state. It is sad to hear how hawkers are seen as encroachers, basti dwellers are seen as illegal and the homeless are considered drug addicts.”

Various testimonies highlighted how the G20 has come as a curse on the livelihoods that are most insecure and precarious. Anand Lakhan from Indore said, “G20 can be an event for them, for us it’s a calamity for the poor. Rahul Verma had a garage in Indore near Nakshatra Garden. His garage was removed as the G20 delegation was to come. He was resettled in an area that had no business prospect for his garage. Such are the realities of “resettlement”. He sank in depression and finally committed suicide.”

Mohammad from Bhuj said, “We were told that because of the G20 new employment opportunities will open up and tourism will improve. Such were the reports in the local papers. But the manner in which evictions and blockades were unleashed in the name of G20, it only spelt doom for the poor. Hawkers in Bhuj even agreed to shut shop for ten days for the delegation’s visit. But when they were back, many were removed within a month.”

Rekha from Bela estate said, “During the pandemic, it is us who gave food, we gave milk, vegetables. And now they are taking our lands and livelihoods away. It is the urban poor who suffer the most when any change takes place in the city.” Reena from Tuglakabad said, “My husband drives an e-rickshaw. Now after demolition there is no electricity. How will he even charge his vehicle? I have been on a hunger strike for 10 days. Am I not being heard just because I am poor?”

Sandeep of National Hawkers Federation spoke of the plight of the hawkers who are losing livelihood in the name of beautification. Some say when guests arrive, we always clean our households. “But does cleaning ever entail throwing the elderly and the most vulnerable out of the house?” He said, “Before G20 never had bulldozers used on street vendors but G20 is witnessing bulldozers on street vendors.” Listening to the attack on the vendor’s livelihoods, Jury member Anand Yagnik asked, if Pradhan Mantri can say he is a chaiwalla, why can’t we sell chai in the streets?

Pruthviraj from Land Conflict Watch said that “India got the G20 presidency in November 2022 and people in Delhi suddenly started getting notices”. He said there are certain patterns that are apparent in the recent demolitions and some are more vulnerable than the other. “While in Mehrauli 700 notices were served, 25 houses were demolished. However in Tughlakabad, around 1500 notices were served and around 3000 houses were demolished as the residents were relatively more vulnerable.” He said in both places the houses/apartments of the relatively more affluent were spared.

Jury member Beena Pallical said, “Even in 2010 during Commonwealth Games they made huge stadiums using 700 crores from SC/ST budget. Even then there were evictions and demolitions. Today, the government has changed, but the situation on ground remains the same.” Tikender Panwar spoke of the obsession of authoritarian leaders with beautification – Napoleon, Hitler and now their descendants here in India. He said that “in the 1990s as land got monetised, the poor were seen as obstacles. So the working class needed to be marginalized in the technocentric model. The poor need to reclaim the city.”

Referring to the testimony of Shah Alam, resident of basti of waste pickers near the Ghazipur landfill, Harsh Mander said that we do not want an India where someone’s house is  burnt eight times and one has to build again from the ashes every time. This must change. The jury members said after analysing the testimonials they will compile a report based on the tribunal within a week. They demanded an immediate end to the G20 related evictions and violence on the poor.

Related:

Aftermath of Demolition Drive in Tughlakabad: Hunger and Homelessness Rife

Tughlakabad Demolition: Dark day for the National Capital as hundreds rendered homeless

Calcutta High Court sets an example, orders Rs. 80,000 compensation for illegal demolition

The post G20 related evictions and violence on India’s poor must stop: Jury appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Hangzhu Summit: Why G20 Needs a Complete Reset https://sabrangindia.in/hangzhu-summit-why-g20-needs-complete-reset/ Mon, 12 Sep 2016 07:04:47 +0000 http://localhost/sabrangv4/2016/09/12/hangzhu-summit-why-g20-needs-complete-reset/ In HangZhu, G20 missed a real opportunity to be relevant. Interview with Rajat Nag G20 nations represent about 85% of the global GDP and two thirds of the world's population. G20 summits would be more meaningful if the leaders focus on a few issues and make a concerted attempt to solve them. Instead, as it […]

The post The Hangzhu Summit: Why G20 Needs a Complete Reset appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>

In HangZhu, G20 missed a real opportunity to be relevant.

Interview with Rajat Nag

G20 nations represent about 85% of the global GDP and two thirds of the world's population. G20 summits would be more meaningful if the leaders focus on a few issues and make a concerted attempt to solve them. Instead, as it happened this time in Hangzhou also, a large number of issues are discussed and then remain as mere platitudes. Rajat Nag suggests that given the people and the portion of the global GDP they represent, G20 summits are important, But they need an institutional structure of some kind to give the summits continuity and a narrower focus. They should try and focus on what they can effectively achieve: specifically issues of the global economy, growing inequality, etc.

Courtesy: Newsclick.in

The post The Hangzhu Summit: Why G20 Needs a Complete Reset appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>