The arms training camp was organised by the Rashtriya Bajrang Dal in Darrang District of the state of Assam. As had been alleged, around 350 Hindu youths received training in handling firearms, martial arts, survival skills, and quick thinking. The intention of this camp was allegedly to fight against “love jihad” and create a divide among people from different communities, religions, and linguistic affiliations.

In Rajasthan, fringe extremist organization of Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Bajrang Dal allegedly distributed sharp-edged tridents among hundreds of Hindu men in Jaitaran, Pali, Rajasthan.Participants took an oath to uphold a “Hindu Rashtra,” pledging allegiance to militant Hindu ideologies.

The complaint highlights hate speeches delivered at these events, targeting religious minority communities, especially Muslims. Highlighting these instances, CJP has urged the authorities to take action against these activities that are promoting hate speech and divisive ideology. The complaint also provided that such distribution of weapons by private groups poses a significant threat to public safety, security, and inter-community relations.

The complaint expresses concern that these events and activities promote communal polarization, fear, and division among communities. It further asserts that the activities of these groups violate the principles of secularism, religious harmony, and social cohesion enshrined in the Indian Constitution. The events are seen as promoting a divisive and extremist Hindutva ideology, potentially marginalizing and alienating minority communities. The distribution of tridents and militant oaths promotes religious vigilantism.

The complaint also gives a background of the groups, by providing the history and ideology of these groups, the complaint contextualizes their actions within a broader framework. By highlighting the controversies, communal tensions, and incidents associated with these groups, the complaint emphasizes the broader impact of their actions on society, public safety, and national security. The background information provided in the complaint about Bajrang Dal and Vishwa Hindu Parishad serves to provide context, enhance credibility, and strengthen the argument for urgent action against the events described in the complaint. The complaint also provided the violations of law that took place in the districts, in Assam and Rajasthan.

The complaint urges authorities to take immediate and stringent action against the organizers of these events, emphasizing the need to uphold the rule of law, ensure public safety, and protect the rights of all citizens, irrespective of their religious background. It seeks investigations, legal action, and steps to prevent further such incidents in the future. The complaint stated- “To direct the DGP, Assam and DGP, Rajasthan or any other appropriate authority to investigate the matter thoroughly, register FIRs against such blatant hate speech and illegal usage of weapons, ensuring that all relevant sections of the Indian Criminal law and Arms Acts are included in the said criminal complaint.”

The complaint can be read here:

Related:

CJP petitions NCM and DGP, Haryana as anti-minority violence spreads takes grip in the state

CJP complains to NCM against Pravin Togadia’s series of hate speeches across several states

CJP complains to NCM against Kalicharan’s series of hate speeches across Maharashtra

UP tops the list in complaints received in 2022-2023, followed by Delhi & Telangana: NCM

CJP moves NCM, writes to DGP Maharashtra against notorious hate offender Kalicharan

The post CJP petitions NCM against arms training camps, weapon distribution events in Assam and Rajasthan appeared first on SabrangIndia.

Pravin Togadia is the founder and President of ‘Antar Rashtriya Hindu Parishad’ and can be regularly seen delivering misinformed and hate filled speeches at several places which target the minorities, specifically the Muslim community.

As a part of CJP’s rigorous Hate Watch campaign, it has been diligently maintaining a record of the hate speeches being made by him on public platforms. CJP thus filed a complaint highlighting the following speeches, and also provided the excerpts of the statements made at the said events:

• Malwa, Madhya Pradesh- May 16, 2023
  He was heard advocating for laws against “love jihad” and provoking the people listening to his speech by saying, “we want someone to break an eye for an eye.” He further made a baseless claim that in the next 50 years, the increase in population of the Muslims would convert India into Afghanistan and added that “2,000 years ago there was no Christianity” and everyone was a Hindu.
• Jhabua, Madhya Pradesh- May 19, 2023
  At this event organized at the Choyal Hospital where he stated that in Riyadh a small town was found where a 6,000 year old Shivling was discovered. He claimed, “over 500 crore Hindus have been killed in 2,000 years.”
• Mandideep, Madhya Pradesh- May 14, 2023
  At the said event, Togadia again delivered insightful speeches and asked the audience to build temples in Kashi- Mathura instead of mosques. He says, “We had said that we will build the temple, even if you do not agree to it, we will stand on your chest and build our temple.”
• Amla, Madhya Pradesh- May 13, 2023
  At the event, Togadia administered an oath to the Hindus asking them to work with their “body, soul, and wealth” for Hindus. He also brought up the idea of Hanuman Chalisa Kendras so that when a Hindu is in danger from a Muslim or Christrian, other Hindus can gather there to protect such a person. He compared this concept to Churches and mosques.
• Itarsi, Madhya Pradesh- May 12, 2023
  At the said event, Togadia claimed that the Muslims are trying to reach the level of population prevalent during the Mughal era. He added that in the next 50 years, their percentage of population will increase to 40% from the current 22%. He concluded that at a time when the Hindu population is 78% women are not feeling safe, then at the future levels, it will become worse.
• Muzaffarpur, Bihar- March 02, 2023
  At the event organized by AHP at MPS Science College, he claimed that India would become “Darul Islam”and based on the public’s mood, he can see this happening in the next 10 years.
• Jind, Haryana, January 28, 2023
  The event was organized by AHP. He praised the Gujarat model, described his role in the 2000 Gujarat riots, and provoked the audience to join his organization.
• Palwal, Haryana- January 23, 2023
  At the said event organized by AHP, Togadia spoke for “love jihad” laws, population control laws, and the need to kick out the Bangladeshis from India. He further administered an oath to the audience saying, “Prosperous Hindu, Safe Hindu, Every Hindu.” The crowd at the end showed its support by chanting “Jai Shree Ram”.
• Karimganj, Assam- December 11, 2022
  At the said event, Togadia in his speech said that he will legislate that “the SP, PM, DM from any other community” other than Hinduism.

The complaint underscores how such Islamophobic and hate filled statements add to an already polarized and divided environment of the country. Such statements are a grave threat to the peace, unity, and integrity of India. The blatantly misinformed statements would invoke fear in the mind of anyone but his speech received applause and support from the audience. He has consistently delivered such speeches since the early 2000’s in Gujarat and has now extended them to North India and Assam.

CJP also highlighted that they have actively reached out to the district and state authorities as well with respect to taking action against Togadia. On May 5, 2022 CJP had filed a complaint to NCM regarding Togadia’s speech made on 24 April, 2022 where he asked the audience to weed out the “outsiders” i.e., the Bengali-speaking Muslims and called for their ethnic cleansing under the guise of an oath. In a prompt action, NCM had, on May 13, 2022 asked the Assam Chief Secretary to take necessary action against him. However, no such action was taken by the state.

Through the speeches highlighted in the complaint to NCM, CJP has sought swift and stringent action against Togadia under the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The complaint states that, “Statements such as these are bound to make things worse; to further generate communal disharmony or feelings of ill will, enmity and hatred between the supporters of different political parties. The utterances also amount to an act which is prejudicial to the maintenance of harmony between different groups and is likely to disturb public tranquility. Moreover, such open intimidation and hate-filled statements only makes the targeted group more vulnerable to violent acts.”

CJP urged that the speeches delivered by Togadia be acted upon and criminal charges be framed against him for making such statements that can affect the lives of the minorities in our country, and threaten the social harmony in general.

The entire complaint can be read here:

Related:

CJP complains to NCM against Kalicharan’s series of hate speeches across Maharashtra

CJP Impact: NCM acts on CJP’s complaint against Hate Offender Pravin Togadia

Pravin Togadia’s Hate Speech selling like hot cakes in Madhya Pradesh

More hate speech against Muslims delivered across India, authorities remain deafeningly silent

Another complaint to Times Now on polarised debate over Madrassa survey in UP

The post CJP complains to NCM against Pravin Togadia’s series of hate speeches across several states appeared first on SabrangIndia.

In CJP’s endeavour to uphold and protect freedom and constitutional rights of all Indians, the organisation monitors rights violations, especially infringements on social peace through the sustained (mis)use of hate speech and targeted violence. We then approachseveral statutory authorities to bring to their attentionthe infringement of these rights. CJP has been systematically carrying out these multi-layered tasks for years, right from its inception in 2002. Year after year, CJP’s impact keeps growing, deepening this effort at demanding accountability and transparency.

Our  persistent efforts to highlight injustices served uponthe most marginalized and voiceless,Adivasis, Minorities, Dalits, and Women, focus on instances of targeted violence and hate speech: this comprehensive complaint mechanism and monitoring has compelled the authorities to take notice and seek action. In 2023, we will redouble these efforts, adding more and more creative dimensions; to ensure systemic monitoring and accountability from institutions of democratic governance.

Let’s take a look back at 2022 and list down CJP’s strikes and their impact: in terms of real action and change.

News Broadcasting & Digital Standards Authority (NBDSA)

Times Now’s ‘Madrassa Jihad’ Trope

On December 5, CJP wrote to NBDSA against the debate segment of Times Now Navbharat aired on November 11, titled ‘Madrasa Jihad’ परबड़ाखुल़ास़ा, मजहबीत़ालीमक़ा ‘491 तंत्र”. The debate, hosted by Naina Yadav and Rakesh Pandey, was based on a survey carried out by the UP government on Madrassas in certain districts of the State whereby it was reportedly found that Bahraich city has 792 madrassas out of which 491 were found to be running “without license”. The complaint raised “concern over the manner in which or the approach chosen to deal with this data. Using terms like “Madrassa Jihad” and “the ‘M’ Factor” the channel has resorted to cheap tactics to spread communal tension and hatred which is unbecoming of a news channel”.

NBDSA has sought a response from the channel, the complaint is ongoing and the case is pending.

Communal venom over garba celebrations

On October 4, News18 India aired a show hosted by Aman Chopra containing themes of communal divide and direct displays of hatred throughout its narrative while dealing with a news that the Gujarat police had openly flogged men while tying them to a pole, for allegedly pelting stones at a garba event. While showing the video on the screen, of police beating the men, Chopra said, “Aapko Gujarat Police ka Dandiya dikhatehai (We will show you “Dandiya”  played by Gujarat Police)”. Then he cheered them more as the beatings continue and the victims, visibly pained and begging for mercy saying “please forgive us”. CJP wrote to NBDSA on October 22, 2022 as it was dissatisfied with the channel’s response.

Through the entire debate, the members of the panel brought into question not just the various principles of Islam as a religion but also mocked speakers belonging to the Muslim community by asking them to hail Hindus gods on national television. The complaint further states, “There is no iota  of doubt that the intention of the host was to incite Hindus against the Muslim by questioning why Muslims should get involved in garba celebrations, by justifying the unlawful police action of flogging Muslim men publicly, by picking one or two incidents to show that Muslims are acting against Hindus by stone pelting or by entering garba celebrations to eve tease Hindu girls, by posing baseless questions like why Muslim girls do not celebrate garba.”

Even Aaj Tak conducted a similar vilificatory exercise over Garba celebrations. Sudhir Chaudhary, against whose show CJP has complained against in the past as well, hosted this show on Aaj Tak called  ‘Black and White Show’ flagging it off by asking the question Muslim yuvaon ka garba ke pandolon mei jaane ka makshad akhir hai kya? (What is the reason for Muslim youth to go to garba pandals?).

CJP moved NBDSA on October 20, 2022 against the show and stated in its complaint that throughout the show Chaudhary did not try to mask his bias in any manner, manipulated facts and actively participating in the communal diatribe. The host has also presented “data” that claimed that the channel’s team went to the pandals and found that Muslim boys are befriending Hindu girls.

These complaints are pending and will be pursued.

Media trial against Teesta Setalvad

On July 28, CJP moved NBDSA against Times Now for consecutively airing 3 shows amounting to a media trial of human rights activist and journalist, Ms Teesta Setalvad. The three shows, while making Setalvad’s arrest by Gujarat Police a point of discussion, made wild allegations against her questioning her patriotism and credibility, and presented information about her in a manner that not only demeans and vilifies her, but also casts aspersions upon her humanitarian work. The channel went as far as to misrepresent judgements attributed to the Supreme Court of India, when in fact they were comments made by a hostile government.

A hearing was conducted before the NBDSA and the order is awaited.

News18 India held accountable!

CJP had filed this complaint on March 15, 2022 with NBDSAagainst News18 unverified and misleading live debate programme titled ‘Toh hijab ke liye bam barsaenge?/ Danke ki chot par’ (Translation: Asking openly- So will bombs be hurled for hijab?) that aired on February 15, 2022.  The host depicted a distorted view around the incident which took place at a school at Murshidabad, West Bengal by making statements such as “Desh ke kayi hisso mei pradarshan kari itne ugr ho chuke hai, haalat itne kharab ho gye hai ki hijab pehen kar aane se mana karne par school mei pathtar bazi ki gayi, tod phod kiya gaya, dawa kiya bam bhi yahan phenke gaye”  (Translation: In various parts across the country the protesters have been so violent that they pelted stones in the school and vandalized it, it is ascertained that bombs were hurled at the school).

In this complaint, CJP pointed out how, by fact-checkers and news portals such as Alt News and The Print, that in truth, there were no bombs being hurled during the protest, and the claims made by News 18 were not supported by any ground reports or statements from local administration officials.

The NBDSA, vide its order dated July 26, 2022 issued a warning to the broadcaster not to hold such debates without verifying the facts and directed the channel to take down the video of the show from all platforms on the internet. The NBDSA also took serious objection to the language used by the anchor in the programme and said, “The broadcasters must be mindful of their duty towards communities and telecast programmes which are accurate, balanced and impartial and in accordance with the Code of Ethics and Broadcasting Standards and Guidelines.”

CJP’s complaint met with success.

Zee News directed to take down communal debate show

Through its June 142022 order, the NBDSA directed Zee News to pull down the videos of its show titled Kudrat ek bahana hai, Muslim abaadi badhana hai? (Translation: Nature is just an excuse, the motive is to increase Muslim Population?) that aired on June 27, 2021. Thr authority held that “the manner in which the topic was framed, and the language used clearly pointed to the fact that there was an agenda to the debate. This was also clear from the images that were displayed during the debate.”

It further noted that “the following taglines were run during the debate: “Nizaam-e-kudrat ya Hindustan pe aafat?”; “Kudrat bahana hain, Muslim abaadi badana hain?” ; “Hum do hamare do par majhabi rukawat kyo?” ; “UP me chunao, isliye abaadi par tanao?” which taglines were used without any supporting data or facts. In the absence thereof, these taglines amount to giving tilt to the debate which created a perception that there is only one community which is responsible for the population growth in the country.”

CJP had filed the complaint with NBDSA on July 23, 2021.

Zee Hindustan pulled up for “Vaccine Jihad” trope

The NBDSA, vide its June 14 order directed Zee Hindustan to take down all videos of the show titled कट्ट़रपंथियों से सीधे सवाल करने वाला बहुत बड़ा खुलासा | देश में कौन कर रहा है Vaccine वाला जिहाद ? (Translation: Fanatics to be questioned on this big revelation. Who is involved in “Vaccine jihad” in the country?) aired on May 30, 2021. CJP had highlighted in its complaint that the show was about a breaking news story about one Niha Khan from Jamalpur Primary Health Centre in Aligarh, UP, who was booked for allegedly disposing 29 syringes filled with Covid-19 vaccine without administering them to the beneficiaries. CJP pointed out that this news story was false and referred to a fact checked article that stated that the incident had actually taken place in Ecuador. CJP’s contention was that the channel did not even bother to fact check the video that they kept alleging to be of an incident in India.

The Nupur Sharma controversy

On May 31, CJP called out Times Now for allowing, now suspended BJP leader, Nupur Sharma to make derogatory comments about Prophet Mohammad on its debate show.CJP has highlighted in its complaint that no attempt was made by the host Navika Kumar to stop or restrict Nupur Sharma from making such hateful and even hurtful comments, all so she could outshout another speaker. The complaint states that the Times Now Channel clearly allowed this kind of extremely inflammatory statements to run their course and do immeasurable damage before removing this video altogether.

What the complaint stressed upon is that it is not just the participants who have to maintain restraint with respect to the language used against fellow panelists, but it is also the duty of the host/anchor representing the channel to monitor the debate and call out the participants for using such foul language.

Communalising UP elections

On February 15, CJP complained to NBDSA against News18 India’s show ‘Desh nahi jhukne denge – Hinduo ke khilaf mahagathbandhan’ hosted by Aman Chopra which aired on January 18. The show was flagged off by the host with a communally charged question, “Hinduon ke khilaf uttar Pradesh me Mahagathbandhan tayyar ho raha hai aur jab 80 vs. 20 ki baat ki thi yogi Adityanath ne toh wo sahi thi?” (Translation: In UP, a grand alliance is being formed, and was Yogi Adityanath right when he said it is now 80 vs. 20?). The complaint also stated that the narrative of the debate show was to show that the Opposition in the state of UP was forming an alliance against the Hindu community, thereby creating divisions along communal lines in the election campaign phase of the Assembly elections.

The hearing in this case is still pending before the NBDSA.

National Commission for Minorities (NCM)

The ‘Miya Muslim’ stigma

On November 25, the NCM directed the Director General of Police (DGP), Assam to send a detailed report in a complaint filed by CJP against BJP leader and previously a Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA) from the Hojai constituency of Assam, Shiladitya Dev.

On October 31, CJP had filed the complaint after he made derogatory statements and spewed hate against Muslims. In the video, that was uploaded on Facebook he said, “Assam is filled with Miyas, so why there is need for a Miya Museum, it should be set on fire and set ablaze.” He then continued, “After the CAA protest, one section of the community wants Miya Museum in Srimanta Shankardev Kalakhetrya, specially one MLA.” This is not the first time that Shiladitya Dev has found himself in trouble over his comments. In Aug 2020, multiple FIRs had been filed against him by several groups and individuals for particularly inciteful speeches

The “Virat Hindu Sabha”

On October 14, CJP wrote to the NCM against the provocative speeches made at Delhi’s “Virat Hindu Sabha”, calling for a boycott of the Muslim community and even threatening violence. The event, organized by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), was held in North East Delhi on October 9, 2022and witnessed some self-professed religious leaders and members of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), espousing a hard, right-wing, exclusionist ideology delivering incendiary speeches.

As per news report, FIR was filed only under Section 188 of IPC, that is, for lack of permission for holding the event. The complaint details excerpts of these speeches and has also shared with the NCM, the videos that were widely circulated on social media, which become proof that these speeches that were delivered. In one of the videos, BJP MP Pravesh Sahib Singh Verma can be heard saying, “Jahan jahan yeh aaapko dikhaee de, mai kehta hun, agar inka dimaag thik karna hai… toh ek hi ilaaj hai, woh hai sampurna bahishkar… Aap is baat se sehmat ho?” (If you want to set their minds right, if you want to cure them, there is only one solution – complete boycott.)

Suresh Chavhanke — the repeat offender

On September 13, CJP wrote to NCM against Sudarshan TV editor-in-chief Suresh Chavhanke for his derogatory, Islamophobic and hate-filled speech at a rally held on September 4 in Badarpur, Haryana. In the video he can be heard saying, “If you marry a Hindu man, he won’t do any kind of injustice to you. I’ll tell you 10 benefits today keeping Hindus as witness, keeping Bhagwan (God) as witness on camera, in the video, I promise that if you get married to Hindu boys and become Hindu, then you won’t have to face talaq. You won’t have to become a baby making factory, you won’t have to give birth to 40-40 children.” The complaint stated that the speech “amounted to spreading of hatred and distrust against vulnerable and marginalised Muslims sections, especially Muslim women, besides being a grave threat to the peace, unity and integrity of India”.

Action sought against Swami Jitendranand Saraswati

On July 29, NCM directed the Mumbai Police to investigate the Islamophobic and misogynistic call for lynching of pregnant Muslim women given by self-styled spiritual leader Swami Jitendranand Saraswati. This was in response to CJP’s complaintwhere we had highlighted that in the video titled “देशधर्मपरआघातहमचुपक्यूँहै” (Why is the country silent on the attack on religion?) he had said, “Aisa singhnad karo ki desh virodhi mahila ki kokhmein koi gauhatyara, koi rashtravirodhi pal raha ho to kokh phaadkar gir jaaye. (Translation: Roar like a lion, so that if there is a ‘cow killer’ or an anti-national, being nurtured in the womb of an anti-national woman, your slogans should result in the unborn baby falling out of the ripped open womb.)” He had also clubbed together all Muslims with the Taliban and made a series of allegations against the community ranging from marrying children, to raping women.

Action against Deepak Sharma

The NCM, on July 29, issued another letter, this time to the Superintendent of Amroha Police, Uttar Pradesh directing them to investigate hate speech of repeat hate offender Deepak Sharma for making derogatory comments about the anatomy and biology of Allah (the word used for God in Islam), which  cannot be repeated in print. These comments were made him in an audio chatroom organised by Deepak Sharma titled Mahadev ko gaali India mein legal, (Translation: Verbally abusing Mahadev is legal in India) on social media app called ‘Clubhouse’.  CJP has tracked Sharma and his hateful diatribe on social media. CJP was one of the first to flag his profile to National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) on December 27, 2018 and had detailed how Facebook helped news and media channels to team up with such offenders to share and transmit discriminatory content.

Swords distribution by Hindu outfit

On June 29,CJP approached NCM against the hardline outfit Hindu Sena for distributing swords at an event organized by the outfit’s National president Vishnu Gupta and its Delhi president Deepak Malik. The event was held at Vishwagiri temple in Rajouri Garden, Delhi on June 19, 2022, in support of suspended and sacked Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders Nupur Sharma and Naveen Jindal. Such distribution of arms are clear violations of the Indian Arms Act.

BJP MLA Haribhushan Bachaul—multiple times, a hate offender

On June 29, CJP wrote to NCM against BJP MLA Haribhushan Bachaul for using the term ‘jihadi’ (which originally means ‘Muslims carrying out a holy war as sacred duty’, often used by Islamophobes in an attempt to demonise the minority community) for the youth protesting the Agnipath scheme for army recruitment.

This was follow up complaint as CJP had written a complaint earlier, on May 12, against Bachaul for openly comparing Muslims to demons and called for them to be set ablaze, amounting to an open call for genocide.

On June 2, the NCM took note of the May complaint and directed the Director General of Police (DGP), Bihar to investigate and file a report before the Commission within 21 days. There is no further update in this case.

Complaint against Islamic scholar

On June 23, CJP brought to the attention of NCM, hate-filled comments of Ilyas Sharafuddin against Hindus which could have led to a communally polarising reaction within the majority. Sharaufuddin is often invited to debate shows by television news channels to speak on ‘Hindu-Muslim’ issues, at which point he proceeds to use words that either mock or hurt the religious sentiments. During one such appearance on Zee News, on May 31, 2022, he was caught describing in a particularly derogatory manner, the “Shivling”, which is a highly revered symbol in Hinduism. Few other comments made by him on different debate shows across TV channels have been highlighted by CJP in its complaint.

Politician calls ‘Bangladeshi’ and ‘Rohingya’ Muslims  ‘Terrorists’

CJP wrote to NCM against BJP Chief Adesh Guptafor addressing ‘Bangladeshi’ and ‘Rohingya’ Muslims as ‘Terrorists’in a video dated May 9. Gupta even wrote a letter to South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC) Mayor Mukkesh Suryaan and East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC) Mayor Shyam Sunder Agarwal, Adesh Gupta asking them to “identify” the encroachment by “anti-social elements” and “bulldoze them”, India Today had reported on April 22, 2022.

Pravin Togadia’s remarks at Trishul Diksha

On May 5, CJP brought to NCM’s notice the hate speech of surgeon-turned-Hindutva leader and president of Antarashtriya Hindu Parishad (AHP), Pravin Togadia. In the complaint, CJP highlights Togadia’s virtual call for an ‘ethnic cleansing’ drive under the guise of an oath to eradicate “illegal Bangladeshis” at a ceremony where youth were also encouraged to bear arms like trishuls (traditional tridents). Togadia also made communal arguments in favour of a divisive National Register of Citizens (NRC) to weed out the so-called “outsiders, who are more often than not Bengali-speaking Muslims, falsely accused of being illegal Bangladeshi immigrants.

In a rather prompt action, the NCM, on May 13 forwarded CJP’s complaint against Togadia to to the Chief Secretary, Government of Assam to take necessary action.

On December 29, 2021NCM asked DGP, Bengaluru to take necessary action against BJP MP Tejasvi Surya for making communal remarks against the Muslim community and accusing them of “blocking beds” in hospitals providing Covid-19 care. In May 2021, CJP had approached the Commission about the incident that took place on May 4, 2021 where  the BJP MP listed out sixteen names all belonging to people from the Muslim minority community, linking them with an alleged bed blocking ‘scam’ in the south Municipal Zone. There has been no update in this matter.

National Commission for Scheduled Tribes

Dalit man attacked for drawing water from tube well!

On November 23, 2022 CJP wrote to NCST seeking protection for the family of the 46-year-old Tribal man, Kishanlal Bheel from Rajasthan who was lynched by a group of people over drawing water from a tube well. On November 7, a 45-year-old tribal man from Rajasthan’s Jodhpur district died as he was assaulted by a group of people over drawing water from a tube well. As per the police, the family of the deceased alleged that the accused also abused the deceased man Kishanlal Bheel (46), from Bhomiyaji ki Ghati, with casteist slurs. The complaint urges the Commission, to “closely monitor the case through the investigation and prosecution to ensure that substantive and exemplary justice is delivered.”

National Commission for Scheduled Castes

On September 19, CJP sought protection from NCSC for the family of the 9-year-old Dalit boy from Rajasthan who succumbed to his injuries after being allegedly thrashed mercilessly by an “upper caste” teacher allegedly for touching a pot of water which was only meant for “upper castes”. According to the boy’s father, the brutal beating had led to haemorrhage, and the boy’s limbs had stopped working. The family accused an upper caste teacher named Chail Singh who was enraged when the boy had touched a pot of water meant for the teacher. The accused teacher, Chail Singh was arrested on August 13 after the child’s death and the police have taken statements of his classmates and other students present on that day. Since the accused was already booked, CJP sought protection of the victim’s family under Section 15 A of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 that provide for “protection of victims, their dependents, and witnesses against any kind of intimidation or coercion or inducement or violence or threats of violence” as well as right of the victim’s family “to be heard at any proceeding under this Act in respect of bail, discharge, release, parole, conviction or sentence of an accused or any connected proceedings or arguments and file written submission on conviction, acquittal or sentencing.”

In what seems to be a spate of unfortunate incidents of violence against Dalits, especially minors, On September 28, CJP once again wrote to the NCSC seeking protection for the family of the 15-year-old Dalit boy, Nikhit Dohre from Uttar Pradesh who succumbed to his injuries after being allegedly thrashed mercilessly with sticks and rods, by an “upper caste” teacher. We also highlighted how the police has also booked the father of the minor boy, “Instead of ensuring that the perpetrator of this crime is put behind bars, the police is busy further tormenting the Dalit family and the protestors. It is to be noted that while assurance was given by the police that the accused teacher will be arrested, no arrest has been made so far. It is clear from the aforementioned that the family of the victims is under attack and the focus of the police officials is to bury this incident,” stated the complaint. The complaint also seeks monitoring of the investigation by Rajasthan police in the offence already registered to ensure that the perpetrator is booked and proceeded against as per law.

NHRC

Adivasis attacked 2 years ago; inaction of UP Police

It’s been two years and counting since CJP complained to the NHRCpleading action against forest authorities for assaulting Tharu Adivasis of Kajaria Village in Dudhwa Tiger reserve, Lakhimpur Kheri, UP and also for molesting the women. CJP and AIUFWP had complained on July 9, 2020 stating that on Juuly 1, 2020 the forest officials came to the fields, allegedly fired shots in the air, molested women and beat up some youngsters. After considering the matter on December 28, 2021 as per the response submitted by the Forest Department and the rejoinder filed by CJP-AIUFW, the Commission directed the SP, Lakhimpur Kheri, UP to submit the status/outcome of the case within the period of four weeks. 

In June 2022 the NHRC took a serious view of the non-responsive attitude of the Superintendent of Police (SP), Lakhimpur Kheri, Uttar Pradesh and issued conditional summons for his personal appearance before the Commission on July 5 in case the requisite report and copies of the relevant documents are not received by the Commission on or before June 28, 2022. There is no further update on this case.

Election Commission of India

During the campaigning for the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, CJP brought to the notice of the Election Commission of India (ECI) as well as the UP State Election Commission (SEC), several violations of the Model Code of Conduct (MCC).

BJP advertisement on last polling day

On March 10, CJP wrote to the Commission that the BJP had published an ad on the front page of Dainik Jagran, a popular Hindi newspaper, on March 7, 2022, the last day of polling for the Uttar Pradesh Assembly Elections. The complaint states that the publication of the said advertisement does not only violate the MCC issued by the ECI, but also constitutes offences as per the provisions of the Representation of People’s Act, 1951. Moreover, it also goes against the guidelines of the Press Council of India. The complaint brings to the attention of the Commissions, how a political advertisement on a poll has the potential to alter people’s perceptions and their voting behaviour even if it is at the very last moment.

Reports of faulty EVMs, bogus voting

CJP also wrote to ECI and SEC about certain reports from the ground it received during polling in different phases of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, about poll code violations. The letter listed down the detailed reports of the incidents along with the booth numbers, constituency and districts of the state, specifically mentioning the allegations behind the incidents by categorising them into different categories such as: Faulty EVM, Bogus voting, Obstruction at booths and Candidates obstructed at polling booths. There were allegedly, six incidents of bogus voting, two incidents of booth obstructions, one incident of faulty EVMs at several polling booths across the constituencies of Mirjapur, Malhani, Sagdi, Zafarbad, Sevapuri, Jaunpur and Varanasi Saudh. While the veracity of these claims could not be ascertained, CJP sought an inquiry into these incidents. A similar complaint was filed on February 24 reporting 6 incidents of faulty EVM, 7 incidents of bogus voting, 5 incidents of booth obstructions and 4 incidents of candidates being obstructed at several polling booths across the districts of Kannauj, Mainpuri, Etah, Firozabad, Kasganj, Kanpur and Etah.

Hate speech

CJP repeatedly complained against BJP MLA Raghvendra Pratap Singh for his hate speeches during UP Assembly poll campaign. In its February 23 complaint, CJP highlighted Singh’s speech where in a recoded video he can be heard saying, “Any Hindu who doesn’t vote for me has Miyan (slang for Muslims) blood in his veins. He’s a traitor. He is a b***ard son of Jaichand. He’s a h****khor son of his father…I am giving warning this time…traitors of Hindu religion will be destroyed.”

In an earlier complaint dated February 15, CJP highlighted another of his hate speech where he said,“If you make me MLA again, they (Muslims) will stop wearing skullcaps and start applying tilaks.” Singh also claimed that after he got elected in the last election, “250 acres of land belonging to Muslims got confiscated, their shops destroyed.” He also asked the crowd, “Will there be Jai Shri Ram or Walekum Salam in Domariyaganj? Durga ji is here with us, promise once in front of her.” In both complaints CJP urges that these “serial hate offences and hate crimes are evaluated and acted upon for what they are, not individual misdemeanors but concerted attempts to not only vitiate the social and political atmosphere but –in brazen violation of Indian criminal law and election law –criminally intimidate voters and also indulge in a corrupt electoral practice.”

The ECI, on February 23, finally acted in one of the complaints made by CJP, whereby itdebarred BJP MLA from Amethi Mayankeshwar Singh from campaigning, for 24 hours. In the complaint dated February 19, CJP had highlighted a video in which Singh had said, “If the Hindus are awakened, we will pull out the beards and make a chotia (a ponytail sported by Brahmin Hindus). If you want to stay in Hindustan you will have to say “Radhe Radhe” (a Hindu chant) else, just like at the time of partition people had gone to Pakistan, you should also go.”

Complaints to Other authorities

Complaint to Haryana DGP

After coming across a viral video on social media of a group of men dragging two men on the streets, while shooting bullets in the air and accusing the two men of “slaughtering cows”, CJP wrote to Haryana’s Director General of Police (DGP) urging him to identify the group of men and book them for abducting and assaulting the two men.

Dalit sanitation worker murdered

On May 13, CJP wrote to the Commissioner of Police of Meera-Bhayandar, Vasai-Virar (MBVV) seeking strict action against the perpetrators behind the brutal killing of 30-year-old Shri Krishna Palaram Tusamad who was allegedly beaten to death with iron rods by his employer. While an FIR was registered, CJP urged further protection be provided to the victim’s family under the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 since the deceased who was the sole earning member of the family is survived by his parents, a wife and four children.

Seeking stricter action against Mahant’ Bajrang Muni Das

On April 18, CJP sought inclusion of stringent offences to be invoked against ‘Mahant’ Bajrang Muni Das from Khairabad, Uttar Pradesh who was booked for repeatedly making hate speeches and issuing rape threats to Muslim women outside a mosque in Sitapur on Hindu New Year on April 2, 2022. CJP, in its memorandum to the DGP, UP urged that key sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) like Sections 153, 153A, 153B, 295A, 354A, 503, 504 and 505 be added to the FIR along with Section 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and Sections 3 and 4 of the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986.

In its detailed communication, to Mr. Mukund Goel, DGP, UP, we contended that only such a comprehensive complaint will ensure both a non-partisan and in-depth investigation as also a prosecution.

Acted against Fake News

On April 7, CJP wrote to YouTube and two YouTube based news channels to immediately take down their baseless “news report” videos where they have claimed that CJP secretary, journalist and Human Rights defender Teesta Setalvad is involved in the making of an upcoming movie titled The Gujarat Files,  since the same is misinformation. The channels Desh Live and The Live TV aired stories claiming that Teesta Setalvad had held a secret meeting in her home with actor Naseeruddin Shah, director Rahul Dholakia, activist Harsh Mander and many others to start work on The Gujarat Files. They further claimed that the script was ready and that Shah would play the role of Narendra Modi! The news being fake, based on as pictures, sourced from a public event held to commemorate 20 years of the Gujarat carnage of 2002, was pointed out to the channels and we asked that these be taken down at the risk spreading misinformation.

Communal posters in train removed

On May 26, the Government Railway Police (GRP) acted upon CJP’s complaint that there were communal posters being put up in local trains and accordingly traced them and had them removed. A video sent by a Mumbai resident showed a train halted at Malad station that had two to four posters in Devnagri-script stuck on the coach windows. The posters read, “Wake Up Hindus! Section 30 should be removed so that schools can teach Ved, Upanishad, Gita, Ramayan and other scripts.”

The GRP thanked the CJP team for bringing this matter to their notice. Borivali Railway’s Senior Police Inspector Anil Kadam told us, “We have removed all posters inside the train. While we could not check the entire train at the time, our officials will inspect nearby coaches again to check if any more posters have been pasted.” Kadam further assured us that the issue will be raised with higher officials.

YouTube alerted for hateful content

On May 20, CJP wrote to YouTube bringing to its notice certain videos that exist on the platform despite being flagged by CJP for their hateful content. These include content aired on Channels namely, Pavitr Sanatan, CarryLime and Ishwar Lal Pracharak. In its complaint, CJP explains the potential repercussions of incitement of violence against Muslim community which has faced incidents of communal violence and genocidal pogroms that have damaged India’s social fabric for decades.

The complaint raises concern that the accounts, mostly anonymous, know that there is hardly any precedent for anyone in India from being prosecuted for misogynistic or hate speech. They are also aware that even if one handle is banned by a platform, it is easy to set up another account using another anonymous handle. The fact that they are able to have such a wide reach despite their content that is violative of YouTube’s community guidelines, means they are able to thrive and mushroom into more and more accounts.

In this case, YouTube acted promptly and on May 31, informed CJP that they had taken cognisance of the accounts we had reported, and suspended six videos for violating YouTube’s Community Guidelines regarding Hate Speech.

Sadhvi Giri’s incitement to sexual violence

On February 9, CJP wrote a complaint to the DGP, Chhattisgarh to take action against and direct filing an FIR Sadhvi Vibhanand Giri for making abhorrent remarks provoking sexual violence against women from the minority community. In the video, Giri can be heard saying,  “If any Muslim man laid their eyes on a Hindu girl from today onwards, their women will give birth to Hindu children, without a nikah or pheras,” thus, openly supporting rape of Muslim women and promoting rape culture.

The dynamic team of Citizens for Justice and Peace (C JP) with its ears to the ground, committed to protecting the rights of all Indians, especially those structurally rendered the most vulnerable, among so much else, will continue to call out such repeat rights violations and alert statutory authorities to intervene to protect the right to life and dignity of all Indians. For all the work that we do, and so much more that needs to be done, we need the support of the wider community of Indians, committed to the Indian Constitutional Vision. As 2023 approaches and challenging times lie ahead, CJP is both ready and committed to this demanding task.

(Through the year, CJP’s on ground teams backed by legal research and communication both compile, monitor and complain to appropriate authorities on hate speech and rights violations of India’s most marginalsied)

Related:

CJP writes to NBDSA against Times Now ‘Madrassa Jihad’ show

Hate Watch: Swords brandished in Udupi’s Durga Daud, FIR registered

Hate Watch: Hindu Sena distributes swords at event supporting Nupur Sharma

CJP moves NCM against the communal ‘Virat Hindu Sabha’, seeks stringent action against all speakers

CJP moves NBDSA against Times Now’s virtual media trial of Teesta Setalvad

Deepak Sharma makes derogatory remarks about Allah, CJP moves NCM

CJP urges DGP Haryana to act against cow vigilantes in Mewat, Haryana

Hate Watch: Dalit boy dies after being allegedly thrashed by teacher; cops deny “caste angle”

Hate Watch: Dalit teen tied to electricity pole and thrashed on suspicion of theft

CJP moves NCM over Haribhushan Thakur Bachaul’s anti-Muslim genocidal speech

The post Real Impact, Real Change: CJP’s year of monitoring violations: a review appeared first on SabrangIndia.

On June 14, CJP filed a complaint with the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) against serial hate offender Deepak Sharma, after he made derogatory statements against ‘Allah’ in an audio chat room on a social audio app called ‘Clubhouse’.

In a screen recording of the audio chat room organised by Deepak Sharma titled Mahadev ko gaali India mein legal, (Translation: Verbally abusing Mahadev is legal in India) he can be heard making a series of extremely crude and derogatory comments about the anatomy and biology of Allah (the word used for God in Islam), which  cannot be repeated in print.

The complaint brought to the Commission’s attention how Deepak Sharma has been misusing social media platforms to build up a following, when actually his credentials are deeply suspect and questionable. Sometime ago, CJP had explained in a video how he has misused Facebook as a platform. The video may be viewed here:

It noteworthy that his ‘main’ Twitter account @TheDeepak2020 was suspended because of mass reporting previously. He had then logged in from his alternate account @TheDeepak2020In (set up in 2020) and complained on video to his followers to help him reach his “voice to the Twitter CEO.” However, even this account has been suspended by Twitter for ‘violating its rules’.

Deepak Sharma’s suspended Twitter account:

Another shocking incident brought to light by the complaint was the manner in which Uttar Pradesh police have been obliging several of Deepak Sharma’s ‘requests’ and filing First Information Reports (FIR) against social media users for allegedly joking about “Shivling”, a symbol holy to Hindus. These jokes started after a “Shivling” was allegedly found in the compound of Gyanvapi mosque, though mosqe authorities say that it was part of an old and defunct fountain. It is this “Shivling” vs fountain narrative that spawned a series of jokes on Twitter, and Sharma took it upon himself to report people to posted such jokes. In a series of tweets, Sharma retweeted or posted screengrabs, identifying and ‘reporting’ people to the police, and giving the cops instructions on what to do. He would then celebrate his ‘wins’ as the police would register FIRs against those he had identified, especially if the social media user was a Muslim.

For the same reason, his main Twitter account @TheDeepak2020 was suspended because of mass reporting, but he continued with his threats from his alternate account (set up in 2020).

What’s inexplicable is why, with these obviously criminal antecedents and background, the UP police are allowing him to instigate criminal complaints. The complaint expressed its concern that the police authorities reacted with exceptional urgency to Sharma’s complaints against a few jokes, whereas no action had been taken against Deepak Sharma himself for committing grave human rights violations and aggravated form of insult to religion with malicious intention of outraging the religious feelings of Muslim minorities.

Although his tweets are unavailable now as his account was suspended for the second time, CJP has, in the letter to the NCM, expressed concern over the fact that there is no stopping him from making another account and continuing with his practice of selectively targeting the members belonging to the Muslim minority as there is hardly any precedent for anyone in India from being prosecuted for misogynistic or hate speech. The complaint has stated that even if one handle is banned by a platform, it is easy to set up another account using another anonymous handle. The fact that he has had such a wide reach despite his content, that incidentally violates Twitter’s community guidelines, means he has been able to thrive, more accounts have been allowed to mushroom.

Here is an example of one such tweet by Deepak Sharma: 

The Complaint claimed that posting jokes or memes on social media cannot be a ground for arresting anyone. It argues that this kind of a pick and choose method undertaken by the UP police to arrest someone only to the whims and fancies of a hate offender and extreme right-wing leader such as Deepak Sharma, who brazenly boasts about his own far right ideology and repeatedly makes hate speech, is fundamentally wrong and against the law.

CJP also brought these recent acts to the notice of Director General of Police (DGP), Uttar Pradesh, Dr. Devendra Singh Chauhan. The complaint to DGP may be read here:

The complaint highlighted how Deepak Sharma confidently claims that he will ensure that these social media users are charged with IPC Sections and Section 66A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 which has been struck down by the Supreme Court as unconstitutional on grounds of violating the freedom of speech guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India

The complaint has cited the case of Mahendra Singh Dhoni vs. Yerraguntla Shyamsundar and Anr (2017) 7 SCC 760 where the Supreme Court held, “It is clear as crystal that Section 295-A does not stipulate everything to be penalised and any and every act would tantamount to insult or attempt to insult the religion or the religious beliefs of a class of citizens. It penalises only those acts of insults to or those varieties of attempts to insult the religion or religious belief of a class of citizens which are perpetrated with the deliberate and malicious intention of outraging the religious feelings of that class of citizens. Insults to religion offered unwittingly or carelessly or without any deliberate or malicious intention to outrage the religious feelings of that class do not come within the section. The Constitution Bench has further clarified that the said provision only punishes the aggravated form of insult to religion when it is perpetrated with the deliberate and malicious intention of outraging the religious feelings of that class. Emphasis has been laid on the calculated tendency of the said aggravated form of insult and also to disrupt the public order to invite the penalty.”

The complaint has demonstrated Deepak Sharma’s past conduct in detail. CJP was one of the first to  flag his profile to National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) on December 27, 2018 and had detailed how Facebook helped news and media channels to team up with such offenders to share and transmit discriminatory content.

A copy of the complaint to NCM may be read here: 

Related:

CJP Impact: Twitter suspends Deepak Sharma’s main account
Hathras horror: News channel teams up with serial hate offender to spread anti-victim propaganda
Tandav Controversy: Deepak Sharma demands ‘anti-blasphemy’ law
Hate Watch: CJP writes to NHRC regarding hate on Facebook
Hate Offender: Deepak Sharma’s Hate Speeches have gone unchecked so far
How does Hate Offender Deepak Sharma manage to get FIRs registered on demand?

The post CJP moves NCM against Deepak Sharma for derogatory remarks against Allah online! appeared first on SabrangIndia.

"We met some local families and spoke to the local administration. We found that there was no evidence to suggest there had been an exodus of any kind. I don't wish to comment on the NHRC report too much, but some of the findings seem baseless," the NCM team, led by member-in-charge for Uttar Pradesh Farida Abdullah Khan told the Times of India.
 
Last month, an NHRC report had validated the allegation made earlier by the BJP MP from the area, Hukum Singh that 250 Hindu families were forced to move out of Kairana in Shamli district of UP out of fear. "At least 24 witnesses stated that the youths of the specific majority community (Muslims in this case) in Kairana town pass lewd/taunting remarks against the females of the specific minority community in town," the report stated.
 
However, in June this year, a probe by the Shamli district administration found Hukum Singh’s allegation to be bogus. As against Singh’s list of 346 Hindu families who had allegedly fled the district, the probe concluded that only in three cases families had faced “rangdari” threats and police had taken timely action in each case.
 
According to an Indian Express investigation, which tracked down 22 people who figure in Singh’s list, five had died, four had moved out of Kairana looking for better opportunities, 10 left more than 10 years ago, three had moved fearing “local criminals”.
 
Khan said the NCM team didn't find much evidence to back the NHRC claim. "For instance, the (NHRC) report claims that the rise in crime in Kairana was linked to the resettlement of refugees. There is no paperwork that can verify this. It also said that the riot-displaced persons changed the demographics of the town since about 30,000 people came and settled here. However, local NGOs said the figure in Kairana is not more than 200 people."

The latest Times of India report may be read here.
 

The post Minorities Commission Probe Team trashes NHRC Report on Kairana appeared first on SabrangIndia.

The Report of the National Minorities Commission (NCM) on the Latehar Hangings in Jharkand severely indicts the Jharkand Police and the Political Class for Failing to Reign in the Gauraksha Samitis who are taking Law into their own hands

Deep and widespread communalisation of sections of the Jharkand police force, and slogans like ‘go-to-Pakistan’ were frequently used by the local police against the Muslims, pointing towards a larger communalisation of the state police, says a report of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) after a team visited Latehar on the brute violence. The report, finalised on May 18 is an indictment of the authorities. Chairperson of the NCM, Naseem Ahmed speaking to Sabrangindia said that the findings contained in the report were self-explanatory. The Report can be read here.

Farida Abdulla Khan member of the team that visited Latehar was categoric. “Sections of the police are seriously implicated,” she told Sabrangindia, “ and there is palpable anger among local Muslim residents against them. “But much more crucial is that this is a communal issue that has been consistently and deliberately fanned politically. So it has to be tackled by the political establishment. The Gau Raksha Samitis etc are on the rampage and unless a clear and direct message from the political establishment is sent out, this kind of violence is not going to stop.

In an incident shockingly reminiscent of the Dadri lynching, a 12-year-old Muslim boy and a Muslim man herding eight buffaloes on their way to a Friday market were beaten up and hanged to death from a tree by suspected cattle-protection vigilantes. The initial report and photographers were pasted on facebook by Ashif Nawaz. The double murders  of the two Muslims [Mazlum Ansari, 32, and Imteyaz Khan] took place in Balumath, Latehar district of Jharkhand on March 18-19.

Mob rule has been the name of the game since the NDA II government came to power.   On April 2, the mutilated body of Mustain Abbas, was found in a drain near Masana village in Kurukshetra, Haryana, after the family belonging to Nai Majra in Uttar Pradesh had spent nearly a month looking for the 27-year-old. Both Jharkand and Haryana are ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

In what the report terms “brazen communal reaction”, there is an instance where one sub-inspector of the Chandwa police station, Ratan Kumar Singh, who is said to have “physically attacked several of the protestors and used extremely provocative, abusive and communally charged language against the Muslims”. Many local Muslim residents of the area talked about Singh’s communal prejudices and said that his presence at the protest aggravated the violence. Ms Farida Khan pointed out that the Muslims of the area were so angry that the families of the victims refused to take the compensation of one lakh rupees that the state government had announced.
It is almost two months after the gruesome lynching of two cattle traders in Latehar, Jharkhand, that this fact finding report turns the gaze again on this brutal killing that had fallen off the national media map. The NCM has questioned the role of the state police in containing the simmering communal tension in the area. The two NCM members who led the fact finding team, Farida Abdulla Khan and Praveen Davar, found that the police ignored several complaints from the Muslim community against regional cow vigilante groups prior to the incident.

Two cattle traders, Majloom Ansari (32) and Imtiaz Khan (13), were beaten and hanged to death by some cow vigilantes in Jhabbar, Latehar on March 18, 2016 when they were travelling to the nearest fair to sell their cattle. Five men, all allegedly belonging to the local Gau Rakhsha Samiti, have been arrested in the case.

A prominent Hindu seer associated with a cow protection vigilante group is accused of fomenting hatred against cattle traders and directing his followers to target and kill them in Jharkhand’s communally sensitive Latehar district that saw two cattle traders murdered on March 18.  Family members of the victims, Muslim villagers, political leaders and rights activists of Latehar on Monday unanimously held Acharya Gopal Maniji Maharaj, a katha vachak (preacher) of the Bharatiya Gau Kranti Manch, responsible for the gruesome killing of Mazlum Ansari, 32, and Imteyaz Khan, 13.The Hindustan Times  reported that Latehar police have arrested five suspects, including a member of a local cow protection vigilante group, for the murders. Police superintendent Anup Birtharay declared it a criminal incident aimed at looting cash and cattle. But ruling parties are crying foul over the police probe.. “We have concrete information that a few Bajrang Dal activists from Balumath block had recently gone to Delhi to meet the seer,” said Madan Pal, member of a prominent human rights group Jharkhand Jansangram Morcha. He alleged the activists returned on February 28 and carried out the killings.

Recommendations:
(A) Pertaining to the incidents in Hazaribagh
 
1. Loss in each shop/house should be properly assessed and adequate compensation be paid to each victim.
2. State Govt must issue strict instructions to the District Administration to explore if the Ramnavmi celebrations could be restricted to only one day as in other parts of the country.
3. All perpetrators and instigators of violence must be identified and proceeded against as per law and a speedy trial.
4. Mohd Hafeez, whose forearms have been shattered in an attack should be provided urgent medical attention by referring him to AIIMS, Delhi. 

(B) Pertaining to the incidents at Latehar:
1. Adequate compensation should be given to the victims’ families at the earliest possible.
2. All efforts be made to punish the guilty and all those associated with the crime either directly or indirectly.
3. Immediate steps to be taken to monitor the Gau Rakshak Committees and to take serious action against those who are attempting to create communal tensions and encouraging vigilante groups into taking the law into their own hands.
4. The Muslim community must be reassured about their physical safety and protection of their livelihoods.
5. The events of 18/03/2016 should be properly screened and charges against the innocent to be dropped.
6. Serious allegations against Ratan K. Singh Sub-inspector Chandwa Thana be investigated and appropriate action be taken.

Communal police actions
The report was finalised on May 18 and sent to the Jharkand government and the aministration, locally. The Centre’s standard response reportedly has been that this is a ‘state issue’.

The report notes that the police acted in a brazenly communal manner with the protestors who came to file a report after the killings. The protest had turned violent with the police resorting to lathi charge and firing in the air. “When we visited Balumath and Nawada villages from where Ansari and Khan came, the Muslims told us that its anger against the police was cumulative as the local police did not take any action despite their repeated complaints over the last few months against the cow vigilantes. ” Farida Abdulla Khan told Sabrangindia adding that villagers complained that the cow vigilante groups often threatened them to stop their business or face consequences.

She said that the Muslim residents have traditionally been in the cattle trading business. “They bought cattle from the market and sold them on a marginal profit. There is no slaughter involved,” she explained. The report says: “…attacks on the (Muslim) community, especially those dealing with cattle trading, have been taking place and increasing in number and viciousness over the last two or three years. Muslims rearing and trading in cattle are being threatened, harassed and physically attacked, and although they have approached the authorities over this, no action has been taken against any of the perpetrators.”
The report also says that the emergence of Gau Raksha Samitis in the area is a relatively new phenomenon. “The residents mentioned a Baba Gopal Maniji Maharaj from Dehradun who started coming to the region in 2012 and initiated this movement which has since become more widespread… the locals report that at meetings of these committees, there is incitement to hatred and an attempt to target Muslims in the name of protection of cows.”

The findings of the committee are in keeping with reports that cow protection committees are centrally managed  by Hindutva groups spread across India and have come to enjoy political patronage especially in BJP-ruled states.

Noteworthy is that the Jharkhand administration was reluctant to admit the association of the five people arrested with cow vigilante groups. “Gau Raksha Samiti activities are a parallel event and there is no direct link to the killing. The group’s members had assaulted some villagers earlier but there is no direct bearing of this on what has happened now,” Latehar superintendent of police Anoop Birthare had said.  The BJP chief minister Raghubar Das, too, towed the Hindutva line in the aftermath of the Latehar incident. “There is a lot of cattle-smuggling in the area. Just like Uttarakhand, in Jharkhand trafficking cows across the border is not permissible,” he had said in his initial response, while quoting the Jharkhand Bovine Animal Prohibition of Slaughter Act, 2005 that bans cow slaughter and transporting cows outside the state. It was only after it was pointed out that the two cattle traders had not violated the law that he asked his officials to take quick action and prevent such incidents in the future.

The NCM report has recommended that the case be handed over to the Central Bureau of Investigation to ensure quick delivery of justice to the aggrieved families. It also says that stern action should to be taken against Ratan Kumar Singh and any one engaged in incitement to communal violence. The team also recommended that compensation for the affected families be increased to 3.5 lakh rupees, already in the state government’s provisions.

Hazaribagh violence
The NCM team also visited Hazaribagh, witness to Hindu-Muslim riots during the Ram Navami procession on April 17. “Over a dozen shops and several vehicles were set ablaze by the mobs. We were told that the puja committees are advised every year to avoid playing songs that are directed against any community. All these check lists are given to them every year and although they agree to abide by these, they circumvent it by using one excuse or the other. Such songs with twisted lyrics were being played for last many years defying the orders of the administration. Though opinion varied, it appears the tenor of the songs played this time was much sharper in their anti-minority bias. A large number of participants consume heavy quantities of liquor which adds to making the situation more aggressive,” the report notes about the Hazaribagh violence.

“The minority community showed us damage that they had to bear because of the riots and that the state administration has not estimated their losses well. No compensation has been paid to them. They also complained that neither the police nor any of the neighbours came to their rescue when their shops and houses were being set on fire,” said Khan.

Communal riots had broken out when the members of a Hindutva group played certain allegedly anti-Muslim songs in the procession. Khan said that just like Latehar, the Muslims of Hazaribagh complained about frequent threats by Hindutva groups. “This ‘go-to-Pakistan’ slogan against Muslims and other such unpronounceable abuses, are slowly being used as the main weapon to attack the minorities in Jharkhand,” said Khan.

The NCM team has recommended adequate compensation for the riot victims and punishment for those who were involved in the riots. In addition, it has instructed the district administrations to “explore if the Ram Navami celebrations could be restricted to only one day as in other parts of the country”. Even in the past, Ram Navami processions have acted as the trigger for communal violence in many parts of the country.
Khan drew parallels between the Jharkhand incidents and the Muzaffarnagar riots and Dadri lynching case. “In all these cases, we have found that the minority community has lost faith in the administration. Despite the fact that they had to live under constant threat, they were absolutely stunned by the way the two persons were killed,” the NCM member said, while talking about the impunity Gau Raksha committee members enjoy in the present times.

That Hindutva groups have gained confidence after the BJP has come to power and enjoy a greater degree of impunity than in the times of the previous government is difficult to disagree with. The BJP-ruled states have increasingly become prone to communal polarisation in the last two years. Even certain BJP parliamentarians have resorted to making  hateful statements against minorities. Given this context, the NCM report pointing to the Jharkhand administration’s complicity in Hindu majoritarian propaganda or even lack of interest in protecting the rights of Muslim citizens is not just significant but a timely reminder of a volatile situation.
 
 

The post Local Jharkand Police Used Communal Slogans: NCM on Latehar Hangings appeared first on SabrangIndia.