In focus | SabrangIndia News Related to Human Rights Tue, 17 Nov 2026 07:05:26 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png In focus | SabrangIndia 32 32 AMUSU Elections: Cheers & caution, from a faculty member https://sabrangindia.in/amusu-elections-cheers-caution-from-a-faculty-member/ Tue, 17 Nov 2026 07:05:26 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50134 A senior professor of history, also a sound critique of malpractice gives the losers and winners in the recent polls a shout out

The post AMUSU Elections: Cheers & caution, from a faculty member appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
15 Nov 2026 was a significant day for the AMU students. It was a day of installation (comparable with oath-taking ceremony) of their Union, something earned through the challenge of agitations: they have studied without this for eight long years.

During the electoral campaigns they raised certain issues. Ugliest realities of most disgusting financial and administrative irregularities, and the nastier issues of narcotics and sex-rackets, prevailing in today’s Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) were also were raised. Some of these issues were raised less prominently.

Oratory with a hollow rhetoric, embellished with sugar-coated obfuscations in “maulviyana” Urdu almost always yields better electoral dividends here. Which is why, at AMU, rhetoric triumphs over concrete issues and grievance. Generation after generation of ‘Aligs’ have become been ace players at the game of playing to sentiments generated from external (majoritarian) threats to cover up the internal rot! Today’s winners and losers must see through these cunning games of the “Kutchehry Milieu”!

In a recent column (“She Is Risen: Jamia’s Student Union Claws Her Way Out Of The Grave”, Nov 7, 2026) on the recent Jamia Milia Islamia (JMI) student agitation, Mouli Sharma has expressed scepticism on whether even the JMI administration will fulfil its commitment of having elections for JMISU in July-August 2027. It will most likely see the emergence and assertion of Muslim conservative and fundamentalist forces, she writes.

Be that as it may, the winners as well as the losers in the AMUSU elections in November 2026 have displayed something which perhaps promises a happy scenario for the campus youth in the days to come. The slackening (or, co-opted?) winners appear to have got an informed, assertive, vigilant opposition in the form of the losers. It was them who turned out to be the actual winners, at least yesterday. Arguably, this is unprecedented. In AMU.

Together, all these brave-hearts, overcoming fear and suppression in recent years, spoke out loudly, assertively (a bit impertinently too) roasting the most powerful exploiters of their university. They spoke out their hearts about the egregious nepotism, and hellish prevalence of the clouts of a handful of (disgusting) teachers continuing perennially in administrative positions and abusing the drivers/vehicles/security-men besides looting AMU fund by defalcating fee, and various other kinds of irregularities.

“Wilful” loss of AMU lands in other’s hands is one of their top concerns. At the moment, they are displaying their priorities of agitations in a manner which puts all varieties of teachers’ representatives to great shame. The most powerful of functionaries were held to account in the election debates that generated heat. Issues flagged included nepotism. Contesting students faced those in positions – the functionaries– eye to eye. They were bold and brave, hence, beautiful.

More important than that, if these so called “losers” in the November 5, 2026 elections keep a strong and vociferous vigil –echoing the vocal electoral campaign that they fostered from the Athletics Ground on November 15, 2026, they will be remembered. Remembered as the actual winners, eventually, of the 2026 student elections.

A few words on the so-called impertinence of the language in which they spoke their hearts out.

Well, if at all one admits to this, let all of us, the teachers at AMU, confess to our collective failure. We didn’t teach our students better, did not impart more refined ways of expressing their grievances. In fact, the criminal silence (or grossly inadequate voice) of the teachers and of the teachers’ representatives, on all these irregularities testify to the fact that these students are way ahead of the teachers, in terms of their political and moral conduct.

We the teachers are more sympathetic to the oppressive plunderers called the clouts (students refer to them as, LOBBY) than to the AMU. This is what keeps us silent, or at the most, keeps us confined to selective outrage.

Well done AMU students! Proud of you all.

Keep a close watch upon the ongoing audit from the Comptroller Auditor General of India (CAG) of India as also to a series of complaints submitted to the University Grants Commission (UGC), Union Ministry of Education, Visitor (President of India). Keep a sharp look out to also information obtained under the Right to Information (RTI). The Fee-scamsters, the fund-looters, the nepotists, the illegal beneficiaries, among us operating as teacher-administrators or as teachers’ representatives must not go un-punished.

I, for one, today share a mix of hope and cynicism. Hope that the bright, young, energetic students (Bulbuls) of AMU (Chaman) will do something significant. Cynicism that many of you will ape your teachers and will eventually get co-opted and (as corrupted as to become co-sharers in the loot/irregularities.

Hai nā-ummīdī kā ye taqāzā ki rāste hī meñ baiTh jā.eñ

Magar hai ye ek savāl nāzuk ki baiTh jāne se kyā milegā

(Saghar Nizami, 1905-1984)


(The author is
s an associate professor at the Aligarh Muslim University-AMU)


Related:

Closing of the Indian Mind: Campus subjugation, intellectual mediocrity, & death of democratic assertion

The AMU Teachers’ Association (AMUTA) and Waqf Worries: Ordinary members of the Qaum are caught between a self-serving elite and a majoritarian Regime

Political History of India’s Two Muslim Universities since 1947

The post AMUSU Elections: Cheers & caution, from a faculty member appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Only 21% of eligible women receive maternity benefits amid digital barriers and debt traps: Survey https://sabrangindia.in/only-21-of-eligible-women-receive-maternity-benefits-amid-digital-barriers-and-debt-traps-survey/ Tue, 17 Nov 2026 06:03:25 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50125 Despite being a statutory legal right under the National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013, maternity entitlements remain out of reach for the vast majority of Indian women, with only 21% of eligible beneficiaries receiving any financial assistance under the Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana (PMMVY). This stark reality is revealed in a comprehensive national survey […]

The post Only 21% of eligible women receive maternity benefits amid digital barriers and debt traps: Survey appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Despite being a statutory legal right under the National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013, maternity entitlements remain out of reach for the vast majority of Indian women, with only 21% of eligible beneficiaries receiving any financial assistance under the Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana (PMMVY).

This stark reality is revealed in a comprehensive national survey released by the Right to Food Campaign, which exposes a deep chasm between legislative intent and ground-level implementation, exacerbated by stringent digital barriers, administrative delays, and crippling out-of-pocket healthcare costs.

The survey, conducted between July and August 2026, assessed 2,849 women across 12 states who gave birth after January 2025. An additional survey of 88 frontline workers (Anganwadi, ASHA, and ANM staff) in Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh highlighted the systemic bottlenecks plaguing the scheme’s delivery.

The Coverage Gap: High Registration, Low Realization

The study highlights a massive drop-off between pregnancy registration and actual financial support. While 92% of the 2,580 eligible women surveyed registered their pregnancies at Anganwadi centres, and 49% formally applied for PMMVY, a mere 21% received any payment. Even among those who successfully navigated the application process, only 39% received funds.

The delays are severe. For women whose first child was between 13 and 24 months old—by which time both instalments should have been disbursed—only 30% had received any money. Furthermore, of those who were paid, less than half (46%) received their full entitlement.

“Accessing maternity benefits should not depend on a woman’s awareness of the scheme or her ability to apply,” the report notes, pointing out that 49% of non-applicants were simply unaware of PMMVY, and 34% reported that no ASHA worker had visited them to register their pregnancy.

The Digital Divide: Aadhaar and OTP Exclusion

A major culprit behind the low realization rates is the scheme’s heavy reliance on digital verification. While 98% of women possessed an Aadhaar card and 92% had a bank account, these documents frequently acted as barriers rather than bridges.

The survey found that 56% of women had neither their Aadhaar nor their bank account linked to their own mobile phone, forcing them to rely on family members—often husbands—to receive crucial OTPs. Consequently, independent access to the application process is heavily compromised.

Name mismatches post-marriage also proved disastrous. Approximately 17% of married women lacked updated Aadhaar details reflecting their married names. The impact was stark: payment success dropped from 46% for women with updated Aadhaar details to just 25% for those with outdated information. This issue was particularly acute in Bihar (56%), Uttar Pradesh (34%), and Gujarat (29%).

Pushed into Debt: The High Cost of Childbirth

The failure to disburse the ₹5,000 to ₹6,000 entitlement in a timely manner has pushed vulnerable households into debt. The NFSA mandates a minimum of ₹6,000 for all births, but PMMVY restricts this largely to the first child, an amount that has remained frozen since 2017 despite soaring inflation.

Meanwhile, the cost of childbirth remains exorbitant. Although 69% of women delivered in public hospitals, 81% incurred out-of-pocket expenses, with a median cost of ₹3,000. For the 25% who delivered in private hospitals, the median expenditure skyrocketed to ₹25,000.

Consequently, 23% of all surveyed women were forced to borrow money to cover delivery costs. For those delivering in private hospitals, this figure rose to a staggering 42%.

Frontline Workers Bear the Brunt

The bureaucratic maze not only excludes beneficiaries but also alienates the frontline workers tasked with implementing the scheme. Anganwadi Workers, ASHAs, and ANMs reported massive operational hurdles, with 55% citing bank account issues, 53% pointing to un-updated Aadhaar details, and nearly a third facing OTP and server downtime problems.

Compounding their frustration is the government’s failure to pay their incentives. Of the 88 workers surveyed, only 15 received their PMMVY incentives on time, while 17 received nothing at all.

This financial delay has severely eroded community trust. “People look at us with suspicion and say that the money must have come and we have all eaten it,” an Anganwadi Worker from Uttar Pradesh told surveyors.

Budget Underutilization and Grievance Failures

The survey’s findings are corroborated by government data. The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education, Women, Children, Youth and Sports recently highlighted severe underutilization of PMMVY funds. For the financial year 2024-25, against a Budget Estimate of ₹2,067 crore, actual expenditure stood at a mere ₹384.36 crore.

When things go wrong, women have virtually no recourse. Only 19% of women were aware of any grievance redress mechanism. Among the 319 women who did file complaints, 42% reported that no action was taken, and a meager 5% saw their issues resolved.

Demands for a Rights-Based Approach

Concluding that the barriers to maternity entitlements are “interconnected and structural,” the Right to Food Campaign has issued a stringent set of demands to the Union and State Governments:

  1. Universalize Entitlements: Remove age and child-number restrictions. Every pregnant woman must receive benefits for all births.
  2. Revise and Index Amounts: Increase the benefit amount to reflect actual wage loss and inflation, ending the freeze on the 2017 rates.
  3. End Digital Exclusion: Abolish mandatory Aadhaar, OTP, and eKYC requirements that disproportionately exclude marginalized women.
  4. Guarantee Timely Payments & Grievance Redress: Establish strict timelines for disbursements and create dedicated, time-bound help desks at the block level.
  5. Support Frontline Workers: Ensure timely payment and revision of incentives for ASHA and Anganwadi workers.
  6. Ensure Free Public Delivery: Implement strict monitoring to eliminate hidden out-of-pocket costs in government hospitals.

“Maternity entitlements are not a matter of charity or government discretion. They are a legal right,” the report asserts. “Every woman must be able to access this right with dignity, without discrimination and without exclusion.”

As the government faces mounting pressure to address these systemic failures, the survey serves as a stark reminder that until the digital and administrative walls are torn down, the promise of the NFSA will remain a broken pledge for millions of India’s mothers.

Courtesy: CounterView

The post Only 21% of eligible women receive maternity benefits amid digital barriers and debt traps: Survey appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP https://sabrangindia.in/chinas-medog-dam-indias-siang-project-could-multiply-disaster-risks-warns-sandrp/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 04:34:25 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50105 A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people […]

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.

The report, titled “The Riskiest Place to Dam a River: Medog, SUMP and the Untamed Yarlung Tsangpo Gorge”, has been authored by Parineeta Dandekar with Chintan Sheth. It argues that the combination of seismic activity, landslides, glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), extreme sediment flows and climate change makes the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge an exceptionally hazardous location for large hydropower infrastructure.

The report comes amid growing opposition in Arunachal Pradesh to the proposed SUMP, which the state government has presented as a strategic response to China’s Medog project on the Yarlung Tsangpo, known as the Siang after it enters India and the Brahmaputra further downstream.

According to the report, China’s Medog project, described as the world’s largest hydropower project, is expected to have an installed capacity of approximately 60,000 MW. However, Beijing has not made public essential details concerning the project’s precise locations, reservoir capacities, water discharge arrangements and operational objectives.

The report says that the lack of transparency is particularly concerning because the project is located close to India’s border and could have significant implications for downstream regions in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

It notes that China’s proposed project is being promoted on grounds of national security, energy production, ecological considerations and international cooperation, but the absence of reliable technical information makes it difficult for downstream countries to assess its potential consequences.

Against this backdrop, Arunachal Pradesh is advancing the proposed 11,000 MW SUMP, which Chief Minister Pema Khandu has described as a water-defence project. The proposed project is expected to involve a dam approximately 280-300 metres high, with a reservoir capacity of 9-10 billion cubic metres.

However, the report questions whether constructing another massive dam downstream is an appropriate response to the risks associated with China’s project.

It points out that the proposed SUMP could completely submerge 27 Adi tribal villages and partially affect another 40-45 villages. Thousands of orange and pineapple farms and traditional wet-rice terraces could also be affected, while more than 100,000 indigenous people could face displacement or loss of livelihoods and land.

The report describes the opposition of indigenous communities as a struggle over their land, livelihoods and future, arguing that the concerns of the Adi people cannot be overlooked in the pursuit of strategic and hydropower objectives.

Beyond the geopolitical concerns, the report identifies the geographical and geological characteristics of the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge as a major reason for questioning both projects.

The gorge, located around the Namcha Barwa or Eastern Himalayan Syntaxis, is among the deepest river gorges in the world. The river makes a dramatic horseshoe-shaped turn around Namcha Barwa before entering India, descending approximately 2,000 metres over a relatively short stretch.

According to the report, this region experiences some of the world’s highest rates of tectonic uplift, rock erosion and river sediment transport. It is also highly vulnerable to earthquakes, landslides, avalanches and glacial lake outburst floods.

The report cites the 1950 Assam earthquake, which measured 8.6 on the Richter scale, as evidence of the region’s seismic vulnerability. It also refers to research documenting more than 200 earthquakes of magnitude above four between 1950 and 2018 in the gorge region.

The sediment carried by the river is another major concern. According to the report, hydrological measurements show that the Yarlung Tsangpo carries approximately 15-30 million tonnes of sediment annually at Nuxia/Pai on the Tibetan plateau. By the time it reaches Pasighat in Arunachal Pradesh, the annual sediment load rises to approximately 210-250 million tonnes.

Studies cited in the report estimate that 61-74 per cent of the sediment reaching Pasighat originates from the relatively small gorge region. Although this area constitutes less than three per cent of the Brahmaputra basin, it contributes approximately 45 per cent of the sediment reaching Bangladesh through the river system.

The report warns that large storage dams could substantially alter this natural sediment movement. Such dams can trap most of the sediment flowing into their reservoirs, affecting downstream river ecology, agriculture and the stability of river channels.

It cites the example of the Tehri Dam, which reportedly retains approximately 95 per cent of the sediment it receives.

If the proposed SUMP traps large quantities of sediment arriving from upstream, its reservoir capacity and ability to accommodate floodwaters could progressively decline. The report also warns that reduced sediment flows downstream could increase riverbank erosion and affect communities dependent on the river’s natural sediment supply.

The report further draws attention to a series of major landslides and river-blocking incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge, demonstrating the scale of natural hazards that could affect projects in the region.

One of the most significant incidents occurred in 2000, when a massive landslide in the Yigong-Parlung Tsangpo valley blocked a tributary, creating a natural dam. The resulting lake eventually breached in June that year, sending floodwaters downstream into Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

The report recalls that the flood swept away forest areas and several bridges. It cites accounts of approximately 30 deaths and destruction affecting more than 50 villages in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

Another major series of incidents occurred in 2017, when landslides and rock-ice collapses in the Sedongpu valley partially blocked the Yarlung Tsangpo. The Siang river in India subsequently turned into a dark, muddy flow, affecting fish and local drinking-water infrastructure.

In October 2018, two successive rock-and-ice avalanches completely blocked the main river channel, creating temporary barrier lakes. The resulting changes in water levels affected downstream flows in Arunachal Pradesh before the blockages were breached and surges of water and debris moved towards Assam.

A further major rock-and-ice collapse in March 2021 again blocked the river.

The report says these incidents demonstrate how landslides, glacier collapses, river blockages and sudden floods can combine to create disasters across international boundaries.

It also highlights the impact of climate change, noting that the Tibetan plateau is warming at approximately twice the global average rate. Rising temperatures are accelerating glacier retreat and permafrost degradation, increasing the potential for landslides, avalanches, glacial lake outburst floods and extreme river flows.

The authors warn that these developments could make the region increasingly unpredictable for large hydropower projects.

A major concern raised in the report is the absence of an effective mechanism for sharing hydrological and disaster-related information between China and India.

The existing memorandum of understanding on hydrological data sharing between the two countries expired in June 2023 and has not been formally renewed. Although China agreed in principle in 2025 to share information on a limited emergency and humanitarian basis, the report says that a reliable institutional arrangement is still lacking.

It recalls that during the 2017 Doklam standoff, China withheld hydrological information on the Brahmaputra and Sutlej rivers for the entire flood season. It also points to the lack of advance warnings during several major landslide-related incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo basin.

The authors argue that the absence of reliable information-sharing arrangements, combined with the possibility of sudden dam releases and natural river blockages, could significantly increase the risks for downstream communities.

The report also questions the flood-control rationale of SUMP. It argues that a large storage reservoir intended to generate electricity would need to retain water and therefore could not remain empty at all times to accommodate sudden floods originating upstream.

If the reservoir’s capacity to absorb floodwaters is reduced by sediment accumulation, the consequences of an upstream disaster could be particularly serious.

According to the report, the proposed SUMP could face extreme flows resulting from upstream dam releases, heavy precipitation or natural disasters. If the reservoir loses a substantial part of its flood-storage capacity because of sediment accumulation, its ability to perform its intended flood-control function could be compromised.

The authors conclude that China’s Medog project poses a serious geopolitical and environmental challenge, particularly because of Beijing’s lack of transparency. However, they argue that India’s decision to construct a massive storage dam downstream could create an additional and potentially permanent vulnerability.

“India is responding to an external upstream hazard by building a permanent domestic structural vulnerability,” the report states.

It adds that the risks associated with SUMP cannot be adequately addressed simply by presenting it as a strategic response to China’s project.

The report calls for China to disclose essential technical information about the Medog project and share it with India and Bangladesh. It also recommends a trilateral basin consultation and a joint transboundary environmental impact assessment involving the countries affected by developments on the river.

Among its other recommendations, the report calls for India to establish an independent earth-observation and early-warning system for the Yarlung Tsangpo basin, using satellite capabilities to monitor landslides, seismic activity, glacial changes and potential river blockages.

It also recommends installing monitoring systems along the border at Gelling, Bishing and Tuting, alongside satellite-based surveillance and scientifically reviewed assessments of geological and hydrological risks.

Equally important, the authors emphasise that the concerns of indigenous communities in Arunachal Pradesh must be taken seriously before proceeding with the proposed SUMP.

The report concludes that the combination of geological instability, climate change, inadequate information-sharing arrangements and the absence of effective disaster-warning mechanisms makes the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang region one of the most dangerous locations in the world for constructing mega hydropower projects.

It says that the risks associated with the proposed Indian project could outweigh its promised benefits, particularly when the potential consequences for downstream communities, river ecosystems and livelihoods are taken into account.

Courtesy: CounterView

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying https://sabrangindia.in/the-bitter-cost-of-the-brew-why-mothers-in-assams-tea-gardens-are-still-dying/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 07:51:19 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50101 Every morning, as the mist lifts over the emerald hills of Assam, thousands of women bend over tea bushes, their fingers moving in a blur to pluck the “two leaves and a bud.” They produce more than half of India’s tea, a beverage savored in drawing rooms across the globe. Yet, in the cramped, damp […]

The post The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Every morning, as the mist lifts over the emerald hills of Assam, thousands of women bend over tea bushes, their fingers moving in a blur to pluck the “two leaves and a bud.” They produce more than half of India’s tea, a beverage savored in drawing rooms across the globe. Yet, in the cramped, damp labor lines where these women return at dusk, a quiet tragedy continues to unfold.

For decades, Assam has recorded some of the highest maternal mortality ratios (MMR) in the country, as documented in the special bulletins of the Sample Registration System (SRS). While the state’s overall numbers have improved over the last twenty years, this progress has not trickled down to the tea estates. Here, among the Adivasi communities—descendants of workers brought from central and eastern India in the 19th century to clear land and pluck leaf—mothers are still dying from entirely preventable causes.

When a woman from the labor lines dies in pregnancy or childbirth, the death certificate will list a medical cause. But the true culprits are rarely just medical. They are social, economic, and systemic.

The Silent Killer Beneath the Surface

The immediate medical causes of these deaths are familiar to obstetricians worldwide: postpartum hemorrhage, high blood pressure disorders like pre-eclampsia, infections, and obstructed labor. The World Health Organization notes that most of these are highly preventable.

But in the tea gardens, these acute crises are built upon a chronic foundation: severe anemia.

The National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) found that around two-thirds of women aged 15 to 49 in Assam are anemic, with the numbers even higher among pregnant women. Studies from tea-growing districts reveal the problem is acutely worse among garden workers. Their diets are notoriously low in iron and protein. Worm infestations and malaria compound the blood loss, and the grueling physical work of plucking continues late into pregnancy.

Simply put, an anemic woman has no physiological reserve. The blood loss that a healthy mother’s body would easily survive can be fatal to hers.

This physical vulnerability is compounded by early and closely spaced pregnancies. NFHS-5 shows that child marriage before 18 and teenage childbearing are more common in Assam than the national average. A girl who conceives at 16 or 17, already thin and anemic, and then has a second child within two years, enters each labor weaker than the last.

The Gauntlet of the “Three Delays”

In public health, maternal deaths are analyzed through the “Three Delays” model. In the tea gardens, these delays are not just bureaucratic hurdles; they are a physical gauntlet that can claim a life in a single night.

The first delay begins at home. Danger signs—swelling, severe headaches, fits, or bleeding—may not be recognized as emergencies by the family. Furthermore, a day away from the bushes is a day without wages for the woman, or for the family member who must accompany her. The decision to seek care often rests with a husband or mother-in-law, and the hesitation costs precious time.

The second delay is one of distance. Many estates are located far from a hospital equipped to perform a caesarean section or administer a blood transfusion. The roads inside and around the gardens are poor, turning into impassable slush during the monsoon. An ambulance called in the middle of the night may take hours to navigate the terrain.

The third delay is the hardest to accept, as it happens inside the healthcare system itself. A woman may finally reach a facility, only to find no obstetrician, no anesthetist, or no blood on the shelves. She is referred onward, sometimes more than once, losing time she simply does not have.

Patches on a Torn Fabric

It would be unfair to say Assam is standing still. The proportion of women delivering in hospitals and health centers has risen sharply since the inception of the National Health Mission (NHM). ASHAs (Accredited Social Health Activists), including those specifically appointed for tea-garden areas, are the unsung heroes of this shift. They register pregnancies early, accompany women to check-ups, and are often the first to notice when something is wrong. Free ambulance services and free delivery care under central schemes have removed some of the financial barriers that kept families at home.

The state has also targeted the gardens directly. Mobile medical units visit the estates, and some garden hospitals have been upgraded through partnerships with the health mission. A wage compensation scheme for pregnant women in tea gardens pays them to rest and eat better before and after delivery, conditional on attending check-ups and delivering in a facility. Anemia testing and iron-folic acid supplements are now part of routine antenatal care.

These interventions are lifelines. But they are not reaching everyone equally.

Beyond the Clinic: What Must Change

To truly protect these women, we must look beyond the delivery room.

First, the Plantations Labour Act of 1951 mandates that estates provide medical facilities for workers and their families. On the ground, compliance varies wildly. Some garden hospitals boast doctors, nurses, and functioning labor rooms; others are little more than empty buildings. The government and the tea industry must agree, estate by estate, on clear responsibilities. Inspections must be regular, and their findings made public.

Second, blood must be closer to the bushes. Establishing and maintaining fully staffed, well-stocked blood storage units at first-referral hospitals in the tea districts would save more lives than almost any other single intervention.

Third, we must treat the girl before she becomes a mother. Anemia must be found and treated long before labor begins, starting in adolescence. Handing out iron tablets is useless if no one checks whether they are being taken, or if the patient isn’t tested again. Furthermore, girls need to stay in school and marry later. Couples need reliable access to contraception so that pregnancies can be safely spaced.

Fourth, every maternal death must be reviewed honestly. These audits should be conducted to find out where the system failed, not to assign blame to the family or the ASHA.

Finally, we must mandate respectful care. A woman who is shouted at, ignored, or made to wait on the floor will not return, and she will tell her neighbors not to go either. Care delivered in a language the woman understands, by staff who treat her with basic human dignity, is not a luxury. It is a medical necessity.

A Legacy Worth Saving

For over 150 years, the women of Assam’s tea gardens have carried a massive industry on their backs. That they still face a significantly higher risk of dying in childbirth than most Indian women is a profound failure of policy and attention. But it is a failure that can be corrected. It is time the system that relies on their labor ensures their survival.

—

Dr. Bhimi Daimari, MBBS, MS (Obstetrics and Gynaecology), is an obstetrician-gynaecologist from Assam. Click here about the author

Courtesy: CounterView

The post The bitter cost of the brew: Why mothers in Assam’s tea gardens are still dying appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence https://sabrangindia.in/srfti-under-siege-alifa-demands-vcs-removal-independent-inquiry-into-campus-violence/ Sat, 14 Nov 2026 05:04:26 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50098 13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for […]

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
13th Nov, 2026: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA) expresses immense concern at the disturbing developments on the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI-Kolkata) campus since late September. We note with shock and alarm that the protesting students have been facing escalating threats from the institute administration and the police. We support the legitimate demands for a free and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September; prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones, recall of rustication orders, withdrawal of orders enforcing academic closure, removal of police presence on campus, a full-time Vice Chancellor for the institute and protection of the right to protest peacefully. 

For 40 days now, the SRFTI campus has been under a siege-like situation, with increasing police presence, and academic activity suspended till 11th December, 2026. The circumstances have placed students under immense stress, with women and transgender students at the receiving end of sexual harassment and trauma. This is on top of the expulsion of six students on the 15th October, for a year, on trumped-up charges. Two contractual faculty members and six resource persons were also suspended on 5th November for the ‘crime’ of standing with their students. Over the past month, life in SRFTI has come to a grinding halt, with the administration hell-bent on treating students as criminals. 

Resistance to Right-Wing Event and Repression at SRFTI

 On 27th September, an event was organised by the RSS-affiliated Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat (ABGP) in the Main Theatre, without a discussion with the student body. The usual convention has been a prior discussion with the student body, before letting the Main Theatre out for any purpose. When students protested the same, they were chased and beaten up by outsiders. Library staff and faculty members were also hurt. The attacks on the students included targeted harassment of female and transgender students, who were sexually harassed and verbally abused, including being given rape threats.

Female students report being made uncomfortable by the event organisers, even before the altercation began, including an incident where they had interrupted a shoot on campus. Furthermore, a rowdy mob had pelted stones on campus, calling students ‘terrorists’ and ‘anti-nationals’. Their ambulance was attacked. It is also painful to note that two students needed extensive plastic surgery, as a result of this mindless violence. Since then, the administration headed by Mr. Santosh Ajmera, Vice-Chancellor has taken one draconian step after the other.

On 4th October, a rally organised by the Bangiya Hindu Jagaran Mancha reached the gates of the institution and injured students again by pelting stones and bottles from outside the gates. The administration failed to name the organisation in their police complaint! Between 5th – 7th October, students protesting peacefully were physically confronted by the institute’s staff and threatened with ‘career destruction’. The administration’s methods became even more heavy-handed from 12th October when the students began an indefinite sit-in demanding the removal of the Vice-Chancellor. On 15th October, the administration installed CCTVs on campus without prior intimation to the students. This happened despite a 2024 pact between the students and the administration, where the administration after a discussion with the Student Union had assured that any CCTV installation and placement will only be done after consultation with student representatives and the department concerned where the CCTV was being installed. Students have expressed extreme discomfort with Mr. Munshi, the Chief Security Officer and his subordinates having access to CCTV footage. This is especially in the light of numerous complaints lodged against Mr. Munshi by female staff in the past, which the administration had not taken any cognizance of.

Notably, the current Vice-Chancellor (VC) made an oral promise to offer 3-days’ notice to the students before the installation of any CCTV; a promise that the students have on record. This was rescinded on the grounds of the alleged vandalization of his office on 14th October, along with the manhandling of the VC. Campus security has denied the occurrence of any such vandalization to the police. The Vice-Chancellor, has also rusticated six students for a year, on allegations of ‘misdemeanour’ with no specific charges but identical, cyclostyled orders! In yet another repressive measure, on 5th November, even as the city was gearing up for Deepavali and Kali Pujo celebrations, the administration suspended two contractual faculty members, six resource persons, who merely stood in solidarity and extended academic closure till 11th December!

The increased police surveillance on campus and outside has given rise to a siege-like situation. Students protesting peacefully have been constantly monitored and photographed. The Vice-Chancellor has hired bouncers for his ‘personal security’, who have been seen going towards the hostel premises that should be out-of-bounds for outsiders. This places students at grave personal risk on campus and hostels, which the administration seems to be oblivious to. Barricades have been set up around the campus, with police officers taking regular photographs and also entering into altercations with students. Reportedly, a young female student was also ‘grilled’ by the police for having the ‘temerity’ to step out for a cup of tea!

Reclaiming SRFTI from the Clutches of the Regressive Administration:

It is indeed tragic and unacceptable that a premier institution like the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute is being converted into a fortress and another ground for the right-wing take over of educational and learning spaces. It has also become abundantly evident that the current VC, Mr. Santosh Ajmera, a PIB official with a history of derogatory comments towards women on X (such as actress Rani Mukherjee), is utterly incapable of managing an institute of learning and is determined to treat students as criminals, going all the way to hire personal bouncers; while neglecting the security, physical and mental health of the students, not to mention their careers and futures.

We therefore support all the legitimate demands of the students, including: 

  1. Fair and independent inquiry into the violence on 27th September, 2026.
  2. Prosecution of the attackers including those who sexually harassed women and transgender students and pelted stones.
  3. Fair and independent inquiry into the alleged violence on the VC on 14th October.
  4. Immediate recall of rustication orders of students.
  5. Complete recall of orders enforcing academic closure until 11th December.
  6. Review of CCTV cameras and hearing students’ concerns regarding Mr. Munshi’s past misconduct.
  7. Immediate withdrawal of suspension of two contractual faculty members and six resource persons.
  8. Immediate removal of the Vice-Chancellor’s personal bouncers from campus, with a review of his own conduct in putting the security of students at risk.
  9. A full-time competent Vice Chancellor, who truly upholds the values and spirit of SRFTI.
  10. Removal of police presence on campus and safeguarding the right to protest peacefully.

A film school is a place of practice and study. It is a matter of great shame that Mr. Santosh Ajmera and his administration have subjected students to extreme trauma, throughout the festive season, while operating with complete impunity. We stand in full solidarity with progressive students and faculty of SRFTI, in reclaiming their campus in true spirit of freedom and creativity.

Issued by: All-India Feminist Alliance (ALIFA – NAPM)          

Contact: narivadinapm@gmail.com

Courtesy: https://countercurrents.org/

The post SRFTI Under Siege: ALIFA Demands VC’s Removal, Independent Inquiry into Campus Violence appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? https://sabrangindia.in/health-why-do-women-in-india-still-carry-the-burden-of-sterilisation/ Fri, 13 Nov 2026 12:38:44 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50089 Exploring the inherent patriarchal attitudes that govern Indian government policies on family planning, the author, a renowned specialist argues how the focus, timing and methods must be on encouraging men to perform vasectomies rather than the more commonly performed intrusive tubectomy on women and specifically advocates more robust all-round efforts than the token November 21-December 4, government observed Vasectomy Fortnight

The post Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
India’s family planning programme rests on one operation, and it is performed only on women. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5, 2019–21), around 37.9% of currently married women aged 15–49 have been sterilised. For men the figure is 0.3%. In 1992–93 the first NFHS recorded male sterilisation at about 3.5%, so the gap has widened over thirty years. Fact sheets from NFHS-6 (2023–24) put the figures at about 36.5% and 0.5%.

As a gynaecologist, I find this hard to defend on medical grounds. The simpler and safer operation is the one we almost never perform.

Two operations, compared

A tubectomy closes the fallopian tubes so that the egg and sperm cannot meet. To reach the tubes, the surgeon has to enter the abdomen. In a minilaparotomy (“minilap”) this is done through a small cut in the lower abdomen, usually under local anaesthesia with sedation. In laparoscopic sterilisation a thin telescope is passed through a small cut near the navel after the abdomen is filled with gas, and a ring or clip is placed on each tube. Both are short and safe in trained hands, but they are –still—an abdominal surgery. The risks, though uncommon, include infection, bleeding, injury to the bowel or bladder, and problems with anaesthesia.

A vasectomy closes the two thin tubes that carry sperm. These lie just under the skin of the scrotum. In no-scalpel vasectomy the doctor reaches them through a single tiny puncture, under local anaesthesia. There is no entry into the abdomen and usually no stitch. The man walks home and can return to light work within a couple of days. Complications are mostly minor, such as bruising, swelling or a small infection. It does not affect erections, sexual desire or physical strength. One point needs honest counselling: a vasectomy does not work at once, and the couple needs another method (of contraception) for about three months afterwards.

Both operations are highly effective. The World Health Organisation (WHO)-supported family planning handbook puts first-year failure at about 0.5 per 100 for female sterilisation and about 0.15 per 100 for vasectomy. Both should be treated as permanent.

On every count, vasectomy is the lighter procedure. Yet the heavier one is done over a hundred times more often.

Camps, Targets and Bilaspur

This did not happen by accident. For decades the programme was run on numerical targets. After the coercive vasectomy drives of the Emergency in the mid-1970s, sterilising men became politically untouchable, and the targets shifted to women. The 1994 International Conference on Population and Development in Cairo moved the world from population control towards reproductive rights, and in 1996 India announced a Target Free Approach. On paper, targets ended. In practice “expected levels of achievement”, incentive payments to acceptors and motivators, and pressure on frontline workers kept much of the old logic going.

Its cost became impossible to ignore in November 2014. At a sterilisation camp in Takhatpur, in Bilaspur district of Chhattisgarh, 83 women were sterilised at a single camp. Thirteen of them died in the days that followed.

In September 2016, in Devika Biswas v Union of India, the Supreme Court held that what was happening in such camps violated women’s right to health and reproductive freedom. The court directed the Union government to phase out sterilisation camps within three years and to strengthen regular health facilities instead. It also said states must not set even informal targets, that consent must be explained in a language the woman understands, that deaths and failures must be audited and reported, and that compensation should be raised.

The standards were already there. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare publishes manuals on standards and quality assurance in sterilisation services, covering screening, asepsis, the number of cases a team may do in a day, and follow-up. The Family Planning Indemnity Scheme provides compensation for death, complications and failure after sterilisation. What has been missing is consistent practice.

Why the gap persists

Myths come first. Many men, and many families, believe vasectomy causes weakness, ends a man’s capacity for hard labour or damages his sexual life. None of this is true, but families who depend on his wages often share the fear. NFHS-5 found that about 35% of men agreed that contraception is women’s business and a man should not have to worry about it.

Then there is timing. A woman meets the health system at delivery, and sterilisation is often offered soon after childbirth or with a caesarean section. That suits the system, but it is not always a good moment for a permanent decision. NFHS-5 gives the median age at sterilisation as 25.7 years. A decision made at 25, sometimes within days of a birth, has to last a lifetime.

Counselling is thin. Among sterilised women in NFHS-5, only about 65% said they had been told about other methods, and about 59% had been told about possible side effects. The public sector now offers a wider range: the intrauterine device (IUCD), including after delivery; the injectable contraceptive MPA under the Antara programme; the non-hormonal weekly pill Chhaya; condoms and daily pills. A woman who has never been offered these has not really chosen sterilisation.

Every year from November 21 to December 4, the government observes a Vasectomy Fortnight to encourage men to come forward. It is welcome, but a fortnight cannot undo a year of silence.

What needs to Change

Counselling must be real: unhurried, in the woman’s own language, without the husband or the motivator answering for her, and never in the labour room. Reversible methods should be offered first to young couples, with steady supplies so that a missed injection does not become an unwanted pregnancy.

Quality standards must apply in every facility, with follow-up visits that actually take place. States should publish what the Supreme Court asked for: how many procedures, how many complications, how many deaths, how many failures, and what was done about each.

Men need to be reached directly. ASHAs and ANMs speak mostly to women. We need male health workers, satisfied vasectomy users and trained no-scalpel vasectomy providers at district level, speaking to men where they work.

Finally, a woman must be free to say no, to sterilisation or to any method, without losing a benefit or the goodwill of the health worker she will need again. Family planning was meant to give women control over their bodies. A programme where one sex does nearly all the bleeding has not yet done that.

(The author holds a degree in medicine, an MBBS, MS [Obstetrics and Gynaecology], is an obstetrician-gynaecologist from Assam and is also a medical reviewer at abortion-riyadh.com)

Sources

  1. NFHS-5 (2019–21), India Fact Sheet, IIPS and MoHFW: https://rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5_FCTS/India.pdf
    2. NFHS-5 (2019–21), India National Report, IIPS and ICF: https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR375/FR375.pdf
    3. Devika Biswas v Union of India & Ors, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 95 of 2012, Supreme Court of India, judgment of 14 September 2016 (summary, Human Rights Law Network): https://www.hrln.org/litigation/devika-biswas-versus-union-of-india-and-ors-writ-petition-c-no-95-of-2012-the-supreme-court-of-india
    4. National Health Mission, MoHFW, Family Planning programme, guidelines and manuals: https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=2&sublinkid=821&lid=222
    5. WHO, Family planning/contraception methods fact sheet: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/family-planning-contraception
    6. WHO/Johns Hopkins, Family Planning: A Global Handbook for Providers, contraceptive effectiveness: https://fphandbook.org/sites/default/files/legacy/book/fph_appendix_a/index.shtml
    7. Centre for Economic Data and Analysis, Ashoka University, “Female sterilisation in India: prevalence, informed choice and regret” (2024): https://ceda.ashoka.edu.in/female-sterilisation-in-india-prevalence-informed-choice-and-regret/
    8. UNFPA, International Conference on Population and Development (Cairo, 1994): https://www.unfpa.org/icpd


Related:

Menstrual health of women in shambles: Surveys highlight need for inclusive and accessible healthcare services

Human rights of Women in mental health institutions violated: SC

India’s Poorest Women Benefit Less From Public Health, Nutrition Services

The post Health: Why do women in India still carry the burden of sterilisation? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination https://sabrangindia.in/god-beyond-patriarchy-recovering-the-feminine-in-the-islamic-imagination/ Fri, 13 Nov 2026 05:55:39 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50085 To affirm that God transcends gender is not merely a doctrinal statement. It is a spiritual and ethical commitment.

The post God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
“I believe femininity is at least as close to divinity as masculinity. The masculine bias in this matter is one of the worst forms of anthropomorphism.” So wrote the process philosopher Charles Hartshorne. Decades later, Christian writer Sarah Bessey would make a related claim in a different register: “Patriarchy is not God’s dream for humanity.”

While these statements emerged from Christian and philosophical contexts, they raise a question that Muslims should not dismiss too quickly: What happens when we confuse God with our own social arrangements? More specifically, what happens when patriarchal culture becomes so deeply embedded in religious interpretation that divine reality itself begins to appear male?

The irony is striking. Islam’s central theological principle, tawhid, insists that God is utterly unlike creation. “There is nothing whatever like unto Him” (Q. 42:11). Yet Muslims frequently imagine and speak of God through overwhelmingly masculine imagery. Even when acknowledging that God’s essence transcends gender, religious discourse often unconsciously associates divine authority, power, judgment, and leadership with masculinity.

Hartshorne’s observation remains devastatingly relevant. If God is neither male nor female, then privileging masculine imagery as somehow closer to divine reality is not theological sophistication. It is anthropomorphism. It is projecting human social structures onto the divine.

Islamic theology, at its best, has always recognized this danger. The Qur’an relentlessly critiques idolatry not merely as the worship of statues but as the tendency to fashion God according to human desires and assumptions. Idolatry begins not only when we worship false gods but when we create God in our own image.

This is why the divine names matter.

Among Allah’s ninety-nine names are al-Rahman and al-Rahim, typically translated as “The Most Compassionate” and “The Most Merciful.” What is often forgotten is that both are linguistically linked to the Arabic word rahm, meaning womb. Classical Muslim scholars frequently noted this connection. The most frequently invoked attributes of God in the Qur’an are rooted in imagery associated with nurturing, care, protection, and life-giving relationality.

The significance of this cannot be overstated.

The Qur’an could have foregrounded sovereignty alone. It could have emphasized divine domination and power above all else. Yet the first words Muslims encounter before almost every chapter are “In the Name of God, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.” Divine mercy precedes divine judgment. Compassion grounds authority. Relationship comes before command.

These are not exclusively feminine qualities, of course. But neither are they traditionally masculine. They point beyond rigid gender binaries toward a richer understanding of the divine.

Indeed, Muslim mystics often grasped this more clearly than legalists and theologians. The great Persian tradition of madhhab-i ‘ishq, the “school of love,” found in figures such as Farid al-Din Attar and Hafez, understood that God is encountered not primarily through domination or hierarchy but through intimacy, beauty, longing, and love. The lover-beloved relationship became a powerful metaphor for humanity’s relationship with the Divine.

quranictheology_NewAGEiLSM.gif

Love dissolves hierarchy.

One cannot meaningfully speak of being over, above, or superior to another while simultaneously speaking the language of genuine love. Love draws persons into communion rather than domination. It creates reciprocity without erasing difference.

This insight carries profound implications for Muslim discussions about gender.

Too often contemporary debates about women in Islam become trapped between two unsatisfactory choices. On one side stand defenders of traditional patriarchy who assume that male leadership reflects some eternal divine order. On the other stand secular critics who conclude that religion itself is inherently patriarchal and therefore irredeemable.

Both positions miss something important.

The deeper question is not whether particular historical Muslim societies were patriarchal. Most were. The real question is whether patriarchy is intrinsic to Islam’s vision of God and humanity.

The Qur’an’s theological trajectory suggests otherwise.

Human beings, male and female, are described as originating from a single soul (nafs wahida). Moral worth is measured not by gender but by taqwa, God-consciousness. The believing men and believing women are repeatedly mentioned together as equal participants in the spiritual project. The creation narrative lacks the notion that woman is somehow a derivative or secondary being whose existence serves male purposes.

When these principles are taken seriously, patriarchy begins to look less like a theological necessity and more like a historical accommodation.

This is where Hartshorne’s critique becomes particularly useful. If God is the supreme exemplar of relationality, love, responsiveness, and care rather than unilateral domination, then our religious communities should mirror those attributes. Authority becomes service rather than control. Leadership becomes empowerment rather than hierarchy. Strength becomes the capacity to nurture flourishing rather than to command obedience.

Such a vision resonates deeply with the Qur’anic conception of divine mercy encompassing all things.

For Muslims today, the challenge is not simply to include more women in religious institutions, important though that is. The challenge is theological. It is to recover aspects of the Islamic tradition that have been obscured by centuries of patriarchal assumptions and to reimagine God not as a cosmic patriarch but as the source of boundless mercy, beauty, creativity, and love.

Patriarchy, after all, narrows both women and men. It restricts human potential by confining people within rigid expectations of what masculinity and femininity should be. The God of the Qur’an is far greater than such limitations.

To affirm that God transcends gender is not merely a doctrinal statement. It is a spiritual and ethical commitment. It means refusing to sanctify social hierarchies simply because they are old. It means measuring our communities against divine compassion rather than inherited power structures.

And perhaps it means taking seriously the possibility that Hartshorne and Bessey, each in their own way, were pointing toward a truth that the Islamic tradition has always contained but has not always fully embraced: that the closer we draw to God, the less convincing patriarchy becomes. For a God whose mercy is womb-like, whose love exceeds every category, and whose reality transcends every human projection can never be reduced to the image of a celestial patriarch. The God of tawhid is infinitely more beautiful, more relational, and more liberating than that.

Adis Duderija is an Associate Professor in Islam and Society and Griffith University and a book series editor of a new book series on Islam and Process-Relational Thought (Routledge).

Courtesy: New Age Islam

The post God Beyond Patriarchy: Recovering the Feminine in the Islamic Imagination appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
UP & Bihar: Tranches of arms & explosives recovered over the Diwali weekend https://sabrangindia.in/up-bihar-tranches-of-arms-explosives-recovered-over-the-diwali-weekend/ Mon, 09 Nov 2026 11:56:20 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50026 The seizure of 19,250 live cartridges from Koilawar police thane near the Kulhadiya Toll Plaza, Bihar over the weekend (Lokmat News, November 5) was connected to another serious incident wherein the Haryana STF seized 25,000 cartridges from two cars being smuggled to UP and Bihar (Hindustan Times, November 3) and even arrested five UP residents. […]

The post UP & Bihar: Tranches of arms & explosives recovered over the Diwali weekend appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The seizure of 19,250 live cartridges from Koilawar police thane near the Kulhadiya Toll Plaza, Bihar over the weekend (Lokmat News, November 5) was connected to another serious incident wherein the Haryana STF seized 25,000 cartridges from two cars being smuggled to UP and Bihar (Hindustan Times, November 3) and even arrested five UP residents. In a third incident, ironically over the Diwali weekend, also involving explosives, had the UP Police arresting two men and seizing nearly 199 kg of gelatin explosives, 100 fuses, seven bundles of red wire and 2.945 kg of powder from a fleeing Bolero vehicle in Chitrakoot district (Reports in Dainik Bhaskar and Amar Ujala, November 5). 


The seizure of 19,250 live cartridges from Koilawar police thane near the Kulhadiya Toll Plaza has drawn strong political reactions with Tejasvi Yadav, leader of the opposition raising serious questions over the accused’s alleged involvement with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). The Lokmat News reported this seizure even as the incident erupted into a political controversy with questions on motives behind the possession and transportation of thousands and thousands of such live cartridges and dangerous explosives over the Diwali weekend arose.

So far, nothing in the publicly disclosed official accounts reveal any such clear organisational link.

In fact, it is on November 2, when a joint task force of the Bihar STF and the Bhojpur District police apprehended and stopped an SUV at the Toll Plaza, and on searching it unearthed these 19,250 live cartridges and one “desi” pistol. Three persons have been arrested in this connection, and they reportedly hail from Muzaffarpur: Laltu Kumar (38), Saras Kumar (27) and Chandan Tiwari (26) from Siwan and are part of an international arms ammunition network. Sections of the BNSS and Arms act have been added in the charges against them. The connection or alleged connection with the RSS surfaced later, according to Lokmat News, their older photographs in the RSS’ uniform started circulating. It is through this seizure and investigation that 25,000 live cartridge seizure by the Haryana STF near Jhajjar was unearthed.

Meanwhile, a team of Haryana police special task force (STF) seized a consignment of 25000 live cartridges that was being smuggled to Uttar Pradesh and Bihar and arrested five suspects from two cars near Rohad toll plaza on Bahadurgarh-Rohtak highway in Jhajjar on Tuesday. The arrested suspects were Afifuddin alias Munna Khan, 49, Asim Rais, 33, Sablu Khan, 32, Arbaz Ali, 27 and Zeenat, 33. All five are residents of different localities in Uttar Pradesh’s Budaun. Eight mobile phones and two cars were also seized from them, STF officials said.

In the third weekend incident involving seizure of explosives, Uttar Pradesh Police have arrested two men and seized nearly 199 kg of gelatin explosives, 100 fuses, seven bundles of red wire and 2.945 kg of powder from a fleeing Bolero vehicle in Chitrakoot district, according reports in Dainik Bhaskar and Amar Ujala published on November 5. News reports published over the weekend and today, Monday November 9 have reported that a leader of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and his close associate have been arrested in Uttar Pradesh’s Chitrakoot district after local police allegedly recovered nearly 200 kg of explosive material from their vehicle near the Madhya Pradesh border. The arrest has resulted in a storm within political circles; however, predictably, the BJP itself has so far maintained a stony silence over the incident. Hari Gopal Mishra is the BJP leader who was arrested while his associate is Pappu Tiwari. Both men are residents of Bhouri village under the Raipura police station area of Chitrakoot.

The reported political background of Hari Gopal Mishra has drawn attention following the seizure. According to Amar Ujala, he had contested a Zila Panchayat election with BJP backing.

In the highway seizure in Jajjhar, Haryana authorities have revealed to the media that Munna owns an ancestral Badaun Gun House in the Civil Lines area of Badaun and had procured the consignment from Vijay Goel, who runs Mehak Gun House in Sirsa, Haryana, which he has been running since 1999.  The Haryana STF said Vijay has also been arrested and was quizzed to ascertain his role in the interstate smuggling network, which is suspected to be running for the last three years.

Waseem Akram, superintendent of police, Haryana STF, said that 24400 cartridges of 7.65mm (.32 bore) used in regular small handguns and .315 bore used in rifles were seized from a Tata Harrier, while another batch of 600 cartridges (.315 bore) were seized from a Hyundai Aura.

“The 7.65mm cartridges are used in illegal country-made pistols manufactured in Bihar’s Munger, West Bengal and Eastern UP, while the rifle bore cartridges are used in breach-load illegal pistols manufactured in these areas for which the smuggling was taking place,” Akram said.

Akram said Munna was the kingpin of the smuggling racket running due to continuous cartridge stock pilferage from the gun houses in Haryana, UP and other places. Shamsher Dahiya, deputy superintendent of police, STF, said the entire consignment was manufactured in an ammunition factory in Pune’s Khadki, as the marking ‘KF’ was engraved on all the cartridges. “The two cars were intercepted near a roadside eatery, Triveni Dhaba, which is located right opposite the toll plaza after we had received a tip-off from Bihar police STF,” he added. Some controversy has erupted over a photograph showing the accused posing in uniforms of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).

Photographs showing Bihar-based accused Chandan Tiwari and his brother Abhishek Tiwari wearing the uniform of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) were reported in a section of the digital media. Another image reportedly showing them posing with a local MLA from Muzaffarpur has also surfaced. The photographs have prompted questions about the alleged political and organisational associations of the accused. However, the images alone do not establish that the RSS, as an organisation, was involved in the arms smuggling network.

Questions over Ammunition manufactured in government factories

Another aspect of the investigation concerns reports that some of the seized cartridges were manufactured in government-owned ordnance factories. If confirmed, the reported origin of the ammunition raises questions about how it entered the alleged illegal supply chain and whether it was diverted through licensed dealers or other intermediaries.

The National Investigation Agency (NIA) has reportedly joined the investigation. It is expected to examine the origin of the ammunition, the supply chain and the possible involvement of other individuals. According to media reports, the investigation has also brought renewed attention to the name of Jalan Shop, which reportedly surfaced in an earlier arms smuggling case in Bihar. Reports in that case alleged that an individual associated with the shop supplied nearly 100 pistols to different parts of Bihar using forged arms licences. The accused was reportedly wanted by the NIA and remains absconding.

Investigators have yet to establish whether the current ammunition network has any connection with that case or other previously investigated arms trafficking operations. The agencies are now attempting to trace the intended recipients of the seized cartridges and identify the ultimate buyers. They are also examining whether the ammunition was meant for organised criminal groups or other illegal networks.

Explosives seized in Chitrakoot

There are differing accounts regarding the intended use of the seized materials from the third incident.

According to reports, the accused told investigators that the explosives were being transported from Majhgawan in Madhya Pradesh for digging a well in a rocky area. Police reportedly said the materials were of the type used for breaking rocks in stone quarries.

However, another Amar Ujala report stated that the accused had told police that the materials were intended for making firecrackers. Investigators are examining the source, destination and intended use of the explosives. Police have registered a case against the two accused under Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908. The Bolero used to transport the materials has also been seized.  Following the recovery, police took both men into custody and informed Chitrakoot Superintendent of Police Arun Kumar Singh, who subsequently reached the spot. The accused, along with the seized explosives, were taken to the police station for questioning. Both men were produced before a court and sent to judicial custody.

Investigators are examining the supply chain, the source of the explosives in Madhya Pradesh, their intended recipients and whether other individuals were involved in the transportation or distribution of the materials.

It was while the police from the Markundi police station were conducting a routine checking operation in their jurisdiction on the night of November 3 when they spotted a Bolero approaching. However, suspiciously, when the police signalled the Bolero vehicle to stop, its occupants allegedly attempted to flee. Thereafter, the police intercepted the vehicle after cordoning off the area.

When police personnel asked the two occupants to step out and allow the vehicle to be searched, Mishra reportedly identified himself as a BJP leader and attempted to use his political influence to avoid the search. However, the police proceeded with the inspection and recovered a large quantity of explosive material from the vehicle.

The seized material included 199 kg of gelatin sticks, 100 red-coloured fuses, seven bundles of red wire and 2.945 kg of explosive powder. It was on November 4, Superintendent of Police Arun Kumar Singh held a press conference and presented the two arrested men before journalists, as reported by Dainik Bhaskar and Amar Ujala.

The SP confirmed that Hari Gopal Mishra was associated with the BJP and had contested the Zila Panchayat member election on the party’s ticket. He had also served as a Zila Panchayat member. The second accused, Pappu Tiwari, was identified as his associate.

According to the SP, the two men were apprehended near the Uttar Pradesh–Madhya Pradesh border with approximately two quintals of explosive material. The police are investigating where the explosives were procured, where they were being transported and what they were intended to be used for. Investigators are also examining whether other individuals or organised groups were involved in the case.

The police are further probing the possible purchase and sale of the explosives; the network of people associated with their supply and whether the accused possessed the mandatory licences and documents for storing and transporting such material.

The SP said that the complete details would emerge only after the investigation was concluded. He also observed that the recovery of such a large quantity of explosives raised serious concerns, as the material could potentially have been used to carry out a major incident.

BJP silent, yet to respond

The arrest of a person identified by the police as a former BJP-backed Zila Panchayat member, along with the recovery of such a huge quantity of explosives, has caused considerable embarrassment for the party. The BJP has not issued any public statement on the matter so far.

The incident has also triggered political questions about the source, illegal procurement and intended use of the explosives. However, the allegations concerning any wider political or organisational involvement remain unsubstantiated and will have to be established through the police investigation.

Related:

Seven Explosives Recovered from Temple, Possible Links with RSS Management

The post UP & Bihar: Tranches of arms & explosives recovered over the Diwali weekend appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Does the ECI’s Nov 6 communication signal a step-back on re-enrolment in the ASSD list? https://sabrangindia.in/does-the-ecis-nov-6-communication-signal-a-step-back-on-re-enrolment-in-the-assd-list/ Fri, 06 Nov 2026 13:43:10 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50016 SC petitioners Anjali Bharadwaj and Amrita Johri welcome ECI’s Nov 6 communication to seven states on facilitating inclusion of left-out voters

The post Does the ECI’s Nov 6 communication signal a step-back on re-enrolment in the ASSD list? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
On October 28, 2026 in the Delhi SIR matter, the SC had observed that making deleted voters on ASDD list fill Form 6 was an ERROR. SC had said that such voters should be allowed to fill enumeration form/ Form 8 if they are marked as permanently shifted or as absent/ untraceable.

Today, November 6, the ECI has issued communication addressed to CEOs of Delhi, Maharashtra, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Jharkhand, Telangana and Nagaland on facilitating inclusion of left out voters. 

The communication states:

– Voters who are on ASDD list as they had shifted residence, can fill enumeration form along with a statement with details of their new address. In case of homeless persons, field verification by BLO will suffice. 

– Voters who could not submit their enumeration form within the deadline and are on ASDD list can submit their enumeration form now along with a statement on why they were unable to do so earlier. 

– All those on ASDD list who will now fill enumeration form along with the applicable statement will be re-assigned their old EPIC number. All such cases will be parked for inclusion in final voter list following due verification. 

– Wide publicity must be given to all these initiatives, including through media, social media, and announcements, reaching out through WhatsApp etc. and facilitation and assistance to be provided to voters. 

Link to ECI communication of Nov. 6, 2026- https://ceodelhi.gov.in/PDFFolders/2026/Left_Out_Electors_6_11_2026.pdf 

Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri, petitioners in the Writ Petition (Civil) 1188/2026 & IA No. 317050/2026 in Anjali Bhardwaj & ANR. Vs Election Commission of India & ANR have in a public communication today stated that they welcome this development:

“We welcome this communication issued by the ECI. We believe this is an important step in addressing large scale exclusions caused during SIR. The provision to re-assign the old EPIC numbers is important as it will ensure preservation of voter’s historical record of being an existing voter. Just in Delhi, out of 47.56 lakh deleted in the first phase and put on ASDD, 31.59 lakh were marked as permanently shifted and 11.73 as absent/untraceable. The SC had observed that asking such people to fill Form 6 with its declaration of being a first time voter was an error. 

We urge the CEO of Delhi and all other states to take immediate steps to operationalise these critical directions. “

Meanwhile, yesterday, November 5, they had in a formal letter the ECI requested for an immediate investigation and legal action based on media report of forgery, identity fraud, and misuse of Form 7 in Mustafabad Constituency of Delhi

In a letter addressed to the ECI, Anjali Bharadwaj and Amrita Johri had relied on a news report published in The Hindu yesterday.

The letter states that,  

“We are writing to draw your urgent attention to a news report published by The Hindu on November 5, 2026, titled “Delhi SIR: several BJP BLAs named as ‘objectors’ deny filing Form 7s in Mustafabad area” (pasted below).

“The investigative report highlights alarming irregularities in the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls in the Mustafabad constituency of Delhi. Out of 1,021 deletion applications filed, at least 787 Form 7—accounting for 94% of third-party deletion requests—were submitted in the names of 20 BJP-appointed Booth-Level Agents (BLAs). All the applications were against Muslim electors. Upon verification, The Hindu has reported that 16 of these 20 individuals denied filling, signing, or having any knowledge of these forms, indicating that their identities appear to have been forged and used fraudulently without their consent.

“The report raises serious concerns about possible systematic and fraudulent attempt to disenfranchise legitimate electors through the deliberate misuse of statutory procedures and warrants investigation.

“In light of these findings, we urge the ECI and the CEO, Delhi, to take immediate cognizance and initiate the following actions:

  1. Register police complaints: Direct the registration of FIRs under relevant provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) including for forgery, criminal impersonation, identity fraud, and submission of false declarations etc.
  2. Comprehensive audit of all Form 7 submissions: Conduct a comprehensive audit of every Form 7 submitted across all constituencies in Delhi during the SIR to verify whether the listed objectors actually authorized and signed the forms.
  3. Statutory penalties under the RP Act: After investigation, enforce strict statutory action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, against all persons who knowingly submitted false or fabricated declarations in Form 7.
  4. No deletions without independent verification: Immediately stay all deletion proceedings originating from third-party Form 7 applications until independent verification with the affected electors and listed objectors is completed.
  5. Publish verification reports: Release a public report disclosing the total number of Form 7 applications received, verified as genuine, or found to be fraudulent to maintain public trust in the electoral process.
  6. Publish all Form 7 submissions on the CEO Delhi website: Publish all Form 7 deletion applications received during the SIR on the website of the CEO, Delhi to enable people to check and verify whether such forms have been fraudulently submitted in their names.

The letter dated November 5 had been addressed to Gyanesh Kumar, The Chief Election Commissioner, ECI, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, Election Commissioner, ECI, Dr. Vivek Joshi, Election Commissioner, ECI and Ashok Kumar, The Chief Electoral Officer (CEO), Delhi

The Hindu, November 5, 2026 (page 4)

The post Does the ECI’s Nov 6 communication signal a step-back on re-enrolment in the ASSD list? appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Assam: Gauhati HC quashes NSA detention of activist Pranab Doley https://sabrangindia.in/assam-gauhati-hc-quashes-nsa-detention-of-activist-pranab-doley/ Fri, 06 Nov 2026 12:11:20 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50006 Doley was arrested in July this year for a protest against a hotel project near Kaziranga, and had been booked under the nefarious National Security Act (NSA) after a court granted him bail; Forum for Social Harmony, AMSU-AIKMS and BAA accuse the Assam government of criminalising land rights activism

The post Assam: Gauhati HC quashes NSA detention of activist Pranab Doley appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A division bench of the Gauhati High Court on Friday, November 6, quashed the detention, under the National Security Act (NSA) of activist Pranab Doley, announced advocate Dipesh Agrawala, one of the lawyers who represented him. The Act allows for long periods of detention without trial up to a year.

A copy of the judgement is not yet available.

Doley was arrested on July 12, days after he took part in a protest against a hotel project at Ingle Pathar, a village adjoining the Kaziranga National Park in Assam. Predictably, the police had alleged that he “unlawfully trespassed into the site of the Tea Tribes Museum and thereafter trespassed into the nearby ATDC [Assam Tourism Development Corporation] Hyatt project at Ingle Pathar with deadly weapons” during the protest. Doley, is the convenor of the Greater Kaziranga Land and Human Rights Protection Committee (GKLHRPC) and a leading face of the agitation against a proposed luxury hotel project near Kaziranga National Park.

On July 29, a sessions court in Golaghat granted bail to Doley, stating that the investigating officer had already recorded the statements of key witnesses and that there was no possibility of the accused concealing or tampering with the evidence.

However, the very next day, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in the state detained Doley under the National Security Act, alleging that he had carried out “suspicious foreign transactions from doubtful sources” in violation of the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act. Shockingly, this means that he was not released from jail, despite the bail order.

In August, the Congress had alleged that the Assam government invoking the Act against Doley was part of a “growing pattern” of the BJP “weaponising extraordinary laws to silence dissent”. Party leader Jairam Ramesh had described the state government’s allegations against Doley as “vague and speculative”.

Citing detentions of at least two other persons under the Act in Uttar Pradesh in April, the Opposition MP claimed that this was a familiar script followed by the Narendra Modi government.

At the time of the arrest itself, three organisations have issued strongly worded statements condemning the arrest of prominent Assam land rights activist Pranab Doley, describing the police action as an attempt to suppress democratic dissent and intimidate communities resisting corporate-backed projects in and around Kaziranga. In separate statements released on July 12, the Forum for Social Harmony, the Asom Mojuri Shramik Union (AMSU) and All India Kisan Mazdoor Sabha (AIKMS), and the Bhumi Adhikar Andolan (BAA) alleged that Doley’s arrest is part of an intensifying pattern of criminalising indigenous rights defenders, farmers and people’s movements challenging land acquisition, displacement and the expansion of corporate interests in ecologically sensitive areas. While each statement approaches the issue from a distinct perspective, all three organisations unequivocally demand Doley’s immediate and unconditional release, withdrawal of what they describe as false and politically motivated criminal cases, and an end to the alleged use of police powers to stifle democratic protest.

The statements were issued hours after the Assam Police detained Doley in Guwahati on July 12 in connection with a criminal case registered at Bokakhat Police Station.

Forum for Social Harmony calls arrest an attack on democratic rights

The Forum for Social Harmony characterised Doley’s arrest as “an attack on democratic rights”, alleging that the Assam government had deployed the police machinery to suppress a legitimate people’s movement centred on land rights, livelihood protection and environmental justice. The organisation said the arrest was deeply alarming because it followed a prolonged and peaceful campaign by local farmers, indigenous communities and several people’s organisations opposing the proposed luxury hotel project at Engle (Inglay) Pathar in Kaziranga.

According to the Forum, the government’s response has not been to engage with the concerns raised by affected communities but to repeatedly invoke criminal law against movement leaders. It alleged that the filing of one criminal case after another reflects a “dangerous trend” of shrinking democratic space, where constitutionally protected rights to dissent and freedom of expression are increasingly curtailed through criminal prosecution and police action.


Related:

‘Attack on democratic rights’: Rights groups denounce Pranab Doley’s arrest

The post Assam: Gauhati HC quashes NSA detention of activist Pranab Doley appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>