Environment | SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/category/environment/ News Related to Human Rights Mon, 16 Nov 2026 04:34:25 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 https://sabrangindia.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Favicon_0.png Environment | SabrangIndia https://sabrangindia.in/category/environment/ 32 32 China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP https://sabrangindia.in/chinas-medog-dam-indias-siang-project-could-multiply-disaster-risks-warns-sandrp/ Mon, 16 Nov 2026 04:34:25 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50105 A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people […]

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China’s proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India’s proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world’s most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.

The report, titled “The Riskiest Place to Dam a River: Medog, SUMP and the Untamed Yarlung Tsangpo Gorge”, has been authored by Parineeta Dandekar with Chintan Sheth. It argues that the combination of seismic activity, landslides, glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), extreme sediment flows and climate change makes the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge an exceptionally hazardous location for large hydropower infrastructure.

The report comes amid growing opposition in Arunachal Pradesh to the proposed SUMP, which the state government has presented as a strategic response to China’s Medog project on the Yarlung Tsangpo, known as the Siang after it enters India and the Brahmaputra further downstream.

According to the report, China’s Medog project, described as the world’s largest hydropower project, is expected to have an installed capacity of approximately 60,000 MW. However, Beijing has not made public essential details concerning the project’s precise locations, reservoir capacities, water discharge arrangements and operational objectives.

The report says that the lack of transparency is particularly concerning because the project is located close to India’s border and could have significant implications for downstream regions in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

It notes that China’s proposed project is being promoted on grounds of national security, energy production, ecological considerations and international cooperation, but the absence of reliable technical information makes it difficult for downstream countries to assess its potential consequences.

Against this backdrop, Arunachal Pradesh is advancing the proposed 11,000 MW SUMP, which Chief Minister Pema Khandu has described as a water-defence project. The proposed project is expected to involve a dam approximately 280-300 metres high, with a reservoir capacity of 9-10 billion cubic metres.

However, the report questions whether constructing another massive dam downstream is an appropriate response to the risks associated with China’s project.

It points out that the proposed SUMP could completely submerge 27 Adi tribal villages and partially affect another 40-45 villages. Thousands of orange and pineapple farms and traditional wet-rice terraces could also be affected, while more than 100,000 indigenous people could face displacement or loss of livelihoods and land.

The report describes the opposition of indigenous communities as a struggle over their land, livelihoods and future, arguing that the concerns of the Adi people cannot be overlooked in the pursuit of strategic and hydropower objectives.

Beyond the geopolitical concerns, the report identifies the geographical and geological characteristics of the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge as a major reason for questioning both projects.

The gorge, located around the Namcha Barwa or Eastern Himalayan Syntaxis, is among the deepest river gorges in the world. The river makes a dramatic horseshoe-shaped turn around Namcha Barwa before entering India, descending approximately 2,000 metres over a relatively short stretch.

According to the report, this region experiences some of the world’s highest rates of tectonic uplift, rock erosion and river sediment transport. It is also highly vulnerable to earthquakes, landslides, avalanches and glacial lake outburst floods.

The report cites the 1950 Assam earthquake, which measured 8.6 on the Richter scale, as evidence of the region’s seismic vulnerability. It also refers to research documenting more than 200 earthquakes of magnitude above four between 1950 and 2018 in the gorge region.

The sediment carried by the river is another major concern. According to the report, hydrological measurements show that the Yarlung Tsangpo carries approximately 15-30 million tonnes of sediment annually at Nuxia/Pai on the Tibetan plateau. By the time it reaches Pasighat in Arunachal Pradesh, the annual sediment load rises to approximately 210-250 million tonnes.

Studies cited in the report estimate that 61-74 per cent of the sediment reaching Pasighat originates from the relatively small gorge region. Although this area constitutes less than three per cent of the Brahmaputra basin, it contributes approximately 45 per cent of the sediment reaching Bangladesh through the river system.

The report warns that large storage dams could substantially alter this natural sediment movement. Such dams can trap most of the sediment flowing into their reservoirs, affecting downstream river ecology, agriculture and the stability of river channels.

It cites the example of the Tehri Dam, which reportedly retains approximately 95 per cent of the sediment it receives.

If the proposed SUMP traps large quantities of sediment arriving from upstream, its reservoir capacity and ability to accommodate floodwaters could progressively decline. The report also warns that reduced sediment flows downstream could increase riverbank erosion and affect communities dependent on the river’s natural sediment supply.

The report further draws attention to a series of major landslides and river-blocking incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo gorge, demonstrating the scale of natural hazards that could affect projects in the region.

One of the most significant incidents occurred in 2000, when a massive landslide in the Yigong-Parlung Tsangpo valley blocked a tributary, creating a natural dam. The resulting lake eventually breached in June that year, sending floodwaters downstream into Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

The report recalls that the flood swept away forest areas and several bridges. It cites accounts of approximately 30 deaths and destruction affecting more than 50 villages in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.

Another major series of incidents occurred in 2017, when landslides and rock-ice collapses in the Sedongpu valley partially blocked the Yarlung Tsangpo. The Siang river in India subsequently turned into a dark, muddy flow, affecting fish and local drinking-water infrastructure.

In October 2018, two successive rock-and-ice avalanches completely blocked the main river channel, creating temporary barrier lakes. The resulting changes in water levels affected downstream flows in Arunachal Pradesh before the blockages were breached and surges of water and debris moved towards Assam.

A further major rock-and-ice collapse in March 2021 again blocked the river.

The report says these incidents demonstrate how landslides, glacier collapses, river blockages and sudden floods can combine to create disasters across international boundaries.

It also highlights the impact of climate change, noting that the Tibetan plateau is warming at approximately twice the global average rate. Rising temperatures are accelerating glacier retreat and permafrost degradation, increasing the potential for landslides, avalanches, glacial lake outburst floods and extreme river flows.

The authors warn that these developments could make the region increasingly unpredictable for large hydropower projects.

A major concern raised in the report is the absence of an effective mechanism for sharing hydrological and disaster-related information between China and India.

The existing memorandum of understanding on hydrological data sharing between the two countries expired in June 2023 and has not been formally renewed. Although China agreed in principle in 2025 to share information on a limited emergency and humanitarian basis, the report says that a reliable institutional arrangement is still lacking.

It recalls that during the 2017 Doklam standoff, China withheld hydrological information on the Brahmaputra and Sutlej rivers for the entire flood season. It also points to the lack of advance warnings during several major landslide-related incidents in the Yarlung Tsangpo basin.

The authors argue that the absence of reliable information-sharing arrangements, combined with the possibility of sudden dam releases and natural river blockages, could significantly increase the risks for downstream communities.

The report also questions the flood-control rationale of SUMP. It argues that a large storage reservoir intended to generate electricity would need to retain water and therefore could not remain empty at all times to accommodate sudden floods originating upstream.

If the reservoir’s capacity to absorb floodwaters is reduced by sediment accumulation, the consequences of an upstream disaster could be particularly serious.

According to the report, the proposed SUMP could face extreme flows resulting from upstream dam releases, heavy precipitation or natural disasters. If the reservoir loses a substantial part of its flood-storage capacity because of sediment accumulation, its ability to perform its intended flood-control function could be compromised.

The authors conclude that China’s Medog project poses a serious geopolitical and environmental challenge, particularly because of Beijing’s lack of transparency. However, they argue that India’s decision to construct a massive storage dam downstream could create an additional and potentially permanent vulnerability.

“India is responding to an external upstream hazard by building a permanent domestic structural vulnerability,” the report states.

It adds that the risks associated with SUMP cannot be adequately addressed simply by presenting it as a strategic response to China’s project.

The report calls for China to disclose essential technical information about the Medog project and share it with India and Bangladesh. It also recommends a trilateral basin consultation and a joint transboundary environmental impact assessment involving the countries affected by developments on the river.

Among its other recommendations, the report calls for India to establish an independent earth-observation and early-warning system for the Yarlung Tsangpo basin, using satellite capabilities to monitor landslides, seismic activity, glacial changes and potential river blockages.

It also recommends installing monitoring systems along the border at Gelling, Bishing and Tuting, alongside satellite-based surveillance and scientifically reviewed assessments of geological and hydrological risks.

Equally important, the authors emphasise that the concerns of indigenous communities in Arunachal Pradesh must be taken seriously before proceeding with the proposed SUMP.

The report concludes that the combination of geological instability, climate change, inadequate information-sharing arrangements and the absence of effective disaster-warning mechanisms makes the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang region one of the most dangerous locations in the world for constructing mega hydropower projects.

It says that the risks associated with the proposed Indian project could outweigh its promised benefits, particularly when the potential consequences for downstream communities, river ecosystems and livelihoods are taken into account.

Courtesy: CounterView

The post China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint https://sabrangindia.in/diwali-2026-smoke-noise-fires-and-the-failure-of-restraint/ Thu, 12 Nov 2026 07:43:15 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=50064 Across cities, Diwali celebrations brought severe pollution, excessive noise, fires, deaths and violence, the events raise questions about civic responsibility and enforcement: when existing rules repeatedly fail, what measures can ensure celebrations do not endanger others?

The post Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The Diwali night began with celebrations, but in several cities, it was followed by smoke, severe pollution and a large number of emergency calls. In Delhi, air quality deteriorated sharply as the evening progressed.

On November 8, at 10 pm, the city’s overall AQI stood at 371, while 20 monitoring stations were in the “severe” category. Smoke hung over roads and residential neighbourhoods, visibility dropped and residents reported difficulty breathing. The manner and method of India’s recording of pollution levels (AQI) is controversial. Independent platforms like AQI.in and IQAir reported morning readings between 600 and 610 (“hazardous”). The numbers differ because of Indian authorities/government playing around with statistics: India’s official National Air Quality Index (NAQI) caps its scale at 500 and averages data over 24 hours. Private trackers typically use the US EPA standard—which has stricter thresholds for fine particulate matter (\ (PM_ {2.5}\)) and no upper cap—and report real-time hourly spikes rather than 24-hour averages! So, in reality air quality in Delhi was worse than what was propagated.

Restrictions were ostensibly already in place, with green firecrackers permitted only during prescribed hours. Yet crackers continued to be burst in several parts of the city, and pollution continued to rise through the night. The following morning, Delhi recorded some of its worst pollution readings in years, with PM[1] 2.5 concentrations crossing 2,000 micrograms per cubic metre at several locations. At Mundka, the reading reached 3,744 µg/m³, while other stations recorded concentrations above 3,000.

The national 24-hour standard for PM 2.5 is 60 µg/m³[2].

These are not marginal departures from permissible levels. They clearly show the scale of pollution produced when a city already struggling with winter air quality enters a night of widespread firecracker bursting. AQI can be checked here: Link: https://www.aqi.in/in

When the monitors went silent

The pollution issue also raised serious questions about monitoring and public information. According to the Indian Express, on Diwali night, 45 of Delhi’s 59 monitoring stations had missing hourly readings for at least one pollutant. By midnight, 29 stations were not reporting some readings, and by 1 am the number had risen to 36. This was also the period when particulate pollution was peaking.

Data later released by the Delhi Pollution Control Committee showed that several of the missing periods coincided with extremely high concentrations. An analysis found that all 125 station-hour readings missing from the Central Pollution Control Board’s records were above 1,000 µg/m³ in the corresponding DPCC data, the Times of India reported.

The gaps matter because people cannot protect themselves from a danger whose extent is not being clearly recorded or publicly reflected during the period when exposure is at its highest.

Stubble burning cannot explain away everything

The issue of Delhi’s air pollution has often been reduced to one familiar explanation: farm fires and stubble burning. Crop-residue burning remains a serious source of pollution across the wider northern air shed. On Diwali day, Punjab recorded 1,152 farm fires, the highest single-day figure of the season, sharply increasing the state’s cumulative tally.

But acknowledging the contribution of stubble burning cannot explain away what happened within Delhi as evening celebrations intensified. The pollution surge followed sunset and continued through the night, with experts pointing to stagnant winter conditions combined with substantial firecracker emissions. At several locations, pollution levels rose sharply during the hours when crackers were being burst.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by The News Man (@thenews.man)

Mumbai also recorded sharp localised spikes after nightfall, while several inland cities in Maharashtra reported poor and very poor air quality. Pune, Pimpri-Chinchwad, Nagpur, Malegaon and other cities recorded serious deterioration.

The available evidence does not require a choice between farm fires and firecrackers. Both can contribute. The problem arises when one source is repeatedly invoked to minimise or divert attention from another.

Mumbai’s averages and the air people actually breathed

Mumbai initially appeared to have had a better Diwali, with its citywide AQI lower than during the corresponding period last year. But citywide averages concealed what was happening in individual neighbourhoods.

In Andheri, PM2.5 stood at 42 at 8 pm. Within two hours, it had surged to nearly 500 in one set of readings and even higher on private monitoring platforms.

Malad recorded similarly extreme levels, while Chembur saw PM10 concentrations of around 480. Other parts of the city also recorded sharp spikes after dark.

A citywide average may suggest improvement, but a resident does not breathe the city’s average. People breathe the air immediately around their homes, workplaces and neighbourhoods.

This is particularly important for children, elderly people and those already affected by respiratory or other health conditions.

The morning after Diwali brought little relief to several areas. Eight monitoring locations in Mumbai entered the “poor” category, with Bandra East among the worst affected.

Even the upper floors are not an escape

A study in Mumbai added another dimension to the problem of urban pollution. There is often an assumption that living high above the street means living above the worst of the city’s polluted air. The findings suggested otherwise.

According to a study by the Mumbai Ecological Research and Analysis Group (MERAG), across residential complexes in Wadala, upper floors of high-rises could be up to 40 per cent more polluted than lower levels. Researchers found a persistent increase in pollution with height in the buildings examined. Smoke and fine particles do not necessarily remain at street level. Air currents, distant emissions and complicated wind patterns created by clusters of high-rise buildings can carry and trap pollutants at higher elevations. For residents of increasingly vertical cities, moving higher may not always mean moving away from pollution.

Less noise, but still too much

There was one limited positive trend. Mumbai’s peak firecracker noise levels were reported to have fallen sharply compared with levels recorded two decades ago. A recent study found peak readings significantly lower than those recorded in 2006. \

But lower does not necessarily mean acceptable or safe.

A peak reading of around 93 decibels was still above permissible ambient noise limits for residential areas. Mumbai has notified silence zones where firecrackers are prohibited and restrictions also exist on bursting crackers late at night.

The purpose of these restrictions is not difficult to understand. An elderly person, a patient, an infant or someone seriously ill cannot simply choose to stop hearing explosions outside the home.

The issue is therefore not merely whether some people enjoy loud celebrations. It is whether others have any right to peace, rest and safety within their own homes.

That question lies at the heart of the larger problem.

Are appeals and restrictions enough?

For years, the response has largely followed a familiar pattern. Courts issue directions. Authorities prescribe timings. Green crackers are promoted. Silence zones are notified. Appeals are made for restraint.

Yet every year there are reports of violations.

But later, allowed certified green crackers in Delhi-NCR for two Diwali days.

On October 15, Bombay High Court had extended the total ban on bursting firecrackers on public streets, lanes, and footpaths to apply throughout the year and across all festivals, including Navratri, Diwali, and Christmas.

The question that now needs to be asked more directly is whether limited permissions and appeals to voluntary compliance can actually be enforced at the scale required in large Indian cities.

If the answer is repeatedly no, then the debate over stronger restrictions or prohibitions cannot simply be dismissed as hostility towards a festival.

A ban or prohibition is not automatically the answer. But if existing regulation repeatedly produces toxic air, excessive noise, injuries and deaths, the effectiveness of the present system must be honestly examined.

The question is whether India can have a Diwali that is celebratory without turning into a night when the elderly and sick live in dread of the next explosion.

A ten-year-old and a firecracker

In Delhi’s Narela, a ten-year-old boy died after a firecracker burst in his hands. He had reportedly been holding a flower-pot firecracker outside his home when it exploded.

The flames burned his chest, and his family initially believed the injury might be minor. He later fainted, was taken to hospital and declared dead. On the same Diwali, the Delhi Fire Services received 281 calls, with at least 24 related to fires caused by bursting crackers.

The danger is known. The repeated injuries are known. The risks of allowing children to handle firecrackers are known. Yet the question remains whether the knowledge of these dangers is reflected in how people actually behave.

Fires across the Mumbai region

In Mumbai, firecrackers were linked to 137 of the 142 fire calls received on Diwali. In Thane, all 44 fire calls received by Sunday night were reportedly caused by firecrackers.

Across the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, more than 500 fire incidents were reported over the weekend.

A day after Diwali, authorities in Mumbai, Nagpur and Thane imposed restrictions on rockets and similar aerial firecrackers following the surge in fire incidents.

In Mumbai, a lift operator died after being trapped as smoke spread through a high-rise building.

Other fires were also reported in residential and commercial structures.

The pattern again raises a question about regulation. Why do additional restrictions so often follow major incidents rather than preventing them?

Fifty people rescued in Thane

In Thane, a major fire engulfed a residential building during the Diwali night. Residents fled through smoke-filled passages, while some took shelter in balconies and utility ducts.

Around 50 people were rescued as the fire spread through several floors of the 17-storey building. An elderly resident described being trapped as flames and smoke spread, while others sheltered with ageing parents.

Firefighters worked through the night, while the exact cause was examined. The episode again demonstrated how vulnerable densely populated vertical cities can become when fire spreads through a residential building.

Thane’s fire services were also reportedly facing a serious manpower shortage, and firefighters from Mumbai had to be called in.

Cities have grown taller and more densely populated. The risks associated with fire have grown with them.

Two families, twelve deaths

In Madhya Pradesh, the scale of tragedy was even greater. Six members of a family were killed in a fire in Katni, including three children and a two-month-old infant.

The fire broke out in a residential-cum-commercial building, and the family was trapped upstairs as the blaze spread. A preliminary inquiry pointed to an earthen lamp as a possible source. The fire was fuelled by highly inflammable material stored below, while rescue teams struggled for hours to save those trapped inside. The district collector later apologised to families and residents, acknowledging that six lives could not be saved despite the deployment of fire tenders.

On the same night, another fire in Seoni killed six members of another family. In both cases, families were asleep when the fires spread.

Twelve people from two families were dead, including children, elderly people and members of different generations.

The other problem: how do we live with one another?

The pollution and fires are one part of the story. The other is the increasingly visible absence of civic restraint. Firecrackers are burst inside housing societies, near parked vehicles, beneath balconies and beside buildings occupied by hundreds of residents.

Those who do not wish to participate have little control over what happens around them.

An elderly person cannot prevent smoke from entering the home. A family with an infant cannot control where a rocket will land. A patient cannot necessarily escape a night of explosions by simply closing a window.

The issue is not whether people have a right to celebrate. It is whether celebration gives anyone the right to disregard the safety and peace of those living around them.

This is a question of civic sense and shared urban life.

One argument, one death

In Mumbai, a dispute connected with firecrackers ended in the death of a 19-year-old. Shubhankar Mukhiya and his friends were heading towards Juhu beach when crackers were burst near a parked motorcycle.

An argument followed. According to police, the motorcycle belonged to one of the accused, and the confrontation initially appeared to have ended.

Police alleged that the accused later returned with two others and that Mukhiya and his friends were attacked with kicks and punches. Mukhiya fell, suffered a severe head injury and later died.

A disagreement over firecrackers had escalated into an alleged fatal assault.

The question is not simply what caused the argument. It is why an increasingly ordinary disagreement in public life can so quickly become an occasion for violence.

Violence around the celebration

In Delhi, another teenager did not return home from a Diwali outing. Sixteen-year-old Devansh had reportedly gone out with friends to buy crackers.

Police said that a group of men allegedly tried to snatch his money and phone. When he resisted, he was stabbed and later died after being taken to hospital. The circumstances were different from the Mumbai case, but both the incidents form part of a larger and troubling picture of aggression in public spaces. Diwali is meant to be a festival of homes, families and communities. Yet the night also produced fights, assaults and confrontations.

When those enforcing the rules are attacked

There is another dimension to the problem. Rules are meaningful only if someone can enforce them. When police personnel or other officials attempt to enforce restrictions on firecrackers, noise or public safety, they can themselves become targets of hostility or violence.

The image of a lone policeman attempting to enforce a rule, while facing an aggressive crowd or being attacked, raises a basic question about civic conduct. What does it say about respect for law when a person performing a public duty becomes the object of anger merely for attempting to enforce regulations?

The issue cannot be reduced to firecrackers alone. It concerns a wider relationship between citizens, public authority and shared rules.

Are we becoming an insensate and uncivil society?

This is the more difficult question raised by the events surrounding Diwali. Are Indians becoming increasingly insensitive to the effect of their actions on those living around them? Are we becoming more aggressive, less restrained and less willing to accept even the most basic rules of shared civic life?

The evidence of one festival cannot answer such a large question by itself. But it can expose a pattern.

Smoke is treated as someone else’s problem. Noise is treated as a neighbour’s problem. A falling rocket is treated as an accident waiting to happen somewhere else.

Rules are often accepted in principle but resented when they are enforced against us. And when a disagreement arises, too often the response is not restraint but aggression.

The old, the sick and the very young have little power in this situation. They cannot negotiate with the person bursting crackers outside their home. The person who chooses silence cannot impose it on the person who chooses noise.

The family that follows the rules cannot guarantee that its neighbours will do the same.

Urban life requires restraint

Living in a crowded city necessarily requires limits.

A person living in a high-rise, an apartment block or a densely populated neighbourhood does not live in isolation. Every action takes place close to someone else.

That is why urban life requires civic restraint.

It requires recognising that a celebration in one flat can become a disturbance in another, and that an act carried out for pleasure can impose danger or suffering on someone who has not chosen to participate.

This is not an argument against celebration.

It is an argument against the belief that celebration means freedom from responsibility.

The question before the next Diwali

The Diwali of 2026 again demonstrated the limits of relying only on appeals, partial restrictions and voluntary compliance.

Court directions and institutional controls remain important, but they are meaningful only when they can be implemented and enforced.

The debate must therefore move beyond the familiar argument between those who want unrestricted celebrations and those who seek restrictions.

The more practical question is what actually works.

Can limited permissions, prescribed timings and appeals to civic sense deliver a genuinely safer and less polluted Diwali?

If they cannot, should authorities consider stronger restrictions, clearer prohibitions and designated spaces where activities involving serious risks can be more effectively controlled?

A saner Diwali should not be impossible to imagine.

It should not be a night when elderly people and patients dread the next explosion, when children lose their lives, when homes and high-rises catch fire, or when those attempting to enforce the rules face violence.

What the Diwali night left behind

A ten-year-old died after a firecracker burst in his hands. A 19-year-old died after an argument connected with crackers escalated into an alleged assault, while another teenager was stabbed after going out to buy Diwali crackers.

Hundreds of fire calls were received across the Mumbai region, around 50 people were rescued from a burning high-rise in Thane, and twelve members of two families died in separate fires in Madhya Pradesh.

Delhi’s pollution monitors developed gaps as particulate levels surged, while corresponding data later showed some readings in the thousands.

Mumbai’s overall air quality appeared better in aggregate, but individual neighbourhoods recorded dramatic spikes after dark. Noise levels may have fallen over the years, but they continued to exceed permissible limits.

The festival has passed, but the questions remain.

What kind of institutional controls can actually ensure compliance? Is a stronger prohibition necessary where limited regulation repeatedly fails? And what does our conduct during these celebrations say about our capacity to live with consideration for others?

These are not questions about whether people should celebrate their festivals.

They are questions about how they celebrate them, and whether celebration can coexist with civic responsibility, public safety and respect for the people living around us.

A festival cannot become an occasion when the old and sick live in dread, young lives are lost, public spaces turn violent and even those attempting to enforce the law face aggression.

The smoke, noise, fires and violence of this Diwali should force a more serious conversation before the next one arrives.


 

[1] PM means Particulate Matter (also known as particle pollution), which is a mix of microscopic solid particles and liquid droplets suspended in the air).

[2] µg/m³ stands for micrograms per cubic meter and measures the mass concentration of a pollutant in a specific volume of air.

 

Related:

Diwali has been celebrated by Muslims for centuries

Toxic Air To Blame For Lung Cancer; No Longer Just A Smoker’s Disease

The post Diwali 2026: Smoke, noise, fires and the failure of restraint appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Climate change accounts for just 3.3% of Indian parliamentary questions over the past decade: Study https://sabrangindia.in/climate-change-accounts-for-just-3-3-of-indian-parliamentary-questions-over-the-past-decade-study/ Tue, 03 Nov 2026 04:52:53 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49938 A comprehensive new report published in September 2026 reveals that climate change has remained a marginal concern in the Indian Parliament despite the country’s growing vulnerability to extreme weather events. The study, titled India’s Parliamentary Discourse on Environment since the Paris Agreement, analyzed legislative engagement over the first ten years following the 2015 Paris Agreement. […]

The post Climate change accounts for just 3.3% of Indian parliamentary questions over the past decade: Study appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>

A comprehensive new report published in September 2026 reveals that climate change has remained a marginal concern in the Indian Parliament despite the country’s growing vulnerability to extreme weather events. The study, titled India’s Parliamentary Discourse on Environment since the Paris Agreement, analyzed legislative engagement over the first ten years following the 2015 Paris Agreement.

Authored by Hajira Puthige and published by the Centre for Financial Accountability (CFA), the report examined a dataset of 8,702 parliamentary questions raised in both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha between December 2015 and December 2025.

The findings highlight a significant gap between the urgency of the climate crisis and the political attention it receives. According to the research, climate-related inquiries accounted for only 3.3 percent of all parliamentary questions asked over the decade. The study notes that legislative interest is heavily concentrated on Clean Energy and Decarbonisation, which made up 33.81 percent of the environmental questions. This focus aligns with what the report describes as prestige-heavy international targets.

Conversely, the study identifies severe blind spots in parliamentary scrutiny. Questions related to Climate Finance and Markets accounted for a mere 0.26 percent of the total, while Global Climate Governance represented just 1.2 percent. Forests and Land Use followed clean energy with 16.81 percent, and Extreme Weather and Natural Disasters took up 15.94 percent of the inquiries.

The report also sheds light on the partisan nature of these discussions. It found that ruling party members predominantly raise status-oriented questions designed to highlight and celebrate government programs. In contrast, opposition members tend to focus on implementation gaps, accountability, and the actual impact of climate policies on the ground.

Furthermore, the study is highly critical of the government’s responses to these parliamentary inquiries, accusing the administration of favoring public relations over substantive action. According to the study, the government consistently prioritises technological optics, such as the Flood Watch India App and the Van Agni portal, as evidence of action. Yet, it often lacks operational benchmarking; for instance, the Ministry has admitted to having no nationally benchmarked firefighting systems despite tracking fires with satellite precision.

When it comes to the health impacts of environmental degradation, the government has repeatedly pushed back against direct accountability. In response to questions linking air pollution to mortality, official replies frequently state that there is no conclusive data available to establish a direct correlation of death exclusively due to air pollution. The study notes that the Executive consistently maintains that there is no conclusive data available to establish a direct correlation of death or disease exclusively due to air pollution, citing overlapping factors like diet and lifestyle, thereby limiting the attribution of health outcomes exclusively to air pollution.

The study also reveals significant data gaps acknowledged by the state, noting that there is no established study for India providing a quantified contribution of climate change triggering displacement of people.

Despite calls from lawmakers for stronger legislative frameworks, the study finds that the Executive has consistently rejected proposals for a dedicated Climate Change Act or the formation of a high-power committee on climate. Instead, the government has maintained that the existing Environmental Protection Act is sufficient to handle the crisis.

As India continues to face escalating climate risks, the report concludes that current parliamentary discussions do not yet reflect the level of ambition and scrutiny that the climate crisis demands. The transition from reactive disaster responses to strategic, well-funded climate policies remains a significant challenge for the world’s largest democracy.

Courtesy: CounterView

The post Climate change accounts for just 3.3% of Indian parliamentary questions over the past decade: Study appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
From Arunachal to Delhi, anti-dam protesters face state crackdown; detained allege sexual assault https://sabrangindia.in/from-arunachal-to-delhi-anti-dam-protesters-face-state-crackdown-detained-allege-sexual-assault/ Mon, 02 Nov 2026 12:34:25 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49917 Around 40 protesters from Arunachal Pradesh were detained during a solidarity demonstration, as the crackdown on indigenous resistance to the proposed mega dam intensifies

The post From Arunachal to Delhi, anti-dam protesters face state crackdown; detained allege sexual assault appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The resistance against the proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) in Arunachal Pradesh has now reached the national capital. On Saturday, November 1, Delhi Police detained around 40 students, indigenous youths and activists who had assembled outside Arunachal Bhawan to oppose the proposed mega dam and demand the release of those arrested during the ongoing anti-dam movement in Arunachal Pradesh. The detention was accompanied by disturbing allegations of police brutality, including physical and sexual assault of protesters.

The demonstration, organised by Himkhand and Youth for Change (YFC) Arunachal, sought to draw attention to the escalating crackdown on indigenous communities opposing the proposed 11,200-MW project. Protesters were demanding the withdrawal of the project, the release of anti-dam activists and villagers arrested in Arunachal Pradesh, the withdrawal of criminal cases against them and the removal of Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) personnel deployed in the Siang region.

According to accounts shared by protesters with Maktoob Media, the demonstration had barely continued for 15 minutes before Delhi Police personnel began forcibly detaining participants. Among those detained was Katon Moyong, popularly known as Abor Man, an environmental engineer and prominent voice in the anti-dam movement in Arunachal Pradesh. Protesters alleged that Moyong was manhandled during his detention, reportedly while interacting with the media.

The allegations of mistreatment extended beyond physical force. Vagheesha, a member of Himkhand who participated in the demonstration, alleged that several protesters were subjected to sexual assault and inappropriate touching by police personnel while being detained.

“My shirt was lifted, I was pinched on my private parts and brutally pushed into the buses,” Vagheesha said, describing the treatment meted out to protesters. The activist maintained that indigenous people from Arunachal Pradesh had travelled to the national capital to exercise their democratic rights and raise concerns about their ancestral land, only to face police brutality. In a video statement recorded while being taken away in a police vehicle, another Himkhand member alleged that protesters had been beaten and sexually assaulted. The protesters also said that police personnel did not initially disclose where they were being taken.

 

The manner in which the detentions were carried out raised further concerns. Speaking to Maktoob, Kranti, another Himkhand member, said that three police vehicles transported protesters to different locations. Seven students from the Northeast were taken to Chanakyapuri Police Station, while other detainees were reportedly taken towards Najafgarh, near the Delhi-Haryana border. Men and women were separated during the process. An independent journalist, Baksheesh Lamba, was also allegedly picked up during the operation and taken away in a separate vehicle. Kranti said that Lamba was subsequently unreachable and that protesters had no information about his whereabouts.

 

According to the organisation, around 40 people had been detained, with approximately 25-30 protesters initially remaining at Baba Haridas Nagar Police Station. Himkhand further alleged that women protesters continued to be detained late into the night and that detainees were asked to sign forms under Section 35(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).

 

Lawyers representing the detainees reportedly waited outside the police stations as families and fellow activists attempted to establish contact with those in custody. Delhi Police had been approached for a response to the allegations of assault and arbitrary detention, but no response had been received at the time of the initial reports.

All protesters released after Congress intervention

All the Arunachal Pradesh youths and students detained during the Delhi demonstration have since been released following the intervention of senior Congress leaders. According to Echo of Arunachal, Arunachal Pradesh Congress Committee (APCC) president Bosiram Siram, accompanied by All India Congress Committee (AICC) in-charges for Arunachal Pradesh Dr A. Chellakumar and advocate Mathew Antony, visited Chanakyapuri Police Station after learning about the detentions. The leaders intervened with police authorities to secure the release of the protesters.

Around 40 young people had reportedly been detained and taken to three different police stations across Delhi. Their release brought immediate relief to the detainees and their families, but it does little to address the larger questions surrounding the police action, particularly the allegations of sexual assault and the circumstances in which the protesters were picked up.

Reacting to the development, Siram said that the voices of Arunachal Pradesh’s people could not be ignored and that young people must be allowed to exercise their constitutional right to peaceful protest. He stressed that concerns relating to land, identity, livelihoods, the environment and the future of indigenous communities must be heard rather than suppressed.

The APCC had earlier condemned the detentions, demanding that the police disclose the legal grounds for taking protesters into custody, communicate their whereabouts to their families and ensure that no peaceful demonstrator faced intimidation or harassment. The party also called for transparent engagement with affected communities, indigenous organisations, student bodies and civil society groups before the government proceeds with further activities related to SUMP.

 

The crackdown in Arunachal Pradesh that brought protesters to Delhi

The demonstration outside Arunachal Bhawan was not an isolated protest. It was an extension of a growing movement against the proposed dam, which has faced sustained opposition from sections of the indigenous Adi and Galo communities in the Siang region. On October 23, youth groups and local organisations had called for a 12-hour bandh across Siang, Upper Siang and East Siang districts to oppose the proposed project. The demonstration in Pasighat subsequently turned violent, with police deploying tear gas and stun grenades as tensions escalated. Angry protesters allegedly vandalised and set fire to police vehicles, an NHPC office and the residences of political leaders, including local BJP MLAs and the state BJP president.

Following the violence, the Arunachal Pradesh government intensified its security deployment and initiated arrests under stringent provisions, including the Arunachal Pradesh Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (APUAPA). Ddozens of people had been arrested or detained, while families raised concerns that the police action had also affected ordinary residents and people who had participated in peaceful demonstrations. The deployment of additional security personnel in the region, reportedly including more than 30 companies of CAPF personnel, has further heightened tensions. The security presence has been linked to efforts to facilitate preliminary project-related exercises, including the preparation of a Pre-Feasibility Report (PFR).

The crackdown has also reportedly extended to government employees and traditional village institutions. The Arunachal Pradesh Congress Committee has expressed concern over the suspension of government employees and action against gaon buras, or traditional village headmen, who have opposed the project.

Detailed report may be read here.

Why indigenous communities are resisting SUMP

The Siang Upper Multipurpose Project, being pursued by the Centre through the National Hydroelectric Power Corporation (NHPC), is envisaged as one of India’s largest hydropower and multipurpose storage initiatives. Its proposed capacity has been reported at approximately 11,200 MW. The Centre has repeatedly invoked strategic, water-security and flood-management considerations to justify the project, particularly in the context of China’s proposed large hydropower development on the Yarlung Tsangpo river in Tibet, which flows into India as the Siang.

However, for the indigenous communities living along the river, the proposed project is not merely an infrastructure or energy-policy question. It concerns the possible destruction of ancestral settlements, displacement, loss of agricultural land and forests, ecological disruption and the erosion of a way of life closely connected to the river.

Reports have indicated that as many as 27 villages could face submergence, with several dozen more potentially affected by the project. For the Adi community, the Siang, traditionally revered as Ane Siang, or Mother Siang, is central to cultural memory, identity, livelihoods and community life. The prospect of a massive dam on the river has therefore generated opposition that cannot be reduced to a disagreement over the technical feasibility of a development project.

Organisations such as the Siang Indigenous Farmers’ Forum (SIFF), Adi Bane Kebang United and various student and youth groups have consistently questioned the project and demanded that the concerns and consent of affected communities be taken seriously.

Chief Minister Pema Khandu has maintained that the government is presently seeking cooperation only for the preparation of the PFR and that the project will not be imposed without public consultation. However, activists have questioned how meaningful public consultation can take place when people opposing the project are being arrested, criminal cases are being registered against them, and security forces are being deployed in areas where the project is proposed. SIFF spokesperson Tagori Mize has also questioned the government’s willingness to engage in genuine dialogue while protesters remain behind bars, and security deployment continues.

Congress demands withdrawal of project and action against protesters

The Arunachal Pradesh Congress Committee has demanded that the proposed SUMP be scrapped and all those arrested for opposing it be released. It has also called for the withdrawal of cases registered against protesters under APUAPA, the revocation of suspension orders against government employees and the withdrawal of action against traditional village headmen.

The party has maintained that no development project should proceed at the expense of indigenous communities’ ancestral land, identity, culture and livelihoods. It has called for the removal of additional security personnel from affected areas, compensation for those who have suffered losses and medical assistance and rehabilitation for injured protesters.

In a statement, the APCC emphasised that the government’s assurances about public consultation must translate into actual democratic engagement. It argued that strategic considerations cannot become a justification for disregarding indigenous rights or bypassing the principle of free, prior and informed consent (FPIC). The party has also urged the Centre and the Arunachal Pradesh government to restore peace through dialogue and confidence-building measures, rather than treating opposition to the project as a law-and-order problem.

“Different groups but one voice; different organisations but one collective resolve — Stop SUMP, Save Siang,” the APCC said in its appeal for solidarity among indigenous organisations, student unions, youth groups, civil society organisations and traditional institutions.

 

Related:

Arunachal’s anti-dam protests intensify as arrests, militarisation and threats to press freedom fail to silence resistance

From treating Adivasi communities to being branded an instigator: Odisha jails doctor Randall Sequeira

Assam NRC: Seven years after 19 lakh people were excluded, rejection slips remain a non-starter

Christian families assaulted, humiliated and forced into Durga Puja rituals in West Bengal village

“Pradhan Helped BJP Win Odisha, Gyanesh Is Helping It Win India” | Aishe Ghosh | Teesta Setalvad 

The post From Arunachal to Delhi, anti-dam protesters face state crackdown; detained allege sexual assault appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Stop construction of Vadhavan Port, have open discussions with local communities: Climate change activists https://sabrangindia.in/stop-construction-of-vadhavan-port-have-open-discussions-with-local-communities-climate-change-activists/ Tue, 22 Sep 2026 07:35:51 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49401 Arguing that the Vadhavan Port Project in Maharashtra has not emerged from the needs of the local communities, and instead threatens the livelihoods of fisher folk, Adivasi lands, agriculture and orchards, the sea, and coastal biodiversity, the NAPM has demanded that the project “should be scrapped immediately”

The post Stop construction of Vadhavan Port, have open discussions with local communities: Climate change activists appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Pointing to the serious impact of climate change becoming serious in the coastal areas, building such massive port projects will have far-reaching consequences for both food security and health said the National Alliance of People’s Movements (NAPM) that has, after a series of interactions with local communities, demanded that the Vadhavan Port project be scrapped immediately. On the contrary, says the collective, the project threatens the livelihoods of fisherfolk, Adivasi lands, agriculture and orchards, the sea, and coastal biodiversity.

On September 19t and 20 2026, representatives of NAPM from Maharashtra and several other states across the country met and interacted with fisherfolk, Adivasis, farmers, die-makers, landless people, workers, and other affected communities in the Vadhavan area.

The Vadhavan Port project proposes to reclaim approximately 1,448 hectares of the sea to create land. In addition, large areas of land will be required for roads, railways, and other associated infrastructure. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has publicly stated that Vadhavan Port will transform Maharashtra’s economy, turn Palghar into a “Fourth Mumbai,” and create lakhs of jobs. But the fisherfolk, Adivasis, farmers, die-makers, and other local communities protesting along the Vadhavan coast do not want a form of development that destroys their lives and livelihoods.

The proposal for a port in the Vadhavan area had been questioned earlier as well on environmental grounds. Today, various agencies of the Union and State governments are taking the project forward. Yet the environmental and social concerns raised earlier remain unresolved, even as the scale of the project has expanded many times over. The experience of JNPT and other ports must be studied – including the traffic, urbanisation, pollution, impacts on fishing, and expansion of infrastructure that they have brought to coastal areas – and an independent assessment of the overall impacts of Vadhavan must be carried out. The damage already witnessed elsewhere should serve as a grave warning.

“We do not want a Fourth Mumbai. Our sea, our farms, our forests and our villages must remain as they are!”

With this demand, communities across the area have united under the leadership of the Vadhavan Bandar Virodhi Sangharsh Samiti to oppose the port. Beyond the port itself, the project entails approximately 1,448 hectares of marine reclamation, over 10 kilometres of breakwater, large-scale dredging, road and rail connectivity, storage and logistics infrastructure, and industrial and commercial development. In other words, this is a project that will transform the entire coastline. In NAPM’s view, this is not a chain of development, but a chain of destruction. The government speaks of an investment of Rs. 76,220 crore and the creation of lakhs of jobs. But alongside government agencies, major international port, terminal, logistics, and dredging operators are participating in this project. Who, then, will count the cost to the generations-old livelihoods of local fisherfolk, Adivasis, farmers, and small producers?

According to government studies, the 16 fishing villages in the project area are home to 20,809 fisherfolk belonging to 5,333 households. Fishing is the principal livelihood of these communities. Skill training or compensation of a few lakh rupees cannot replace the sea for a fisher. Traditional fishing, local fish resources – including lobster – and the entire economy built around them must be protected. Vadhavan lies within the ecologically sensitive Dahanu region. The cumulative impacts of massive marine reclamation, dredging, and the breakwater on sea currents, sediment movement, fishing grounds, and tidal ecosystems must be examined seriously.

A fundamental question remains: Have the traditional knowledge of local communities, their lived experience of the sea, and data on local biodiversity been adequately reflected in these studies?

If mangrove areas are affected, marine ecosystems could be destroyed. Such ecosystems are nearly impossible to recreate elsewhere, making their protection and conservation critically important. The impacts of sourcing material for Vadhavan’s reclamation and associated infrastructure – including quarrying in hilly areas, impacts on Adivasi areas, and deforestation – must also be taken into account. Cutting down a forest in one place and planting trees in another district cannot compensate for the loss of that ecosystem.

Official information indicates that private land, Adivasi land, forest land, and government land will be required for the roads and railways connecting the port. The impact of the project will therefore not remain confined to the port area. For Adivasi communities, land cultivated over generations is the very basis of survival. We cannot accept taking away these lands in the name of development – blasting hills, cutting forests, and dumping reclamation material, and calling this “development.”

It is misleading to present Vadhavan as simply a “container port.” According to official documents, it is a deep-draft major port with the capacity to handle bulk chemical and crude cargo in addition to containers. Under the Central Pollution Control Board’s classification, ports, harbours, jetties, and dredging operations fall under the Red Category, while ports handling only containers fall under the Orange Category.

Government documents claim a sea depth of 20 metres. However, the local Sangharsh Samiti says that measurements taken at low tide found the depth to be lower. Activists say that although this issue was raised during the public hearing, no satisfactory response was provided.

The NAPM has demanded:

—Put a halt to the Vadhavan Port project immediately.

—Immediately halt tree-felling and all related infrastructure works.

—-Conduct an independent and transparent cumulative impact assessment, with the participation of local fisherfolk, Adivasis, farmers, and women.

 

—-Independently re-measure the depth of the sea, including verification of the claim of a 20-metre depth. The exercise must be public and conducted in the presence of local communities.

—-Protect the generations-old livelihoods of fisherfolk. Traditional fishing must not be destroyed in the name of compensation or alternative employment.

—Protect Adivasi land and forests, and safeguard all their legal rights, including rights under PESA.

—-Protect the local ecosystem instead of afforestation in distant districts as compensation for the destruction of local forests.

—-Instead of imposing uncontrolled urbanization in the name of a “Fourth Mumbai,” establish schools, colleges, hospitals, healthcare services, and employment opportunities based on the needs of the local people.

Finally, the statement issued by NAPM states that the people’s movement at Vadhavan is not a struggle against one port alone. It is a struggle to defend the coastline, fisherfolk and Adivasi communities, agriculture, forests, and biodiversity.

“The people of Vadhavan do want development – they want schools, a college, hospitals and doctors; they want markets for their agriculture and horticulture; fisherfolk need facilities and fair prices; and young people need dignified employment in their own region.

“NAPM stands firmly with the Vadhavan Bandar Virodhi Sangharsh Samiti and with the fisherfolk, Adivasis, and local communities fighting this project. We reject a model of development built by destroying the sea, forests, land, and livelihoods.NAPM appeals to people’s movements across the country to express their solidarity with the sit-in protest that has now continued for the past 48 days.”

NAPM has been part of this struggle, which has continued for several decades, from the very beginning. Medha Patkar, the late Thomas Kocherry, Rambhau Patil, N. D. Koli and many other activists have stood with this struggle over the years.

The statement has been issued by Sanjay Mangala Gopal, Suniti S. R – National Convenors (from Maharashtra), Sujay More, Sirat Satpute, Maharashtra State Convenors. The Solidarity Team Members include Prasad Chacko, Ahmedabad; Pranjali Tripathi, Jaipur; Adv. Mini Mathew, Bandra; Siddharth Chakravarti, Bengaluru; Sakshi Samant, Thane; Nandkumar Pawar, Mumbai; Ramesh Koli, Uran; Mangesh Koli, Uran; Mayur Koli, Uran; Dhananjay Shinde; Rajshree Shinde, Mumbai


Related:

Dahanu locals reject JNPT survey that pushes for a new port at Vadhavan

Maharashtra’s fishing community fights to protect its ‘golden belt’ coast

50,000 strong Adivasi, farmers march from Charoti to Palghar, hold indefinite dharna for land rights

The post Stop construction of Vadhavan Port, have open discussions with local communities: Climate change activists appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Climate, riverine & indigenous movements from across India express full solidarity with the democratic anti-dam struggle in Arunachal Pradesh https://sabrangindia.in/climate-riverine-indigenous-movements-from-across-india-express-full-solidarity-with-the-democratic-anti-dam-struggle-in-arunachal-pradesh/ Mon, 21 Sep 2026 11:11:37 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49389 India-wide networks call for an end to intimidation of activists Bhanu Tatak, Ebo Mili, SIFF and the Siang People’s Movement

The post Climate, riverine & indigenous movements from across India express full solidarity with the democratic anti-dam struggle in Arunachal Pradesh appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The National Alliance of People’s Movements (NAPM), National Alliance for Climate and Ecological Justice (NACEJ) and All-India Rivers’ Forum (AIRF) have, in a clear statement, expressed their strong solidarity with the people of Arunachal Pradesh, who, in the forums view, “are resisting the forcible imposition of multiple mega-dam projects on their ancestral lands, rivers and forests. Ther solidarity also extends to the Siang Indigenous Farmers’ Forum (SIFF) and environmental lawyers and activists Bhanu Tatak and Ebo Mili, who have stood firmly with affected communities in their struggles to save their lands, forests and cultures.”

In this context, the NAPM, the NACEJ and the AIRF have stated that they see the recent case registered by CBI against Ms. Bhanu Tatak, as part of a series of repressive measures by the Government over years, to quell democratic resistance by the indigenous communities and farmers. The FIR by CBI against Bhanu, which alleges violations of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010 (FCRA), state the NAPM and NACEJ, “is a means of intimidating, discrediting and weakening a peaceful people’s movement.” The nationwide forums have saluted the Siang Indigenous Farmers Forum Youth Wing (SIFFYW) that has resolutely stood with Bhanu, in the face of intimidation and divisive tactics of the Government, calling her true daughter of the Abor land. 

Instead of dialoguing with the local communities and wider Siang people’s movement, it is unjustifiable that an FCRA investigation has been instituted as an instrument of intimidation against Ms. Bhanu Tatak, a young woman indigenous leader, reads the detailed statement. “The timing and circumstances of this FIR are particularly troubling because they come amidst intensified efforts to advance surveys and pre-feasibility activities for the Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP), in the backdrop of sustained opposition from affected communities.”

Most crucially, the networks of people’s organisations have emphasised that a democratic people’s movement cannot be treated as a ‘security problem’ by the government.  In this context, the much criticised “FCRA is being increasingly weaponised to intimidate people’s organizations and harass their leaders. It is in fact the free flow of foreign funding for toxic infrastructure projects enabled by the Government (for ex. the disastrous SHANTI Act to privatize nuclear power generation) that poses a major risk to the people and environment in India. It is such decisions of the Government that need to be strongly questioned.”

Background: A retrospective amendment to the FCRA Act, 2010 through the Finance Bill, 2016, validated the foreign funds received by political parties after September 26, 2010. To avoid scrutiny before this date, the Government introduced another amendment in the Finance Act, 2018 to cover the period beginning August 5, 1976 – the date the original FCRA law came into existence. These amendments were done to counter a landmark judgement of the Delhi High Court in 2014, in a case filed by EAS Sarma and the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR). The judgement found that the BJP and INC had taken donations from Vedanta & its subsidiaries, registered in England and Wales. 

The central question that people’s movements are asking today is: When a political party illegally takes foreign funds from corporates, is found guilty, amends the law to legalize its actions, and then weaponizes the FCRA to intimidate people’s movements, which are legitimately and democratically protesting the terrible environmental and social cost of ill-conceived projects, which only benefit corporates in the name of ‘development’, who is actually guilty of taking foreign funds to harm the interests of the country?

For years, communities of the Siang valley have raised fundamental objections to mega-dam construction. The proposed SUMP – described as a 12,500 MW project in recent reporting, would have profound implications for ancestral settlements, forests, agricultural land, riverine ecosystems and the cultural landscape of the indigenous Adi people. The opposition to these projects is neither ‘sudden’ nor an ‘externally manufactured phenomenon’. Resistance to large dams in the Siang basin has a history stretching back decades. Academic research published in 2025-26 documents the long-standing conflict between state-led hydropower development and indigenous communities in the valley.

The communities have repeatedly been at the forefront of the opposition. In 2025, villagers and the SIFF protested the deployment of Central Armed Police Forces in and around areas where SUMP-related pre-feasibility activities were being undertaken. Reports documented the presence of armed forces in multiple villages like Beging, Geku, Yingkiong and Boleng, while project-affected communities demanded their withdrawal. In September 2026, SIFF again publicly objected to the deployment of security forces for SUMP-related PFR activities and reported that project-affected families were demanding both the withdrawal of security forces from the villages and reversal of actions against community-level representatives.

Outlining in detail this background to how state power and the deliberate weaponisation of the FCRA law is being used to criminalise legitimate citizen’s protests, interventions and activity, the NAPM, the NACEJ and the AIRF have given detailed reasons for the reasoning behind this statement.

“Villages inhabited by citizens of India should not become militarized spaces simply because their inhabitants oppose a harmful “development” project. The presence of armed personnel around communities resisting a dam creates an unmistakable atmosphere of coercion. It risks transforming a question of democratic consent, indigenous rights, ecological protection and displacement into a question of law-and-order and national security. That is a completely wrong and unconstitutional approach.

“The Siang is not an ‘empty valley’.  For the Adi people, the Siang is not merely a water resource waiting to be converted into electricity. The river, forests, mountains and agricultural landscapes constitute an interconnected living cultural and ecological system. The Adi community has described the Siang as ‘Ane Siang‘ – the sacred river. The Adi Bane Kebang has also demanded the scrapping of SUMP and withdrawal of the Central Armed Police Forces deployed for project-related activities.

“Project-affected communities have repeatedly raised concerns over displacement, loss of ancestral land, destruction of forests, disruption of livelihoods and damage to cultural identity. Independent research also records the profound importance of these territories to indigenous agro-ecological systems and cultural continuity.

“Reports have also documented opposition to other mega-dam projects across Arunachal Pradesh, including projects in the Dibang and Siang/Siyom river systems. The experience of the Dibang Multipurpose Project, where indigenous communities have long resisted the project because of its implications for forests, land and livelihoods, should be a warning against repeating the same model of ‘development’ elsewhere.

“Consent cannot be replaced by force. We strongly reject the proposition that ‘development’ can be secured by deploying military personnel first and seeking people’s ‘consent’ later. If the government claims that local communities genuinely ‘support’ SUMP or similar mega-dam projects (as the govt propaganda states), the answer is simple:  Let the affected communities speak freely. And let their views and rights be respected and given precedence, instead of the vested interests of the dam-builders and corporations.”

Hence the forums have demanded:

  • An immediate end to all oppressive measures against the local communities, SIFF, Bhanu Tatak, Ebo Mili and other community leaders and activists, including by misuse of the FCRA law against Bhanu Tatak.
  • Immediate withdrawal of all armed forces / military personnel from the indigenous villages, de-militarization and restoration of space for democratic participation by communities in Government decisions that affect their livelihoods, ecology and futures.
  • Free, fair and transparent public consultations at the village level must be held in the presence of neutral observers.
  • Revocation of all clearances and permissions granted to the hydro-electric and power projects in the region, in violation of law and democratic processes.


Related:

Voices of resistance: Indigenous peoples’ struggle against the Siang Mega-Dam in Arunachal Pradesh

Arunachal Pradesh University students join protests against CAB; Show Support to NESO

The post Climate, riverine & indigenous movements from across India express full solidarity with the democratic anti-dam struggle in Arunachal Pradesh appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Prioritise ecological security of country over “false narrative” of “highway development”: CCG to Govt & Courts https://sabrangindia.in/prioritise-ecological-security-of-country-over-false-narrative-of-highway-development-ccg-to-govt-courts/ Thu, 17 Sep 2026 13:38:21 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49346 Former bureaucrats protest the “steady lowering of statutory safeguards for protecting India’s Environment and Forests” in an open letter to the government; both government and the judiciary need to prioritise the ecological security of our country and the health and life of its citizens over the false narrative of more roads, more buildings, more townships, more mines, more industries, more destruction of the natural world that is currently seen as progress.

The post Prioritise ecological security of country over “false narrative” of “highway development”: CCG to Govt & Courts appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
The diversion of 215,943 hectares (ha) of forestland for non-forest use during the period from 2014–15 to 2025–26 by express government approval, as declared before Parliament in July 2026 has been contested and protested by a group of civil servants, the Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG) in an open letter to government dated September 17. The group former civil servants of the All India and Central Services who have worked with the Central and State Governments in the course of their careers has stated that nearly 62 per cent of this land (diverted 215,943 hectares) was cleared for mining, hydropower, irrigation and road projects. The pace of forest diversion has accelerated sharply in recent years.

Stating that they are deeply dismayed at the recent reports of large scale, state driven deforestation due to diversion of forestlands for developmental projects, the open letter cites a July 2026, reply of the Minister of State for Environment, Forest and Climate Change in response to a Parliament question. Further, the communication states that, in the five years from 2014–15 to 2018–19, a total of 74,705.68 ha of forestland was approved for diversion. In the next five-year period from 2019–20 to 2023–24, this increased, by nearly 29 per cent, to 96,112.90 hectares. If the current pace continues, forest land diversion during the next five years is likely to exceed 110,000 hectares. Besides, the increase in deforestation is most evident in the ecologically sensitive Himalayan and North Eastern states, in Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, etc. And many other proposals are in the offing, the most appalling of them being the cutting down of nearly a million trees, over 13000 hectares of rainforest in Great Nicobar Island.

The communication also emphasises that, the compensatory afforestation that is expected to be undertaken for the diversion of these forest areas is either not undertaken or if undertaken is almost never successful. The proposals are also, often, ludicrous, e.g. taking up compensatory afforestation for the rainforests of Great Nicobar in dry Haryana, 4500 km away.

Within this alarming trend, of particular concern is the fact that lands within National Parks and Wildlife Sanctuaries. I.e. Protected Areas (PAs) along with their Eco-Sensitive Zones (ESZs) are also being diverted at an alarming pace. Proposals to divert lands inside PAs require the approval of the Standing Committee of the National Board of Wildlife (SC-NBWL), a statutory body   tasked with promotion, conservation and development of wildlife and their habitats. However, it is seen that 97% of the diversion proposals placed before the SC-NBWL since 2014 have been cleared.  In just four meetings held in 2024 and 2025, as much as 5824 ha of land inside PAs and ESZs have been cleared for non-forest use with as many as 100 plus proposals getting cleared in almost every meeting.  The diversions permitted were for industrial parks, quarrying, mobile towers, tunnels, oil refineries, railway lines, synthetic organic chemical manufacturing unit, petrochemical park, temples, helipads, mining, hotels, apartment complexes, oil drilling, etc. – entities which in no way benefit wildlife and their habitats. More worryingly, an increasing trend of diversions is noted in Protected Area clearances with every passing year: from 91 projects within Protected Areas granted clearance in 2019, the number steadily increased to 378 in 2024 and 312 in 2025.  PAs make up only 5.4% of the geographic area of the country and the headwaters of many rivers originate in these PAs, providing water and ecological security to the country.  Fragmentation of forests and wildlife habitat drastically reduces the ability of these areas to perform their vital role as a green lung for the country.

How did this happen

The implementation of infrastructure development, mining, etc. through diversion of forests and Protected Areas, has been possible due to the weakening of environment and conservation laws by the government as well as through judicial rulings.  For instance, the Forest Conservation Amendment Act 2023, has   redefined forests in a way that leaves out huge tracts of forested land from legal protection and allows easy diversion of such lands.

Projects which have gone ahead without obtaining the mandatory forest clearances as required under law are being regularised on payment of nominal fines, or by the ridiculous requirement that the violator undertake three to five times penal compensatory afforestation. This is totally antithetical to environmental jurisprudence which directs that EIAs should be done prior to commencement of the project and the diversion of forest and other lands, and not as a fait accompli after the project has started.   After the Forest Conservation Act of 1980 was amended and the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam or the Forest Conservation Amendment Act came into being in 2023, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change  has, in just two years (2024–25 and 2025–26), already approved the diversion, for non-forestry purposes, approximately 22562 ha of forestland per year , as compared to an average of 19223 hectares per year during the five year period 2019 – 24, and 14941 hectares  per year for the preceding  five year period.

The letter also contends that, the SC-NBWL, which is constituted of mainly top government officials, unfortunately, “seems to have no hesitation in approving almost all the diversion proposals placed before it.  It is particularly condemnable that in the past decade more than 30 wildlife sanctuaries and National Parks have been de-notified or drastically reduced in area to enable easy diversions of their land for “developmental” projects.  This includes the Megapode Wildlife Sanctuary as well as the Galathea Bay Wildlife Sanctuary in Great Nicobar, despite the latter being India’s most important and the northern Indian Ocean’s largest nesting site for endangered giant leatherback turtles.”

The recent Supreme Court ruling in July 2026 stating that post-facto environmental clearances (ECs) are legally acceptable if they are authorised by a post-facto valid statutory notification under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, does nothing to improve matters, permitting the central government to regularise violations under Section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.  The Court effectively replaces the ’precautionary principle’ (preventing harm) while dealing with India’s environment with a “pollute and pay” model.  Entrepreneurs can construct big-ticket projects without taking any of the mandatory prior clearances, present the government with a fait accompli and simply pay compensation to stay operational.

Every day brings a new, foolhardy proposal to reduce forested and wildlife protected areas. One such is the recent proposal of the Assam Government to reduce the Eco-sensitive zone (ESZ) of the iconic Kaziranga National Park from 10 Kms to 1 km and allow brick kilns, stone crushers, hotels, commercial warehouses, etc., to operate much closer to the park boundary. It does not apparently matter that the rhinoceros population will be severely and adversely affected. Another such proposal is the use of 12.6 hectares of the Delhi Ridge for the President’s Bodyguard parade ground, which, if implemented, will further fragment the already degraded ridge in Delhi which serves as a green lung for the metropolis.

Do highways mean growth?

The recent push for “development” arises from a misguided understanding that roads, infrastructure, mines, etc. will ensure the growth of the country. There is no realisation that an unpolluted environment together with extensive forest cover and thriving wildlife is even more important for human well-being. Recently issued environmental, forest and wildlife laws, rules and office orders along with “development friendly” judicial rulings have weakened the earlier strong environmental and conservation approach of the country.

The over 700 signatories state that while they acknowledge that infrastructure development projects are necessary for the country, but they should not come at the cost of ecological security. This can only imperil the country as evident from the massive landslides, mudslides, alarming AQI’s, heat waves, deluges, floods, and other environmental calamities occurring across the country. Such a prioritisation is against all aspects of the “precautionary principle” and “intergeneration equity” enunciated by the Supreme Court, as well as being in contravention of Articles 48 A and 51 A of the Constitution and most importantly of Article 21, the Right to Life.

Finally, the communication urges both the government and the judiciary to prioritise the ecological security of our country and the health and life of its citizens over the false narrative of more roads, more buildings, more townships, more mines, more industries, and more destruction of the natural world that is currently seen as progress.

Constitutional Conduct Group (77 signatories as below)

1. Anand Arni RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
2. Aruna Bagchee IAS (Retd.) Former Joint Secretary, Ministry of Mines, GoI
3. Sandeep Bagchee IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
4. J.L. Bajaj IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Administrative Reforms and Decentralisation Commission, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh
5. G. Balachandhran IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
6. Vappala Balachandran IPS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
7. Chandrashekar Balakrishnan IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Coal, GoI
8. Rana Banerji RAS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
9. Sharad Behar IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
10. Madhu Bhaduri IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Portugal
11. Pradip Bhattacharya IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Development & Planning and Administrative Training Institute, Govt. of West Bengal
12. Nutan Guha Biswas IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Police Complaints Authority, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
13. Meeran C Borwankar IPS (Retd.) Former DGP, Bureau of Police Research and Development, GoI
14. Ravi Budhiraja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Jawaharlal Nehru Port Trust, GoI
15. R. Chandramohan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary, Transport and Urban Development, Govt. of NCT of Delhi
16. Rachel Chatterjee IAS (Retd.) Former Special Chief Secretary, Agriculture, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
17. F.T.R. Colaso IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Karnataka & former Director General of Police, Govt. of Jammu & Kashmir
18. Anna Dani IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
19. Vibha Puri Das IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, GoI
20. Nitin Desai   Former Chief Economic Adviser, Ministry of Finance, GoI
21. M.G. Devasahayam IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Govt. of Haryana
22. Sushil Dubey IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Sweden
23. Suresh K. Goel IFS (Retd.) Former Director General, Indian Council of Cultural Relations, GoI
24. Meena Gupta IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Environment & Forests, GoI
25. Wajahat Habibullah IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, GoI and former Chief Information Commissioner
26. Siraj Hussain IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Department of Agriculture, GoI
27. Syed Masood Husain IES (Retd.) Former Chairman, Central Water Commission & ex officio Secretary, Ministry of Jal Shakti, GoI
28. Sanjay Kaul IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Secretary, Govt. of Karnataka
29. Naini Jeyaseelan IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Inter-State Council, GoI
30. Najeeb Jung IAS (Retd.) Former Lieutenant Governor, Delhi
31. Sudhir Kumar IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Central Administrative Tribunal
32. Aloke B. Lal IPS (Retd.) Former Director General (Prosecution), Govt. of Uttarakhand
33. Subodh Lal IPoS (Resigned) Former Deputy Director General, Ministry of Communications, GoI
34. Harsh Mander IAS (Retd.) Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
35. Amitabh Mathur IPS (Retd.) Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI
36. Aditi Mehta IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Rajasthan
37. Malay Mishra IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Hungary
38. Satya Narayan Mohanty IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary General, National Human Rights Commission
39. Jayashree Mukherjee IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra
40. Ruchira Mukerjee IP&TAFS (Retd.) Former Advisor (Finance), Telecom Commission, GoI
41. Anup Mukerji IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of Bihar
42. Deb Mukharji IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to Bangladesh and former Ambassador to Nepal
43. Shiv Shankar Mukherjee IFS (Retd.) Former High Commissioner to the United Kingdom
44. Gautam Mukhopadhaya IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Myanmar
45. Jugal Mohapatra IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Department of Rural Development, GoI
46. Surendra Nath IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Finance Commission, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
47. P. Joy Oommen IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary, Govt. of Chhattisgarh
48. Amitabha Pande IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Inter-State Council, GoI
49. Mira Pande IAS (Retd.) Former State Election Commissioner, West Bengal
50. Alok Perti IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Ministry of Coal, GoI
51. G.K. Pillai IAS (Retd.) Former Home Secretary, GoI
52. Smita Purushottam IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Switzerland
53. V.P. Raja IAS (Retd.) Former Chairman, Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission
54. V. Ramani

 

IAS (Retd.) Former Director General, YASHADA, Govt. of Maharashtra
55. M. Rameshkumar IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
56. Archana Ranjan IRS (Retd.) Former Director General, Central Economic Intelligence Bureau, GoI
57. Madhukumar Reddy A. IRTS (Retd.) Former Principal Executive Director, Railway Board, GoI
58. K. Sujatha Rao IAS (Retd.) Former Health Secretary, GoI

 

59. Satwant Reddy IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Chemicals and Petrochemicals, GoI
60. Julio Ribeiro IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police, Govt. of Punjab
61. Manabendra N. Roy IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal
62. A.K. Samanta IPS (Retd.) Former Director General of Police (Intelligence), Govt. of West Bengal
63. Deepak Sanan IAS (Retd.) Former Principal Adviser (AR) to Chief Minister, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
64. Biswaranjan Sasmal IRS (Retd.) Former Additional Secretary, Department of Social Justice Empowerment, GoI
65. G.V. Venugopala Sarma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Odisha
66. N.C. Saxena IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Planning Commission, GoI
67. Aftab Seth IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Japan
68. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFoS (Retd.) Former MD, State Forest Development Corporation, Govt. of Gujarat
69. Ashok Kumar Sharma IFS (Retd.) Former Ambassador to Finland and Estonia
70. Raju Sharma IAS (Retd.) Former Member, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh
71. Shivendu IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Health & Member (Finance), Jharkhand State Electricity Board, Govt. of Jharkhand
72. Avay Shukla IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary (Forests & Technical Education), Govt. of Himachal Pradesh
73. Tara Ajai Singh IAS (Retd.) Former Additional Chief Secretary, Govt. of Karnataka
74. Mridula Sinha IAS (Retd.) Former Director General, Administrative Training Institute, Govt. of Jharkhand
75. Prakriti Srivastava IFoS (Retd.) Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Special Officer, Rebuild Kerala Development Programme, Govt. of Kerala
76. Anup Thakur IAS (Retd.) Former Member, National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
77. Geetha Thoopal IRAS (Retd.) Former General Manager, Metro Railway, Kolkata

 

Related

Swaraj India decries MoEFCC’s Forest Conservation Rules 2022 notification

Environmentalist demand withdrawal of changes to Biological Diversity Act

Palghar Adivasis decry ecologically-dangerous infrastructural projects

AIUFWP’s 2nd National Conference begins in New Delhi

The post Prioritise ecological security of country over “false narrative” of “highway development”: CCG to Govt & Courts appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Pune’s DJ Controversy, Ganeshotsav and Assault: The politics of who gets to make noise https://sabrangindia.in/punes-dj-controversy-ganeshotsav-and-assault-the-politics-of-who-gets-to-make-noise/ Mon, 07 Sep 2026 06:14:53 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49169 The assault on Pune activist Vidyanand Bapat reveals how a demand for lawful, quieter festivals became entangled with political power, religious identity and intolerance of dissent

The post Pune’s DJ Controversy, Ganeshotsav and Assault: The politics of who gets to make noise appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
On September 3, Vidyanand Bapat was speaking to the media on Tilak Road in Pune when a man approached him and slapped him on camera. Bapat, a 37-year-old Pune resident who works at a BPO, had in less than two weeks become one of the most recognisable voices in the city’s growing campaign against high-decibel DJ systems and amplified sound during religious festivals.

The assault was not an isolated disagreement over music. It was the latest and most disturbing episode in a controversy that has exposed a larger question: who gets to decide how much noise a religious celebration can impose on everyone else?

The Indian Express reported that Bapat was attacked while giving a live interview, with the assault captured on camera. Pune Police Commissioner Amitesh Kumar said the accused had been arrested and that a cognisable, non-bailable case would be registered. Bapat was subsequently provided police protection.

 

 

From one voice at a civic meeting to a statewide debate

The controversy began on August 24, when the Pune Municipal Corporation held its preparatory meeting for Ganeshotsav, scheduled to begin on September 14. Among several hundred people present, Bapat was reportedly the only person to object to the use of DJs and dhol systems. His argument was straightforward: the festival should not become a source of excessive noise, traffic disruption and public inconvenience. He invoked the history of Ganeshotsav, pointing out that when Lokmanya Tilak popularised the public festival, DJ systems obviously did not exist. He argued that amplified music was neither intrinsic to the festival nor necessary for its celebration.

 

The response was hostile. Bapat was shouted down and eventually escorted out by the police as tensions rose. But footage of the confrontation circulated widely on social media, transforming an otherwise ordinary civic meeting into a national talking point. The controversy was then amplified by Marathi television.

ABP Majha brought Bapat face-to-face with BJP Pune city president Dheeraj Ghate. During the debate, Bapat calmly explained his position on noise pollution. Ghate reportedly mocked him, asking who even knew Bapat in his neighbourhood. The exchange subsequently went viral. Within days, television channels, YouTube platforms and social-media personalities were interviewing Bapat. He repeatedly made the same argument, drawing on Sanskrit texts, the Mahabharata, Greek and Latin literature and his own rationalist worldview. His fluency in Marathi, Sanskrit, Hindi and English and his refusal to be provoked made him a social-media sensation.

The real issue is not whether festivals should be celebrated

The debate has sometimes been presented as a conflict between religious devotees and people opposed to Ganeshotsav. That is a misleading frame. Bapat has not argued against Ganeshotsav. Neither have many of the citizens who have subsequently joined the campaign.

At a Goodluck Chowk gathering, protesters explicitly said that their objection was to excessive noise from DJs, loudspeakers, dhol-tasha systems and other high-intensity sound equipment — not to Ganeshotsav itself. Hindustan Times reported similar assertions from participants who said the restrictions should apply to every religious celebration, irrespective of religion.

 

A constitutional democracy does not give religious expression a licence to override the rights of everyone around it. Freedom of religion does not mean freedom from regulation. Public celebrations take place in shared civic spaces, and their exercise necessarily has to coexist with the rights of residents, children, elderly people, patients, workers, motorists and others. The question, therefore, should not be whether Ganeshotsav is important. It plainly is. The question is why excessive noise has been allowed to become synonymous with celebration in the first place.

The numbers make the argument harder to dismiss

The College of Engineering, Pune has measured noise levels on Lakshmi Road during Ganesh immersion for roughly 25 years. With the exception of the pandemic years, readings have consistently exceeded 80 decibels. The levels recorded in recent years were particularly stark: 105.2 decibels in 2022, 101.3 in 2024 and 94.8 in 2025.

The Union Environment Ministry’s prescribed limits are substantially lower. In residential areas, the permissible limit is 55 decibels during the day and 45 at night. Even commercial areas have limits of 65 and 55 decibels respectively.

For years, the state has known that noise levels during major processions can far exceed permissible standards. The more uncomfortable question is: why has enforcement remained so inconsistent?

The politics of noise

Several Ganesh mandal representatives and BJP leaders initially opposed Bapat’s position and defended DJs and dhol during the festival. Yet once the issue gained significant public support, political leaders began positioning themselves on the side of noise control.  BJP leader and Maharashtra Higher and Technical Education Minister Chandrakant Patil appealed to Punekars not to overuse DJs and laser beams. Bengaluru South MP Tejasvi Surya similarly welcomed citizen mobilisation around clean air and reduced noise. Neither, however, publicly challenged the BJP’s local leadership that had been supporting the use of DJs.

Chief Minister Fadnavis adopted an equally cautious position at the BJP state executive meeting in Pune on August 31, calling for festivals to be celebrated in a “cultured” manner without directly taking a clear position on the DJ controversy. That changed somewhat after the assault.

On September 4, Fadnavis described DJ noise as being comparable to the sound of an earthquake and called for a return to more traditional forms of Ganeshotsav. Hindustan Times reported that he also argued that consensus and dialogue were necessary to reduce the use of such systems. But there is an obvious political contradiction here. If excessive noise is genuinely harmful, the state does not need to wait for a viral citizen campaign or an assault before taking a firm position. The legal framework already exists.

Solapur shows that another model is possible

Pune is not the first Maharashtra city to confront this issue. Solapur has moved towards a DJ-free Ganeshotsav, with the campaign emerging from citizen mobilisation rather than merely being imposed from above. The effort followed growing concern about the health and civic consequences of high-decibel celebrations.

The campaign acquired particular force following accounts of two incidents in 2025 involving the alleged health consequences of excessive festival noise. A citizen who objected to loud music during Shiv Jayanti reportedly suffered permanent hearing loss after being forced to sit near speakers, while another young man reportedly suffered a fatal heart attack after dancing to loud DJ music during a procession. The resulting campaign brought together lawyers, doctors, senior citizens and students and reportedly collected tens of thousands of signatures. Solapur demonstrates that religious celebration and restraint do not have to be opposites.

The movement is now larger than Bapat

Bapat may have become the face of the Pune controversy, but the demand predates him. The campaign against DJs has been building for several years. In 2023, Sunil Mane, an Ambedkarite and former journalist who is now associated with the NCP (Sharad Pawar), petitioned against DJ use during Ambedkar Jayanti processions, Hindustan Times reported.

By August 30, hundreds of people had gathered at Goodluck Chowk despite the cancellation of a proposed march by Sakal Hindu Samaj, as per the report of Free Press Journal. One participant told reporters that elderly residents and heart patients were particularly affected by the noise. Another directly warned the BJP leadership that voters who had supported the party could change their political loyalties if they felt their concerns were being ignored.

Nagpur has moved from appeals to enforcement

Nagpur Police have imposed restrictions on high-powered DJ systems, customised sound trucks, multi-speaker systems and other high-intensity amplified equipment under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. The order, effective from September 3 to November 1, covers multiple festivals, including Ganeshotsav, Eid, Navratri, Durga Puja, Dussehra and Diwali. Importantly, systems operating within permissible noise limits are not covered by the prohibition.

Nagpur has also restricted high-intensity laser and beam lights on public-safety grounds, citing the possibility of temporary visual impairment for motorists and consequent accidents. The city has simultaneously created a mechanism through which citizens can report noise pollution, upload evidence and track complaints, with the system reportedly requiring action within 30 minutes and providing for escalation if no response is recorded.

The state must protect dissent, not merely condemn violence after the fact

The assault on Bapat should not become another moment when political leaders condemn violence only after it has occurred while ignoring the conditions that allow intimidation to flourish. Bapat was not attacked while obstructing a procession. He was attacked while speaking to journalists.

His position could be challenged. His arguments could be criticised. His understanding of tradition could be disputed. His demand for a ban could be opposed. But none of these disagreements legitimises physical violence.

The Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti, while condemning the assault, warned that allowing violence to replace argument creates a dangerous precedent: if people become afraid to speak about noise pollution, they may eventually become afraid to speak about corruption, superstition, pollution or injustice more broadly. NCP (SP) chief Sharad Pawar similarly said that assaulting someone for exercising the right to express an opinion amounts to an attack on democracy. He also backed restrictions on DJs and loudspeakers and pointed to Solapur and other districts as examples.

Former MLC Sandip Joshi has supported a complete ban on DJs and laser systems and described the assault on Bapat as an act of cowardice. He has been campaigning for restrictions beyond the immediate festive period. But BJP city president Dayashankar Tiwari and MLA Pravin Datke have opposed the restrictions. Datke questioned why restrictions were being imposed during Hindu festivals, while the BJP maintained that the leaders were speaking in their individual capacities.

 

Related:

Maharashtra SIR draft rolls leave 2.07 crore electors out; Pune records highest exclusions at 28.66 lakh

Two women journalists allege police assault after questioning Delhi CM, say attack intensified after police heard they were Muslim

Maharashtra’s schools are struggling to survive as students protest, infrastructure crumbles and Marathi-medium institutions disappear

3,404 SIR Forms Found at Kharghar Xerox Shop: CJP, VFD and BCS demands answers from Maharashtra SEC

The post Pune’s DJ Controversy, Ganeshotsav and Assault: The politics of who gets to make noise appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
A people on the brink: The fight to protect the Shompen of Great Nicobar https://sabrangindia.in/a-people-on-the-brink-the-fight-to-protect-the-shompen-of-great-nicobar/ Thu, 27 Aug 2026 11:01:43 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=49041 India’s tribal communities have long lived at the margins of society, shaped by histories of displacement, fragile livelihoods and limited access to essential services. Among them, the Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) represent the most delicate thread in the country’s social fabric. Many continue to depend on forests and natural ecosystems for survival, while others […]

The post A people on the brink: The fight to protect the Shompen of Great Nicobar appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
India’s tribal communities have long lived at the margins of society, shaped by histories of displacement, fragile livelihoods and limited access to essential services. Among them, the Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) represent the most delicate thread in the country’s social fabric. Many continue to depend on forests and natural ecosystems for survival, while others have been pushed toward urban centres in search of work. Their vulnerability is often intensified by isolation, demographic fragility and the pressures of modern development. Nowhere is this more evident than in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, home to several indigenous groups whose futures hinge on the protection of their territories, cultures and autonomy.

The Shompen of Great Nicobar Island stand out as one of India’s most distinctive and endangered tribal communities. Living deep within the island’s forests, they have traditionally followed a semi‑nomadic life of hunting, gathering and horticulture. Their diet—coconuts, bananas, tubers, fish, wild animals and honey—reflects a sophisticated understanding of the forest ecosystem. Their indigenous methods of storing water in bamboo, their linguistic uniqueness and their customary practices have long fascinated anthropologists and administrators. Yet these very characteristics also make them exceptionally vulnerable to external pressures.

Historically, the Shompen have maintained minimal contact with outsiders, a factor that helped preserve their culture but also left them exposed to new risks as interactions increased. Their population numbers tell a story of extreme demographic fragility. Estimates have fluctuated sharply over the past century: 348 in 1901, 375 in 1911 and 1921, dropping to 200 in 1931, plummeting to 20 in 1951, rising again to 212 in 1981, falling to 135 in 1991 and reaching 229 in 2001. These swings must be interpreted cautiously, given the difficulty of enumerating isolated communities, but they nonetheless reveal how even minor disruptions—disease outbreaks, habitat loss or food scarcity—can have catastrophic consequences for such a small population.

Health remains one of the most serious concerns. Indigenous groups with limited historical exposure to communicable diseases are at heightened risk when contact with outsiders increases. The Andaman Islands have witnessed outbreaks of measles, mumps and tuberculosis among other tribal communities, underscoring the dangers of uncontrolled interaction. For the Shompen, healthcare policy must strike a delicate balance: ensuring access to essential services without exposing them to infectious diseases or creating dependency on external institutions. Preventive, culturally sensitive strategies—surveillance, vaccination where appropriate, nutritional support and emergency response—must be designed with respect for autonomy and minimal intrusion.

The Shompen’s survival is inseparable from the forests of Great Nicobar. Their traditional economy depends on access to wildlife, water sources and forest produce. The Andaman and Nicobar Islands (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956 sought to safeguard indigenous territories by restricting land transfers and outsider access. Yet protected areas can create dilemmas when conservation measures unintentionally limit indigenous communities’ access to resources they have relied on for generations. Protection must therefore prioritize tribal rights rather than impose rigid administrative boundaries. Encroachment, agricultural expansion, commercial extraction and unauthorized entry threaten both the forest ecosystem and the Shompen’s livelihood security.

Contact with outsiders remains one of the most sensitive policy issues. Tourism, settlement and infrastructure development have increased opportunities for interaction, often with harmful consequences. Experiences involving other indigenous groups in the islands reveal how treating tribal communities as tourist attractions can lead to exploitation, cultural disruption and nutritional decline. When traditional food systems are replaced by market commodities, diets may become inadequate or unhealthy. Policy must follow the principle of minimum necessary contact, ensuring that interaction occurs only for essential purposes such as healthcare, protection or administration.

Tourism, in particular, demands strict ethical safeguards. The controversies surrounding the Andaman Trunk Road illustrate how commercial interests can overshadow indigenous rights. The Shompen must never be approached, photographed or displayed for entertainment. Their privacy, dignity and right to determine the nature of contact must take precedence over tourism revenue. Responsible tourism requires prohibiting exploitative encounters and preventing entry into protected tribal territories except under strictly regulated conditions.

Education presents another complex challenge. The Shompen possess their own language, ecological knowledge and cultural practices. Conventional schooling, if imposed without sensitivity, may erode indigenous knowledge and produce limited outcomes. Experiences from Tamil Nadu and Madhya Pradesh show that educational programmes become more effective when they incorporate local languages and traditional learning systems. For the Shompen, flexible, community‑based approaches—introduced only with their consent—may be more appropriate than mass‑schooling models.

Government policy in the islands has evolved from colonial settlement and penal administration to post‑independence efforts aimed at protecting tribal communities. The 1956 Regulation established a legal framework for safeguarding indigenous territories, and subsequent measures strengthened restrictions on unauthorized access, tourism and photography. Research institutions have contributed to documenting tribal societies and informing policy. Yet legislation alone cannot ensure protection; effective implementation, monitoring and coordination are essential.

The Shompen require a policy approach tailored to their unique circumstances. Their territorial rights must be protected from encroachment. Contact with outsiders should be strictly regulated. Healthcare interventions must prioritize disease prevention and nutritional security. Cultural preservation—including documentation of language and traditional knowledge—should be undertaken only with community consent. Traditional food systems and livelihoods must be strengthened rather than replaced. Tourism must never compromise their dignity. Governance should respect their choices and customary institutions. Data collection must be careful, ethical and non‑intrusive.

The way forward lies in protecting the Shompen’s relationship with their environment. Their traditional practices—hunting, gathering and horticulture—are finely adapted to Great Nicobar’s ecology. Development interventions must avoid disrupting this balance. Infrastructure and economic projects in the Nicobar Islands must be planned with sensitivity to ecological and tribal concerns. The goal is not assimilation into mainstream society, nor romanticized isolation that denies essential services. The appropriate path lies between these extremes: protection without exploitation, assistance without dependency, development without displacement and contact without coercion.

The Shompen’s future depends on decisions made today. Their small population, isolation and dependence on natural resources make them acutely vulnerable. The history of tribal administration in the islands shows that even well‑intentioned interventions can produce unintended harm when indigenous autonomy and ecological realities are ignored. Policy must therefore place the Shompen’s life, land, health, culture and dignity at its centre. Their survival should not be measured by integration into mainstream society, but by their ability to retain identity, knowledge, territorial security and dignity while receiving essential protection when needed.

*Associate Professor (Retd.), National Institute of Rural Development (NIRD)

Courtesy: CounterView

The post A people on the brink: The fight to protect the Shompen of Great Nicobar appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
As mining lobby “hijacks” Ajmer public hearing, “tokenism” on Aravallis condemned https://sabrangindia.in/as-mining-lobby-hijacks-ajmer-public-hearing-tokenism-on-aravallis-condemned/ Mon, 10 Aug 2026 09:48:14 +0000 https://sabrangindia.in/?p=48794 The People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), Rajasthan has raised serious questions on the tokenisms behind the recent public hearings on the Aravallis, and condemned the “hijacking” of the process by the “mining lobby”

The post As mining lobby “hijacks” Ajmer public hearing, “tokenism” on Aravallis condemned appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>
Raising serious questions over the functioning of the High Powered Committee constituted by the Supreme on the Aravallis, the People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), Rajasthan, along with several people’s organisations, have strongly criticised the public hearings being conducted at Ajmer and other locations as a mere formality. The organisations have called for an immediate overhaul of the process to ensure meaningful and inclusive public participation.

In a statement issued on Sunday, August 9, the organisations said that the Committee has been entrusted with examining the overall ecology of the Aravalli region, its impact on people’s lives, social and economic conditions, water resources and groundwater, mining, employment, animal husbandry and other related issues.

Such an assessment is simply not possible through what amounts to a token tour of nine districts in just four days, the organisations said.

Only One Hour for the Ajmer Hearing

The organisations also questioned the decision to allot only one hour for the Ajmer public hearing. People were invited from different districts, but were asked to make their submissions within just two minutes. This, they said, clearly demonstrates that the Committee is not serious about hearing the concerns and experiences of different sections of the population.

The organisations had submitted the names of 11 representatives from Ajmer, Jaipur, Beawar, Bhim and Bhilwara to represent the people. However, only a few were actually given an opportunity to speak.

The organisations strongly condemned the systematic hijacking of today’s Ajmer public hearing by the mining lobby, with large numbers of mining operators and other stakeholders reportedly brought in from Nagaur and Makrana.

The presence of hundreds of people associated with the mining business, who repeatedly raised their hands in a show of strength during the proceedings, raises serious questions about the role of the administration and suggests possible administrative complicity, the organisations said.

No Genuine Effort to Involve the Public

There was no meaningful effort by the administration to inform or involve ordinary people in the public hearing. No public notice was issued in newspapers and no adequate publicity was undertaken. As a result, there was very little participation from rural areas.

Instead, the gathering of government officials from different departments and large numbers of business representatives appeared to be an attempt to create the appearance of a public hearing, the organisations alleged.

When representatives of people’s organisations objected to the manner in which the hearing was being conducted, attempts were made to silence them, and several sections were denied an opportunity to put forward their views.

Aravalli Cannot Be Discussed Without Those Who Live and Work There

The organisations emphasised that any meaningful discussion on the Aravallis remains incomplete without the participation of rural communities, farmers, pastoralists, environmental activists, scientists, geologists and experts on water and groundwater resources.

The Committee must travel to rural areas and mining-affected regions and directly examine the ground realities faced by local communities, they said. It must also meet and directly assess the condition of silicosis patients whose lives have been devastated by mining.

Concerns over the Composition of the High-Level Committee

The organisations also termed the composition of the High powered Committee inappropriate and demanded representation for all relevant stakeholders.

They pointed out that it is deeply problematic that the Chairperson and two members of the Committee are representatives of the very department that had earlier recommended that only hills rising more than 100 metres should be considered part of the Aravallis.

The exclusion of even a single environmental activist from the Committee is equally alarming and indicates, the organisations said, that the government continues to pursue a policy of protecting the interests responsible for the destruction of the Aravallis, rather than protecting the range itself.

“Mining Lobby Creates an Unsafe Atmosphere”

The most disturbing development, the organisations said, was the aggressive behaviour and threatening and violent language used by persons associated with the mining lobby during the public hearing.

Representatives of people’s organisations were specifically targeted. After the hearing, some of the mining lobby representatives confronted them outside the venue, engaged in heated arguments, hurled abuses and issued threats, creating an atmosphere of considerable insecurity.

The organisations said that such intimidation is completely unacceptable in a process that is supposed to provide a safe and democratic space for citizens to express their concerns.

Demands for a Genuine and Comprehensive Process were made

Representatives of the people’s organisations, including Kavita Srivastava, Bhanwar Meghwanshi, Anant Bhatnagar, Indira Pancholi, Shankar Singh, Komal Srivastava, Tarachand Verma, Dhiresh Kumar Jain, Shashi Meena, Prashant Patni, Mary Reen, Rajkumar Nahar, Suresh Mathur, Jyoti Prakash Bhati, Kuldeep Gehlot and Neelam Ahluwalia, have demanded:

(i) Extension of the tenure of the High-Level Committee

(ii) A transparent and meaningful process to ensure participation of the general public;

(iii) Adequate opportunity for all affected sections and stakeholders to present their views;

(iv) A comprehensive study covering all districts falling within the Aravalli region;

(v)Field visits to rural and mining-affected areas;

(vi) Direct assessment of the impact of mining on communities, including the condition of silicosis-affected workers and families; and

(vii) A comprehensive ecological, social, economic and hydrological assessment of the Aravalli region before any final conclusions are drawn.

The People’s Union for Civil Liberties, Save Aravalli, Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, Bharat Gyan Vigyan Samiti, Save Dol Ka Badh Movement, Shahabad Valley Sangharsh Samiti, Climate Action for Youth, Jaldhara, People for Aravalli, and other organisations said that if the Committee fails to make the process genuinely participatory and inclusive, people’s organisations will organise their own genuine public hearings at different locations across the Aravalli region.

Related:

In North Gujarat’s Granite-Rich Idar, Locals Fearful About Aravalli Mountains’ Future

Say No to ‘Toxic Governance’: Arrest air pollution, not activists and protesters: NACEJ

Whose ‘ENVIRONMENT’ is it, anyway?

 

The post As mining lobby “hijacks” Ajmer public hearing, “tokenism” on Aravallis condemned appeared first on SabrangIndia.

]]>