“The Division Bench of this court, under the order sought to be reviewed, has considered the locus of the applicant and also the fact of religious harmony in India. No new grounds are set up in review. The review cannot be entertained as an appeal in disguise,” the Bench led by the Chief Justice wrote, as provided by the report of the Hindu.

The bench also noted that the power of the High Court to review a judgment can only be exercised in cases where there is an apparent error in the record. The bench found that there was no said error in the judgment against which the review application was filed. “The jurisdiction of this court in review is in a narrow compass and can be exercised only upon an error apparent on the face of the record. There is no error apparent on the face of the record. In view of the above, the review application is dismissed.”

The current review plea had been filed against the order passed by a Division Bench of the High Court on April 17, 2023 wherein the court had taken exception to the petitioner, a resident of Tiruppur, objecting to the construction of a mosque in Chennai. In its order, the bench comprising the then Acting Chief Justice T. Raja and Justice Chakravarthy had observed that the petitioner had also not explained as to what harm would be caused by converting an Arabic college into a mosque.

“The petitioner has simply mentioned that there is a temple called Subbaiah Mutt Sivan temple nearby the place in question and if the Arabic college is converted into a mosque, there will be a public nuisance. In our considered opinion, the apprehension of the petitioner is unfounded,” the Bench led by the then ACJ had said, as per the report of the Hindu.

The bench led by the then ACJ had further emphasized upon religious harmony, an idea supported and encouraged by the Constitution of India.

The bench had stated: “The Constitution of India supports and encourages religious harmony. Probably, the petitioner is unaware of the fact that in Karaikal, inside the Arulmighu Angala Parameswari Temple, a Muslim Saint, by the name of Mutthalu Ravuthar, was buried and people belonging to both communities worship both the deity as well as the Dargah by lighting lamps or incense sticks, as the case may be. When there is such religious harmony in diversity in this land, we do not find any substance in the apprehension of the petitioner that riots may occur if the college is used as a mosque.”

Notably, while dismissing the writ petition, the Bench had also directed the petitioner to pay costs of ₹25,000 to the Madras High Court Advocate Clerks Welfare Association.

Related:

As the ruling party peddles hate, the people of Assam live in harmony and hope

India revels in Durga-Pooja with zest, harmony overrides the hate

India’s Struggle for Social Harmony: Challenges Amidst Surge in Hate Speech

Haryana’s farmers’ Mahapanchayat: Fostering unity across communities, vowing for communal harmony

The post Madras HC: Review plea against judgment hailing religious harmony dismissed appeared first on SabrangIndia.

Most architecture needs to withstand a few hundred years before it can be known for any particular significance. However, a humble ‘welcome’ arch in the Kuniya region of Kasaragod district in Kerala is to receive a glowing inauguration on Republic Day for its secular origins, the arch is merely 20 years old.

The arch, constructed on a road connecting to National Highway 66, marks the entry way to two religious places in the area – the Bilal Masjid and the Mahavishnu Temple, known locally as the Urulamkodi temple.)

“The arch was built only 20 years ago by the Bilal Masjid committee. However, members asked the construction workers to include the name of the nearby temple as well. This they did without consulting the temple people,” Urulamkodi temple committee member Akash Kunhiraman told SabrangIndia.

Kunhiraman, who was walking to the police station on January 23, 2021 for finalising the inaugural event was happy for the “secular symbol” and the feeling of good-will in the committee. He praised the local people for their secular attitude that was free of any communal bias.

“I was in Mumbai on December 6, 1992 when the Bombay riots started. I remember I was at the hospital when the doctor told me what had happened. I used to live with a Muslim at the time. But when I came here, I saw that the people were completely unaffected by any such incidents. Even the Ayodhya and Babri Masjid incidents did not phase them,” he said.

The bonds between the two communities further strengthened when temple official K Narayanan Vaniyan Vallappy (now arch committee Convener) met with masjid khateeb Abdul Khader Shahid (now arch committee Chairman) and offered to pitch in for the renovation of the welcome arch that showed an ‘Om’ symbol on one side and the ‘crescent and moon’ symbol on the other side. The two groups thus agreed to pitch in Rs. 2.5 lakh each to have the monument ready by January 26.

It may be noted that the temple authorities did not require a sign for their entryway since locals claim the Mahavishnu temple is over 15,000 years old. However, touched by the generosity shown by Masjid committee members two decades ago, they decided to show a sense of camaraderie.

However, according to local visitor and close friend of masjid officials Hassan K. A., the two religious institutions have always pitched in to amplify any sort of event or celebration.

During Hindu events, the temple folk take out processions while the Masjid priests stand along the path to offer water, food and similar relief to people. Similarly, Hindu priests visit the Masjid during important Islamic events to support their religion.

“Even during coronavirus lockdown, the two communities did not face any difficulties. Both sides followed due protocol and both communities received equal ration from state government authorities,” said Hassan.

Kuniya’s residents were not even aware of the atrocities faced by Muslim communities in northern and central India owing to the Tablighi Jamaat incident in 2020.

“If you come here, you will see that children here do not even know of such communal differences. There has never been any need for police intervention when it came to interaction between any religious communities,” said Kunhiraman.

The town is not completely free of religious restrictions as the area is still divided in a Muslim area and a Hindu area. Moreover, the region has also not witnessed many inter-religious marriages. Yet, the various groups do not harbour any ill-will towards each other and intend to celebrate Republic day on a positive note of celebrating secularity.

When asked what people in Kuniya thought about the communal tensions seen in other parts of the country, the temple officials said, “We think people should once again live together peacefully as we did in the past.”

Related:

How the Covid-19 pandemic was communalised: Report by Bebaak Collective

Why The Incarceration Of Munawar Faruqui Should Worry Us

Festivals: Occasions for spreading communal harmony in India

Dharma and humanity are like our two eyes: The secular philosophy of Jhansi

The post Kerala prepares a token of religious harmony for Republic Day appeared first on SabrangIndia.