On January 13, 2025, Maha Kumbh, the largest human gathering in the World, began in Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh (U.P.). More than 400 million people are expected to attend the Maha Kumbh in the period of 45 days of this auspicious religious event. The Maha Kumbh holds a great religious significance for Hindus as it happens only once every 144 years. Prayagraj, which is considered to be sacred as it is the home of the Triveni Sangam, the confluence of the rivers Ganga, Yamuna and the mythical Saraswati, has attracted pilgrims, ascetics, devotees and travellers, not just from India but from around the world. Bathing in these holy waters is believed to purify one’s soul.
History of Kumbh Mela
The history of the Kumbh Mela goes back to the Hindu myths of Samudra Manthan, or the churning of ocean, which was done by the Gods and the Demons, to obtain invaluable jewels and amrita, the nectar of immortality. In the churning, the God Dhanvantari appeared with a pot in his hand filled with amrita. The son of Lord Indra, Jayant, saw the pot and snatched it from the hands of God Dhanvantari and ran to prevent the demons from consuming the amrita and becoming immortal. Jayant ran for 12 days, while taking rest at 4 places in a 3 days interval, Haridwar, Prayag, Nashik – Trimbakeshwar and Ujjain. At all these four places when Jayant stopped, he spilled some of the amrita, giving these places mystical powers. All these four places are located at the banks of holy rivers, Haridwar located on the banks of Ganga, Prayagraj has the confluence of the Ganga, Yamuna and the mythical river Saraswati, Ujjain has the Kshipra, and Nashik – Trimbakeshwar has the Godavari, often referred as Ganga of the South. It is believed that by taking a dip in these holy rivers during Kumbh, washes away one’s sins and helps them gain punya (spiritual merit).
As per divine counting, one day for the Gods is considered to be equal to one year for the humans. And therefore, every three years, Kumbh Mela takes place in one of the four cities of Prayag, Haridwar, Nashik – Trimbakeshwar and Ujjain. Normal Kumbh Mela takes place every three years, whereas the Ardh Kumbh Mela is held every six years at Haridwar and Prayagraj, and the Purna Kumbh Mela takes place every four years in one of the four cities based on the locations of planets. The Maha Kumbh Mela takes place once in 144 years at Prayagraj, after 12 Purna Kumbh Melas, as per the official website of the Kumbh Mela.
The location of Kumbh Mela is determined by the location of the Sun, moon and Jupiter in different zodiac signs in that time period.
Maha Kumbh 2025
The festivities and the celebrations in this year’s Kumbh is expected to be more extravagant than all previous iterations. With the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ruling both in the Centre and the state of U.P., the event is expected to be more overt. The festival is viewed by many to be a potential symbol of Hindu unity and power. Backed by huge state resources and widespread PR campaigns, this year’s Maha Kumbh is expected to be the most expensive on record. Estimated 40 to 45 crore visitors are expected to visit the Maha Kumbh in Prayagraj, as reported by the Economic Times.
As per reports, a sum of 7,000 crore Rupees has been spent by the U.P. State Government on the Maha Kumbh Mela of 2025 on infrastructure projects and sanitation facilities, with nationwide posters of Chief Minister of U.P., Hindu monk Adityanath Yogi, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi on promotional material for the Maha Kumbh, 2025.
The festival has also become a ground for sowing seeds of communal tensions between Hindus and Muslims thus making it the most polarised Kumbh Mela in history. One of the senior-most priests of the festival, Mahant Durganand Bhramachari, stated that “Kumbh Mela is a great convergence of humans, gods and our sacred rivers”, and expressed concern and dismay over attempts at using the festival to promote sectarianism and religious divide in the country.
He further added stating that “What bothers me this time is how some people are trying to polarise the atmosphere on communal lines. There has to be peaceful coexistence and hate should have no place. We see some people are trying to create Hindu-Muslim tensions,” as reported by the Guardian.
Digital innovations and AI have also been used to help with multiple problems faced by chaotic and large–scale festivities. Thousands of drones have been employed to monitor the security at the celebration. Meanwhile, devotees have each been given radio frequency wristbands to help locate lost family members that might get separated in the crowd.
While the Kumbh Mela is celebrated to promote spirituality, there have been various shortcomings with regards to the organization of the event as well as behaviours of extremist Hindu devotees who have used the festival and attempted to incite communal disparity.
Communal Disparity
The Maha Kumbh which is a spiritual and religious festival for Hindus has sadly become a ground for promoting communal disparity and rising communal tensions due to various instances. Even the Government has diverted its attention from major concerns such as the cleanliness of the rivers Ganga and Yamuna and the efficient management of the Maha Kumbh, towards petty issues creating further rifts between the Hindus and the Muslims.
- Prohibiting Muslims from participating in the Maha Kumbh
The All India Akhara Parishad (AIAP), which has been formed by the Saints and Sadhus of 13 affiliated Akharas, has been pushing for banning the entry of Muslims and their business participation as well from the Maha Kumbh Mela, 2025. For the first time the AIAP is taking active steps by garnering support of other devotees and saints in banning the participation of Muslims and restricting their business activities in the Mela.
The rationale behind this demand of the AIAP stems out of an incident during the Kanwar Yatra, where allegedly Muslim hotels and restaurants served non-vegetarian food to the devotees taking part in the Yatra, thus hurting their religious sentiment. This, the Akhara Parishad argues, justifies their demands of restricting the participation of Muslims from the Mela.
Maulana Mufti Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi, National President of the All India Muslim Jamaat, has requested the U.P. Government to intervene. He stated that “The Akhara Parishad’s decision is fostering division and promoting communalism. Such actions only serve to create rifts in society. I urge the state government to reverse this decision and take strong action against those spreading communal hatred,” as reported by India Tomorrow.
Shankaracharya Avimukteshwaranand Saraswati, supported the decision of the Akhara Parishad by arguing that just as Hindus are not allowed to visit Mecca and Madina, even Muslims should not be allowed to participate in the Maha Kumbh. He stated that “Mecca and Madina are Muslim sacred sites, and Hindus are restricted from going there. Similarly, the Kumbh is our religious festival; Muslims should have no business being involved.”
While Shankaracharya’s statement provides prima facie support to the claims of the Akhara Parishad, his claims are based on unfounded reasoning. Mecca and Madina are hosted in foreign countries and the Indian Government only exercises jurisdiction over events in India. Furthermore, with India’s history of co–existence between the Hindu and Muslim religions and taking part in each other’s festival, it is only right to allow Muslims to be a part of the biggest Hindu festival of the century.
Jamiat Ulama-e-Hind’s Uttar Pradesh legal advisor, Maulana Kaab Rashidi stated that “Such calls violate the rights enshrined in the Constitution because India is known all over the world as a secular country. So, talking about banning Muslims from Maha Kumbh is like crushing the soul of the Constitution,” as reported by Livemint.
Even the U.P. Chief Minister, Adityanath Yogi has become a part of the controversy as he stated that “Anyone who has respect for India and Sanatan traditions can come to Kumbh….people with bad mentality should not go there….they may face problems,” as reported by the Deccan Herald.
Reference can be made here to Gandhiji’s reflections of the Kumbh Mela of 1915 in his famous book My Experiments with Truth. While traveling from Saharanpur to Kumbh Mela in Haridwar, Gandhiji highlighted the inhumane conditions in which people had to travel. He then went ahead to focus on the prevalent religious prejudices, where orthodox Hindus would not consume water if the person offering them the same was Musalmani. By witnessing the dividing of food and beverages on religious lines, Gandhiji understood the extent of religious polarisation in the country. He expressed his disappointment at such a state of affairs.
These attempts at restricting the entry and business activities of Muslims in the Maha Kumbh furthers the rift between the society and becomes a ground for promoting cultural disparity in a country where different religions and cultures have coexisted for a long time.
- Fake news
Outrage sparked on January 10, 2025, as a man was caught urinating on one of the banners for Maha Kumbh in Raebareli. Media outlets and users of social media soon gave the incident a communal twist, circulating videos of the man being verbally and physically assaulted for his actions.
UttarPradesh.ORG News shared a video of the man being abused on X and said that a man from “another community” was thrashed by locals on accusations of urinating on a poster of Maha Kumbh.
Multiple users shared similar videos of the incident and labelled the man as a Muslim terrorist and expressed their concerns causing outrage over social media handles.
However, on 11 January, 2025, Raebareli police issued a statement clarifying that the name of the accused was Vinod, a Hindu vendor, and the claims that the man belonged to “another community” were entirely false. According to the statement of the Police, the accused was in an intoxicated state and urinated 3-4 feet away from the wall that had the poster and banners of Maha Kumbh, however, people present at the scene soon surrounded him and began accusing him of being from another community and started assaulting him, as reported by ALT News.
Such incidents reflect the deeply entrenched stereotypes and prejudices in the minds of people which get flared up and are exaggerated further by social media posts and false new reporting. A question however arises here, why such accusations are attributed to the Muslim community alone? Why is it that when any miscreant does any action to disturb the peace, the first assumption is made regarding his religion and his labelled as a Muslim terrorist.
There have also been incidents where people have assumed false identities as a Muslim and threatened violence just to worsen the communal rifts in our country. In the first week of January, a post on social media emerged, where a user named Nasar Pathan threatened a bomb blast at the Maha Kumbh taking the lives of at least 1000 devotees. However, after investigation by the Police, it was revealed that a student of class 11th, Ayush Kumar Jaiswal had created this fake account under the name of Nasar Pathan and posted the threat on social media handles, which spread like a wildfire, as reported by The Quint.
This incident is a recent case of a concerning trend where people impersonate themselves as Muslims to spread hateful content, make threats, or commit crimes.
This trend has become a cause of concern as it is being used to spread communal hatred and hamper the societal structure of India.
- Heightened cultural sensitivity amongst Hindus
A man was beaten up by Sadhus at the Maha Kumbh Mela, 2025, for dressing up as a sheikh at the festival. The man, who is a social media influencer, dressed as a sheikh identifying himself as Sheikh Premanand at the festival, to film content. Not much later he caught the attention of Sadhus who found his attire and his behaviour as outrageous towards their religious feelings, and physically assaulted him. His actions were perceived by the Sadhus as offensive towards the holy place and the festival, as reported by Munsif News.
However, this incident raises severe concerns about the declining cultural sensitivities of Hindus, where a man’s attire was enough to be offended upon.
Is our faith in our religion so weak that a man dressed as a sheikh could shake it, and force us to take action against him to protect our religion from his clothes of a different religion?
- Hate Speech
Yati Narsinghanand, a right-wing Hindu priest, has caused an uproar after his recent statements regarding the Maha Kumbh. The priest added another thread to the Islamophobic narrative he has been weaving by making various hate speech comments in the past as well.
The priest said that “This might be the last Maha Kumbh Mela if the population of jihadists increases and they make India an Islamic nation. Even a single temple will not be left.” He further added that “Not just temples, if the number of jihadists increases there will not be a single woman left in your house nor my house.”
The 58–year old priest has faced various criminal cases and complaints for making communally charged statements under the Indian law for hate speech. Despite his Islamophobic and misogynistic comments, Yati Narsinghanand has been allowed to roam scot–free even after having been arrested multiple times, as reported by the Siasat Daily.
On January 21, 2025, two individuals including a journalist were arrested in U.P. for allegedly making offensive comments on Maha Kumbh on social media. The content of the two individuals offended the members of the Hindu community, which led the authorities to issue alerts and increase social media monitoring, as reported by Hindustan Times.
Kamran Alvi, a journalist, was arrested after his remarks were found offensive. SHO Alok Mani Tripathi stated that “The accused was promptly arrested, and a case was registered under section 299 (deliberate and malicious acts, intended to outrage religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion or religious beliefs) of the BNS Act for insulting religious symbols. He will be presented in the court.”
In a separate case, SHO Amit Pratap Singh stated that, “Abhishek Kumar, a resident of Boja village near Jaidpur, made objectionable remarks on social media about Hindu deities and the Maha Kumbh. A case has been registered and the accused arrested.”
Critics have pointed out the double–standards adopted by the Police in dealing with cases regarding hate speech. Individuals such as Yati Narsinghanand roam scot–free and remain outside the reach of law after making hateful comments, whereas reporters from minority communities or even the ones who report instances of hate speech are immediately arrested.
Plight of Sanitation Workers
The Maha Kumbh, 2025, which is expected to have more than 40 crore devotees take a dip in the holy Triveni Sangam, the confluence of Ganga, Yamuna and mythical Saraswati, is the largest ever religious gathering.
The expected footfall poses the significant challenge of sanitation and public health. The organisers have installed more than 1,50,000 temporary toilets across the campsite on the river banks, and more than 5,000 workers have been hired to clean those toilets nearly all of whom belong to the lower rung of the archaic and rigid societal hierarchy that divides Hindus based on their roles and functions in the community. As per the official data, 9 out of the 10 sanitation workers are from marginalized communities, majority of them being Dalit, also known as the “untouchables”, as reported by The Wire.
Cleaning a toilet piled with faecal matter, Suresh Valmiki, a sanitation worker said that “I clean and clean, but people make a mess of it in barely ten minutes.”
Five years ago, when the festival was held, Prime Minister Narendra Modi washed the feet of five sanitation workers. Many say that the move, which came 3 months before the general election, was an attempt to appeal to Hindu unity casting aside age-old caste differences in the Hindu society. However, not much has changed for the marginalised sanitation workers.
Pyare Lal, a sanitation worker employed at the Maha Kumbh said that “Now, this grand Maha Kumbh is being organised, there are so many ads of ‘luxurious Kumbh’ but did anything change for us sanitation workers.” He further added, “We have been watching ads for Tent City, but nothing has changed in our tents.” Pyare Lal lives in one corner of the Maha Kumbh in a make-shift tent with no proper supply of electricity or water.
As reported by The Print, several sanitation workers also complained that they applied for a house under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY), however, they have not heard anything back from the authorities, and find their futures bleak.
The jobs of sanitation workers have been made even more difficult as there are no water connections in the toilets, which has been done purposefully by the organisers to avoid the frequent suctioning of the septic tanks. As a result, the users must fill a bucket of water from a tap outside, and to avoid the same, the users carry bottles with them which they dump inside the toilet, increasing the work and difficulty for the cleaners.
A cleaner named Geeta Valmiki said, “People say it’s our job to clean the toilets, so why should they bother?”
The plight of the sanitation workers highlights the lackadaisical attitude of the Government regarding protecting the basic human rights and the right to dignity of the cleaners. Further, not proper awareness campaigns have been conducted by the Government for the devotees who are visiting the Maha Kumbh, regarding maintaining cleanliness and the usage of toilets to avoid the over–exploitation of cleaners.
Furthermore, the abysmally inadequate and insufficient pay provided to the sanitation workers is a matter of concern. The workers who are spending all their time cleaning up after others use the toilet facilities, are being paid a daily wage of less than Rs500.
All these concerns raise questions about the management of the Maha Kumbh Mela, 2025 and the unabashed disregard towards the violation of human rights of the sanitation workers.
Influencing Media Coverage
In December 2024, the publicity wing of the Uttar Pradesh government, published a letter directing how the reporters and journalists should cover the Maha Kumbh Mela, 2025 while praising the exemplary work done by the ruling government for the organisation of the event.
The festival presents itself as a great opportunity for the journalists to report on the celebrations, however, the U.P. government has made sure to spoon–feed the journalists as to how the festival should be reported and covered in news.
The letter contains 70 detailed themes that the reporters could potentially cover, along with directions to approach the stories and whom to interview for every particular story.
Shishir, the director of the information and public relations department of the Uttar Pradesh government, sent the document to editors in Lucknow, emphasizing the need to focus on the “pre–determined” themes as mentioned in the document.
As reported by The Wire, Shishir stated “As the Mahakumbh draws closer, various related topics of immediate relevance are likely to emerge. Alongside addressing such immediate concerns, our aim is to focus on the predetermined themes as well.”
This attempt by the government to thwart the journalists and reporters to report the festival based on their own perspectives and perception, and hampering the most fundamental element of the media, its freedom, is alarming.
Impact on Environment and Public Health
Kumbh Mela, which was recognized as an intangible cultural heritage of humanity by the United Nations, Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) in 2017, poses significant environmental and health risks that need to be mitigated.
While the World Health Organisation (WHO) has noted that due to increase in seasonal epidemics in respiratory influenza, the acute respiratory infections increase at this time of the year, along with the alert in India over the spread of the Human Metapneumovirus (HMPV), mass gatherings such as Maha Kumbh, may pose serious health risks.
An article published in Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease in 2024, available on the Researchgate website, stated that “The upcoming Kumbh Mela [2025], one of the largest religious gatherings globally, is expected to draw millions of pilgrims across India and beyond. While this event is deeply rooted in tradition and spirituality, it also presents significant public health challenges.”
Further, as per a study published by the Journal of Travel Medicine, it has been indicated that “acute respiratory infections, fever, skin disorders, diarrhoea and other infectious diseases like influenza, gastroenteritis, chickenpox, hepatitis etc can spread more easily during the Kumbh Mela because of the numerous religious events, cramped living quarters, and solid and liquid waste produced throughout the event.”
There have been various outbreaks of diseases and sporadic epidemics at the Kumbh Mela previously as well, such as in 1892, 1948, and in the 1960s, as per a report published by the International Journal of Infectious Diseases. The earliest documented record of such epidemics is the outbreak of Cholera in the year 1817.
It is also to be noted that the Kumbh Mela in 2021 had a huge impact of large gatherings which played a significant factor in the rise of COVID–19 cases.
As reported by LiveMint, Upper Mela Officer Vivek Chaturvedi has mentioned that continuous workshops are being conducted for the doctors and consultants so that they are fully equipped to handle any situation.
Further, the influx of millions of devotees has the potential to severely damage the ecological balance and harm the biodiversity. Fouling of rivers to a large number of bathers harms the aquatic ecosystem. Due to close proximity of a large number of people, the risk of water–borne diseases also drastically increases.
With millions of devotees expected to visit this year’s Maha Kumbh, the health and environmental risks are higher than ever, and would require constant monitoring and extensive efforts by the Government to mitigate the same.
Other issues with the management of Maha Kumbh
While the major challenges posed by the Maha Kumbh have been discussed, there are multiple other instances which reflect inefficient planning and management at the end of the Government.
- Stampede
In Uttar Pradesh’s Jhansi, as the devotees rushed to board a train at the Veerangana Laxmibai Railway Station, panic ensued due to a stampede. Officials reported that as the train was being repositioned, the devotees mistook the train’s movement for repositioning as departure and rushed to board the train, whereby two individuals narrowly escaped being run over by the train as reported by ETV Bharat. This incident that stemmed from a misunderstanding, led to chaos which could have claimed lives of multiple people present there.
This incident reflects the lack of vigilance and proper management of large crowds by the authorities which could have resulted in a tragic accident.
- Fire at the Kumbh Mela
In another incident, the tent city that has been set up by the Government to accommodate the visitors at the Maha Kumbh, became a centre of attention as a tragic fire consumed approximately 180 cottages, 70 to 80 huts, more than 10 tents, and goods worth crores. The fire began as a result of a gas cylinder leak in the Geeta Press Gorakhpur camp’s kitchen. Although there have been no casualties due to the fire, one individual suffered injuries while attempting to escape from the fire as reported by Financial Express. After the incident, the U.P. Government issued a fire safety advisory to all the camps at the Maha Kumbh Mela. The advisory consists of detailed important guidelines to be followed by individuals to avoid any such incidents in the future and for smooth functioning of the Maha Kumbh Mela.
However, it is pertinent to note here that potential of such incidents was not taken into account and the Government is attempting to address every challenge as it props up. Had such advisory and mandatory guidelines been issued beforehand, huge damages could have been prevented and the fire at the Maha Kumbh Mela could have been avoided.
- Use of Technology
The Government has efficiently employed technology and Artificial Intelligence (AI) for the better management of the Maha Kumbh. The Integrated Command and Control Centre (ICCC) which was originally built for Kumbh Mela – 2019, has been upgraded with latest technology to better manage and monitor the large volume of crowd expected at the festival. “Around 1,650 new CCTV cameras, 24 ANPR cameras, 40 VMCDs, 100 smart parking systems, and AI components for crown management and vehicle counting have been installed for Maha Kumbh, 2025,” as reported by the Times of India.
Crowd management and surveillance systems have been ramped up with AI controlled CCTV cameras. Pilgrims have been given Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) wristbands to ensure their safety and security. Predictive models have been used for better resource management. Internet of Things (IoT) has increased energy efficiency by optimizing electricity usage, enabling sensors in trash cans to notify when they need to be emptied, monitoring water quality of the river, etc. as reported by Boston Institute of Analytics.
With the use of technology and AI for management of Maha Kumbh, it becomes imperative to ask why such revolutionary technologies and methods are not used for crowd management and control in cases of any riots or public unrest? Why is such technology not used for better resource management in cases of natural disasters? The potential benefits of technology are vast and the same must be used by the Government in times of crisis for better management of situations.
Conclusion
The Maha Kumbh, 2025 holds special religious value for the devotees as it is celebrated once every 144 years. The festival promotes spirituality and the religious sentiments in devotees, as millions of people from the World gather to celebrate Maha Kumbh. While this is a remarkable cultural event, it poses various challenges that need to be addressed. The festival is being used by certain individuals to create communal disparity, and harm the social fabric of our society. While the sanitation workers are in a plight as their right to dignity is being violated and they are forced to work in inhumane conditions at less than subpar pay, the journalists and reporters face challenges as the most basic element of media, its freedom is being taken away. Various other instances also reflect the need for better management by the Government of the celebration. For Maha Kumbh to be truly successful, the government must ensure inclusivity, uphold human rights, address environmental and public health concerns, and prioritize effective planning and transparency to make it a celebration that truly honours its spiritual and cultural significance.